Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this isn't ok in a marriage?

304 replies

Cloud991 · 03/05/2023 20:42

I'm really struggling with my dh's behaviour... All sorts of things but this is about our finances. I have no experience of how other married couples sort out finances so I don't know if this is normal...

Every month, my dh makes me pay a certain amount of what I earn into our joint account to go towards bills, whatever's left I can keep. The issue is I'm self employed and income can vary but he never cuts me any slack and will remind me how much I owe etc. If we buy anything else, he reminds me to send over my half towards it and if this isn't done quickly, he will nag me in a nasty way for it. Even the rest of the money I have after I've paid my share of the bills, he passes judgement on anything I buy and when he comes home from work, the first thing he does is to go round the house to check if I've bought anything. I feel very stressed all the time. Is this a normal set up because I feel like it's not ok but he says it is.

OP posts:
REignbow · 04/05/2023 20:21

Paying a proportion based on your salary is normal. Paying half of everything when you have a chronic illness, are caring for a young child whilst working part time is not.

^^

mandlerparr · 04/05/2023 20:18

and this shouldn't have to be said, but no, his allowance does not get to be bigger because he makes more. No. All of his day to day needs will have been taken care of from the joint account and he doesn't need extra money.

mandlerparr · 04/05/2023 20:16

He is trying to control you through finances. your choices are leave him, or sit him down and have a conversation. Tell him there will no longer be him telling you how things get paid. You are going to sit down together, figure out what daily, weekly, monthly, and intermittent bills and costs your family has. Then, you will both put all your money (minus what you have to put back into business expenses) into that joint account. So, if you don't have one, you should do a budget for your business as well so you know how much it needs. and then save another 25% above that into a business account for emergencies.
You will figure out how much money you both have left over after the bills and expenses. Some of that will go to a joint savings account and some will go to both of you as an allowance.
And when we are talking about shared costs and expenses, we are also talking about transportation costs. If you go to the store and buy him a snack he wants out of the joint account, he can't then complain when you buy a snack at work out of the joint account.
An allowance will be if you go out without each other. If going out as a couple or with the kids, that is from the joint account. If you go out with friends or respective family alone, that is from allowance. shave needs, toiletries, etc come out of joint account. If the roof falls off, that is joint account. If someones tooth falls out, joint account.
The only thing that does not come out of joint account is grabbing lunch alone, more than 3 pairs of shoes at a time, resets yearly (barring if they are literally for work and do need to be replaced) that cute purse or wallet.
So, when making a purchase you say, "does this benefit only me or others in the home as well and how much is the cost?". If it benefits others, but his more than a threshold you both discuss and agree to, then you discuss the purchase first. (there should also be a limit on smaller purchases under the threshold if there are a lot of them) and it comes out of the joint account.
If it is just for the individual, then buy it if you want if you have enough in your allowance.
The goal from both sides should be to do what is best for the family as a whole. That means no one should be buying a ton of unnecessary items (that the average person would deem unnecessary. Some out there think toilet paper is unnecessary.) or hoarding money that the other doesn't have access to.
You have already been doing more childcare and housework than him. for him to expect to do a smaller percentage of unpaid work, but expect you to fully pay half the expenses is ridiculous. If that is the case, then hire a cleaner and a nanny and take it out of the joint account.
If he has a problem with any of this, it is because he is trying to control you with money. financial abuse. And from what you have said, verbal abuse as well.

ign0re · 04/05/2023 20:10

Paying your way is normal.

the passing judgement on what you buy/going round the house looking for anything new that you’ve bought is bonkers/controlling

Mummabear89 · 04/05/2023 20:08

This might be financial abuse. My ex was the same with me on top of physically and s£xually abusive. I was the one who was employed because he didn't want to work but he got benefits to help him. He saw my earnings as his and I was never allowed to buy anything for myself. Didn't matter if my clothes were falling apart, I was told to mend them myself. It sounds like you feel scared, you need to get out of this relationship and leave. Seek help from your local council and explain what is happening to you. They may put you and your child in protected housing for a period but thats surely better than being scared of your partner? It is not normal behaviour and you should be able to spend your leftover money how you want to.

Batalax · 04/05/2023 20:08

So what has he done with all his extra money if you pay half?
You are entitled to half his savings. Copy any statements etc before you go.

Strawberrydelight78 · 04/05/2023 20:05

Control freak I had one of them. I got out best thing I ever did.

Skodacool · 04/05/2023 20:04

Cloud991 · 04/05/2023 18:26

Thanks for all your replies. He's very obsessed with money. I tried to talk to him today and he shuts me out saying I'm always trying to pick a fight. I'm always the unreasonable one, nothing I ever do will be good enough in his eyes because I don't work full time.

He tells you that you’re always trying to pick a fight because he’s incapable of making his case rationally. He’s abusing you.

Pleezgivemestrength · 04/05/2023 20:03

This is oh so not normal. This is controlling and abusive . Why on earth did you marry this dick. I'm not married, thank god, but in the 13 years together we respect and trust each other. Why on earth do you allow yourself to be treated like this. Do you have kids? Is there a reason why you stay with him. If not, get out. I dont know you , but I am sure that you are worth more than this. ...x

Catsandallthingscrazy · 04/05/2023 20:03

I've just left a relationship like this as asmwell as everything else it's economic/ financial abuse ! Sadly in my case he was also domestically abusive ( yes occasionally violent ) so slightly different. But this is NOT normal and very much should be interpreted by you as ecomonoc abuse !

Puckthemagicdragon · 04/05/2023 20:01

Start getting on his case. A few choice remarks at things he has bought and I'm sure he'll soon back off

REignbow · 04/05/2023 19:56

He is emotionally and financially abusing you.

You realise that when he says bye or goes through the house looking for purchases this is coercive control? Any time you want to discuss the set up he says that you are starting a fight is manipulation and gaslighting?

Have you got any real life support? Could you move in with a relative?

You really need to separate. For good this time

FairyUpLiquid · 04/05/2023 19:50

Rumplestrumpet · 03/05/2023 21:17

Oh OP I see so many threads on here like this and it's never fair. Esp when the woman works part time to care for the child - of course you earn less and should contribute less- and be compensated for the work you do as "free" childcare.

You need to sit down together, look at earnings and shared outgoings (including everything for the child) and agree a fair division. And then what you spend out of your own money is no one's business as long as its not harmful to the family.

But this may not solve the problem if he is, as it appears, a nasty controlling man....

This will bells on!

This is absolutely financial abuse and I’d remind him that as you are married finances and assets would be split 50/50 during a divorce unless in extreme circumstances but you provide essential care for a sick child so he can earn his high wage. You get to spend your hard earned money on what you want after bills and if you’re able to without the threat of fear I’d be putting my foot down. The fact he goes around the house to check for the things you’ve brought is absolutely mental.

3BSHKATS · 04/05/2023 19:46

Cloud991 · 04/05/2023 19:28

We don't have a mortgage ...

Do you have any assets that would be split in the event of divorce ?

sassyclassyandsmartassy · 04/05/2023 19:44

Get out of this relationship and quickly! This is financial abuse. I had a relationship like this once (except I was the main earner and he would try to control my money).

My DH and I are very relaxed about money. We pay into the joint account (me slightly more as I am still main earner wage earner), but if we go out and spend our money whoever just pays and let’s it go, it all basically comes in and out of the ‘household’. If I need cash because I haven’t got any on me he’ll just give me it out of his wallet and vice versa, we just don’t really think about it. Same with anything his son wants/needs, I will pay if I want to get it for him…

Money can be the route of all evil if it’s a ‘thing’ in a relationship, it’s a non negotiable that you both have to be on the same page about!

dementedmummy · 04/05/2023 19:41

So a couple of things from a fellow self employed person....
*Self employed is like having a job with none of the perks - no holiday pay, no employee contribution to pension and no sick pay and a wing on a prayer for what you bring in every month

  • Does he pay half of what he earns into the joint account? If not, what you are experiencing is at best a control freak DH and at worst financial abuse with gaslighting about usage of funds *Desperation for money smacks to me of financial trouble on your dh's part. Do you see mail coming in? Are there reminders about bills? Is he actually using your money to pay the bills or is he doing something else like gambling, matched betting, bitcoin etc so is always playing catch up and that is why he is always chasing you so his lies cannot be uncovered?
  • In any event, this isn't working. We always did a percentage basis of earnings for contribution to bills with me taking the higher amount to contribute when he went part time to look after our kids when I went back to work. Best of luck x
Viviennemary · 04/05/2023 19:38

Depends what your contibution is. Can you afford to be self-employed.

Conkersinautumn · 04/05/2023 19:33

Yeah my EX used to go on about what I owed for the mortgage when I was contributing less in my maternity leave, whilst he didn't buy a single item of baby items. Funnily enough I found myself cutting my maternity short because I'd shot through my savings much quicker than I'd planned for. I then paid childcare. The trouble is with this sort is once their gone you won't see a penny either, they don't give a shit what happens to your kids and my ex tried to fuck me over on the house sale too. Be very careful with paperwork now.

Sceptre86 · 04/05/2023 19:33

Many people will have different set ups. So some will have a joint account into which both incomes go and everything is split down the middle. Some will have joint accounts for bills, some will have completely separate finances. It's not other people's set up that is important, it's how you feel about yours. This upsets you so isn't the way forward. Also checking what purchases you make isn't normal. He comes across as stingy and controlling which are unpleasant character traits. If you need a more reliable income op then look for part time work that would suit you. Appreciate you might have to make compromises but surely there is better out there for you than this.

FootieMama · 04/05/2023 19:32

Well, this could be written: My husband wants me to contribute with a fixed monthly amount to the household's bills. I am unresponsible and sometimes don't pay in time and expend my money instead on things for myself. My husbands looks around for things I buy and try to his from him. Of course he maybe financially abusive but it depends a lot of wether you are responsible with money and not a liability that wants to be financed by his.

Cloud991 · 04/05/2023 19:29

@Toomanylatenightprogs thanks I will look into contacting them

OP posts:
Cloud991 · 04/05/2023 19:28

We don't have a mortgage ...

OP posts:
3BSHKATS · 04/05/2023 19:23

Cloud991 · 04/05/2023 19:16

I split up with him in the summer but ended up taking him back because I panicked and a number of things were really difficult for me to manage on my own. And now I feel more stuck than ever. I'm constantly doubting myself and think maybe I'm being unreasonable.
Also is it weird that whenever I go into another room in the hosie he says 'bye' to me multiple times ...it makes me feel really uncomfortable and I don't know how to respond.

I disagree with those say pick bills and food and buy that instead of paying into the joint account - if you get divorced you need evidence you contributed to the mortgage.
We split over covid and I couldn't access a previously closed account from which I'd paid the mortgage for 5 years. Ex told the judge I'd just paid for the kids clothes, toys and food and the odd bill for 15 years and SHE believed him.

"Just" the children's costs counts for nothing, make sure you are paying towards the assets.

Toomanylatenightprogs · 04/05/2023 19:22

Also is it weird that whenever I go into another room in the hosie he says 'bye' to me multiple times ...it makes me feel really uncomfortable and I don't know how to respond.

As if he’s dismissing you, or giving you permission to leave.
He really is horribly abusive @Cloud991 , emotionally, financially.
Suggest you contact Women’s Aid, speak to them then work through your plan to leave. Your husband is not going to get any better, and your life could be so much better without him.

Hayliebells · 04/05/2023 19:21

How far off being possible to manage, are these things that were difficult to manage when you separated? That's what I'd put all my energy into, getting myself in a position where it's possible to leave, then leaving asap. Your DH sounds like a controlling bully, and ime (my father was similar), men like that won't change. The only thing to be done is to leave.

Swipe left for the next trending thread