Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm accidentally a bad dog owner

83 replies

LetDownDog · 03/05/2023 17:47

Name changed for this.

Please be a little gentle.

Ok.... So, I had dogs growing up from birth til I left home. Always thought I knew them. We had several different breeds.

About 2 years ago we, as a family, finally decided after much deliberation to get a dog. Thought it would be nice for DC to learn to care for something and develop empathy skills etc.. learn to help a bit. But mostly DH and I just wanted to make our house a home, and loved the idea of a dog to snuggle in the evening while watching movies, or taking him/her for long family walks etc ..

We spent a good year researching what would make a suitable pet for us. We had wanted a dog a long time, but waited til I was work from home and DCs old enough to handle dog well and to be safe around dog. We waited til we lived somewhere with a garden, near appropriate fields for off lead walking etc...

We visited a few dogs, researched some online, and eventually after a year of actively looking, we found one that seemed perfect for us. He was a Labrador cross (trying stay anonymous, so not saying what crossed with - but think along lines of a collie or working dog). We knew he'd require 2 good long, off lead walks a day

For some stupid reason, I considered the following:
-will i be at home to keep him company - yes
-suitable for family - yes
-able to provide walks - yes
-garden space - yes
-suitable walking areas for off lead - yes

  • Children old enough etc.. - yes
-good temperament - yes

But now we have said dog I discover he needs 3 or 4 X 1 hour + walks a day (I had banked on 2). I can cope with that. What I can't cope with is how much attention he needs. How much mental stimulation. I have no idea why I didn't consider this.

He constantly wants to play, is in between my feet, eats everything in sight if I don't play with him, follows me around. He needs so so much stimulation.

  1. AIBU not to have thought about this (I guess I am, but it's not really covered in any of the stuff I read about finding the right breed for the family etc..)
  1. How do you keep a dog stimulated? We now send him to a dog play group once a week so he can play with other dogs (which he also does on his walks), and have fun and stimulation. But we can't afford it daily. Any tips??? Pleeeease. We want to stick with him, would never consider re homing unless it was in his v best interests, we love him. But...how do we keep him entertained while also working, making dinner for the children etc...?? He has toys, chew sticks, balls etc...

Help! I genuinely thought we did everything right prior to getting him!

OP posts:
bookwormcrazy · 03/05/2023 19:15

If it helps, the favourite activity I do with my dog is to chuck a handful of kibble or small treats into the grass in my garden. Probably more is required for a lab cross. This gives him an activity that mentally stimulates him while he sniffs it all out and hunts it down. Even just the activity of using their nose increase hearts rate and wears him out to a degree as well as keeping him occupied. You can even do this with his dinner if you feed him kibble. A way to to stimulate his brain without the physical exercise.

TillyTollyTully · 03/05/2023 19:15

Oh my word. 4 x 1 hour walks is BONKERS op. The dog will be so overstimulated, constantly on a high and the behaviour is likely due to that.

I'm wondering if your cross is lab x springer? You mentioned the dog being bored, I just wondered if you meant looking bored? Because those sad spaniel eyes look like they're right out of an RSPCA advert sometimes, even when they're living their best life! However, spaniels tend to look sad when they're relaxed ime so if that is the case you need to get used to not bothering them at that time!

For comparison, we have a working springer who's 10 months and currently gets one 1.5 hour walk a day and scent work training at home for about 30 mins. She has adhoc tug of war with whoevers around and a long lasting chew or licky mat sometimes. But she's left to her own devices (with company, whilst I WFH) for plenty of time because she has to. If she brings me a toy when I'm working I say 'not now' and don't engage, then she'll huff and wander off to have a nap.

Ideally we'd walk her twice, her main offlead and then a second shorter on lead walk - but we've had to stop the second one for a bit because we're really struggling to keep weight on her so the vet advised to drop a walk.

The first think I'd do in your shoes is drop 4 walks to 2, give it a few weeks and see if that makes a difference.

BiddyPop · 03/05/2023 19:15

Posting to find this again as we have a somewhat similar story

PepeParapluie · 03/05/2023 19:14

We had this same issue with our mixed breed rescue, and it took us a while to realise that overtired/ overstimulated is definitely a thing! As some PPs have said, frozen kongs were great for getting her to settle down and sleep in the evening, and we gave her food in a snuffle mat, a wobbly food dispenser thing or a ball she’d roll around to get the food out. We also started giving her nap time shut in a separate room. Now she’s older (over 2) she is much more chilled out and able to just chill herself during the day without us having to structure naps etc.

I think it’s really easy to fall in the trap of forgetting what puppies/ teen dogs are like because it’s a short part of their life, so it’s a surprise when you have a young dog! But they definitely get easier.

appletreeyard · 03/05/2023 19:13

LetDownDog · 03/05/2023 17:47

Name changed for this.

Please be a little gentle.

Ok.... So, I had dogs growing up from birth til I left home. Always thought I knew them. We had several different breeds.

About 2 years ago we, as a family, finally decided after much deliberation to get a dog. Thought it would be nice for DC to learn to care for something and develop empathy skills etc.. learn to help a bit. But mostly DH and I just wanted to make our house a home, and loved the idea of a dog to snuggle in the evening while watching movies, or taking him/her for long family walks etc ..

We spent a good year researching what would make a suitable pet for us. We had wanted a dog a long time, but waited til I was work from home and DCs old enough to handle dog well and to be safe around dog. We waited til we lived somewhere with a garden, near appropriate fields for off lead walking etc...

We visited a few dogs, researched some online, and eventually after a year of actively looking, we found one that seemed perfect for us. He was a Labrador cross (trying stay anonymous, so not saying what crossed with - but think along lines of a collie or working dog). We knew he'd require 2 good long, off lead walks a day

For some stupid reason, I considered the following:
-will i be at home to keep him company - yes
-suitable for family - yes
-able to provide walks - yes
-garden space - yes
-suitable walking areas for off lead - yes

  • Children old enough etc.. - yes
-good temperament - yes

But now we have said dog I discover he needs 3 or 4 X 1 hour + walks a day (I had banked on 2). I can cope with that. What I can't cope with is how much attention he needs. How much mental stimulation. I have no idea why I didn't consider this.

He constantly wants to play, is in between my feet, eats everything in sight if I don't play with him, follows me around. He needs so so much stimulation.

  1. AIBU not to have thought about this (I guess I am, but it's not really covered in any of the stuff I read about finding the right breed for the family etc..)
  1. How do you keep a dog stimulated? We now send him to a dog play group once a week so he can play with other dogs (which he also does on his walks), and have fun and stimulation. But we can't afford it daily. Any tips??? Pleeeease. We want to stick with him, would never consider re homing unless it was in his v best interests, we love him. But...how do we keep him entertained while also working, making dinner for the children etc...?? He has toys, chew sticks, balls etc...

Help! I genuinely thought we did everything right prior to getting him!

second dog to play with

marleyandme · 03/05/2023 19:12

It sounds like you're a great dog owner and just reaching out for support which is commendable!
I agree with other posters in that it sounds like it's a combination of pure 'teenage twatdom' (couldn't think of a better way to put it than said above) 😂 which he will grow out of after about 18 months plus neutering, it's the worst of it now.
Plus it sounds like you're being too active with him and not giving him a chance to switch off. To start with as he's used to being so active now, try and introduce quiet times after he's done something tiring, ideally mentally not just physically tiring.
E.g. Trying some brain games, things you buy off the shelf or scent work depending on the cross might appeal to you both? Then when that is over, try and make it a clear segmentation almost so pack it away or do that in one area of the house/garden then move somewhere else. Then just ignore him! Unless he's doing something dangerous or destructive of course! You might have to redirect some of his initial energy by offering something safe to chew if he's a chewer. But try and let everyone in the household know that now it's his time to rest which means no one fussing him or even talking to him for a bit.
It will probably feel mean at first as you're used to interpreting his energy as needing to be matched, but he will feed off your energy too so if he sees you calm and distracted (like just watching the tv/reading) he will start to learn to copy. Try not to anticipate him being active and destructive if you can.
Gradually build up the time you do these almost no contact periods for, but start off with around 30 minutes-1hour initially to give him a chance to settle and you'll get there.
He'll be sleeping for hours or copying your lower energy soon enough I promise, it's just a routine that he needs building on! Consistency and energy are key.

I do agility with my 2 collies which gives them lots of mental stimulation which is so important for working dogs, things like that or just walking them somewhere new are great for them. But it doesn't have to be anything big or expensive, just start small and with something you can get behind as you'll want to be setting the routine up and repeating it a lot. You shouldn't need to do more than 2 x 1hr walks most days when he learns to settle.

LetDownDog · 03/05/2023 19:11

TwoPointFourCatsAndDogs · 03/05/2023 19:10

I could have written your post about our Spaniel, he’s 17 months old. We crate him after morning walk, afternoon walk and for his dinner. He definitely needs rest or he’s worse than overstimulated toddler!

I use licky mats, cow hooves for chewing (box of 30 from Amazon), Kongs with frozen sweet potatoes. I make my own liver cake and use inside plastic bottles that I cut small holes in so he can use as a shaker toy. Also treats folded into an old sheet keeps him occupied for ages.

Good luck!

Thanks!! 👍🐶

OP posts:
TwoPointFourCatsAndDogs · 03/05/2023 19:10

I could have written your post about our Spaniel, he’s 17 months old. We crate him after morning walk, afternoon walk and for his dinner. He definitely needs rest or he’s worse than overstimulated toddler!

I use licky mats, cow hooves for chewing (box of 30 from Amazon), Kongs with frozen sweet potatoes. I make my own liver cake and use inside plastic bottles that I cut small holes in so he can use as a shaker toy. Also treats folded into an old sheet keeps him occupied for ages.

Good luck!

Landndialamrhf · 03/05/2023 19:05

He needs to learn to be alone. Start working on going out or to another room for periods of time. That way he learns to settle and you get a break too - you’ll be more ready to play after that!

work on a place/bed command and build up time he can be there with you next to him and then you out the room

try brain games, snuffle mats and make him work for every single meal or treat he gets

take all his toys and chews away except one. Then throughout the day change out which one he has, to break his day up.

get the kids to help, so at least once or twice a day they each need to do a walk or some training or intense playing with him, so it’s not all on you.

i think with all the walks you might just be making him fitter haha. You’ll be better off giving him ‘jobs’ maybe - see what breeds he is and what jobs they may typically like.

LetDownDog · 03/05/2023 19:03

Delatron · 03/05/2023 18:58

You’re not a bad owner! No dog needs 4 walks a day of that length though.. And they need to sleep lots in the day too.

He sounds over stimulated and unable to settle. He will calm down but I would cut down the walks. Especially as he’s only 11 months and half Labrador- you have to be careful not to over exercise due to joint issues.

The more you walk them, the fitter they will become and they need more and more. A couple of long walks is plenty.

The more you walk them, the fitter they will become and they need more and more. A couple of long walks is plenty.

yes, we were thinking this! I also have 2 DC, one of whom is v sporty. And since toddler hood when have tried to ware him out! By increasing activity! He's now 11 and swims 7 times a week, football twice a week, running, athletics, basketball team. I am truly exhausted just taking him everywhere and watching him!! But I have realised you cannot exhaust a battery when it comes to kids, it only gets charged up more!! I should have realised this also applies to dogs! (I totally need a spa day!!...no wonderful dogs or children, as lovely as they all are!!)

OP posts:
PinkFootstool · 03/05/2023 19:00

Less distance walking! If your dog is marathon trained, it'll want more and more of it. Dogs like labs and collies are basically adrenaline junkies and they have no idea what's good for themselves and you'll find lots will end up with health issues from too much distance e walking / running in time.

Reduce the length of the walks - drop one or two ASAP. Do one really good "sniffy" walk a day and maybe one exercise walk. Encourage stopping to sniff on the sniffy walk. Don't march, slow down and be ready to stand around a lot.

Have a day off long walks! It's good for you and the dog to have a day of rest each week as well.

If your dog has a ball you take on a walk, throw it away. No tennis ball chasing! That the action of chasing breeds obsession and it's terrible for joint problems when used as a primary source of exercise.

Use snuffle mats and scatter feeding for food to keep them busier for longer in the house.

Have a look at the free videos from trainers like Southend Dog Training for settle / keeping the dog entertained on its own / boundaries for things like when you're working.

Delatron · 03/05/2023 18:58

You’re not a bad owner! No dog needs 4 walks a day of that length though.. And they need to sleep lots in the day too.

He sounds over stimulated and unable to settle. He will calm down but I would cut down the walks. Especially as he’s only 11 months and half Labrador- you have to be careful not to over exercise due to joint issues.

The more you walk them, the fitter they will become and they need more and more. A couple of long walks is plenty.

LadyLump · 03/05/2023 18:56

I know you said saying the cross would be outing but I think it would be interesting to know. There are so many different working dogs that would have so many different outcomes when crossed with something else. We’ve got a lab x springer who gets a lot of mental stimulation and 2 good walks a day and he’s an absolute dream now. He’s 5 years old

LetDownDog · 03/05/2023 18:56

OllytheCollie · 03/05/2023 18:54

Excellent advice on here re settling. We have a BC and I could have written your post too. She's three now and waaaaay calmer, teaching settle and just ignoring her lots helped her learn to switch off. You will get there.

Two other things - you cannot tire a working dog out with walks. You can only tire them out mentally by making them work. Make sure you practice obedience on walks, hide things, teach tricks whatever it takes to make your dog focus on you. He'll come back way more tired than from just hurtling around and eventually you can get down to the 2 walks you planned. Which is all he should need.

You don't have to do competitions to learn from obedience or agility trainers. In the end we learnt how to do rally training with our dog. We don't compete, but it's fast, focused and requires her to really work and she loves it.

Thanks :)

OP posts:
LetDownDog · 03/05/2023 18:55

Bovrilla · 03/05/2023 18:50

As a comparison my spaniel gets 1x 1hr offlead training walk, one village walk of 20 minutes to do the school run and one "neighbourhood watch" block walk first thing for a wee and poo. 2/3 x 5 minute training sessions during the day whilst kettle boils etc. He sleeps for 12 hours a night and a fair chunk of the day!

Hopefully my pooch will get to that point :) the 'sleeps a fair chunk of the day' sounds like heaven!! And less walks will be like a gift from the gods! 4 is just sooo many!! I can't tell if my DH is loving the walks or about to have a complete nervous breakdown! I think maybe both :)

OP posts:
OllytheCollie · 03/05/2023 18:54

Excellent advice on here re settling. We have a BC and I could have written your post too. She's three now and waaaaay calmer, teaching settle and just ignoring her lots helped her learn to switch off. You will get there.

Two other things - you cannot tire a working dog out with walks. You can only tire them out mentally by making them work. Make sure you practice obedience on walks, hide things, teach tricks whatever it takes to make your dog focus on you. He'll come back way more tired than from just hurtling around and eventually you can get down to the 2 walks you planned. Which is all he should need.

You don't have to do competitions to learn from obedience or agility trainers. In the end we learnt how to do rally training with our dog. We don't compete, but it's fast, focused and requires her to really work and she loves it.

bumpytrumpy · 03/05/2023 18:52

LetDownDog · 03/05/2023 18:47

Thank you so much everyone. I have read all the posts, sorry I am too knackered to reply to them all individually, but there are so many useful tips, so thank you for each post! DH just got home and has taken him out just now (4th walk of the day!!) - I said as he was walking out the door that I think we need to teach him to settle and he's overstimulated, but it wasn't registering! (I think he'd been looking forward to the walk!) But when he gets back and children in bed, and hopefully dog a bit calmer, I'll have a chat about us not taking him out so much and trying to get the doggy settled a bit more throughout the day! With less play and more quality over quantity!

Thanks everyone. So much useful advice. I'll read it all again tomorrow and start taking some action!

You're definitely not bad owners!! If anything he needs less attention, not more. He needs to learn to chill out and you can teach him that.

Have a look at the Absolute Dogs website and you tube channels - they advocate short bursts of games and then a LOT of active rest time.

Bovrilla · 03/05/2023 18:50

As a comparison my spaniel gets 1x 1hr offlead training walk, one village walk of 20 minutes to do the school run and one "neighbourhood watch" block walk first thing for a wee and poo. 2/3 x 5 minute training sessions during the day whilst kettle boils etc. He sleeps for 12 hours a night and a fair chunk of the day!

LetDownDog · 03/05/2023 18:47

Thank you so much everyone. I have read all the posts, sorry I am too knackered to reply to them all individually, but there are so many useful tips, so thank you for each post! DH just got home and has taken him out just now (4th walk of the day!!) - I said as he was walking out the door that I think we need to teach him to settle and he's overstimulated, but it wasn't registering! (I think he'd been looking forward to the walk!) But when he gets back and children in bed, and hopefully dog a bit calmer, I'll have a chat about us not taking him out so much and trying to get the doggy settled a bit more throughout the day! With less play and more quality over quantity!

Thanks everyone. So much useful advice. I'll read it all again tomorrow and start taking some action!

OP posts:
Bovrilla · 03/05/2023 18:44

Your pooch is right in the throes of teenage twatdom. Mine was an attention seeking nightmare at that age

That's far too much walking though. You need to stimulate his brain.

Gundog training is brilliant, as is agility, mantrailing and scentwork. Do the Kennel Club good dog citizen scheme: just get training so that he's working his brain. When mine has been to gundog class he literally walks in, has a drink and immediately flops into bed 🤣🤣. It's only an hour, with hardly any physical exercise. He's just mentally shattered. That's what you want!

Loads of training, and teaching him to settle with a frozen Kong or chew and you'll get there.

But those teen months are bloody awful. I promise they get loads better by 2!!!

BreakfastClub80 · 03/05/2023 18:39

In terms of when to have the snip, we have an assistance dog puppy and the charity had him done at 12 months. One vet advised they would have waited until 18 months for a large breed (lab) but our charity didn’t follow that
practice. He’s calmed down quite a lot though it takes a few weeks.

bookwormcrazy · 03/05/2023 18:38

It sounds like you have the puppy blues! And that is totally normal. My dog didn't start settling down until about 18 months and he's only a little Westie.

He could be an absolute terror especially when it comes to playing and wanting to be outside all of the time and wanting attention every single waking minute. I used to sink down of an evening when he finally settled wondering what the hell I had got myself into but... it doesn't last. He had to go through his shi#y teenage years before he seemed to calm down. You go through the same phases with a dog as you do children. 😂

My mother in law got a puppy last year and she stayed with us for an evening recently. It bought it all back and reminded me of what we went through with our dog and how glad I am that he has matured a little bit now! 🤣

What you are feeling is totally normal and doesn't make you a bad dog owner. And I would definitely cut down his walks, quality over quantity.

KnackeredAF · 03/05/2023 18:38

Blimey! 11 months is still young so will definitely be high energy.
We had a black lab retriever x border collie when I was growing up and he had 2x1h walks/day and that was plenty.
Lots of enrichment activities to keep busy - can hide treats in old towels and knot them up, there are balls you can put kibble in and they have to bop it around to get the treats out, there are the mats you can smush food into and they have to spend time licking them to get the food out etc.
After the snip our lad became much calmer and chewed a lot less…
Give him time, he’ll get there (as will you!)

TheSecretaryBird · 03/05/2023 18:27

We found with our high energy breed that he needed to be taught how to settle and to have regular naps. Between the ages of 8 and 18 months he was an absolute nightmare!

We use frozen kongs and lick mats to give him something to do in in the evenings before he settles. Also we give them beef slices which are really long and take ages for them to chew on which helps him settle.

We also started flyball and it’s surprising how much that tires his wee brain out (and he absolutely loves it). He goes flyball training on a Saturday morning for about 40 mins to an hour and is zonked for the rest of the day.
He also does agility training which makes him use his brain too. Scentwork is good for challenging them mentally too.

We also find that food makes a massive difference. The AADF website is really helpful when looking at alternative food options.

AL96 · 03/05/2023 18:27

The Facebook group previously mentioned may well be Canine Enrichment. Full of loads of great, often very budget friendly ideas for mental stimulation.

You could also look at Absolute Dogs which is a brilliant online based training company that use short, simple games to engage both you and the dog (and the kids if you want to get them involved)
Alot of their training is really handy for teaching your dog to settle independently without you needing to be in constant contact with them.
They quite often have deals on their courses too so we'll worth looking out for those😊

As for neutering the general advice is usually to wait until around 18 months for larger breeds as they take slightly longer than smaller dogs to reach maturity.
Part of the reason I have chihuahuas😂