Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not like the term 'on the spectrum' to mean autistic/has autism

243 replies

UndertheCedartree · 03/05/2023 16:20

It really bugs me! Lots of conditions have spectrums so you could be talking about anything. It's so imprecise.

Also, I think it perpetuates the myth that there is one spectrum and everyone is on it somewhere so everyone is autistic to a greater or lesser extent.

OP posts:
xyxygy · 05/05/2023 10:06

Cuckoosheep · 05/05/2023 10:00

That's really interesting. Can you point me in the direction of reading material on this please?

My friends son has had a brain scan (autism dx) as he had a large birth mark across his scalp which indicated something (not sure what) to the doctors as yo why the scan was needed. It did show abnormalities. My own ds has never had a brain scan, I'd be really interested in what it would show but he'd never be able to lie still for it and I wouldn't put him through sedation without a proper medical need, if a scan was ever offered.

The more info and knowledge about causes the better, it can only help families. I really want to know what caused my ds presentation, I go back over his/ pregnancy do much questioning if I did anything, was around any chemicals, was I too stressed etc he was conceived just after a miscarriage as we were told I stood a better chance of conception due to hormone rates. I question this decision alot.

We're still waiting for the additional findings of our genome tests.

I really hope they pinpoint and give clarity. I sometimes feel the autism dx is a get out of jail free card for doctors as it covers such a vast number of presentations. It feels like it's become an easy dx to be given rather than root out what is really going on.

It was several years ago that I read about it (back when I was beginning my journey), but this one's a good start:

https://www.cell.com/neuron/fulltext/S0896-6273(14)00651-5

Cuckoosheep · 05/05/2023 10:02

If it was an excess of connections I wonder if they can create a way of removing some so that people who are really impacted can get some of the skills they lack eg become verbal.

Cuckoosheep · 05/05/2023 10:00

xyxygy · 05/05/2023 09:44

The problem is, genes aren't the only factor (at least, it doesn't seem that way). From the studies I've read, the only true test is a brain scan - it used to be that autism was considered to be a deficiency in neural connections (ie fewer connections) in the brain, but it's now known that it's the opposite...an excess of connections relative to the neurotypical brain.

The underlying condition is always the same, therefore - the presentation, however, depends up on precisely where in the brain the excess of connections is concentrated. Not only that, it's possible that the relative concentration compared with other parts of the brain is a factor too - so there would be a negative correlation (ie an excess of connections is that brain's "normal", so a more typical concentration in the speech centre may result in a non-verbal presentation).

That's really interesting. Can you point me in the direction of reading material on this please?

My friends son has had a brain scan (autism dx) as he had a large birth mark across his scalp which indicated something (not sure what) to the doctors as yo why the scan was needed. It did show abnormalities. My own ds has never had a brain scan, I'd be really interested in what it would show but he'd never be able to lie still for it and I wouldn't put him through sedation without a proper medical need, if a scan was ever offered.

The more info and knowledge about causes the better, it can only help families. I really want to know what caused my ds presentation, I go back over his/ pregnancy do much questioning if I did anything, was around any chemicals, was I too stressed etc he was conceived just after a miscarriage as we were told I stood a better chance of conception due to hormone rates. I question this decision alot.

We're still waiting for the additional findings of our genome tests.

I really hope they pinpoint and give clarity. I sometimes feel the autism dx is a get out of jail free card for doctors as it covers such a vast number of presentations. It feels like it's become an easy dx to be given rather than root out what is really going on.

xyxygy · 05/05/2023 09:44

Cuckoosheep · 05/05/2023 09:11

I hope that in time with research and likely more understanding of genetics there will be more distinct diagnosis. Conversations like this will be fewer as what's covered by the autism umbrella will be less and less. As a family we've taken part in a genome study and I know many families have had results showing mutations of genes likely related to their autism presentation.

The problem is, genes aren't the only factor (at least, it doesn't seem that way). From the studies I've read, the only true test is a brain scan - it used to be that autism was considered to be a deficiency in neural connections (ie fewer connections) in the brain, but it's now known that it's the opposite...an excess of connections relative to the neurotypical brain.

The underlying condition is always the same, therefore - the presentation, however, depends up on precisely where in the brain the excess of connections is concentrated. Not only that, it's possible that the relative concentration compared with other parts of the brain is a factor too - so there would be a negative correlation (ie an excess of connections is that brain's "normal", so a more typical concentration in the speech centre may result in a non-verbal presentation).

Cuckoosheep · 05/05/2023 09:11

I hope that in time with research and likely more understanding of genetics there will be more distinct diagnosis. Conversations like this will be fewer as what's covered by the autism umbrella will be less and less. As a family we've taken part in a genome study and I know many families have had results showing mutations of genes likely related to their autism presentation.

InattentiveADHD · 05/05/2023 00:22

UndertheCedartree · 03/05/2023 21:17

I have a feeling there is a word people sometimes use...but could be wrong.

I think ADHD isn't as recognised as a neurodiversity as autism as yet so the reason there isn't a mainstream word.

Woah back small pony! ADHD is definitely recognised as a neurodiversity! The reason is more to do with the name of the condition - Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder - is hard to make an "----ic" word out of. This is something often discussed on ADHD forums. Personally, I don't mind "has/have ADHD" (and my autistic and ADHD son doesn't mind "has/have autism" etc) I prefer person-first language. Although my ADHD is absolutely integral to who I am, I am also not just ADHD and I don't really want to be defined by it. It's definitely a disability and it largely negatively affects my life, so it's something I want to treat and mitigate, not something I want to define me. But obviously people have different views on this. I do object to people trying to dictate to others what language they MUST use though, as views amongst ND people vary widely as evidenced on this thread.

But I am going off a tangent (sorry ADHD :-)), back to people on ADHD forums. What most people tend to use that's equivalent to "autistic" is ADHDers (I do use this occasionally), or some people just say "I am ADHD" or similar. I struggle with the grammar of this last one personally though!

Daftasabroom · 04/05/2023 23:16

CampsieGlamper · 04/05/2023 20:20

Cancer can range from squamous cell or Basel cell carcinoma to a full blown neoplast, malignant or metastatic - from the "nothing to worry about" to the " you are not likely to be here in 6 months"

My understanding is that a condition is not lifelong even though it maybe life limiting, a disorder is lifelong though may have a wide range of impacts.

xyxygy · 04/05/2023 23:12

Conkersinautumn · 04/05/2023 22:58

It's just one of those phrases that helpfully let's me know to give someone a swerve. Not only ignorant but think it makes them sound knowing.

Heh...that's a pretty decent way of looking at it. My problem is that some of those people might be teachable (and thus have more value to the autistic community)...I just can't figure out which ones.

Conkersinautumn · 04/05/2023 22:58

It's just one of those phrases that helpfully let's me know to give someone a swerve. Not only ignorant but think it makes them sound knowing.

Arkestra · 04/05/2023 22:48

I understand that people want to use the term "spectrum" to capture the fact that autism is not some binary on/off condition.

But the term "spectrum" is itself simplistic, because autism isn't a single sliding scale, but is an umbrella term for a bunch of clusters of symptoms, which will be present to different degrees in any given person.

In the same way that "dyslexia" is now often unpacked into a number of distinct, but correlated, syndromes, I think that public understanding of "autism" will develop over time, making it easier for people to discuss it effectively.

Some examples from my own life:

  • One of my DC has some symptom clusters to an extent that have resulted in an Asperger's diagnosis, although they are managing to cope with mainstream schooling and socialisation.
  • I have friends with children with more pronounced symptoms, where mainstream schooling is not a goer.
  • I personally have some symptoms myself, although not at a level that would typically attract a formal label of Asperger's.

Neither "autism" nor "on the spectrum" can capture all of that! But we lack the language to do any better right now, so in the meantime, I don't really mind which people use as long as they are kind.

Example of the kind of discussion that's going on: this paper https://bmcneurol.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12883-019-1254-1

Autism, spectrum or clusters? An EEG coherence study - BMC Neurology

Background Autism prevalence continues to grow, yet a universally agreed upon etiology is lacking despite manifold evidence of abnormalities especially in terms of genetics and epigenetics. The authors postulate that the broad definition of an omnibus...

https://bmcneurol.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12883-019-1254-1

itsgettingweird · 04/05/2023 21:20

People prefer different approaches.

Especially those who have an autism diagnosis.

My ds hates autistic spectrum condition.

He prefers people saying he's autistic.

But others we know prefer "on the spectrum" "has autism" or "has an ASD".

Generally its best just to respect the person who you describing away of describing them self. And if that's "on the spectrum" then that's what you should use.

Jonei · 04/05/2023 21:15

xyxygy · 04/05/2023 20:49

It makes perfect sense if you already understand it. Most people who use the term "on the spectrum" as a euphemism are just doing so out of ignorance in order to avoid the word "autistic", and have no idea what it actually means.

I know. I came across a great picture that really described it, but I probably won't find it again.

xyxygy · 04/05/2023 20:49

Jonei · 04/05/2023 20:19

The spectrum makes perfect sense if you look at it. It makes sense how people are different in different areas. And no one is the same.

It makes perfect sense if you already understand it. Most people who use the term "on the spectrum" as a euphemism are just doing so out of ignorance in order to avoid the word "autistic", and have no idea what it actually means.

Cuckoosheep · 04/05/2023 20:20

@UndertheCedartree thank you.

CampsieGlamper · 04/05/2023 20:20

TallulahBetty · 03/05/2023 16:31

Just shows we are all different - I LOATHE the term 'is autistic' as you wouldn't say 'she is cancerous' - you would say she HAS cancer. I don't see why autism is any different, but there we go. Horses for courses

Cancer can range from squamous cell or Basel cell carcinoma to a full blown neoplast, malignant or metastatic - from the "nothing to worry about" to the " you are not likely to be here in 6 months"

Jonei · 04/05/2023 20:19

The spectrum makes perfect sense if you look at it. It makes sense how people are different in different areas. And no one is the same.

xyxygy · 04/05/2023 20:16

UndertheCedartree · 04/05/2023 20:13

I must admit I don't know much about Simon Baron-Cohen but was he the one that said autism is extreme maleness? I couldn't feel further away than from maleness, personally! 😂

Yep. He's wrong about most things, really, because the majority of his findings didn't involve actually asking autistic adults what their experience was - essentially, it seems like he's always started from the assumption that autistic people have limited agency (at least, from the parts of his work I've seen/read).

Ironically, the evidence for his hypothesis about Newton and Einstein was actually pretty compelling.

UndertheCedartree · 04/05/2023 20:13

xyxygy · 04/05/2023 19:46

The daft thing is, the one who proposed the idea that they were autistic - and supplied plenty of evidence to support it - is none other than Simon Baron-Cohen, the darling of the high-functioning vs low-functioning crowd.

I must admit I don't know much about Simon Baron-Cohen but was he the one that said autism is extreme maleness? I couldn't feel further away than from maleness, personally! 😂

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 04/05/2023 20:10

Cuckoosheep · 04/05/2023 19:46

We have liquid melatonin prescribed for my son. We used it years ago and found that it gradually stopped working. We've just started with it again to see if it will help again.

I know that you can get it over the counter in the states quite cheaply, they even sell them in gummy form like haribo sweets. If by chance you or someone you know is going over there.

Thank you. I do have a Canadian friend I could ask.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 04/05/2023 20:09

Cuckoosheep · 04/05/2023 19:40

Where have I complained about high functioning people on this thread? I think you're projecting or reading something into it that isn't there?

This thread until this has mostly been quite accepting and respectful of different views which has been quite refreshing.

You've not @Cuckoosheep , your posts have been very insightful of your experience.

Let's keep this thread respectful of all views, please 🙏

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 04/05/2023 20:07

LaMaG · 04/05/2023 19:19

Let's be nice!!!

I've been thinking about this thread. I have sympathy OP that this phrase irritates but I think we all have to endure phrases or descriptions of ourselves that we don't like and can't really control. Like I used to hate SAHM and I know others who thought full time parent was offensive. I changed jobs once doing exactly same thing but the second co gave me a different job title I didn't like at all whereas I had like the 1st place. These are just examples obviously, I'm sure we all have some. Just have to suck it up and tell those relevant in your life how you prefer to be referred to.

I used to hate SAHM too because it sounds like you stay at home all day! I think it's because I take it too literally but it doesn't make sense to me! ☺️

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 04/05/2023 20:04

thekindlyone · 04/05/2023 19:11

Do you wonder why some people feel the need to justify their support, when people like you try to turn every thread into complaining about so-called high functioning autistic people?

We all need to listen to each other.
@Cuckoosheep has been giving us some really good insight into her experience with autism. I haven't felt she is complaining, just explaining frustrations.

@thekindlyone it would be good to hear your experience too. Have you felt the need to justify your support?

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 04/05/2023 19:58

Mydcchangedmyusername · 04/05/2023 12:55

I don't mind 'on the spectrum' but I loathe 'I have the tism'. Makes it sound like an infection or disease.

To each their own though.

I've never heard 'I have the tism' but sounds like the kind of thing my teenager would say in an ironic way. Not sure if that is how it is said though!

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 04/05/2023 19:56

ChocolateTea · 04/05/2023 07:21

I agree with this - I hate people telling me how I should refer to myself because of their preference. There’s a local autism group that does it a lot, and it really grates on me!

every body is still an individual and has their own preference about their own identity.

re disability - I don’t class my Asperger’s as a disability when I fill in forms etc although it affects me daily, where as my son does; he’s mainstream etc but struggles a lot more than I do. But I would never tell another person they are or aren’t disabled.

I also agree with a previous poster way back who said it’s really hard to have the same condition given to people at such different levels of affect. It’s where the term Asperger’s was useful I think. I know friends with children who have autism who will never live alone, nor talk, still teens in nappies etc, and it feels so odd to me that my son has the same diagnosis yet is studying a levels. I can’t put my finger on why, but I almost feel like it lessens their struggles if that makes sense?

I definitely feel that too. There is such a wide range of disabilities/difficulties and some people feel there are positives/super powers etc.

And autism can be so hard that I understand wanting to try and improve people's self esteem by talking about super powers etc. It helps some people to accept themselves or understand themselves better. But it does really seem to grate when you consider the people that actually don't have super powers, that actually there aren't really any positives to their autism. I don't know what the answer is, but I think we need to make sure all voices are heard so the non-verbal don't get marginalised and forgotten about.

OP posts:
xyxygy · 04/05/2023 19:46

happyumwelt · 04/05/2023 06:49

Just opened this thread this morning to see that my response was called bizarre and stupid!

A couple of posters said that it annoys/bugs them that people like Darwin, Einstein and Newton are often considered autistic through a modern gaze and I asked why is bugs them. Why is their automatic response to dismiss the strong possibility that these individuals were autistic? The implication is that they think autism somehow besmirching these figures and their contributions and so I asked whether that is what they think. They could have defended their position if they chose to.

Also, the poster who called my question bizarre and stupid lifted it out of the context of the rest of my post - if you read the whole post, rather than just the question in isolation, it is clear what I am asking.

Thanks for the defence @UndertheCedartree

The daft thing is, the one who proposed the idea that they were autistic - and supplied plenty of evidence to support it - is none other than Simon Baron-Cohen, the darling of the high-functioning vs low-functioning crowd.