Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm accidentally a bad dog owner

83 replies

LetDownDog · 03/05/2023 17:47

Name changed for this.

Please be a little gentle.

Ok.... So, I had dogs growing up from birth til I left home. Always thought I knew them. We had several different breeds.

About 2 years ago we, as a family, finally decided after much deliberation to get a dog. Thought it would be nice for DC to learn to care for something and develop empathy skills etc.. learn to help a bit. But mostly DH and I just wanted to make our house a home, and loved the idea of a dog to snuggle in the evening while watching movies, or taking him/her for long family walks etc ..

We spent a good year researching what would make a suitable pet for us. We had wanted a dog a long time, but waited til I was work from home and DCs old enough to handle dog well and to be safe around dog. We waited til we lived somewhere with a garden, near appropriate fields for off lead walking etc...

We visited a few dogs, researched some online, and eventually after a year of actively looking, we found one that seemed perfect for us. He was a Labrador cross (trying stay anonymous, so not saying what crossed with - but think along lines of a collie or working dog). We knew he'd require 2 good long, off lead walks a day

For some stupid reason, I considered the following:
-will i be at home to keep him company - yes
-suitable for family - yes
-able to provide walks - yes
-garden space - yes
-suitable walking areas for off lead - yes

  • Children old enough etc.. - yes
-good temperament - yes

But now we have said dog I discover he needs 3 or 4 X 1 hour + walks a day (I had banked on 2). I can cope with that. What I can't cope with is how much attention he needs. How much mental stimulation. I have no idea why I didn't consider this.

He constantly wants to play, is in between my feet, eats everything in sight if I don't play with him, follows me around. He needs so so much stimulation.

  1. AIBU not to have thought about this (I guess I am, but it's not really covered in any of the stuff I read about finding the right breed for the family etc..)
  1. How do you keep a dog stimulated? We now send him to a dog play group once a week so he can play with other dogs (which he also does on his walks), and have fun and stimulation. But we can't afford it daily. Any tips??? Pleeeease. We want to stick with him, would never consider re homing unless it was in his v best interests, we love him. But...how do we keep him entertained while also working, making dinner for the children etc...?? He has toys, chew sticks, balls etc...

Help! I genuinely thought we did everything right prior to getting him!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
bozzabollix · 04/05/2023 06:04

I’ve got a year old lab. We have one hour walk a day, but on that walk she sees her high energy best mate and they roll about, run, wrestle etc. by the time she’s back she’s barely able to keep her eyes open. She might become a bit terrible later but then the kids are mucking about with her, and that knackers her out.

Find your dog a BFF!

stayathomer · 03/05/2023 22:34

Why honestly do they not put this in ads? I have never heard people say ‘you will spend more time with your dog than anyone else!’ (Even the kids!) I love our little man but it’s true that it’s like having a newborn crossed with a toddler!!

strawberriesarenot · 03/05/2023 22:27

There is something called 'Capturing calm' so that when, for instance, they don't bark at an unexpected event in the garden, you notice and praise them for it. A down time place works too, so 'in your basket now' means 'that's it for a while,' and they can switch off their 'alert' mode. It's also really useful for when they come in wet in winter- they soon learn to flake out on an old towel instead of getting everywhere damp. Lots of old fashioned tricks, like 'stay' and them staying while you go out of sight, and 'leave it' where you leave a treat or little biscuit on a paw until you say 'ok', all those self control and concentration things wear them out, and are really useful too. And using hand signals at first with words, and then without, so they have to watch you. You can keep a dog entertained and busy without walking miles. They are so rewarding to teach.

Batalax · 03/05/2023 22:26

The kong wobbler to feed their kibble is good. We also put kibble and/or treats in a snuffle mat and

I'm accidentally a bad dog owner
bookwormcrazy · 03/05/2023 20:16

@JetWashingIsMyHobby My dog is exactly the same at being reluctant to come in after his last wee. 🤣 He is a stubborn Westie, so this has become his "dentastix" time, just before bed and it works every single time. As soon as he hears that cupboard door go, he's in and sat down waiting for his dentastix.
Because he is a small dog he suffers with his tummy if he doesn't have something to eat before bed so this is perfect. It's funny how we adapt things to create a routine and get what we want. 😂 I never knew that with dogs you needed to learn the art of negation and bribery! 😂

primoseyellow · 03/05/2023 20:10

You sound like a really good owner. I think as others have said you need to teach to him to settle, it sounds like too much exercise. Our 11 month gets 2 walks a day, one 30/40 min morning with some off lead ( we have only recently started this as we didn't want her over exercised too young) and a 20 min walk in the afternoon.

At one point I realised I was giving her so much attention in the house, that I had to make myself pull back so she doesn't follow me around all the time and will happily lie in one room whilst I get on with stuff.

JetWashingIsMyHobby · 03/05/2023 20:10

bookwormcrazy · 03/05/2023 19:15

If it helps, the favourite activity I do with my dog is to chuck a handful of kibble or small treats into the grass in my garden. Probably more is required for a lab cross. This gives him an activity that mentally stimulates him while he sniffs it all out and hunts it down. Even just the activity of using their nose increase hearts rate and wears him out to a degree as well as keeping him occupied. You can even do this with his dinner if you feed him kibble. A way to to stimulate his brain without the physical exercise.

I only feed my dogs like this - lobbing it out into the garden so they can go and hunt for it. 😂 I hold back a little bit for the evening though as one of them can be a bit stubborn about coming back in after his evening wee, so I tempt him back in then with it.

NewtyB · 03/05/2023 19:55

Summerpetal · 03/05/2023 19:47

There’s an electronic ball thrower thing ,you just have to train the dog to put the ball on the top and it throws the ball back out …id get that for my dogs if I had a big enough garden

We had one of these - they aren't cheap but our dog loved it! It only lasted 3 months max though, and when we complained they said it was only designed to last a certain number of throws and apparently our dog used an entire lifetime of throws in less than 3 months 🤦‍♀️😂

Missingmyusername · 03/05/2023 19:52

Lol @LetDownDog made those same mistakes. I paid a behaviourist to come in and she said I didn’t reward good behaviour and that my dog couldn’t differentiate between good attention and bad attention. It was just attention and he didn’t care which kind of attention he got.
Had to learn to ignore his naughty behaviour or redirect it, which was hard at times and reward and praise calm behaviour.

It’ll work out.

(Beware throwing balls for dogs- my vet says it’s the worst thing you can do for a dogs joints… )

Comfortingpigeon · 03/05/2023 19:51

PinkLemonadee · 03/05/2023 17:53

Teach him how to settle. In my experience, dogs who have constant stimulation end up like over tired kids where they just get more and more wound up. Get him a crate or other "bed" space and when he's tired, give him whatever command you want to use so he associates it with chill time.

Lickey mats and scatter feeding might be worth a try too.

This. I have working gundogs and frankly, you could spend 24hrs a day 'stimulating' them and they,'d still be ready for more. You have to put them somewhere safe and give them a chew toy to just chill out.

Summerpetal · 03/05/2023 19:47

There’s an electronic ball thrower thing ,you just have to train the dog to put the ball on the top and it throws the ball back out …id get that for my dogs if I had a big enough garden

Shopper727 · 03/05/2023 19:43

Spaniels are high energy I remember having one as a kid and he was very bouncy but so lovely 😊. As others have said could you do some specific work with him? Hoopers/agility/working trials/scent work etc to keep him ‘busy’

i would also work on calm. Reward calm ignore calm and just not give him attention when you’re not doing things with him. My retriever was like this as my partner constantly bloody gave him attention etc so he constantly wanted attention etc. it took ages to just let him be, training partner and dog to just not react to each other. Or if he’s needing something he gets a licky mat, long lasting chew or frozen kong just to settle him. Works well. Am sure you’ll find what works but our golden retrievers face can often be hard to ignore as I’m sure your dogs is whwn he wants love and cuddles but give them when you choose rather than him asking, we do the same for walks etc to stop him predicting and getting stressed if he can’t be walked then etc

NewtyB · 03/05/2023 19:37

We have a lab x spaniel and she was exactly like this until she was about 18 months, and then it was like overnight she just learnt that during the day is work time, and she just naps on our bed (think she thinks she's being sneaky 😂) or on the sofa. We found as well that she settled amazingly if she could just see outside. Is there a place he can watch through a window? Ours will happily stare at people and dogs walking past for hours.
We originally played with her constantly and had an automatic fetch machine which she loved but it did just make her a bit more energetic!

Idratherbepaddleboarding · 03/05/2023 19:35

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

OrlandointheWilderness · 03/05/2023 19:32

My spaniels get two walks a day. Some days they get one. They have 4 training sessions a week and through shooting season the one who isn't retired will be out working too.
They are both working bred spaniels and the young one is a year and a half. They need switch off and settle time to do nothing. Mine will sleep all day then they turn on instantly if needed!

ElmTree22 · 03/05/2023 19:32

PinkLemonadee · 03/05/2023 17:53

Teach him how to settle. In my experience, dogs who have constant stimulation end up like over tired kids where they just get more and more wound up. Get him a crate or other "bed" space and when he's tired, give him whatever command you want to use so he associates it with chill time.

Lickey mats and scatter feeding might be worth a try too.

I second this. We have a working line GSD and he has a 1-2 hour walk a day (whatever I can fit in with the baby, but plenty of outdoor time in the garden and interaction through the day. But when I say "that's enough" he knows it's time to wind down and stop the crazy!
Dogs will take whatever you give them, you can actually build up their stamina. You give them 4 x 1 hour walk and they will expect it. Give them less and they will get used to that too!! My boy would go and go and go until I tell him it's enough because he can't switch that working line brain off.

Namefortodayandtomorrow · 03/05/2023 19:31

Highly recommend Susan Garrett’s Recallers program. If that is too pricey, try Homeschool the Dog. Her philosophy and approach work amazingly well. She also has a podcast and lots of free material on her YouTube channel if you want to see before you buy.

PontefractCakesRemindMeOfGrandpa · 03/05/2023 19:30

LetDownDog · 03/05/2023 18:02

Thank you so much for that! I thought everyone would pile on and say 'well what did you expect, you r a really bad person'. Which I would have deserved! But thank you, your post has made me feel better!

I agree with nearly all this too! We got a Lab and she if brilliant but it’s been such hard work, far more than I anticipated. It’s the evenings that still get me when she wants to play every night between 8-9.30 and I just want to sit after a busy day! But at just over 2 she is becoming very rounded. Stick with it OP, it does get easier!

gotmychristmasmiracle · 03/05/2023 19:29

We play a game call 'find it' for our dog and hide treats around the house, can keep her busy for ages.

Jellybebe · 03/05/2023 19:27

Yes you are unreasonable as this is a live animal and not a cuddly toy. However, dog ownership is tough and you are not the first person to have made this mistake and you certainly won't be the last. I'm glad you are seeking help.

I can't think of a breed that needs 4 hours of walking a day. I can only think of a collie who need 2-3 hours which you can achieve by walking dog before work, lunchtime and after work. Join a club that could provide mental stimulation of some kind- agility training or scent training. I know someone who joined search and rescue team in the local area.

Good luck x

LetDownDog · 03/05/2023 19:20

Thanks again everyone! I'm so surprised at the lovely and v helpful posts!! I really thought everyone would say how I'm a rubbish dog owner and should have thought about all this beforehand etc... And 'if you can't cope with 4 walks you should never have had a dog ...' It's so so reassuring hearing all the comments. Especially hearing that 4 walks is too many! I can't wait to cut that down!! :)

OP posts:
LetDownDog · 03/05/2023 19:16

BiddyPop · 03/05/2023 19:15

Posting to find this again as we have a somewhat similar story

Good to know I'm not alone!! Hope you r finding the tips helpful too :) 🐶👍

OP posts:
LetDownDog · 03/05/2023 19:15

second dog to play with

well I suggested this to poor knackered DH! And he looked at me like I'd just asked him if we could have another 3 kids!! It was a v definite 'no'! 😁😁🐶

OP posts:
strawberriesarenot · 03/05/2023 19:15

Puzzles. Treasure hunts- sprinkled grated cheese in the garden - very little cheese keeps them going for ages. Boxes to unpack. Training sessions where he has to use his brain and self control. Proper down time, so he learns to relax.

Monkeynuts57 · 03/05/2023 19:15

How olds the dog?
would a second help? We have two and it’s amazingly good as they entertain play and company for each other! We do a lot less because of this