Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

UC think my tenancy agreement is fraudulent/contrived. Advice please

113 replies

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 19:18

I have just moved in to a privately rented property. I do not know the landlord personally and had never spoken to them before in my life until I applied to the advert on the open rent website.

I receive (atleast I did) the housing element of universal credit to help me to pay my rent.

When I moved in I uploaded the tenancy agreement on my UC portal as advised. They came back to me and said I need to provide evidence of my address and housing costs.

I was confused as the rent etc is all detailed in the tenancy however the landlord promptly wrote me a signed letter addressed to me at the new place FAO universal credit with the required details to support my claim.

Somebody called me the next day to clarify a few points (making sure I don't know the landlord personally, asking who else lives with me etc)

I answered honestly and UC said they'd get back to me shortly with a decision on my housing costs. That decision came back and the verdict was they would not be paying my housing costs. A generic letter was put up on my UC portal saying I hadn't provided enough evidence to satisfy them that I lived where I said I live and haven't shown evidence of housing costs(??)

Confused, I called them pretty upset and said I don't know what's going on here but I've done everything asked of me. The UC representative was sympathetic and said she would escalate it to a manager who would look at the claim.

Days later I check my UC portal and the decision has come back exactly the same. I'm entitled to my personal entitlement but no housing costs.

I contact them again, and again, and eventually they make an appointment for me to take my documents (IE tenancy etc) to be verified at my local job centre - that appointment was today.

I arrive there at 1pm with my tenancy agreement and some new documents I've been able to collect (a council headed letter regarding my children's school meals, more paperwork from the energy company) and before I've even sat down the advisor tells me that it's already gone above his head and the decision maker has rejected the housing element of my claim.

I'm completely baffled by this point and ask him what the problem is. He said there was several things "the decision makers" weren't happy with, a spelling mistake of the landlords name was one thing he mentioned but he offered no further context. He went on to say that during lockdown they saw a huge influx of fraudulent / contrived claims and now they leave no stone left unturned. He asked whether I could provide anything else. I said well no I've only been here just over a week I don't have anything else.

I'm then reminded of the tenancy deposit protection scheme and he asked whether I could provide the certificate for that. I was able to and said of course. He added a "to do" task for me on my journal which was exactly the same "to do" as I've done three times now (uploading the same documents) and said I could ask for a mandatory reconsideration and I'm now at the mercy of the same decision maker again I think.

If they reject it again I won't be able to remain here as I can't afford to.

I don't know what's going on here. I don't know the landlord personally. I'm not trying to defraud anybody of anything. I'm a lone parent who has never had any issues with the housing element of UC and now I may be at risk of homelessness.

Landlord is equally as dumbfounded. We are both completely genuine.

What on earth am I going to do?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 23:06

Whichnumbers · 03/05/2023 22:56

Council tax will not chase you for any owed tax before the date you moved in. It will have a different account number, even though it’s fir the same property

i would guess your multiple names on envelops means a few to many UC claims for rent have been received ^in to short a time* for that particular address and the question of “do you live with your LL, and that’s set a bell off at the job Center - thus the man’s comment about “ well you could just print out a tenancy agreement

go to council and put in a claim for DHP asap as UC are not paying your rent element, it’ll take a while but might help you and you have nothing to lose trying.

I've actually already tried to apply for a DHP and haven't heard a peep back dispite the site saying I'll hear back within 7 days.

I sent the DHP online form off on the 24th April as I already knew that the LHA wouldn't cover the entirety of the rent so I was trying to be proactive and having that in place for when my housing element of UC was sorted (as I had no idea of the shit storm I was about to encounter and thought the UC would be up and running within days)

There isn't a massive shortfall between the LHA and the rent but it's enough to make things a bit tight for a while until I'm back to work properly.

But yeah, I haven't heard back from them at all regarding the small top up I was asking for.

I'm going to get on the phone to the council tomorrow and go through a few things with them.

OP posts:
AfraidToRun · 03/05/2023 22:59

You can also go to prison for not paying council tax... but you'd only be liable from move in date. So you've done everything you need to. No reason why you should be punished.

I think MP and/or councilor could work wonders here

LangClegsInSpace · 03/05/2023 22:57

The mandatory reconsideration is the most important next step. Did you ask for this verbally in a meeting? If so, follow up in writing in your journal.

You are also entitled to a full statement of reasons which, from the images you posted, you have not yet had, so ask for this asap. This should shed some light on exactly what has gone wrong.

The good news about mandatory reconsideration is it gets looked at by a different decision maker. The bad news is there's no time limit for how long they get to reconsider. If the decision comes back the same you can appeal. It's worth seeking help at this stage, sometimes you can get free representation.

Not many decisions are overturned at the MR stage unless there's a glaringly obvious fault but from what you have written, your claim may fall into that category.

Meanwhile pay what you can towards your rent and keep your LL in the loop.

Whichnumbers · 03/05/2023 22:56

Council tax will not chase you for any owed tax before the date you moved in. It will have a different account number, even though it’s fir the same property

i would guess your multiple names on envelops means a few to many UC claims for rent have been received ^in to short a time* for that particular address and the question of “do you live with your LL, and that’s set a bell off at the job Center - thus the man’s comment about “ well you could just print out a tenancy agreement

go to council and put in a claim for DHP asap as UC are not paying your rent element, it’ll take a while but might help you and you have nothing to lose trying.

Kona84 · 03/05/2023 22:48

I reckon that the landlords residential details are the property you are renting.
she may be registered to vote and obv for council tax there.
I can’t imagine how she could be so behind with council tax for it to say home at risk if she has had tenants in for 6 years.
the tenant is liable for any arrears not the landlord.

I also think open rent is quite easily open to fraudulent tenancies been set up, meaning if I had a room to rent out I could easily list it, rent it to my partner and then create a tenancy document so maybe UC are more cautious around open rent tenancy agreements

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 22:39

Oh bollocks I've put the wrong move in date on the council tax form, I put March instead of April. That's something else I'll need to chase up and sort out now. Argh. What a bloody week.

OP posts:
Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 22:34

JanglyBeads · 03/05/2023 22:28

Shelter are brilliant and have loads of info on their website.

I'm on there as I type! It seems v helpful definitely

OP posts:
Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 22:33

Thank you all for the suggestions and support 🙂

I've just sent off the online form to the council telling them when I moved in. I made a point of mentioning the letter I've seen here and explained how I'm now the sitting tenant as of my move in date but am not responsible for any outstanding council tax prior to this period.

OP posts:
JanglyBeads · 03/05/2023 22:28

Shelter are brilliant and have loads of info on their website.

Bergamotte · 03/05/2023 22:19

That's so stressful that they say you haven't provided enough evidence, but it is not possible to upload more!
Let alone the fact that they won't clarify what sort of evidence might be acceptable.

I hope it gets sorted out soon and you can relax and enjoy your new home.

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 22:17

HadalyEve · 03/05/2023 22:13

I can definitely fill in my details on the C.T envelope and get that back to them

Or you can go online and contact them
https://www.gov.uk/guidance/start-paying-council-tax

Brilliant ill do that now. I'd rather do it online and not write all over her letter if she's coming to collect it. Thank you

OP posts:
Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 22:16

HadalyEve · 03/05/2023 22:09

The landlady sounds dodgy or incompetent. I’d definitely be going round to Citizens Advice and having them look at your tenancy agreement. It may not even meet minimum legal requirements for an AST.

Council Tax or mortgage arrears are very important too as if the landlady loses the property- it is you who is made homeless even if you’ve paid all your rent on time and all your utility bills.

I'm planning on giving CAB a call first thing in the morning and will ask for an appointment ASAP so I can go down with my tenancy agreement.

It was created on one of those online tenancy agreement generators, is 22 pages long and really comprehensive. My previous landlord used a similar platform to create that tenancy and I had no issues with his one.

I had no idea you could lose your bought home due to council tax arrears, that's very concerning for me as you said it'll be me who is kicked out. I don't fancy my chances being at the mercy of the council to house me. I've been turned away from them multiple times over the years as I didn't qualify for housing and there was none available anyway.

OP posts:
HadalyEve · 03/05/2023 22:13

I can definitely fill in my details on the C.T envelope and get that back to them

Or you can go online and contact them
https://www.gov.uk/guidance/start-paying-council-tax

Start paying Council Tax

How to set up a new Council Tax account on a property you have recently moved into.

https://www.gov.uk/guidance/start-paying-council-tax

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 22:11

Jusmakingit · 03/05/2023 22:09

You could check companies house for the businessss and see if your current home is listed as the mailing address for her businesses.

also things like (but not sure) if the property is registered as an actual let and not a permanent residence for her own home. The mortgage should be in a letting type mortgage not a home one, so she may never have registered it as a let and still claiming on paper to live there but actually living in the pub. She may be getting some sort of reduction or increase in something. Buy to let mortgages aren’t cheap, usually higher interest rate etc than a normal residence . Not sure but worth thinking about.

Definitely worth thinking about and a v reasonable theory, thank you!

OP posts:
HadalyEve · 03/05/2023 22:09

The landlady sounds dodgy or incompetent. I’d definitely be going round to Citizens Advice and having them look at your tenancy agreement. It may not even meet minimum legal requirements for an AST.

Council Tax or mortgage arrears are very important too as if the landlady loses the property- it is you who is made homeless even if you’ve paid all your rent on time and all your utility bills.

Jusmakingit · 03/05/2023 22:09

You could check companies house for the businessss and see if your current home is listed as the mailing address for her businesses.

also things like (but not sure) if the property is registered as an actual let and not a permanent residence for her own home. The mortgage should be in a letting type mortgage not a home one, so she may never have registered it as a let and still claiming on paper to live there but actually living in the pub. She may be getting some sort of reduction or increase in something. Buy to let mortgages aren’t cheap, usually higher interest rate etc than a normal residence . Not sure but worth thinking about.

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 22:07

PotatoSoufle · 03/05/2023 22:02

Can you upload a copy of your bank statement showing the first months rent being paid, and a copy of the original advert for the property, as extra evidence?

Absolutely. I've actually offered to show them both of those things in my long rambling complaint on the UC journal today. I've even offered to give them my log in details for OpenRent so they can go in and look at it all for themselves.

When completing the (2 now) To-Do lists you only have the space to upload a few documents, which is annoying, as I had to use those spaces to show the most pressing docs IE tenancy, proof of address. I've asked for another To-Do link to be created so I can upload more evidence.

OP posts:
Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 22:05

I can definitely fill in my details on the C.T envelope and get that back to them, I probably should have taken a proper look and done that already given the apparent urgency.

I've been waiting for landlord to come and collect all of those letters as she told me she had some important ones to tend to so I didn't want to steam roll in if she had it in hand iykwim?

She planned to come this week but couldn't get over so is aiming to come and get them next week.

I'll raise the letter with her tomorrow and see what's best to do.

OP posts:
PotatoSoufle · 03/05/2023 22:02

Can you upload a copy of your bank statement showing the first months rent being paid, and a copy of the original advert for the property, as extra evidence?

Bergamotte · 03/05/2023 22:01

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 21:21

The letter in question with all identifying information removed obviously.

Am I clutching at straws?

It sounds like landlord hasn't picked up the letters yet?

Could you fill in your name & move-in date on the envelope, and send it back to the appropriate department?
(I can't tell whether they expect you to open the envelope if you're not the addressee, but presumably not as they have a space to write on the outside.)

Maybe that will help a little with getting the various council systems to recognise that landlord doesn't live there.

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 21:49

Babyroobs · 03/05/2023 21:45

It could be nothing. She may have thought that previous tenant had put the Council tax in their name and they never did and she doesn't know there is now an overpayment ?
Also people will always seem decent and kind when they want your trust and your money.

Valid points!

God this is so confusing. The lack of feedback from UC is making me wonder about all sorts.

OP posts:
Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 21:47

OurChristmasMiracle · 03/05/2023 21:41

I had an issue with housing costs back in January after my partner moved in with me. It then became a joint claim- as it should be, but they then asked to verify my housing costs- it was sent to my landlord as it’s a housing association but wasn’t verified for a number of weeks. I provided my tenancy agreement, proof of rent payments, rent statement and rent increase letter. All of it wasn’t “enough” eventually they got my landlords verification (I was told I would need to do a change of circumstances to get it resent which I did) I was then told that as I had “reported the change late” January’s housing payment wouldn’t be paid.

the issue they were having was that my tenancy was with x housing association which has now been merged with y housing association and despite explaining that they ignored it (although a little google would have shown what I was saying was correct!)

I have spent almost 4 months back and forth and finally januarys payment was made at the end of last month! It seems that they are making it almost impossible.

Wow thats so frustrating, 4 whole months. Was you at risk of losing your home? I've never been a tenant in a H.A (unfortunately, wish I was!) but I can't imagine many landlords would be very tolerant of that length of wait. It's terrible that they can do this to people when they'd easily be able to get the information they need if they bothered to make contact with the necessary department and or people. I'm glad you're finally sorted, what a headache.

OP posts:
Babyroobs · 03/05/2023 21:45

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 21:42

Blimey! I didn't know things like that were a frequent thing until all of this pallava came about and I started looking into what constitutes a contrived tenancy etc.

My landlord is a woman so landlady rather than lord (I was trying to be vague as its probably quite outing already) and she has a child although I don't know how old and what her relationship status is. She strikes me as a really decent, kind person and not somebody who would commit benefit fraud. She runs multiple pubs so I don't think she'd even be in receipt of benefits would she? No idea about the council tax though.

I'll have a chat with her tomorrow and ask If she's aware of any reason the DWP / council would have to believe she lives here.

It could be nothing. She may have thought that previous tenant had put the Council tax in their name and they never did and she doesn't know there is now an overpayment ?
Also people will always seem decent and kind when they want your trust and your money.

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 21:42

Blimey! I didn't know things like that were a frequent thing until all of this pallava came about and I started looking into what constitutes a contrived tenancy etc.

My landlord is a woman so landlady rather than lord (I was trying to be vague as its probably quite outing already) and she has a child although I don't know how old and what her relationship status is. She strikes me as a really decent, kind person and not somebody who would commit benefit fraud. She runs multiple pubs so I don't think she'd even be in receipt of benefits would she? No idea about the council tax though.

I'll have a chat with her tomorrow and ask If she's aware of any reason the DWP / council would have to believe she lives here.

OP posts:
OurChristmasMiracle · 03/05/2023 21:41

I had an issue with housing costs back in January after my partner moved in with me. It then became a joint claim- as it should be, but they then asked to verify my housing costs- it was sent to my landlord as it’s a housing association but wasn’t verified for a number of weeks. I provided my tenancy agreement, proof of rent payments, rent statement and rent increase letter. All of it wasn’t “enough” eventually they got my landlords verification (I was told I would need to do a change of circumstances to get it resent which I did) I was then told that as I had “reported the change late” January’s housing payment wouldn’t be paid.

the issue they were having was that my tenancy was with x housing association which has now been merged with y housing association and despite explaining that they ignored it (although a little google would have shown what I was saying was correct!)

I have spent almost 4 months back and forth and finally januarys payment was made at the end of last month! It seems that they are making it almost impossible.