Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that driving 10hrs overnight with toddler is a good idea?!

140 replies

MintGreenLife · 03/05/2023 17:02

DS is 21 months and we are going away for 10 days in the UK. To drive it’s 10hrs and we were thinking of driving overnight. He doesn’t go to bed until 9pm, so we would probably leave around 8pm, keep him entertained for the first hour, then hopefully he will go to sleep. Imagine we would arrive around 7am with a couple loo/coffee stops, and this would be his usual wakeup time. We will share the driving and one of us will be in the back with him at all times.

Are we mad to do this? Has anyone got any experience of this? We are going on holiday with family, so they will be able to help with DS the next day while we catch up on a bit of sleep. Also can’t find any info, but the 2hr in the car seat rule must not apply once they are toddlers??

The alternative is leave the house at 6am, 2hr drive, bus to airport, 2hrs in the airport, 1.5hr flight, 2.5hr drive out the other side. I just feel like that’ll be so much more stressful, and DS isn’t a good sleeper, so all that sitting still will most likely result in a terrible night first night of our hols.

What would you do?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JudgeJ · 21/06/2023 10:58

Leftoverssandwich · 03/05/2023 17:05

We've done many overnight drives across Europe with children and it's fine. We swap over and get some sleep in turn. I wouldn't want to do it more than one night in a row but it does the job.

We too used to do this sort of trip regularly, 5 hours to the coast, a couple of hours on the ferry then 5 or 6 hours from Dover north. The children from being tiny would usually sleep part of the first leg, be awake to eat on the ferry then sleep for the drive north. Obviously we would split the driving.

hufflepuffbutrequestinggriffindor · 21/06/2023 06:48

Every year I drive 500 miles south to my parents. I always drive in the day time. I would be tired and not be able to concentrate driving over night and I would really worry about having an accident. At least day time is akin to my working hours so I'm awake and alert and not putting my child in danger.

unsync · 20/06/2023 13:02

MatildaTheCat · 03/05/2023 18:41

My parents drove us down to the South of France overnight when we were young. They put the back seats down, chucked in some padding and tucked all 3 of us up in our sleeping bags. I guess our luggage was on the roof rack. We must have looked a total sight 😂.

In their defence it was the 70s, we were absolutely awful about squabbling in the car and it was probably worth the effort.

Go for it but I’d recommend using appropriate restraints 😀

Yup, this, with Phenergen cough syrup to knock us out! Silent Generation parents with Gen X kids.

caringcarer · 20/06/2023 11:09

DH and I used to drive to Italy for summer holidays. We always caught late afternoon ferry so DC would be tired once we arrived in France then gradually fall asleep. DH and I drove through the night taking turns driving and plenty of black coffee. We would arrive about 10.30am next morning and kids would wake about 7.30-8am.

MeridaBrave · 20/06/2023 10:57

I’d leave earlier, eg around 6pm. We used to drive to Scotland and back, leave at 5:30
/6pm (no day time sleeps that day!) and arrive around midnight. If it was longer I’d leave around 4pm, keep him away stop for dinner.

Ginisatonic · 19/06/2023 17:03

Just realised this is an old thread.

Ginisatonic · 19/06/2023 17:01

TeenLifeMum · 03/05/2023 18:44

I’d leave at 4/5pm and entertain/keep awake, then stop for dinner at 7.30pm and a run around. Put pjs on at service station and do the rest of the drive so you arrive early hours and can get some sleep before morning.

I agree with this. We used to drive from London to Glasgow frequently and we either did this or woke up very early, 4 or 5 put children in car in PJs. They’d go straight back to sleep as soon as the car moved. Managed to get a few hours done before they really woke up.

Wiseflower · 19/06/2023 16:55

Sounds sensible! You would be exhausted travelling with a baby overnight anywhere, it is not worth the hassle. Time will fly and it will be a lot easier and you will enjoy family hols a lot more x

MintGreenLife · 19/06/2023 16:47

@Wiseflower no we didn’t 😂 I realised as he doesn’t even sleep through in his bed at home, the likelihood of him sleeping through overnight in the car and not waking up upset was slim 🤦🏻‍♀️ think it’s something we will try when he’s a little older and sleeping better x

OP posts:
bluebird3 · 19/06/2023 16:33

Personally I need at least some sleep to not get jet lagged. I'd do something like this...

Leave at 6:30pm, drive till 8:30. Stop for loo break/nappy change and pjs. Back in the car 9-12. Stop at a hotel and sleep till 6am.
Set off and stop at 8:30 for a break and breakfast. Back in the car 9-11:30.

We drove 20 hours over two day times with my DD when she was that age. We did rely on some screen time and snacks but with breaks to run around it was ok.

Chickpea17 · 19/06/2023 16:25

Honestly, I don't think it's a good idea to have a 21 month old in a car seat for 10 hours. Isn't there there a two-hour rule for toddlers in a car seat if I remember rightly.

OneStepOneStumble · 19/06/2023 16:19

We do this with our toddler but tend to leave around 530, stop at a nearish services at 6/7 to do dinner. Then drive on and she sleeps. We then get there early morning and at least have a couple of hours to get our head down at our destination. Of course this depends on whether you have a bed immediately available where you go.

But yes I would recommend. Our toddler can be a nightmare in the car so any drive time where she's likely to be asleep is a bonus.

Wiseflower · 19/06/2023 16:14

Did you drive overnight in the end? Travelling with a baby long distance is difficult because they have their routines which change as they grow. As long as you are able to easily feed, change, keep baby comfortable.

Onehappymam · 04/05/2023 21:37

If we feel like we’re flagging, we pull over at a service station for a nap. The kids are asleep anyway.

Can’t imagine pulling over for a rest through the day while the kids were wide awake.

Caspianberg · 04/05/2023 18:52

@BertieBotts - ha, it’s exhausting, but there’s no way my toddler will do the journey without stopping often. can be a small petting zoo with park where Ds can burn energy an hour or so and adults down caffeine , not a massive day out. We tend to fly now most trips.

BertieBotts · 04/05/2023 18:46

Caspianberg · 04/05/2023 08:46

When we do our 1000km+ drive home from England, I wouldn’t do overnight. I like to actually make the drive part of the trip if you see what I mean, and we take a slightly different route each time so we can stop off at different castles/ towns/ zoos on route. Doesn’t feel such a ‘chore’

I'm honestly in awe of you doing a 1000km drive and fitting in a trip to a castle or a zoo! We find it totally exhausting so I can't imagine doing these things as well. How long would you usually spend at those places? Usually we just want to get back on the road as quickly as possible.

BertieBotts · 04/05/2023 17:53

All the people going on about research etc have clearly never actually done it - talk to people who have, and remember some of the stats about driving in the early hours of the morning will be drunk people, and people who've got stranded so they are pushing on through when they're already tired. Motorway driving at that time is very safe, especially since there is hardly anybody else on the road. Most people I know who live here (EU country) and drive home do it this way. Some stop overnight. But for us that would add an extra day to the travel time as well as the expense - it just makes it impractical. For us leaving at about midnight is the optimal way to do it.

Definitely goes without saying that you must be aware of the tiredness risk and of course stop if you feel tired.

When we drive home from UK we tend to do it in the day instead, so 3h from our families' town to the ferry port, which we get up early and try to do in one go before rush hour.

Then cross, which adds an hour this way, so it's late morning by the time we get over. Try to do a couple of hours then stop for lunch, then another couple of hours then stop for a run around, another hour or so then stop for dinner, and then the last stretch of about 2 hours.

So this is early morning (4/5am) until about 9-10pm. It's OK. It's a stressful day because the DC get fed up. We've done this with various ages of kids (have DC 1.5 - 14yo) and between crawling and about 6yo is when they are the most difficult to travel with.

Doing the journey 100% during their awake time makes it harder because they get bored, so you have to stop off more often and for longer so the journey takes longer. A 10 hour drive takes us about 16h this way. Older children probably do best with this option, though, because they can understand the purpose of the journey. Toddlers just do not understand why they are being strapped into a seat again and they get really angry about it unless they are tired enough to not care or you build in more/longer stops.

Doing the journey during 100% of their usual sleep time (leaving at their bedtime) tends to mean they don't sleep well and then they are really grumpy all the next day. Plus, we found that the adults felt more tired this way, because we hadn't had any time to rest between (hyper, manic with excitement) child wrangling all day and then driving. So arguably you do that "dangerous stretch" of 2-6am when you've been awake for the longest. However it's probably the quickest way to do it. When we did this the whole trip took only 13 hours. There are no rush hours to avoid. We did find they woke up more disorientated in the first part of the journey and then they had long periods awake in the middle of the night, though not as moany as they were when we drove in the day.

Leaving in the middle of the night, so they have had a good 4-5 hours' sleep (and adults get to sleep for 3-4 hours too) means that they tend to sleep through a good portion while the roads are also clear so you can cover a lot of ground. And when you stop you only do minimal stops for a wee and then back in the car and they go to sleep again. This minimises the overall length of the journey. You still have to stop every hour or two in the second half, but that's not as bad. And you attack that "dangerous time" of driving with the energy and enthusiasm of the start of the trip. This usually takes us about 14 hours depending on traffic.

Whatever you do it seems to work to front-load, so do longer stretches in the first half of the journey when everyone has more tolerance and then more frequent stops towards the end of the journey, sometimes with a longer push for the last ~25%.

With positional asphyxiation the "clock resets" when you take them out of the seat, so it's not quite the same as leaving them in a car seat to sleep for the whole night in one go.

You will probably have to change nappies at every stop just because you want to keep DC as comfortable as possible but also because they wee more when they are awake than asleep, and they'll be awake for at least some of the journey.

You/partner will probably end up spending some time in the back with DC.

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 04/05/2023 09:57

We do Aberdeen to the south coast and back at least once a year and have done since dc1 was very small. Always in day time with lots of stops. Sometimes we break the journey with a random premier inn or similar but basically we make the travel part of the trip.

Overnights are a great idea in theory but the risk of no one getting any sleep has always put me off based on my mum's description of attempting it with me who could apparently make it from the middle of Germany to Yorkshire via ferry without any sleep but much vomiting as a toddler (and back). My kids are hit and miss car sleepers though so a long day of doing many things and then falling into a new bed has always worked.

MintGreenLife · 04/05/2023 09:36

@blobby10 I’m definitely considering something like this! Because DS naps well in the car, I assumed he would probably sleep all night, but then again he doesn’t even sleep through in his bed. I guess I just assumed the movement of the car would keep him asleep and it would be an easy option but possibly not! I’ll look into all the different timing options and possible places to stop x

OP posts:
blobby10 · 04/05/2023 09:17

We tried late night travelling on the way back from Cornwall (8 hour journey for us) and it failed miserably every single time. Not one of the children would fall asleep and certainly didn't stay asleep if they did! even our 12 week old daughter wouldn't bloody sleep!

Would it be better getting up very early (4am) and travelling then? This always worked better for us as the kids just slept really well the first night after all the excitement. Set off at 4.15am, stop for picnic breakfast at 7 and change into day clothes, stop again for picnic 'lunch' and run around at 9, arrive at destination late morning. Another picnic around 1pm, afternoon full of fresh air and running around, dinner at 5pm then bed at normal time which was 7pm.

Caspianberg · 04/05/2023 08:46

When we do our 1000km+ drive home from England, I wouldn’t do overnight. I like to actually make the drive part of the trip if you see what I mean, and we take a slightly different route each time so we can stop off at different castles/ towns/ zoos on route. Doesn’t feel such a ‘chore’

MintGreenLife · 04/05/2023 08:09

Like several of the PP this is something I grew up doing - same journey with my own parents overnight was a child.

OP posts:
MintGreenLife · 04/05/2023 08:08

@Whosaidthattt thanks ☺️ this is how I was feeling for the most part, until I got some mixed responses with some people very much against the idea. And now I’m doubting if it’s a good idea myself 🤦🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
Whosaidthattt · 04/05/2023 08:05

We have driven overnight from Sussex to Edinburgh many times with the babies/toddlers. It has always been the best option and the kids don't mind- they sleep most of the way. Bring a flask of coffee and take turns to drive. You'll be fine!

Simianwalk · 04/05/2023 07:58

But DH does a job that involves driving at night so he did lots of that bit. Also the night bit was through France on straight, boring roads.