Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

UC think my tenancy agreement is fraudulent/contrived. Advice please

113 replies

Tenancyproblems · 03/05/2023 19:18

I have just moved in to a privately rented property. I do not know the landlord personally and had never spoken to them before in my life until I applied to the advert on the open rent website.

I receive (atleast I did) the housing element of universal credit to help me to pay my rent.

When I moved in I uploaded the tenancy agreement on my UC portal as advised. They came back to me and said I need to provide evidence of my address and housing costs.

I was confused as the rent etc is all detailed in the tenancy however the landlord promptly wrote me a signed letter addressed to me at the new place FAO universal credit with the required details to support my claim.

Somebody called me the next day to clarify a few points (making sure I don't know the landlord personally, asking who else lives with me etc)

I answered honestly and UC said they'd get back to me shortly with a decision on my housing costs. That decision came back and the verdict was they would not be paying my housing costs. A generic letter was put up on my UC portal saying I hadn't provided enough evidence to satisfy them that I lived where I said I live and haven't shown evidence of housing costs(??)

Confused, I called them pretty upset and said I don't know what's going on here but I've done everything asked of me. The UC representative was sympathetic and said she would escalate it to a manager who would look at the claim.

Days later I check my UC portal and the decision has come back exactly the same. I'm entitled to my personal entitlement but no housing costs.

I contact them again, and again, and eventually they make an appointment for me to take my documents (IE tenancy etc) to be verified at my local job centre - that appointment was today.

I arrive there at 1pm with my tenancy agreement and some new documents I've been able to collect (a council headed letter regarding my children's school meals, more paperwork from the energy company) and before I've even sat down the advisor tells me that it's already gone above his head and the decision maker has rejected the housing element of my claim.

I'm completely baffled by this point and ask him what the problem is. He said there was several things "the decision makers" weren't happy with, a spelling mistake of the landlords name was one thing he mentioned but he offered no further context. He went on to say that during lockdown they saw a huge influx of fraudulent / contrived claims and now they leave no stone left unturned. He asked whether I could provide anything else. I said well no I've only been here just over a week I don't have anything else.

I'm then reminded of the tenancy deposit protection scheme and he asked whether I could provide the certificate for that. I was able to and said of course. He added a "to do" task for me on my journal which was exactly the same "to do" as I've done three times now (uploading the same documents) and said I could ask for a mandatory reconsideration and I'm now at the mercy of the same decision maker again I think.

If they reject it again I won't be able to remain here as I can't afford to.

I don't know what's going on here. I don't know the landlord personally. I'm not trying to defraud anybody of anything. I'm a lone parent who has never had any issues with the housing element of UC and now I may be at risk of homelessness.

Landlord is equally as dumbfounded. We are both completely genuine.

What on earth am I going to do?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
HappiDaze · 10/05/2023 07:44

This situation is so unfair

They really should at least pay the bloody rent whilst they sort out their incompetence

I'm so please you managed to resolve it

But equally frustrated that those that make these awkward decisions come from family money on the whole in the government with no regards as to how a normal human is supposed to survive in your circumstances

bluejelly · 10/05/2023 07:36

Wonderful news! Thanks for updating too.

LangClegsInSpace · 09/05/2023 16:10

Brilliant news! I'm so pleased for you.

Mydcchangedmyusername · 09/05/2023 13:38

Tenancyproblems · 09/05/2023 12:14

Update

They've changed their decision and agreed that I am entitled to the housing element. So relieved I cried!

My home is saved.

Thanks for all the advice given, no doubt it really helped :)

Well done! Happy for you and your children. Now you can begin to settle in and carry on with life.

OhwhyOY · 09/05/2023 12:23

Great news! Glad the system has worked in your favour for a change:-)

Tenancyproblems · 09/05/2023 12:14

Update

They've changed their decision and agreed that I am entitled to the housing element. So relieved I cried!

My home is saved.

Thanks for all the advice given, no doubt it really helped :)

OP posts:
Tenancyproblems · 06/05/2023 12:47

Thanks Dizzy :)

OP posts:
Dizzywizz · 05/05/2023 20:11

Hope it all gets sorted out for you @Tenancyproblems

Tenancyproblems · 05/05/2023 18:13

You've been v helpful indeed thank you!

I've got hold of a full pdf doc of my bank statements downloaded on my phone showing the first month's rent and deposit transaction to the landlady.

I've also got a pdf of my first council tax bill downloaded on my phone too. The council put that on my account this eve, perhaps in the nick of time!

I've been pestering poor "Heather" at the service center and she kindly added a To Do List for me to upload them. That poor woman must be sick of the sight of my name 😂 I think, and hope, those docs will make a difference so fingers crossed the decision maker / caseworker sees them before a decision is made 🤞🤞🤞

OP posts:
Preeeettyprettygood · 04/05/2023 22:36

Tenancyproblems · 04/05/2023 19:36

Thank you I'll bare that in mind. Are you allowed to talk about cases like mine anonymously? I know you couldn't advise on my particular case but I was wondering if you'd ever seen something like this before and whether it was resolved in the claimants favour?

I personally haven't come across a case like yours, and it's usually the job of the work coaches when it's comes to housing - any further issues in regards to housing costs then usually get passed on to us. I will add as you have had a couple of comments previous to mine, when you get document feedback, once a decision has been made,the documents will show as 'deleted', we cannot keep these documents and they are usually seen in the Job centre etc but not saved electronically for data protection, so that is true. I can see that even though the feedback for your documents just contained a full stop, the imagine you posted on your journal is the electronic response for that feedback of documents be "an agent", so it seems like you had no response but it alerted you that it couldn't be verified.

I have been trying to think of where you stand here and your next steps, I do agree it needs another opinion and can again confirm you'll never be given the same decision maker and unfortunately because of the backlog of cases, we can't give a time frame but its reassuring it has been escalated. You can also ask for a written explanation by the DM. If the outcome does not work in your favour then you will have to appeal should you wish and got to tribunal, at this point it's taken out of UC's hands.

Something does sound a little sketchy, but from a CM's point of view a man recon is the best port of call.

I'd be interested on your updates of this.

I'm sorry if I don't make sense or haven't helped, I've been doing 10 hour shifts and can't function at the moment 🙈😫 I hope you get to the bottom of this

malpa · 04/05/2023 19:40

Is there a reason they don't make contact with the landlord personally if there is any doubt? I feel like the whole thing is on me and I feel so overwhelmed and scared that I'm going to lose my home then lose my kids as i don't have anywhere else to live 😔

I did mention in my last post that UC might contact your landlord as part of their investigation but I doubt they will bother her too much other than maybe send a form to confirm her details. Unfortunately the whole thing is on you due to it being your claim, not your landlord's.

Having said that, there is nothing stopping your landlord from involving herself and supporting your case (this is her rent money we are talking about, after all). In my situation, after waiting patiently for two months my landlord accompanied me to the council office with the relevant paperwork and asked many questions: why they thought we were lying about my claim, why it was taking so long, why she should go without rent for months, why put unnecessary stress on her tenant, etc. At the time it was a bit embarrassing but looking back I think her actions not only sped up my housing benefit decision but firmly awarded it in my/our favour - they really couldn't argue with "Hi, I'm the landlord. This is my tenant. Here is the paperwork. Why is all this taking so long?" Is it possible for your landlord to help you chase this up in a similar manner?

Thank you so much, that's really encouraging and I needed some of that as it's all got on top of me this afternoon and I've had to leave the room a few times so the children don't see me crying. I've got it stuck in my mind that I'm going to lose the flat, and then them.

It's normal to be worried about this sort of thing. Logically, having looked at this in a little more detail, you can understand their concerns. They are correct - at present they do have insufficient evidence - but we also know that you are correct and can provide the evidence required so please try not to worry. I'm sure common sense will prevail and the confusion will be rectified. Hopefully it won't even get to the appeal stage. 🙂

Just want to add: take screenshots of all your communication with the UC staff and what they have posted on your portal (even just typing a full stop in a box) so if this is taken further (an appeal, for example) you can show that you were trying everything in your power to resolve the situation while they were being vague regarding why your evidence was insufficient.

Apparently it's rather unMumsnety to give hugs but flowers are fair game, so here: 💐

Tenancyproblems · 04/05/2023 19:36

Preeeettyprettygood · 04/05/2023 19:07

Hey OP, I'm a case manager for UC, just wanted to add we are incredibly overwhelmed and swamped under with claims so journals are not getting reached as quickly as we'd like to. I would always advise to call the service centre number and ask the telephony agent to send a handover to your case manager, chances are you will get a response a hell of a lot quicker then your journal messages.

Thank you I'll bare that in mind. Are you allowed to talk about cases like mine anonymously? I know you couldn't advise on my particular case but I was wondering if you'd ever seen something like this before and whether it was resolved in the claimants favour?

OP posts:
Preeeettyprettygood · 04/05/2023 19:07

Hey OP, I'm a case manager for UC, just wanted to add we are incredibly overwhelmed and swamped under with claims so journals are not getting reached as quickly as we'd like to. I would always advise to call the service centre number and ask the telephony agent to send a handover to your case manager, chances are you will get a response a hell of a lot quicker then your journal messages.

Clementineorsatsuma · 04/05/2023 18:50

Contact your MP as the DWP have a duty to look at complaints from an MP.
Really awful for you OP!

Tenancyproblems · 04/05/2023 18:00

malpa · 04/05/2023 17:40

Sorry, excuse my scattered brain. I have ADHD 🙈

Ha, your scattered brain is excused; don't worry about it. I imagine this must be very stressful for you.

Indeed I should have put my name on the council tax the day I moved in. That is now done and I've applied for the council tax reduction. I'm not sure when I'll be able to provide a bill though, I'll have to wait until they send one.

You mentioned in an earlier post that you can now access your council tax bill online - if it clearly shows your address alongside the other details then I don't see why you can't screenshot or print the page as proof of residence. They should accept it I would think (hopefully).

For proof of address so far I've uploaded 2 letters from the energy provider (gas and electric) and a letter on council headed paper regarding my children's school meals. I don't have anything else yet to give them.

I'm not sure if that would have been sufficient. They usually require two separate forms of evidence (at least). If you have one energy provider supplying both your gas and electricity then those two letters coming from the same company will be classed as one form of evidence. Also, I'm unsure if the letter about your children's school meals, even on council headed paper, is valid or not (I'm guessing it could be easily forged). UC usually require something a bit more official, such as bank statements, council tax bill or utility bills.

The bank statement showing transactions to landlady is a good idea. I'll nip to my branch tomorrow morning and ask for a print out.

I'm surprised they haven't asked for this already. Bank statements (proof of rent payment) was one of the first things requested of me when applying for housing benefit. It's actually quite odd that they are saying you lack sufficient evidence when they don't seem to have requested it in the first place.

I called up this afternoon and asked for a statement of reasons to be sent to me. The advisor told me to put it on my journal as she couldn't see anything apart from what's on the journal. She said in her opinion it looks like they don't think the landlady is real, I just need to wait for the decision now.

Yes, from what you have stated on this thread I agree with the advisor: that they are likely concerned about the landlord's legitimacy. And I can understand their suspicions...

However! You and the landlord are genuine and your claim contained arguably common mistakes (misspelling a landlord's name or getting an address wrong) so I don't think you have too much to worry about. Just keep bombarding them with evidence and let them do the box-ticking stuff until they are satisfied (and they will be, eventually). The confusion regarding your landlord's address can easily be explained by the fact she owns/runs multiple properties/businesses (this won't be the first time it's happened with a claim).

The UC will be backdated so hopefully your landlord will understand (you did say she is nice); just warn her that the UC staff might be in contact with her as part of their investigation. I'm sure you will be fine. 😀

Thank you so much, that's really encouraging and I needed some of that as it's all got on top of me this afternoon and I've had to leave the room a few times so the children don't see me crying. I've got it stuck in my mind that I'm going to lose the flat, and then them.

I agree its odd that they haven't asked me for bank statements as I could have easily provided them with no issue.

When somebody called me last week they asked how I'd paid the deposit and rent in advance and I said bank transfer and that I could provide that if they wanted. They never took me up on it. I wish I'd have just printed them off before I put in for the M.R.

OP posts:
malpa · 04/05/2023 17:40

Sorry, excuse my scattered brain. I have ADHD 🙈

Ha, your scattered brain is excused; don't worry about it. I imagine this must be very stressful for you.

Indeed I should have put my name on the council tax the day I moved in. That is now done and I've applied for the council tax reduction. I'm not sure when I'll be able to provide a bill though, I'll have to wait until they send one.

You mentioned in an earlier post that you can now access your council tax bill online - if it clearly shows your address alongside the other details then I don't see why you can't screenshot or print the page as proof of residence. They should accept it I would think (hopefully).

For proof of address so far I've uploaded 2 letters from the energy provider (gas and electric) and a letter on council headed paper regarding my children's school meals. I don't have anything else yet to give them.

I'm not sure if that would have been sufficient. They usually require two separate forms of evidence (at least). If you have one energy provider supplying both your gas and electricity then those two letters coming from the same company will be classed as one form of evidence. Also, I'm unsure if the letter about your children's school meals, even on council headed paper, is valid or not (I'm guessing it could be easily forged). UC usually require something a bit more official, such as bank statements, council tax bill or utility bills.

The bank statement showing transactions to landlady is a good idea. I'll nip to my branch tomorrow morning and ask for a print out.

I'm surprised they haven't asked for this already. Bank statements (proof of rent payment) was one of the first things requested of me when applying for housing benefit. It's actually quite odd that they are saying you lack sufficient evidence when they don't seem to have requested it in the first place.

I called up this afternoon and asked for a statement of reasons to be sent to me. The advisor told me to put it on my journal as she couldn't see anything apart from what's on the journal. She said in her opinion it looks like they don't think the landlady is real, I just need to wait for the decision now.

Yes, from what you have stated on this thread I agree with the advisor: that they are likely concerned about the landlord's legitimacy. And I can understand their suspicions...

However! You and the landlord are genuine and your claim contained arguably common mistakes (misspelling a landlord's name or getting an address wrong) so I don't think you have too much to worry about. Just keep bombarding them with evidence and let them do the box-ticking stuff until they are satisfied (and they will be, eventually). The confusion regarding your landlord's address can easily be explained by the fact she owns/runs multiple properties/businesses (this won't be the first time it's happened with a claim).

The UC will be backdated so hopefully your landlord will understand (you did say she is nice); just warn her that the UC staff might be in contact with her as part of their investigation. I'm sure you will be fine. 😀

Tenancyproblems · 04/05/2023 17:28

Is there a reason they don't make contact with the landlord personally if there is any doubt? I feel like the whole thing is on me and I feel so overwhelmed and scared that I'm going to lose my home then lose my kids as i don't have anywhere else to live 😔

OP posts:
Tenancyproblems · 04/05/2023 16:37

They've responded to my request for the statement of reasons to tell me the request has been referred so that's good.

I'm absolutely bricking myself that the decision isn't going to change. Reading it all back in black and white about how they'll now have 3 different addresses for the landlady if the council tax bill is included, it does look really damn dodgy 😔

OP posts:
LangClegsInSpace · 04/05/2023 16:09

x post - that's good, you've done everything you can for now.

LangClegsInSpace · 04/05/2023 16:06

Tenancyproblems · 04/05/2023 15:12

If the mandatory reconsideration draws the same conclusion as the previous decision maker can I keep appealing?

My friends attempt to claim PIP springs to mind. They refused it. She appealed. They refused that. Eventually it went to tribunal but that was the complete end of the road then, they wouldn't keep looking at it.

I have an awful feeling that I'll be told they're not paying it end of and to just accept it.

If there is no change when you get your mandatory reconsideration response then you can appeal.

Appealing is the same as going to tribunal. The tribunal decision is final (unless you can show they erred on a point of law, which is very unusual).

You can ask for a statement of reasons now, via your journal, and this is worth doing because it should at least indicate what evidence they believe is missing.

Tenancyproblems · 04/05/2023 16:05

malpa · 04/05/2023 15:35

Oh, OP... Deep breath! I understand you are stressed but it's actually a little frustrating reading your posts. The UC staff keep coming back to you with "you have not provided sufficient evidence of where you live and how much you pay in rent" and you seem to be more focused on contacting your MP/Citizens Advice or making a Subject Access Request, etc than simply handing over the required information.

"What information?" I hear you cry. As others have mentioned, UC probably won't tell you why your claim was rejected due to suspicion of fraud (they don't want to help potential fraudsters cover their tracks).

With these sort of things, always start at the basics. Here's why I think your claim was rejected:

  • You hadn't informed the council about your new address; in other words, you were trying to claim housing benefit for a property you were not registered as living at.
  • Your landlord's name was still on the council tax bill meaning she was registered as living at the property you are trying to claim for. Additionally, apparently this council tax bill in your landlord's name is in arrears.
  • There was a misspelling of your landlord's name on the tenancy agreement.
  • You provided the wrong home address for your landlord which didn't match the address provided by her. The UC staff now have your landlord at three different addresses (including the one you are trying to claim for).
  • You hadn't provided any bank statements as proof of rent payment.
  • You hadn't (as far as I can tell) provided any utility bills as proof of residence.
  • You have provided a copy of your tenancy agreement... which any Tom, Dick or Harry can print off and fill in.
I could be wrong but I suspect the above is why your claim has been rejected and possibly flagged up as fraudulent.

In short, here's a to do list:

  • Inform the council you live there; have your landlord's name removed from the council tax bill; request a council tax bill in your name only (you should have done this the day you moved in). - Done! ✅
  • Get a new tenancy agreement from your landlord with no spelling mistakes and all details correct (especially your landlord's address).
  • Get two forms of proof of address, in particular a council tax bill and a utility bill.
  • Get a bank statement showing rent payments to your landlord (this can also be a third proof of address).
  • Probably not needed by this point but have copies of your ID to hand.
  • Politely (or with a sigh of relief and a "Ta-da!") inform the UC people you believe you have the information they are requesting.
All of the above should be sufficient evidence for claiming UC. If not, the issue probably lies with your landlord or the property - in which case there's probably not much you can do. Regarding losing your tenancy if you can't pay the rent, your UC should be backdated to when you first made your claim so if your landlord is prepared to wait a bit longer than usual you should be okay.

Finally, good luck! I had a similar problem when my housemate moved out and I applied for housing benefit as the sole occupant. It took two months for them to sort it out (they weren't convinced I was living alone). Luckily my landlord was understanding and didn't mind waiting for the arrears. So, all the best! (And sorry for the long post.)

Thank you 🙂

Sorry, excuse my scattered brain. I have ADHD 🙈

Indeed I should have put my name on the council tax the day I moved in. That is now done and I've applied for the council tax reduction. I'm not sure when I'll be able to provide a bill though, I'll have to wait until they send one.

For proof of address so far I've uploaded 2 letters from the energy provider (gas and electric) and a letter on council headed paper regarding my children's school meals. I don't have anything else yet to give them.

The bank statement showing transactions to landlady is a good idea. I'll nip to my branch tomorrow morning and ask for a print out.

I won't be able to show them anything else unless they add another To Do list for me but I'll have it ready.

I called up this afternoon and asked for a statement of reasons to be sent to me. The advisor told me to put it on my journal as she couldn't see anything apart from what's on the journal. She said in her opinion it looks like they don't think the landlady is real, I just need to wait for the decision now.

OP posts:
malpa · 04/05/2023 15:35

Oh, OP... Deep breath! I understand you are stressed but it's actually a little frustrating reading your posts. The UC staff keep coming back to you with "you have not provided sufficient evidence of where you live and how much you pay in rent" and you seem to be more focused on contacting your MP/Citizens Advice or making a Subject Access Request, etc than simply handing over the required information.

"What information?" I hear you cry. As others have mentioned, UC probably won't tell you why your claim was rejected due to suspicion of fraud (they don't want to help potential fraudsters cover their tracks).

With these sort of things, always start at the basics. Here's why I think your claim was rejected:

  • You hadn't informed the council about your new address; in other words, you were trying to claim housing benefit for a property you were not registered as living at.
  • Your landlord's name was still on the council tax bill meaning she was registered as living at the property you are trying to claim for. Additionally, apparently this council tax bill in your landlord's name is in arrears.
  • There was a misspelling of your landlord's name on the tenancy agreement.
  • You provided the wrong home address for your landlord which didn't match the address provided by her. The UC staff now have your landlord at three different addresses (including the one you are trying to claim for).
  • You hadn't provided any bank statements as proof of rent payment.
  • You hadn't (as far as I can tell) provided any utility bills as proof of residence.
  • You have provided a copy of your tenancy agreement... which any Tom, Dick or Harry can print off and fill in.
I could be wrong but I suspect the above is why your claim has been rejected and possibly flagged up as fraudulent.

In short, here's a to do list:

  • Inform the council you live there; have your landlord's name removed from the council tax bill; request a council tax bill in your name only (you should have done this the day you moved in). - Done! ✅
  • Get a new tenancy agreement from your landlord with no spelling mistakes and all details correct (especially your landlord's address).
  • Get two forms of proof of address, in particular a council tax bill and a utility bill.
  • Get a bank statement showing rent payments to your landlord (this can also be a third proof of address).
  • Probably not needed by this point but have copies of your ID to hand.
  • Politely (or with a sigh of relief and a "Ta-da!") inform the UC people you believe you have the information they are requesting.
All of the above should be sufficient evidence for claiming UC. If not, the issue probably lies with your landlord or the property - in which case there's probably not much you can do. Regarding losing your tenancy if you can't pay the rent, your UC should be backdated to when you first made your claim so if your landlord is prepared to wait a bit longer than usual you should be okay.

Finally, good luck! I had a similar problem when my housemate moved out and I applied for housing benefit as the sole occupant. It took two months for them to sort it out (they weren't convinced I was living alone). Luckily my landlord was understanding and didn't mind waiting for the arrears. So, all the best! (And sorry for the long post.)

Tenancyproblems · 04/05/2023 15:12

If the mandatory reconsideration draws the same conclusion as the previous decision maker can I keep appealing?

My friends attempt to claim PIP springs to mind. They refused it. She appealed. They refused that. Eventually it went to tribunal but that was the complete end of the road then, they wouldn't keep looking at it.

I have an awful feeling that I'll be told they're not paying it end of and to just accept it.

OP posts:
Tenancyproblems · 04/05/2023 15:08

I've applied for my council tax reduction and have to wait up to 10 days for a response from them for that 🤞

Any idea why my tenancy wouldn't be legitimate? Could it be that I'm not legally entitled to live here or something else?

OP posts:
Blackbyrd · 04/05/2023 15:01

You need to make a Council Tax Reduction claim directly with your local authority, they can liaise directly with the DWP to ascertain your entitlement if you give them permission.
Proofs uploaded onto a UC claim are automatically detected once viewed, they are not printed out. The DWP likes to maintain this is because of GDPR issues-it isn't, it's because their system doesn't have adequate storage capacity.
Fundamentally, Housing Benefit was and is far too complicated a benefit to wrap up into UC. Case managers don't have a clue about it, and decision makers are making the rules up as they go along.
It seems as if your tenancy may not be legitimate, in which case your landlady won't be able to serve an eviction order. You will not under any circumstances get a DHP to pay the full rent if UC refuse, you rightly have applied for a temporary top up of your Local Housing Allowance.
Your MP and possibly Citizens Advice are your best options as previously advised