Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not like the term 'on the spectrum' to mean autistic/has autism

243 replies

UndertheCedartree · 03/05/2023 16:20

It really bugs me! Lots of conditions have spectrums so you could be talking about anything. It's so imprecise.

Also, I think it perpetuates the myth that there is one spectrum and everyone is on it somewhere so everyone is autistic to a greater or lesser extent.

OP posts:
xyxygy · 05/05/2023 16:08

SparklyBlackKitten · 05/05/2023 13:24

Spectrum to me is autism
But I feel like it should be numbered though . As in: you have been diagnosed with autism 5
Because there's such a big difference with autism and autism.

Being on the spectrum i think embodies that really well . But the beginning of the spectrum(autism 1) wouldn't be a neurotypical person. It would be a person with what previously be called Aspergers. And on the other end of the spectrum would be a non verbal, violent 9 year old with a mental capacity of a 2 year old. (Which would be autism 10) And then everything in between.
Dunnow. Might be whack too.
But there are so many autistic kids in my dcs school. And some of them seem like any regular oll' student and some of them are stood in the courtyard yelling and throwing bins around etc.

What I actually hate is when people talke about "being autistic" vs having autism

You are not autistic, you are you. And you have autism

The term " aspie" makes me cringe too

There are so many misconceptions about what autism actually is here that I'm not sure where to start.

Safe to say...this is basically the entirety of what autistic people are trying to get people to stop thinking, because it's just plain wrong.

Let's start with this: there isn't a scale of autism, like "a bit autistic" to "extremely autistic". There is a scale of support needs (which itself is incorrect, but it's used to determine insurance payouts in the US, so it kind of makes sense in the context of their inhumane system), but that's not remotely the same thing.

And..."the spectrum" is not a linear scale as you seem to believe it is. You can't put a number on it, because it's a collection of traits and not a straight line.

Cuckoosheep · 05/05/2023 15:17

The dwp have case law defining autism as meeting the arrested development or incomplete development of the brain in the criteria for severe mental impairment dla. Just the dx alone satisfies this aspect of the criteria. There are other criteria that have to be also. Some other awful terms are used as well.

So not only scientific language but bureaucratic/ legal definitions. In order to get the dx a person's life has to be impacted in some way so by that alone surely it's a disability plus it is a medical diagnosis. What people find acceptable or comfortable shouldn't impact on scientific definitions. I read a great article on this which I'll see if I can dig out. It discussed professionals being limited by the language their audiance found acceptsble and how this will limit recruitment and research progress. (I think it was looking at the general high/ low advocates/ family debate).

I think the language we use is incredibly important and reflective of how we view autism As this thread shows.

LlynTegid · 05/05/2023 15:05

Whilst it may not be said in a positive way on occasions, I think it is a helpful expression, if it highlights that many people with autism or other neurodiversities are very intelligent people.

SequinsandStilettos · 05/05/2023 15:03

No, I know, I was just musing. Some use ASC. Many - including medical professionals - as you say, use the medical terminology ASD.
SENco is now SENDco but I see both all the time.
Language use and change is always interesting. Atypical/neurodiverse/neurodivergent. I tend to use the middle one but am seeing the latter more often.

DinoHat · 05/05/2023 14:55

Daftasabroom · 05/05/2023 14:49

@SequinsandStilettos disorder and condition have very specific (medical/scientific) definitions. I think there's a conflict between very dry specific medical and scientific terminology and the way that people actually describe themselves.

This is true. People might not like a term, or might prefer a term because of the connotations of that term but they might be medical definitions/terminology.

Daftasabroom · 05/05/2023 14:49

@SequinsandStilettos disorder and condition have very specific (medical/scientific) definitions. I think there's a conflict between very dry specific medical and scientific terminology and the way that people actually describe themselves.

SequinsandStilettos · 05/05/2023 14:45

linear myth

disorder - whilst I may feel disordered (often!) condition seems more neutral.
ASC, ADHC, SPC, OCC and the DSC as Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Conditions all seem more neutral.

SequinsandStilettos · 05/05/2023 14:38

I hate the term ASD which I still keep seeing. D being Disorder.
I thought it was now ASC. C being Condition.
Yet I see ASD used more often than ASC across the board.

I hate the term HFA as high-functioning minimises the daily stresses and reinforces the trope of having a special skill.

The argument between using the terms having autism, autistic or aspie, has played out on here hundreds of times.
Personally, I think it is up to the individual how they want to define themselves and I'll respect that. There are arguments for and against person-first language and diagnosis-first language.

On the spectrum is a difficult one - it is a shorthand many associate with ND and so I have used it primarily to signal DC is not neurotypical but I feel I cannot say autistic (yet) as we are in limbo (on the pathway to diagnosis).
But I agree that it is problematic: I have been told not once but twice, that we all have our little quirks don't we? and we're all on the spectrum/autistic by professionals who really should know better. I have said countless times You meet someone with autism, you've only met that person with autism, yelled NOT LINEAR, but it falls on deaf ears.

I can also appreciate the difficulty between actually autistic people advocating for their identity and parents/carers with non-verbal children who may never live independently, navigating that particular road. By having such a range of neurodiversity under the same umbrella, and associated but varying challenges, it becomes harder to dispel the linear trope.

InattentiveADHD · 05/05/2023 14:36

"Whoah! I didn't say it wasn't recognised as a neurodiversity, I said it was not as recognised as a neurodiversity as autism. I've come across many people who had no idea ADHD makes you ND and I know some people with ADHD that do not accept the ND label. With autism everyone seems to know it's a neurodiversity and I personally haven't come across people that disagree with that."

Is that you whoahing back OP 😀

Ummm not sure I agree with taking a view as to whether something's "recognised" based on a sample of people you know but maybe we have a different understanding of the meaning of that word when used in this context.

I'm also not sure that "everyone knows autism is a neurodiversity". There are lots of people who barely understand what autism is, let alone whether autism = ND or not. Which is sort of the point of your whole thread. 😀

Anyway my point was that ADHD not having an easy "ic" is due to the name of the condition not whether it's an ND or not. Feels like if that is up for debate it needs a separate thread! 😀

UndertheCedartree · 05/05/2023 14:12

SparklyBlackKitten · 05/05/2023 13:24

Spectrum to me is autism
But I feel like it should be numbered though . As in: you have been diagnosed with autism 5
Because there's such a big difference with autism and autism.

Being on the spectrum i think embodies that really well . But the beginning of the spectrum(autism 1) wouldn't be a neurotypical person. It would be a person with what previously be called Aspergers. And on the other end of the spectrum would be a non verbal, violent 9 year old with a mental capacity of a 2 year old. (Which would be autism 10) And then everything in between.
Dunnow. Might be whack too.
But there are so many autistic kids in my dcs school. And some of them seem like any regular oll' student and some of them are stood in the courtyard yelling and throwing bins around etc.

What I actually hate is when people talke about "being autistic" vs having autism

You are not autistic, you are you. And you have autism

The term " aspie" makes me cringe too

The spectrum of autism is much more complicated than that.

And many of us feel we are autistic in the same way, I am a woman, it is just who I am.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 05/05/2023 14:08

DinoHat · 05/05/2023 10:41

I have a DC with ASD, amongst other diagnoses (incl a moderate LD), whose ASD, or the behaviours attributed to their ASD has a profound impact on their life, their ability to function all of which means their future is looking increasingly bleak.

I am constantly tripping over myself to talk about their ASD for fear of offending someone and frankly get fed up of having to give so much thought to what I’m saying when I’m just trying to be descriptive. If someone tells me they have a preference in how their ASD is identified, that’s fine, but I find it difficult to keep up! Not least, as is shown by this thread, even those with ASD or who are autistic don’t agree. So I think the answer is to just decide what you’re comfortable with and stop policing everyone else’s use of language - unless they are of course being intentionally, or negligently offensive.

Just a note, I'm not policing anyone else's language. Just explaining why I dislike the term 'on the spectrum'.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 05/05/2023 14:03

InattentiveADHD · 05/05/2023 00:22

Woah back small pony! ADHD is definitely recognised as a neurodiversity! The reason is more to do with the name of the condition - Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder - is hard to make an "----ic" word out of. This is something often discussed on ADHD forums. Personally, I don't mind "has/have ADHD" (and my autistic and ADHD son doesn't mind "has/have autism" etc) I prefer person-first language. Although my ADHD is absolutely integral to who I am, I am also not just ADHD and I don't really want to be defined by it. It's definitely a disability and it largely negatively affects my life, so it's something I want to treat and mitigate, not something I want to define me. But obviously people have different views on this. I do object to people trying to dictate to others what language they MUST use though, as views amongst ND people vary widely as evidenced on this thread.

But I am going off a tangent (sorry ADHD :-)), back to people on ADHD forums. What most people tend to use that's equivalent to "autistic" is ADHDers (I do use this occasionally), or some people just say "I am ADHD" or similar. I struggle with the grammar of this last one personally though!

Whoah! I didn't say it wasn't recognised as a neurodiversity, I said it was not as recognised as a neurodiversity as autism. I've come across many people who had no idea ADHD makes you ND and I know some people with ADHD that do not accept the ND label. With autism everyone seems to know it's a neurodiversity and I personally haven't come across people that disagree with that.

OP posts:
thekindlyone · 05/05/2023 13:41

SparklyBlackKitten · 05/05/2023 13:24

Spectrum to me is autism
But I feel like it should be numbered though . As in: you have been diagnosed with autism 5
Because there's such a big difference with autism and autism.

Being on the spectrum i think embodies that really well . But the beginning of the spectrum(autism 1) wouldn't be a neurotypical person. It would be a person with what previously be called Aspergers. And on the other end of the spectrum would be a non verbal, violent 9 year old with a mental capacity of a 2 year old. (Which would be autism 10) And then everything in between.
Dunnow. Might be whack too.
But there are so many autistic kids in my dcs school. And some of them seem like any regular oll' student and some of them are stood in the courtyard yelling and throwing bins around etc.

What I actually hate is when people talke about "being autistic" vs having autism

You are not autistic, you are you. And you have autism

The term " aspie" makes me cringe too

The spectrum isn't linear.

And I am autistic, thanks.

SparklyBlackKitten · 05/05/2023 13:24

Spectrum to me is autism
But I feel like it should be numbered though . As in: you have been diagnosed with autism 5
Because there's such a big difference with autism and autism.

Being on the spectrum i think embodies that really well . But the beginning of the spectrum(autism 1) wouldn't be a neurotypical person. It would be a person with what previously be called Aspergers. And on the other end of the spectrum would be a non verbal, violent 9 year old with a mental capacity of a 2 year old. (Which would be autism 10) And then everything in between.
Dunnow. Might be whack too.
But there are so many autistic kids in my dcs school. And some of them seem like any regular oll' student and some of them are stood in the courtyard yelling and throwing bins around etc.

What I actually hate is when people talke about "being autistic" vs having autism

You are not autistic, you are you. And you have autism

The term " aspie" makes me cringe too

Cuckoosheep · 05/05/2023 13:13

#dyspraxia

Cuckoosheep · 05/05/2023 13:12

He does have hypermobility and dydpraxia also. He goes to a school with two on site OT's (under 100 children, each child has at least 1:1 support at all times, some have 2:1, 5 children per class as more adults than kids, on site slt's too etc). The OT's run the yoga.

Daftasabroom · 05/05/2023 13:01

@Cuckoosheep be careful with yoga if he's hyper mobile, it's a weird common comorbidity with Autism.

Cuckoosheep · 05/05/2023 12:31

@Daftasabroom thank you, he's nearly 13. School have started to do some basic yoga with him which he clearly enjoys. I'll look at different mindfulness techniques, I know there are many different types.

Daftasabroom · 05/05/2023 11:09

@Cuckoosheep you don't say how old your son is but mine started mindfulness at about 14 or 15 IIRC and it was pretty transformative in him coping.

DinoHat · 05/05/2023 10:44

I think disability is something that you define for yourself.

This statement is similar in principle to saying “everyone is on the spectrum” disability isn’t something you “define yourself” if you’re disabled, whether as a co-morbidity to ASD or as a consequence of ASD you cannot simply decide to stop being disabled. In the same way you cannot simply decide to stop having ASD.

DinoHat · 05/05/2023 10:41

I have a DC with ASD, amongst other diagnoses (incl a moderate LD), whose ASD, or the behaviours attributed to their ASD has a profound impact on their life, their ability to function all of which means their future is looking increasingly bleak.

I am constantly tripping over myself to talk about their ASD for fear of offending someone and frankly get fed up of having to give so much thought to what I’m saying when I’m just trying to be descriptive. If someone tells me they have a preference in how their ASD is identified, that’s fine, but I find it difficult to keep up! Not least, as is shown by this thread, even those with ASD or who are autistic don’t agree. So I think the answer is to just decide what you’re comfortable with and stop policing everyone else’s use of language - unless they are of course being intentionally, or negligently offensive.

Cuckoosheep · 05/05/2023 10:32

Just had a quick look at that article. I need tonedit my post to 'try to digest'.

Cuckoosheep · 05/05/2023 10:27

@xyxygy thank you for the link. Much appreciated, I'll read it this afternoon/ evening when I can spend the time digesting it.
I think science will always move forward regardless of the impact on society. If this is a possible way forward I hope it's pursued. I'm glad it isn't my decision but if it was I couldn't sentence an immeasurable amount of people and their famies to live with the severe side of autism if there was a way to improve or even"cure" them for fear of where it might lead.

xyxygy · 05/05/2023 10:08

Cuckoosheep · 05/05/2023 10:02

If it was an excess of connections I wonder if they can create a way of removing some so that people who are really impacted can get some of the skills they lack eg become verbal.

Editing synapses is something that only happens in sci-fi - there's nothing even approaching that kind of tech in the real world. And...I don't think we (as a society) would want there to be - there's a whole level of dystopian nightmare stuff that follows down that road, no matter how good the intentions.