Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is not what parental leave is for?

409 replies

Friendlybreadbin · 03/05/2023 21:07

I may well BU but interested in people’s opinions. My company offers a fairly standard 25 days plus bank holidays leave package. New colleague comes from a company where they had been for over 20 years and so had got up to 30 days, their old company also offered a ‘buy an additional 10 days leave’ package. Our company doesn’t. Having passed their 3 month probation period (where they also took a lot of leave) they are using leave days like they are going out of fashion, and have already had a skiing holiday and an all inclusive this year. As well as lots of other random days off, it’s seems rare they work a full week. Have been openly saying that they intend to take unpaid leave because they can’t see how they will possibly manage on 25 days when they were used to 40 days and asking how does anyone do that with kids? I have not dissimilar aged kids and have managed with 25 days for my whole career. There are no special needs or circumstances. Their job is flexible and from home.
AIBU that they should learn to manage within their holiday allowance that they accepted by contract? Or as the extra leave is unpaid is this an acceptable strategy? It seems to me they intend to exploit parental leave just because they feel entitled to more holiday than they are contracted to have.
Our company charges customers rates for their time and will therefore lose revenue as we can’t charge when they are OOO. I am their line manager.
I have managed people for 20 years and have never come across anyone with this attitude before, when I have managed people who have taken parental leave it has been for understandable reasons.

OP posts:
TooOldForThisNonsense · 04/05/2023 10:48

Snoopsnoggysnog · 04/05/2023 10:35

This is interesting because I have always wondered how it works or how your employer could check if you’ve gone over the entitlement. Is there a record anywhere?

I took 3 months off one summer years ago just before my twins started reception, using 3 weeks holiday and 9 weeks parental leave. I then took a bit more leave a few years later but I can’t remember how much - maybe two weeks. This summer I’m planning to take 6 weeks parental leave. So in theory I will probably have used 17 weeks of my 36 weeks but how can this be checked? I mean I think it’s really unlikely I’d ever exceed 36 weeks - my twins are teens now - but you never know.

does anyone know the answer to this?

As far as I know there isn’t - it depends on employees being honest with employers!

Snoopsnoggysnog · 04/05/2023 10:35

MrsPinkCock · 04/05/2023 08:36

I’m an employment lawyer so I was aware of this right fairly early on and I’ve taken parental leave myself to spend time with the kids in school holidays.

It used to only apply to children under 5 though (or 18 for a disabled child) and wasn’t as generous as 18 weeks. Even so, spread over your child’s “young” life, it’s only an extra week a year (and it isn’t per employer, it’s a cumulative entitlement, so you couldn’t take your 18 weeks, move to another job and take another 18 weeks - although I suspect it’s never checked)

It’s still rarely used though and employers can put blocks in the way of you taking it. For example you might need the leave for childcare during school holidays, but if it clashed with another employee already on leave then they’d be within their rights to postpone it to another time where less employees are on leave outside of the school holidays (which makes it far less useful).

Then if you’re in an industry like mine, full of old school boys, you’ll be judged heavily for using it (although ironically my male colleague was judged far more heavily than I was and ended up cancelling his leave as a result). On one request I also had an HR Manager ask me “why did you take a full time job if you want part time hours?”

It made my working life a lot easier though when it was actually approved so I think it’s a good thing! Hopefully things have moved on a bit and it isn’t as frowned on now as when I took it 10 years ago.

This is interesting because I have always wondered how it works or how your employer could check if you’ve gone over the entitlement. Is there a record anywhere?

I took 3 months off one summer years ago just before my twins started reception, using 3 weeks holiday and 9 weeks parental leave. I then took a bit more leave a few years later but I can’t remember how much - maybe two weeks. This summer I’m planning to take 6 weeks parental leave. So in theory I will probably have used 17 weeks of my 36 weeks but how can this be checked? I mean I think it’s really unlikely I’d ever exceed 36 weeks - my twins are teens now - but you never know.

does anyone know the answer to this?

Snoopsnoggysnog · 04/05/2023 10:28

evuscha · 04/05/2023 06:37

Ahh, I live in the US now where 10-15 days is a norm if you’re lucky! I probably come across similarly when talking about my days in Europe and 25 days + bank holidays. 40 I can’t even imagine but sounds like a dream.

I think if eligible then parental leave can be used for anything, so if it’s yet another skiing trip, then so be it.

This is one of the reasons I could never live in the US! How do you manage school holidays?

TheYearOfSmallThings · 04/05/2023 09:41

She mainly did this by working ‘extra’ days on her days off and then taking them back for holiday. It drove me crazy. You can say ‘what’s wrong with that’ but my view was it gave her an unfair contract compared with full time employees who could not work extra days

I have to say this could be me - I work 3 days and often work on my non-work days to make up for missed days (strikes, chickenpox etc). Yes it is not possible for colleagues who work full time to do this, but then that is why I work part time and they earn nearly twice as much. I sacrifice the extra pay to make my life manageable, so I don't think it is unfair.

pollykitty · 04/05/2023 09:28

I used to line manage a woman who had a part-time contract for 3 days a week and was forever trying to add on to her holiday allowance or trying to take 3-week holidays (which were not allowed). She mainly did this by working ‘extra’ days on her days off and then taking them back for holiday. It drove me crazy. You can say ‘what’s wrong with that’ but my view was it gave her an unfair contract compared with full time employees who could not work extra days (eg bank holidays or at the weekend) to improve their holiday allowance. If she didn’t get what she wanted, she would take parental leave etc - fine, whatever. But basically she constantly acted very entitled and like she didn’t need to accommodate her colleagues when she wanted to go on holiday. I eventually asked that she be transferred to another manager because I didn’t want to deal with her constant ‘requests’ anymore.

SuseB · 04/05/2023 09:08

My DH works for a big company that has generous AL entitlements and buy-back. We have 3DC and he has taken at least a week of unpaid parental leave and often more in every year since the oldest was a baby. Obviously he earns less money that month but the extra family time has been invaluable especially when the DC were small as looking after them was hard work. There are some calculations to do to work out if you are better off buying back holiday, or taking unpaid parental leave (eg bought-back holiday does allow you to take odd days here and there as it's just added to your normal holiday entitlement) - some years we have done a combination of both to maximise time off/convenience/childcare etc. I am self-employed so have always been flexible. Interestingly as a man he's never had any grief at all about any of his leave arrangements, even though he works in a male-dominated industry and few of his colleagues have used their entitlements this way. He has also worked part-time (4 days per week) since youngest was born. No complaints from the company about his commitment/performance, he is always rated incredibly highly in reviews.

TheKobayashiMaru · 04/05/2023 08:53

I'd find it hard to move to an organisation with less leave than I have now. You get used to it.

Didtheythough · 04/05/2023 08:45

I usually take at least 1 week of unpaid parental leave a year (I have 30 days annual leave and flexi time) I use parental leave to cover a half term. Me taking leave doesn't impact my team, I don't ask anyone to cover anything whilst I'm off. If that's the case for your colleague then what's the problem? People have lives outside of work.

OMG12 · 04/05/2023 08:40

ArticMonkeyBusiness · 04/05/2023 08:31

As an ex-HR Manager and HR Consultant, I am yet to come across a company that genuinely gives a shit about its staff. They will happily oust you, as soon as their profits drop.

Also, employees are either fully aware of their rights and entitlements or take the piss. My own workplace is a good example. I have the least sickness in my operation. 1 day in 3 years. Others have months and months of sickness and despite a clear HR policy, it is not enforced. Some of the people I work with are off with headaches, and lack of sleep (from clubbing to 4 am) and some are genuine. I end up doing both their and my work and we are already short-staffed as it is. I get my holiday rejected as we don't have enough staff at those times.

So, I've decided to look at our HR and see what the guidelines are. I have a few things I need to do, and I won't get the holiday approved, so I'll be throwing a sickie. It is not something I have ever done, but at some point if you can't beat them, you have to join them.

Tbh, I realised the employers don’t give a shit about their employees a long time ago. I’ve seen so many people basically give their lives to the job then get ousted because of the economy whilst the partners maintain their income.

dmaller firms might be a bit better but larger firms, happy to make it work for me, it’s not a two way relationship. Never become emotionally attached to your job. If you died next week they would have forgotten about you in less than a month once the admins over.

MrsPinkCock · 04/05/2023 08:36

I’m an employment lawyer so I was aware of this right fairly early on and I’ve taken parental leave myself to spend time with the kids in school holidays.

It used to only apply to children under 5 though (or 18 for a disabled child) and wasn’t as generous as 18 weeks. Even so, spread over your child’s “young” life, it’s only an extra week a year (and it isn’t per employer, it’s a cumulative entitlement, so you couldn’t take your 18 weeks, move to another job and take another 18 weeks - although I suspect it’s never checked)

It’s still rarely used though and employers can put blocks in the way of you taking it. For example you might need the leave for childcare during school holidays, but if it clashed with another employee already on leave then they’d be within their rights to postpone it to another time where less employees are on leave outside of the school holidays (which makes it far less useful).

Then if you’re in an industry like mine, full of old school boys, you’ll be judged heavily for using it (although ironically my male colleague was judged far more heavily than I was and ended up cancelling his leave as a result). On one request I also had an HR Manager ask me “why did you take a full time job if you want part time hours?”

It made my working life a lot easier though when it was actually approved so I think it’s a good thing! Hopefully things have moved on a bit and it isn’t as frowned on now as when I took it 10 years ago.

ArticMonkeyBusiness · 04/05/2023 08:31

As an ex-HR Manager and HR Consultant, I am yet to come across a company that genuinely gives a shit about its staff. They will happily oust you, as soon as their profits drop.

Also, employees are either fully aware of their rights and entitlements or take the piss. My own workplace is a good example. I have the least sickness in my operation. 1 day in 3 years. Others have months and months of sickness and despite a clear HR policy, it is not enforced. Some of the people I work with are off with headaches, and lack of sleep (from clubbing to 4 am) and some are genuine. I end up doing both their and my work and we are already short-staffed as it is. I get my holiday rejected as we don't have enough staff at those times.

So, I've decided to look at our HR and see what the guidelines are. I have a few things I need to do, and I won't get the holiday approved, so I'll be throwing a sickie. It is not something I have ever done, but at some point if you can't beat them, you have to join them.

Tryingtoconceivenumber2 · 04/05/2023 08:31

I'm sure parental leave has you be taken as a block. I don't think they can split it up as it suits them. They may also change their mind when they realise how sort they are in their pay x

CheersForThatEh · 04/05/2023 08:23

Read the parental leave guidance. Regardless of what you consider an attitude problem, if they are entitled to it then you need to follow the law and guidance.

Confusion101 · 04/05/2023 08:21

Life is short! Take the days off and don't begrudge others who do. If its unpaid leave I don't see the issue it's not like they are using paid sick leave to go away with the family for a week or something like that. Family time is important!!

Lcb123 · 04/05/2023 08:18

Unless you’re their line manager and it’s causing an issue for the business then it’s none of your concern. Sounds like they have the right attitude to life in my opinion! If you can afford to take unpaid and it’s authorised why wouldn’t you

Bunnycat101 · 04/05/2023 08:15

Lots of people are totally unaware of the unpaid statutory leave. I fully intend to take it once my youngest is in school for at least a week. In the scheme of things it makes very little difference to the employer if you’re only taking an extra week. For 2 kids in holiday camp for 4 days it would be around £400 for me, by the time I’ve then commuted etc then yes I’m losing out because of unpaid leave but not by a huge amount.

Sissynova · 04/05/2023 08:14

TooOldForThisNonsense · 04/05/2023 08:02

True. I tend to assume most people on here are female unless specifically informed otherwise! It actually sounds like quite male behaviour when I think about it though

Taking time off work to spend it with your children and take them on holiday us “male behaviour”?

TooOldForThisNonsense · 04/05/2023 08:02

NotAnotherBathBomb · 04/05/2023 08:00

Side note but interesting to see some PPs have referred to the employee as 'she'. In my head they were clearly male but I've just reread the OP to see they've not mentioned sex

True. I tend to assume most people on here are female unless specifically informed otherwise! It actually sounds like quite male behaviour when I think about it though

NotAnotherBathBomb · 04/05/2023 08:00

Side note but interesting to see some PPs have referred to the employee as 'she'. In my head they were clearly male but I've just reread the OP to see they've not mentioned sex

icelollycraving · 04/05/2023 07:58

It’s irrelevant what type of holidays she enjoys, skiing or sitting on her bum tbh.
I’ve never had an employee use parental leave really, I did when Ds was tiny and in hospital. Not many people can afford it.
Does your company have a guideline of how many days can be taken in one period. I would out how much per quarter etc. If someone leaves having used more than the YTD entitlement they would have that deducted.
I think you’ve listened to people on this thread and perhaps do have a slightly dated approach. In some industries, things are more flexible and in some, for example yours, maybe there needs to be a clear understanding on both sides of expectations and why leave needs to be taken in a certain framed way.

Orders76 · 04/05/2023 07:55

There is also the risk that if you don't approve, she'll take sick. Cheeky but I've seen people do it.
It also sounds like you're in consultancy or some other billable business which isn't conducive to any leave type of mindset. I'd be considering if I needed another resource so everyone can take their entitlements.

Dishwashersaurous · 04/05/2023 07:46

The reason for taking leave is immaterial as is any attitude.

The issue for you is managing the workload.

Why did you authorise ad hoc days off every week if that is bad for organising work?

You are the line manager.

You need to authorise any leave taken.
You need to cover the workload and ensure it is done.

If work requires someone to be there five days a week for a project then don't authorise single day leave unless in an emergency.

She's giving you plenty of notice for taking unpaid leave, so you need to assess business need against the HR policy.

If there is a problem for the business then YOU need to address and manage it.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 04/05/2023 07:44

Simonjt · 04/05/2023 05:57

I take four weeks of parental leave each year, surely taking paid holiday is actually more entitled due to cost in wages and NI to an employer.

Not really if the expectation is that the person is there to work at other times. You can’t just swan off work when it suits you if it impacts the business just because it’s unpaid.

however this is the OP’s job to manage instead of moaning about the employee taking time off that seems for whatever reason to have been permitted

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 04/05/2023 07:40

But they are entitled to take it. Its designed to help parents manage. I only took it twice, 2 blocks of 2 weeks, because that then gave me sufficient to mop up the days my kids were off sick etc.
Yes it's a luxury cos it's unpaid but don't moan about people using it. It was hard fought for.

KittyAlfred · 04/05/2023 07:38

Facetyme · 03/05/2023 22:50

It’s a couple of weeks a year. Hardly part time job level

The employee hasn’t worked a full week.

Swipe left for the next trending thread