Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

UC think my tenancy agreement is fraudulent/contrived. Advice please

113 replies

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 19:18

I have just moved in to a privately rented property. I do not know the landlord personally and had never spoken to them before in my life until I applied to the advert on the open rent website.

I receive (atleast I did) the housing element of universal credit to help me to pay my rent.

When I moved in I uploaded the tenancy agreement on my UC portal as advised. They came back to me and said I need to provide evidence of my address and housing costs.

I was confused as the rent etc is all detailed in the tenancy however the landlord promptly wrote me a signed letter addressed to me at the new place FAO universal credit with the required details to support my claim.

Somebody called me the next day to clarify a few points (making sure I don't know the landlord personally, asking who else lives with me etc)

I answered honestly and UC said they'd get back to me shortly with a decision on my housing costs. That decision came back and the verdict was they would not be paying my housing costs. A generic letter was put up on my UC portal saying I hadn't provided enough evidence to satisfy them that I lived where I said I live and haven't shown evidence of housing costs(??)

Confused, I called them pretty upset and said I don't know what's going on here but I've done everything asked of me. The UC representative was sympathetic and said she would escalate it to a manager who would look at the claim.

Days later I check my UC portal and the decision has come back exactly the same. I'm entitled to my personal entitlement but no housing costs.

I contact them again, and again, and eventually they make an appointment for me to take my documents (IE tenancy etc) to be verified at my local job centre - that appointment was today.

I arrive there at 1pm with my tenancy agreement and some new documents I've been able to collect (a council headed letter regarding my children's school meals, more paperwork from the energy company) and before I've even sat down the advisor tells me that it's already gone above his head and the decision maker has rejected the housing element of my claim.

I'm completely baffled by this point and ask him what the problem is. He said there was several things "the decision makers" weren't happy with, a spelling mistake of the landlords name was one thing he mentioned but he offered no further context. He went on to say that during lockdown they saw a huge influx of fraudulent / contrived claims and now they leave no stone left unturned. He asked whether I could provide anything else. I said well no I've only been here just over a week I don't have anything else.

I'm then reminded of the tenancy deposit protection scheme and he asked whether I could provide the certificate for that. I was able to and said of course. He added a "to do" task for me on my journal which was exactly the same "to do" as I've done three times now (uploading the same documents) and said I could ask for a mandatory reconsideration and I'm now at the mercy of the same decision maker again I think.

If they reject it again I won't be able to remain here as I can't afford to.

I don't know what's going on here. I don't know the landlord personally. I'm not trying to defraud anybody of anything. I'm a lone parent who has never had any issues with the housing element of UC and now I may be at risk of homelessness.

Landlord is equally as dumbfounded. We are both completely genuine.

What on earth am I going to do?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Babyroobs · 03/05/2023 21:35

Babyroobs · 03/05/2023 21:32

That is a routine question asked on a few benefit forms though. I guess he could be living with a partner who is claiming as single and he is making sure he is registered at another address so he's not linked to her !

This kind of benefit fraud is pretty common. My adult ds's gf's mum was doing this and ds and his gf were renting her new partners house and they wanted his name left on the CT bill to look like he was still living there so she could claim as a lone parent ! My ds and gf wanted it all above board with their names on the CT bill but her mum just kept saying "leave it as it is as it includes the single person discount ". they quickly moved back home with me !

Babyroobs · 03/05/2023 21:32

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 21:27

Potentially yes. Unless he has only picked up the C Tax bill while the property was empty (but why not send it to the address he lives at? It is possible) then he could be claiming to live at the property that is also being let to you

WOW something just clicked.. the DWP lady who called me to go over the details of my housing costs specifically asked me whether the landlord lives here with me!

I thought that was a routine question, but if the landlord was thought to live here that would totally explain the question wouldn't it!

And ofc they wouldn't pay my housing costs if they think I'm living with the landlord...

That is a routine question asked on a few benefit forms though. I guess he could be living with a partner who is claiming as single and he is making sure he is registered at another address so he's not linked to her !

2bazookas · 03/05/2023 21:29

It sounds to me as if you've been given the runaround by more than one jobsworth.

Take this complaint to your local MP at their constituency office. I would start with a clear written account of what's happened (similar to your OP here) and request the MP's to take up the issue on your behalf.

IME, the involvement of my MP had electrifying results on the DWP.

I hope you noted the name of every person you've been dealing with; and the date of each contact.

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 21:27

Potentially yes. Unless he has only picked up the C Tax bill while the property was empty (but why not send it to the address he lives at? It is possible) then he could be claiming to live at the property that is also being let to you

WOW something just clicked.. the DWP lady who called me to go over the details of my housing costs specifically asked me whether the landlord lives here with me!

I thought that was a routine question, but if the landlord was thought to live here that would totally explain the question wouldn't it!

And ofc they wouldn't pay my housing costs if they think I'm living with the landlord...

OP posts:
Babyroobs · 03/05/2023 21:24

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 21:21

The letter in question with all identifying information removed obviously.

Am I clutching at straws?

If the council tax reminder is addressed to the landlord then that suggests that the last tenant perhaps never switched it to his name ? No idea why though. It does all sound a bit dodgy to be honest.

HobnobsChoice · 03/05/2023 21:23

Potentially yes. Unless he has only picked up the C Tax bill while the property was empty (but why not send it to the address he lives at? It is possible) then he could be claiming to live at the property that is also being let to you.

When I rented and had to make a claim for housing benefit after being made redundant(pre UC) I had put down what I thought was my landlady's name on the forms. It was actually her mother's property that was being rented out to provide some income towards carehome fees so she didn't show on the land registry as the owner. They had to provide all their details of the power of attorney, land registry/deeds etc for my claim to be valid

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 21:21

The letter in question with all identifying information removed obviously.

Am I clutching at straws?

UC think my tenancy agreement is fraudulent/contrived. Advice please
OP posts:
Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 21:16

Council tax reminder that's what it is. Addressed to landlord. The front says

"Your home is at risk if you ignore this notice"

Relevant or not?

OP posts:
Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 21:15

Some other considerations as I've been wracking my brain..

When I moved in there was a large stack of unopened letters addressed to multiple people. I've counted 4 different surnames and then some addressed to the landlord personally.

Landlord said they'll need to be picked up as there's some important ones that need to be tended to.

One in particular caught my eye due to what was written on it, something about "final notice you could lose your home" or something like that. I didn't think anything of it at the time as its obviously not addressed to me.. but now I'm wondering whether that's something to do with it and the fact there's loads of post to different people?

OP posts:
FuckNuggets · 03/05/2023 21:08

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 20:55

It has been a very stressful week for sure. I will say though, this aside, I've never had any other problems with UC whatsoever and I've been under them for a good few years now. This is the first time anything has ever gone wrong for me so don't let that discourage you from switching if you'll be better off

Thanks! But it's probably not worth it anyway, my youngest dd is nearly 17 so my claim will be ending in around 18 months - 2 years when she leaves full-time education anyway.

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 21:01

Babyroobs · 03/05/2023 20:57

This is worrying. No-one really gets refused for UC unless the DWP suddenly find hidden funds of more than 16k which had not been declared or they are found to have no recourse to public funds or something and therefore not eligible due to their immigration status..

It's very unusual isn't it?

I have many working friends who have been able to claim supplemental universal credit with no problem whatsoever.

There was no problem whatsoever with me getting housing costs at the old place.

OP posts:
Babyroobs · 03/05/2023 20:57

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 20:50

Gosh I really hope there is nothing to worry about on the landlords side. If there is then it's way beyond my control isn't it. I'll be screwed.

The property is the landlords former home, then it was rented out to tenants previous to me. Previous tenant was here for 6 years with no problems so I'm told.

She moved on and the next applicant who applied to live here was refused for universal credit so that fell through and the property was advertised again - to which I applied.

I wonder if the clue lies in the fact the other applicant was refused for UC? I dont know any further details as to why they couldn't get it. I wonder if they had the same problem as me!

Landlord seems completely genuine to me. Everything done above board. All gas safety checks etc completed and given to me. Deposit protected. Very down to earth, helpful, wanted everything done above board.

I have no idea what the problem may be but now you've mentioned it, maybe there is something they've found and are holding back from telling me because I know I haven't done anything wrong 😐

This is worrying. No-one really gets refused for UC unless the DWP suddenly find hidden funds of more than 16k which had not been declared or they are found to have no recourse to public funds or something and therefore not eligible due to their immigration status..

Babyroobs · 03/05/2023 20:55

FuckNuggets · 03/05/2023 20:52

It's things like this that put me off applying for UC. I'm currently still getting tax credits, but I'd be about £80 per week better off on UC. I'd rather have less money and know for certain I'm getting paid every week than be at the mercy of some jumped-up little jobsworth.

In my experience there are plenty of jumped up little jobsworths at HMRC too ! They will likely all be switched over to DWP when everyone is migrated over by the end of 2024.

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 20:55

FuckNuggets · 03/05/2023 20:52

It's things like this that put me off applying for UC. I'm currently still getting tax credits, but I'd be about £80 per week better off on UC. I'd rather have less money and know for certain I'm getting paid every week than be at the mercy of some jumped-up little jobsworth.

It has been a very stressful week for sure. I will say though, this aside, I've never had any other problems with UC whatsoever and I've been under them for a good few years now. This is the first time anything has ever gone wrong for me so don't let that discourage you from switching if you'll be better off

OP posts:
Babyroobs · 03/05/2023 20:53

Mydcchangedmyusername · 03/05/2023 20:40

As someone said, the landlord not filling the paper correctly must have cuased a problem. It could be that the landlord is not 100% genuine in some way and that's blowing back on you, with them thinking you're in on it. They wouldn't really tell you exactly what they've found because they often don't want that person to then go and rectify their ways in order to get away with it (if the person is being shady, that is).

I'm sorry that you're going through this though with dc. It must be really distressing. I hope they sort you out so you and the dc can settle in.

This.

FuckNuggets · 03/05/2023 20:52

It's things like this that put me off applying for UC. I'm currently still getting tax credits, but I'd be about £80 per week better off on UC. I'd rather have less money and know for certain I'm getting paid every week than be at the mercy of some jumped-up little jobsworth.

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 20:50

Mydcchangedmyusername · 03/05/2023 20:40

As someone said, the landlord not filling the paper correctly must have cuased a problem. It could be that the landlord is not 100% genuine in some way and that's blowing back on you, with them thinking you're in on it. They wouldn't really tell you exactly what they've found because they often don't want that person to then go and rectify their ways in order to get away with it (if the person is being shady, that is).

I'm sorry that you're going through this though with dc. It must be really distressing. I hope they sort you out so you and the dc can settle in.

Gosh I really hope there is nothing to worry about on the landlords side. If there is then it's way beyond my control isn't it. I'll be screwed.

The property is the landlords former home, then it was rented out to tenants previous to me. Previous tenant was here for 6 years with no problems so I'm told.

She moved on and the next applicant who applied to live here was refused for universal credit so that fell through and the property was advertised again - to which I applied.

I wonder if the clue lies in the fact the other applicant was refused for UC? I dont know any further details as to why they couldn't get it. I wonder if they had the same problem as me!

Landlord seems completely genuine to me. Everything done above board. All gas safety checks etc completed and given to me. Deposit protected. Very down to earth, helpful, wanted everything done above board.

I have no idea what the problem may be but now you've mentioned it, maybe there is something they've found and are holding back from telling me because I know I haven't done anything wrong 😐

OP posts:
Mydcchangedmyusername · 03/05/2023 20:40

As someone said, the landlord not filling the paper correctly must have cuased a problem. It could be that the landlord is not 100% genuine in some way and that's blowing back on you, with them thinking you're in on it. They wouldn't really tell you exactly what they've found because they often don't want that person to then go and rectify their ways in order to get away with it (if the person is being shady, that is).

I'm sorry that you're going through this though with dc. It must be really distressing. I hope they sort you out so you and the dc can settle in.

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 20:20

Also, I have asked them several times on the journal to tell me what it is they actually want me to provide that I'm not providing but they just won't do it. They won't give me any context, instructions, anything, just repeating the same rubbish and then rejecting my evidence.

OP posts:
Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 20:17

I've just sent a lengthy email to my local M.P

The most recent decision, IE housing costs rejected, was the decision yes. I have asked for a mandatory reconsideration today. It's encouraging to know it'll go to a different decision maker.

If this mandatory reconsideration is rejected is that the end of the road or can I continue to appeal against the decision?

What evidence do you need for payment and liability conditions? I assume the occupation condition evidence is the tenancy agreement.

Payment liability conditions - proof of how much the rent is, how often it's due and how its paid. All of that information is available within the tenancy agreement but I've provided an additional letter from the landlord reiterating all of those points.

The advisor in the job centre today said "with all due respect anybody could go and type up a letter and tenancy agreement and say its legitimate"

I mean sure, they certainly could, but I'm a genuine claimant and that's a genuine AST.

I really really hope the deposit protection scheme certificate tips the balance.

OP posts:
Pixiedust1234 · 03/05/2023 19:57

I would definitely try Shelter or CAB.

I notice they have emboldened the word "all" conditions. What evidence do you need for payment and liability conditions? I assume the occupation condition evidence is the tenancy agreement.

lashy · 03/05/2023 19:56

Odd that the landlord would spell their own name with an error in it. I can understand why that might potentially ring alarm bells, but suspect there must be more than that alone that does not tally. Quite possibly the Tenancy Agreement has not been completed correctly by the landlord (happens surprisingly often).

Regarding a Mandatory Reconsideration - it would be carried out by a different Decision Maker (otherwise could be bias, or perceived to be bias if the original decision is upheld).

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 19:54

I'm just going to try and find an email contact for my local MP, thank you!

OP posts:
Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 19:53

Startyabastard · 03/05/2023 19:51

Bastards. I've had similar and can empathise. Sorry no advice xxx

Can I ask what happened in your case? Was it eventually rectified?

OP posts: