Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this isn't ok in a marriage?

304 replies

Cloud991 · 03/05/2023 20:42

I'm really struggling with my dh's behaviour... All sorts of things but this is about our finances. I have no experience of how other married couples sort out finances so I don't know if this is normal...

Every month, my dh makes me pay a certain amount of what I earn into our joint account to go towards bills, whatever's left I can keep. The issue is I'm self employed and income can vary but he never cuts me any slack and will remind me how much I owe etc. If we buy anything else, he reminds me to send over my half towards it and if this isn't done quickly, he will nag me in a nasty way for it. Even the rest of the money I have after I've paid my share of the bills, he passes judgement on anything I buy and when he comes home from work, the first thing he does is to go round the house to check if I've bought anything. I feel very stressed all the time. Is this a normal set up because I feel like it's not ok but he says it is.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Jojofjo44 · 10/05/2023 14:00

Absolutely not normal, very controlling behaviour. This is financial abuse.

JudgeRudy · 10/05/2023 10:28

JudgeRudy · 10/05/2023 10:11

I think it's reasonable to pay half of the household expenses. If I thought I couldn't do this I'd be having a conversation before I committed to the mirtgage/outgoings/lifestyle. Of course it would be usual to support someone you care about when they're struggling, but your work situation sounds like a predictable occurance. I know many couples contribute pro rata to their income, which is fine too but I don't think it's fair to change the 'rules' midway.

Checking what you've bought, now that sounds plain odd. If you have a habit though of buying things from joint money with no discussion then id say this is more a trust than control issue. Maybe you're complaining you're short of money but then have spent £100 on some pillows. You're entitled to do that, but it would be a bit unfair to expect someone else to then subsidise you.

Posts like yours make me focus less on the situation, snd more on yhe build up. How did you find yourself in this situation? What's changed to make you dissatisfied with the arrangent now?

Apologies, I have re-read and see that you have household/family responsibilities which are affecting your earning potential. Under these circumstances it would be usual for your financial contribution to reduce.
Obviously I don't know your commitments but it doesn't sound like you're broke. If your mortgage is paid off that's a huge advantage, so lm assuming it's the attitude of your OH more than the financial penalty.
You're unhappy and he sounds unlikely to change so why don't you split up? You said you did once but found it hard managing so went back to your usual. Just something to consider but are you an anxious person, or maybe a bit younger than him. Does he view you more as a 'charge' than an equal, that he has to 'look after' you because you can't manage? If any of that rings true it could explain his behaviour. It might also mean youll be 'stuck' and unable to achieve your full potential. I think if your OH died you would cope. If this isn't the marriage you want(and are showcasing for your child) then separate. You have half a home, and a job and would be entitled to child maintenance which would allow you to take out a small mortgage. You could then live your life as you like

JudgeRudy · 10/05/2023 10:11

I think it's reasonable to pay half of the household expenses. If I thought I couldn't do this I'd be having a conversation before I committed to the mirtgage/outgoings/lifestyle. Of course it would be usual to support someone you care about when they're struggling, but your work situation sounds like a predictable occurance. I know many couples contribute pro rata to their income, which is fine too but I don't think it's fair to change the 'rules' midway.

Checking what you've bought, now that sounds plain odd. If you have a habit though of buying things from joint money with no discussion then id say this is more a trust than control issue. Maybe you're complaining you're short of money but then have spent £100 on some pillows. You're entitled to do that, but it would be a bit unfair to expect someone else to then subsidise you.

Posts like yours make me focus less on the situation, snd more on yhe build up. How did you find yourself in this situation? What's changed to make you dissatisfied with the arrangent now?

newnamethanks · 10/05/2023 09:58

Normal for him, evidently, but not for anyone else. My sympathy. If you can move him on, do so.

Cloud991 · 10/05/2023 09:52

@RK800 sorry you are also going through something similar. Is you DH controlling in other ways?

OP posts:
RK800 · 10/05/2023 08:55

Thanks @billy1966 really appreciate your candid response, I really needed to hear that.

billy1966 · 10/05/2023 08:47

OP, he is abusive and that will never change.

Get out while you can and are childless.

He is a nasty controlling mean man.

This is your future.

billy1966 · 10/05/2023 08:45

RK800 · 10/05/2023 07:09

Stumbled across this thread and unfortunately I think I’m in a similar situation but I feel so confused that I don’t know what’s acceptable and it just makes me feel so stupid.

DP and I have our salaries paid into out joint account and then we draw out a monthly allowance to spend on whatever. I don’t mind this tbh as it means all bills are paid and we have a decent amount to go into savings.

What I do have an issue with is that any purchase from our joint account, for example buying some trainers for our DD, he said we should discuss first. I’m talking less than £12 for some decent trainers that apparently should be discussed before purchasing. Totally agree that big purchases should be discussed but I feel like I need permission to buy clothes for our children.

Would appreciate some insight from others as I’m so lost and don’t have anyone to talk to IRL. And sorry OP for high jacking your thread.

So you need to discuss money you actually earn?

This is financially controlling.

This is not healthy nor normal.

You need to talk to Women's aid.

You earn a salary why are you discussing how you spend it?

Start having your salary paid into your own account.

You have very poor boundaries and self respect if you think it is normal for a partner to tell you what you can spend money you earned on, right down to tiny amounts.

No doubt he is controlling in other ways.

Does he get your permission for every small amount?

You have brought a child into a very controlling unhealthy environment.

Take it very seriously.
It will only get worse.

Do not have another child with him.

Call Womens aid.

You deserve better.

RK800 · 10/05/2023 07:09

Stumbled across this thread and unfortunately I think I’m in a similar situation but I feel so confused that I don’t know what’s acceptable and it just makes me feel so stupid.

DP and I have our salaries paid into out joint account and then we draw out a monthly allowance to spend on whatever. I don’t mind this tbh as it means all bills are paid and we have a decent amount to go into savings.

What I do have an issue with is that any purchase from our joint account, for example buying some trainers for our DD, he said we should discuss first. I’m talking less than £12 for some decent trainers that apparently should be discussed before purchasing. Totally agree that big purchases should be discussed but I feel like I need permission to buy clothes for our children.

Would appreciate some insight from others as I’m so lost and don’t have anyone to talk to IRL. And sorry OP for high jacking your thread.

Stewball01 · 10/05/2023 05:54

This.

porridgeisbae · 10/05/2023 00:42

@Cloud991 I have severe mental health problems (bipolar etc) and admittedly don't happen to have had children but I live alone and manage my life fine. I mightn't have the greatest of housework standards but everything else is ok.

If I need help I contact MH services. They tweak my meds a bit and all is fine.

You can do it xx

joycies · 09/05/2023 17:11

There are loads of comments here about why he treats you like this: I find that irrelevant - the way he treats you is abusive and that's it really all you need to accept: If he won't talk about this issue politelly then things aren't likely to improve: Thieway of thinking is what our Grandmas had to putup with but not these days:

Pixiedust1234 · 08/05/2023 20:30

He will hold it against you, thats guaranteed.

Again, what overwhelmed you so much that you took this man back? Let us help you.

Cloud991 · 08/05/2023 20:23

Thanks for everyone's replies. He did agree to reduce my contribution to the bills but it's hard for me not to feel as though he will hold this against me. I'm feeling very burnt out by everything I have to do and the mental load I feel I'm carrying

OP posts:
PeachyPeachTrees · 08/05/2023 09:27

He's not going to change and if you stay, you will be miserable forever.

joycies · 06/05/2023 18:13

I think 'hobby job' for work from home is in the class of saying 'blind' instead of visually impaired.

joycies · 06/05/2023 18:10

100% agree with Rosejasmine.

Madamum18 · 06/05/2023 15:58

Thanks for all your replies. He's very obsessed with money. I tried to talk to him today and he shuts me out saying I'm always trying to pick a fight. I'm always the unreasonable one, nothing I ever do will be good enough in his eyes

He is gas lighting you! And no, his behaviour is NOT normal; it is abusive. Flowers

Rosejasmine · 06/05/2023 07:00

Well of course you know this isn’t normal.
If you divorce you will be so much better off and he will also be forced to support you and your child financially with no say whatsoever as to how you spend your money. He doesn’t care or help you around the house or with childcare so what have you actually got to lose?
I don’t think there is any saving a relationship like this because he doesn’t care at all about your wellbeing.

You have a chronic illness and instead of supporting you he’s making you stressed? Kicking off about paying for a bus fare - really?? This is not a man with any shred of perspective or decency.
What would happen if you had to stop working entirely due to illness? Would the control get even worse and maybe even move in to something else?
It’s not just about money it’s about power and control and keeping you in your place, it’s abuse.
What a horrible situation for you - I feel for you and your life will be so much better on your own with your child. It’s got good for them to grow up in this nasty atmosphere with an oppressed mum.

Cariadm · 05/05/2023 19:34

Ellyess · 05/05/2023 13:17

Dear Cloud991,
I've put together some of the helpful information you gave:
"I just work part time because we also have a 2 year old and I have a chronic illness. Yes I do feel like a slave, I do everything in the house and garden, admin, dealing with problems etc
he shuts me out saying I'm always trying to pick a fight. I'm always the unreasonable one, nothing I ever do will be good enough in his eyes because I don't work full time.
Whenever I go into another room in the hosie he says 'bye' to me multiple times ."

Now,

  1. Can you see he is not logical? That is my polite way of saying he is unreasonable.
  2. How can anyone say you "don't work full time." when you have a 2 year old, and run a business and do everything in the house and garden, admin, dealing with problems etc????? On top of which you have a chronic illness. No wonder you are ill! Seriously, doing all that and being harassed and bullied too, anyone would be ill.
  3. Number 3 does suggest he is not normal, surely! Unless it is some kind of pet-joke between the two of you... which you would have told us.
I was very blunt first time. I am so sorry you are going through this. These kinds of men actually choose their victims. They test us to see how easy it will be to bully us and make us feel everything is our fault. I'll never forget the first time I should have realised my then future husband was a deadly danger to me. I was 17, he was 30, we were 'playing leapfrog' he came thundering down the hill, put his hands on the side of my back and pushed my 8 stone body with all his 18 stone so that I flew off my feet and hit the ground hard hitting my head. Immediately he started screaming at me, berating me for 'deliberately falling over' and risking him getting hurt! I was devastated. I could not take it in.

You might think, your husband has never done anything like that. Believe me, he is like that. He sees the world only from his own perspective and you are his plaything in the way some people like being cruel to someone weaker, younger, smaller, kinder, easier to bully. He is using you for a free ride. Please leave him. If you have nowhere to go, get advice, see a Solicitor, get a divorce. I promise you he will only get worse.
I am so sorry. But as soon as you start to look after yourself you will feel better.
Sending you lots of love and prayers.

I second that advice 100% and said more or less the same thing to her myself! He is a lost cause and she needs to wake up and smell the roses before he moves on to the next level, because, as we can almost certainly predict, he probably will? I grew up in a violent household in the 50's and it still haunts me with pictures in my head that will never fade...if she can't do it for herself she needs to get away from him for her child.😥😱

WindUpPenguin · 05/05/2023 15:42

Every month, my dh makes me pay a certain amount of what I earn into our joint account to go towards bills, whatever's left I can keep.

This bit is possibly normal. DH and I both contribute a set amount to our joint accounts for bills, food shop, shared expenses etc. However, we have both agreed on this set amount, and although DH did the sums and came up with the figures, I would never say he 'makes' me pay £x...

The rest of it gets less and less normal, and by the time you get to "when he comes home from work, the first thing he does is to go round the house to check if I've bought anything" it's completely bonkers and clear that he is financially controlling and abusive.

lljkk · 05/05/2023 15:32

Very hard not to simply say LTB.
You're not convincing us that you need this guy in your home, OP.

Pixiedust1234 · 05/05/2023 15:29

I split up with him in the summer but ended up taking him back because I panicked and a number of things were really difficult for me to manage on my own.

@Cloud991 if you are still reading this. Can you tell us (even in a new thread) what you find difficult to manage on your own so you had to take an abuser back? I bet my last penny there will be others who experienced the same problems but have worked out an easy way to deal with it,

Let us help so you can leave 💕

Ellyess · 05/05/2023 13:34

Dear Cloud991 You could, of course, charge for your two other jobs besides your part-time business.
Explain to him, you don't engage in full-time paid employment because you are doing two unpaid jobs, i.e. looking after your 2 year old and all the house keeping, cleaning, gardening etc. For you to work elsewhere full time it would require 2 or 3 other people to be paid to fill these roles you cover right now.
Meanwhile, you will deduct X per hour for XX hours of whatever a Nanny costs per week and XX per week for Housekeeping work plus gardening, cooking etc. I won't estimate here but other MN members will know the current rate for Nannies and Cleaners and Gardeners etc. I paid my Gardener £20 per hour 5 years ago. But remember you are not just a Cleaner, you cook, plan, organise, indeed run the house.
I'm guessing that the amount you are saving the family income by covering these vital roles yourself greatly exceeds any amount he asks from your income from your part-time business.
Please do this.
Value yourself.

Ellyess · 05/05/2023 13:17

Dear Cloud991,
I've put together some of the helpful information you gave:
"I just work part time because we also have a 2 year old and I have a chronic illness. Yes I do feel like a slave, I do everything in the house and garden, admin, dealing with problems etc
he shuts me out saying I'm always trying to pick a fight. I'm always the unreasonable one, nothing I ever do will be good enough in his eyes because I don't work full time.
Whenever I go into another room in the hosie he says 'bye' to me multiple times ."

Now,

  1. Can you see he is not logical? That is my polite way of saying he is unreasonable.
  2. How can anyone say you "don't work full time." when you have a 2 year old, and run a business and do everything in the house and garden, admin, dealing with problems etc????? On top of which you have a chronic illness. No wonder you are ill! Seriously, doing all that and being harassed and bullied too, anyone would be ill.
  3. Number 3 does suggest he is not normal, surely! Unless it is some kind of pet-joke between the two of you... which you would have told us.
I was very blunt first time. I am so sorry you are going through this. These kinds of men actually choose their victims. They test us to see how easy it will be to bully us and make us feel everything is our fault. I'll never forget the first time I should have realised my then future husband was a deadly danger to me. I was 17, he was 30, we were 'playing leapfrog' he came thundering down the hill, put his hands on the side of my back and pushed my 8 stone body with all his 18 stone so that I flew off my feet and hit the ground hard hitting my head. Immediately he started screaming at me, berating me for 'deliberately falling over' and risking him getting hurt! I was devastated. I could not take it in.

You might think, your husband has never done anything like that. Believe me, he is like that. He sees the world only from his own perspective and you are his plaything in the way some people like being cruel to someone weaker, younger, smaller, kinder, easier to bully. He is using you for a free ride. Please leave him. If you have nowhere to go, get advice, see a Solicitor, get a divorce. I promise you he will only get worse.
I am so sorry. But as soon as you start to look after yourself you will feel better.
Sending you lots of love and prayers.