Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School says “bring lots of cash”

171 replies

Queestuproblema · 03/05/2023 16:55

I’ll start this by saying I understand schools are underfunded and have been doing Christmas markets/summer fayres/wear x colour for £1 days since even I have been at school. It’s not going to stop but the leaflet we’ve been sent this week quotes:

”Spring market
Come and toast the coronation!
Support our school, bring bags and lots of cash”

AIBU to think the wording of bring lots of cash is completely insensitive to how much everyone is struggling right now? I don’t feel that part was necessary. They could’ve made the leaflet without that surely given some children wont even be able to attend with a few pounds.

OP posts:
Clarabell77 · 03/05/2023 20:44

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 03/05/2023 19:25

They're using a public interest news hook to drum up interest in their fundraiser. Coronation stuff is everywhere, it's the obvious theme. Which do you value more, supporting the school or expressing your opposition to the monarchy in an event that doesn't actually make any difference to it?

Jaysus, I'm so glad I refused the volunteering role that involved communicating with members of the public. I do something else instead that means I can be useful without having to take all this crap because I possibly missed a nuance in something I've never done professionally, offending a load of people who can't actually do it any better.

A lot of the public aren’t interested though. We’re being told to be interested, it’s like living in a dictatorship. Same as the forced mourning when the Queen died. Sombre music in supermarkets and on the radio, absolutely bloody ridiculous.

I probably value expressing my opposition to the monarchy more than supporting the school, because we shouldn’t need to be supporting schools to the extent we do in the first place, and that mob of inbred scroungers are part of the problem. Abolish them, distribute the country’s wealth more fairly and fund our public services properly. And that’s not to say I don’t support the school, I’ve done and given plenty over the years, but you did ask.

Queestuproblema · 03/05/2023 20:42

I’m in my late 20s and gave 8 years of my life working in primary education before leaving. I really don’t need to think about what teachers and school staff have to deal with- I lived it. To address those posts.

With the replies about people who feel the need to be offended on behalf of the poor and speaking for them - I am the poor. I’m part of the people they talk about on the news who can’t pay their bills, can’t afford to eat and have to miss meals, wear clothes that no longer fit or aren’t warm enough. So if you think I’m speaking on behalf of poor people, it’s because I am one.

OP posts:
DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 03/05/2023 20:42

HeadbandOverMyEyes · 03/05/2023 20:30

Why would I be trying to rewrite a leaflet that's already happened? The example/typical stuff I typed was longer because it wasn't an attempt to rewrite a "better" version 🤣 (hence the central chunk full of random additional stuff) — I wanted to use an example to the type of thing I'm used to seeing for fundraisers round here, regurgitated some of their phrasing, and let it run longer to give more components of the style they tend to use.

I mean, on that front, at least, good on whoever wrote OP's leaflet for breaking away from the formulaic stuff. No slating here Confused even though I was interested in the reasons people might take offence at it, and thought that it did come across as pretty blunt. If they're here and reading, do you think you're making them feel better by telling them that some horrible random internet person is telling them they're shit (rather than an internet person who's interested in what happens to make people feel offended by something not intended to be offensive)? Or by trying to elicit sympathy for their imagined background? For all you know they're in marketing and kindly donated some of their expensive time to the PTA, which is why they broke away from the less abrupt kind of thing I'm used to seeing.

Why would I be trying to rewrite a leaflet that's already happened?

What, so you did do it as an exercise in pointlessness? Even you can't think of a reason why you rewrote it?

You did it to try to show how it "should" be done. As you say, giving examples of what you think people usually do. And you failed because it isn't actually as easy as you think it is. It's no good getting in a load of clichés if you're producing a wall of text that nobody's going to read.

Your verbose posts are an ongoing exercise in blaming some hapless volunteer who almost certainly isn't a communications professional. Trying to make out that she's more to blame than any professionally offended parent who'd prioritise their need to be offended over supporting the school.

Caramac555 · 03/05/2023 20:40

I'd be more bothered if it said all major credit cards accepted.

I think it was just a clumsy way of saying bring your own carrier bags and it's cash only. PTA relies on volunteers they don't have a marketing and coms department.

Gollumsring · 03/05/2023 20:33

Yawn

HeadbandOverMyEyes · 03/05/2023 20:30

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 03/05/2023 19:20

You posted to slate some poor volunteer doing their best and try to show how much better a job you could do. As it happens, your own offering was so over-wordy that it probably wouldn't have fitted on the poster, or it would have looked like a total wall of text. And people would have fallen asleep before they got to the end of it.

Nobody who actually prioritises a school fundraiser over their own need to feel offended or superior will refuse to go because some unpaid volunteer who isn't a comms professional used a turn of phrase that some people don't like. Nor will they blame the non-professional volunteer over the school parent who chooses to try to ruin a fundraiser because they were so desperate to be offended and righteous.

Why would I be trying to rewrite a leaflet that's already happened? The example/typical stuff I typed was longer because it wasn't an attempt to rewrite a "better" version 🤣 (hence the central chunk full of random additional stuff) — I wanted to use an example to the type of thing I'm used to seeing for fundraisers round here, regurgitated some of their phrasing, and let it run longer to give more components of the style they tend to use.

I mean, on that front, at least, good on whoever wrote OP's leaflet for breaking away from the formulaic stuff. No slating here Confused even though I was interested in the reasons people might take offence at it, and thought that it did come across as pretty blunt. If they're here and reading, do you think you're making them feel better by telling them that some horrible random internet person is telling them they're shit (rather than an internet person who's interested in what happens to make people feel offended by something not intended to be offensive)? Or by trying to elicit sympathy for their imagined background? For all you know they're in marketing and kindly donated some of their expensive time to the PTA, which is why they broke away from the less abrupt kind of thing I'm used to seeing.

nopenotplaying · 03/05/2023 20:29

P.s our newsletter said contactless payment is available at the fete 🤣 chill out

nopenotplaying · 03/05/2023 20:28

The children probably made the flyer 🙄

electriclight · 03/05/2023 20:23

OP, please know that the relentless scrutiny and criticism from parents is one of the reasons lots of teachers are leaving. It's not the only reason of course, but one of several. It doesn't matter what we do, we get this sort of shit, even about a leaflet asking for cash at a fundraiser. I realise it's a novel idea but why not occasionally see something that raises your hackles a bit and just turn the other fucking cheek. Or try to see the other point of view. Or weigh it against all the good things they've done and let it fucking go.

Dodgeitornot · 03/05/2023 20:18

Meepledeep · 03/05/2023 20:07

It's tricky as most people have good intentions and invariably the response is really defensive and along the lines of omg I won't bother in the future then. But the reality is that being supportive or an ally is sometimes speaking up if people are silenced and being their voice, but often it's facilitating their own voices. People who assume x, y or z is offensive whilst being outside of the group they think its offensive for is just another sort of condescending aw bless they can't speak for themselves so I'm going to swoop in. The reality is for people struggling financially this is unlikely to be a big deal, and making it one ruins things needlessly in their name without their consent or want.

Exactly. There's nothing wrong with being an ally and stepping in and saying hey this may not be very nice. However, I very often experienced situations in my childhood when people tried to 'advocate' for me, wouldn't stop banging on to everyone and their mother about said event and what they did to intervene and help poor old me. It sometimes felt like they were doing it just to feel better about themselves. Just like this thread, it's rarely done discreetly.
If you want to be an ally and help the poor, do it so they have dignity and don't shout from the rooftops how little X didn't get included, they're making fetes far too expensive, but thank goodness you helped out and gave him some coins!

Meepledeep · 03/05/2023 20:15

Redebs · 03/05/2023 20:09

Yes

Usually school fundraisers go out of their way to avoid pressuring parents. There are usually low priced items so that children can get something without spending much.

I hope the event isn't in school time.

Ffs it's a bloody fundraiser, there'll be plenty of cheap tat and crap to buy for cheap don't worry. The point is to raise money, have we reached the point where you have to say we are raising money but don't worry not too much. People struggling financially aren't bloody stupid.

Endlesssummer2022 · 03/05/2023 20:10

Oh it’s another one of those ‘read the room!’ threads. How depressing.

Redebs · 03/05/2023 20:09

SchoolTripDrama · 03/05/2023 17:34

This. It would certainly stop me attending. There are plenty of people without ANY spare cash. Many children will be missing out

Yes

Usually school fundraisers go out of their way to avoid pressuring parents. There are usually low priced items so that children can get something without spending much.

I hope the event isn't in school time.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 03/05/2023 20:09

Turn up with £40. In pennies

Clarabell77 · 03/05/2023 20:07

Dodgeitornot · 03/05/2023 19:41

Who said we should? But we're here and this school is trying. Instead of getting on the PTA herself, the OP has decided to critique it and advocate on behalf of alllll the stupid poor people that obviously can't speak for themselves, how horrifying the wording it.

I think OP is entitled to have an opinion on it without having to join the PTA. That’s like saying we can’t have an opinion on politics without being a Member of Parliament. Our PTA which I was on for a couple of years is very mindful of how things are worded, how often they fundraise and how much they charge for things. It’s not hard.

Meepledeep · 03/05/2023 20:07

Barbecuebeans · 03/05/2023 18:52

That must be so infuriating. I can't even imagine what it's like to have people talking on your behalf, as if you can't quite happily talk for yourself.

It's tricky as most people have good intentions and invariably the response is really defensive and along the lines of omg I won't bother in the future then. But the reality is that being supportive or an ally is sometimes speaking up if people are silenced and being their voice, but often it's facilitating their own voices. People who assume x, y or z is offensive whilst being outside of the group they think its offensive for is just another sort of condescending aw bless they can't speak for themselves so I'm going to swoop in. The reality is for people struggling financially this is unlikely to be a big deal, and making it one ruins things needlessly in their name without their consent or want.

londonrach · 03/05/2023 19:47

Seriously you ott op...it's said as a joke.. spend what you want...my DD school says the same..we visit and sadly don't buy anything...no one judges ..my DD enjoys seeing her friends

12345mummy · 03/05/2023 19:46

I agree OP that in the current climate it could have been worded better

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 03/05/2023 19:44

Yes, I know it's wordy. It was an example of the kind of phrasing I've seen a million times on this sort of thing, not My Superior Alternative. I considered including a shorter version too (or instead), but decided that for a quick MN post — where I'm not claiming to be putting forth suggested wording, just trying to hold the OP's example next to a more common or typical way of phrasing this kind of thing — a version which bolds the most important parts would do.

Oh ffs. If it wasn't supposed to be a good example of suggested wording, what was the point of it? A deliberate attempt to waste time?

You tried to outdo the volunteer you're criticising and you failed because the job isn't as easy as you think it is. Cut the volunteers some slack, recognise their intentions and prioritise supporting the school.

ourflagmeansdeath · 03/05/2023 19:41

There is no way anyone could be this sensitive.

Dodgeitornot · 03/05/2023 19:41

Clarabell77 · 03/05/2023 19:28

We shouldn’t need to fundraisers for essential items for our schools and the scroungers are part of the problem.

Who said we should? But we're here and this school is trying. Instead of getting on the PTA herself, the OP has decided to critique it and advocate on behalf of alllll the stupid poor people that obviously can't speak for themselves, how horrifying the wording it.

Dodgeitornot · 03/05/2023 19:39

@HeadbandOverMyEyes I really cannot be bothered to read your essay. I'm sure you're a lovely person irl. Take care.

HeadbandOverMyEyes · 03/05/2023 19:38

Dodgeitornot · 03/05/2023 18:29

@HeadbandOverMyEyes What about being inclusive to all the parents who's first language isn't English? Those who may be illiterate? Your advert is very wordy. Bring lots of cash is much easier to understand.
can you see that you can't please everyone?

Yes, I know it's wordy. It was an example of the kind of phrasing I've seen a million times on this sort of thing, not My Superior Alternative. I considered including a shorter version too (or instead), but decided that for a quick MN post — where I'm not claiming to be putting forth suggested wording, just trying to hold the OP's example next to a more common or typical way of phrasing this kind of thing — a version which bolds the most important parts would do.

If this thread were about providing information in formats accessible to those with difficulties extracting information from large chunks of text, I'd have plenty to say about it. I'm reasonably confident I've done more pressuring and campaigning on that front than the majority of those on this thread. But the thread is about phrasing that the OP, and some others, find offensive, insulting, annoying, insensitive, or otherwise offputting, to one degree or another, not reading ability. I found it interesting to think about things like, for example, how the interpretation of the meaning "cash" affects the level of formality, which might affect whether people feel their money is being respected.

I think that the response "can you see that you can't please everyone" is a bit of a cop-out. Apart from the fact that I'm not trying to please anyone and posted because I think it's an interesting topic rather than because I have fayre leaflets to write, if I was told that my phrasing for something like this might have soured some people against my fundraising event, no matter how unreasonable I thought that offence-taking might be, I'd want to at least think about whether there was an alternative that met the same requirements but didn't put those people off. I wouldn't think "Hmm… when some random person on Mumsnet typed something phrased differently for comparison, it was too long and a bit shit — ah well, can't please everyone, so we'll stick with the one that some people found offputting." I might even decide to stick with my original phrasing.

Funny thing is, I don't even personally find it offensive 😅 I just got my interest piqued and started thinking about why some people might.

MrsCrustyBread2 · 03/05/2023 19:38

Clarabell77 · 03/05/2023 19:24

Oh dear… that was quick. What next? I’ll take the bank holiday - damn right I will, I’ve done more to earn it than they have.

The full cost of the parasites is actually well hidden, thanks to them making sure they are above the law when it comes to freedom of information.

Any tourism generated is more to do with the buildings etc which would still exist if the monarchy was abolished. No one comes to the country to see them in person. France gets plenty of tourists as a republic, and so would we.

People won't be travelling to the UK from across the globe, staying in hotels, and eating at restaurants in London to stare at an empty building this weekend. They're coming to try and catch a glimpse of the King and so they can say that they were here during his Coronation.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 03/05/2023 19:32

Clarabell77 · 03/05/2023 19:28

We shouldn’t need to fundraisers for essential items for our schools and the scroungers are part of the problem.

I'm not a royalist myself, but the reason schools need more money is not because of the Royal Family.

At any rate, even if it were, you complaining about a coronation fundraiser and refusing to support it makes no difference to Charles and only punishes the school.