Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to despair about DofE cheating

283 replies

WhatTheHeckIsIt · 03/05/2023 15:47

Someone I know very well is the teacher who leads the Duke of Edinburgh at a school. Their teen is going to Buckingham Palace to receive their gold award. There is no way on this planet the teen has completed any of the activities - it's a stitch up.

It's made me feel really sad.

a) I expected more of this person
b) I expected more of their child
c) how could you let your child accept an award amongst people who have worked really hard to achieve it
d) it devalues everyone else's award
e) it's just shit

Rant over - but there's nothing I can do is there?

OP posts:
Iwasafool · 03/05/2023 22:20

ArcticSkewer · 03/05/2023 22:17

Ah yes, that poster will be getting mixed up with the residential. Ideally that's done without friendship group.
I'd completely forgotten that part of it!
Mine loved that almost as much as the camping.

I'm glad there are other kids who did it but never submitted the paperwork - I was starting to think it was just mine! I can't say I nagged them to do it. Really ... who cares ... apart from op, obvs

Sorry, I think you posted while I was typing.

Iwasafool · 03/05/2023 22:18

ArcticSkewer · 03/05/2023 21:59

No it isn't.

Noone is mad enough to send a lone teen hiking in the mountains for days on end.

I think people are confusing it with the residential. They are encouraged to go off and do something without their friends, it will be something organised and they aren't alone but they aren't with their group from school/scouts or whatever.

Mooshamoo · 03/05/2023 22:18

I remember one teacher telling me this. He worked in another centre to me. He worked in a training centre not a school, but it had teenagers in it.

He said that he would set an exam, then he would go around the class and write the exam answers for all of students, on their papers.

It doesn't look good for these centres if students fail. It doesn't look good for teachers if students fail.

So there is a total conflict of interest. The teacher is worried that he will look bad if the students fail, so he is worried about his own job, so he does the work for the students.

It's a crazy system. Teachers doing all the work first students is so common. Education doesn't happen.

I've worked in about 5-6 centres delivering national awards, and I've seen this happen in all of them.

Places are not checked properly. Or maybe the external checkers just don't really care either. Nobody seems to check much or care much.

ArcticSkewer · 03/05/2023 22:17

Ah yes, that poster will be getting mixed up with the residential. Ideally that's done without friendship group.
I'd completely forgotten that part of it!
Mine loved that almost as much as the camping.

I'm glad there are other kids who did it but never submitted the paperwork - I was starting to think it was just mine! I can't say I nagged them to do it. Really ... who cares ... apart from op, obvs

Iwasafool · 03/05/2023 22:12

potatohead1 · 03/05/2023 21:04

Good is pretty full on. If you know a family very well, it would be hard not to see evidence of things being done. The expedition and residential are always being talked about as they require so much planning and volunteering is fine for 12 months. I can easily see how someone who knows the people well could be lying.
It's very easy to lie. You just get people you know to sign stuff off for you and if the parent is they Escher-coordinator then they could easily bluff the residential and expedition. But OP surely the other dc at the school know who was and who wasn't on the expedition and residential.

They don't do the residential as a group, they ideally do it with people they don't know. It isn't hard to organise, you go onto the DofE site and look at what is on offer, sometimes it is volunteering and sometimes it is paying for an art/drama/outdoor activity organised by an outside provider. I can't imagine why the teacher/leader would book it, just makes it more complicated as they aren't going to pay for it are they. It gets signed off by the organisation why would they risk losing out on future business if they got found out lying.

I think lots of friends will probably think GS is off on a school trip when he does his expedition, if they are stalking him they will see him set off in the school minibus with a couple of teachers and the other kids doing the expedition. I don't think anyone would think anything of him going off to do a sport he has been doing for years. I don't think anyone we know could hand on heart say they know GS has actually done all he needed to do but apart from the expedition which he is doing in a couple of months he has done it all.

Thekirit · 03/05/2023 22:10

ArcticSkewer · 03/05/2023 21:24

Another of my kids had to get a lift from the teacher on their expedition (not gold).
They still passed.
Vague but I don't think they had to re-do anything.
I'm also pretty confident they didn't have to bribe the instructor.

It's not the Royal Marines, they don't hold them to quite such a high standard

I had to laugh at the ‘ it’s not the royal marines’ and bribing.
Our d of e instructor is also ccf teacher. Ex Royal Marines 🤣🤣🤣🤣 so maybe it was a bribe.

Thekirit · 03/05/2023 22:07

ArcticSkewer · 03/05/2023 21:59

No it isn't.

Noone is mad enough to send a lone teen hiking in the mountains for days on end.

Yes actually I think when my boys did Gold there was a few of them doing it together.
I wasn’t involved, just let them get on with it.

Bronze was a larger group, my example related to the bronze

KitKatLove · 03/05/2023 22:04

Conversely my DD did everything for her DofE gold but never submitted it.

ArcticSkewer · 03/05/2023 21:59

Thekirit · 03/05/2023 21:57

Yes I know, mine have done it,
But my example wasn't for gold.
Im aware OPs is

No it isn't.

Noone is mad enough to send a lone teen hiking in the mountains for days on end.

Thekirit · 03/05/2023 21:57

2bazookas · 03/05/2023 21:34

The DoE Gold expedition is a solo expedition. Alone. No group.

Yes I know, mine have done it,
But my example wasn't for gold.
Im aware OPs is

thecatsthecats · 03/05/2023 21:56

Oh and I notice that you minimise the incidents of dishonesty in your own youth, OP.

I'm afraid, if I'm to join in handwringing, I'm going to need an example or two.

(But I'm sure you had your reasons - so long as you allow that others have theirs too)

thecatsthecats · 03/05/2023 21:53

WhatTheHeckIsIt · 03/05/2023 20:38

I’m not being a person asking probing questions though am I? I’ve expressed disappointment on an anonymous forum.

Don’t be that person who minimises dishonesty, or anything of that ilk. To do so would make you a dick tbh. Remember this is a teenager who has started adult life. Don’t lower your expectations of them being able to achieve great things without cheating.

Well people might get more engaged in your handwringing crusade about dishonesty if you... Made an honest effort to explain how you know that the teen couldn't have done the work at school?

Incidentally, I didn't get the Gold Award because I was on holiday during the expedition, and I didn't get around to attaching myself to another one.

But it wasn't hard work at all to complete the other parts. My skill and physical were both school based, and I volunteered in my favourite teacher's class giving one to one support to a lovely autistic boy. It was a doddle, all done within my regular schedule. Same for literally everyone else who did it at my school. Not something to moon over.

Abzs · 03/05/2023 21:45

2bazookas · 03/05/2023 21:39

Gold Expeditions are solo. Not a group, no team.

Gold expeditions are done in a team of 4-7 (8 if using tandem transport like double kayaks).

WotNoUserName · 03/05/2023 21:45
  1. There must be between four and seven participants in a team (eight for modes of travel which have tandem).

From the D of E website about expeditions.

WotNoUserName · 03/05/2023 21:43

The Gold expedition is for teams. My son is doing it next year. He's worked hard at his gold - he has SEN so he's allowed a bit of leeway on some bits (I accompanied him on his residential for example, but he didn't know the others there)

I know a Scout leader who awarded their son the Chief Scout Gold Award at 11 years old. No way he did that in 6 months, during covid. As a Scout leader whose own kids have worked hard to get theirs that really pissed me off. I was worried people would think I'd done the same. I expect the kid has his Gold D of E now. Hmm

The only loser is the cheater at the end of the day. All those kids that work hard for these things know what they've achieved and know that they deserve their award.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 03/05/2023 21:43

2bazookas · 03/05/2023 21:39

Gold Expeditions are solo. Not a group, no team.

You've said this twice but the person I know who has now completed it was going to struggle because they needed to make up at least a 4 person group...

Booklover40 · 03/05/2023 21:42

2bazookas · 03/05/2023 21:39

Gold Expeditions are solo. Not a group, no team.

I don't know if this was true for your dc's but it wasn't for my dc's school. They just completed the gold trek last week and it was 100% done in a group. Not my dc's personally but their friends.

Booklover40 · 03/05/2023 21:39

jgw1 · 03/05/2023 21:33

UCAS are conducting a consultation on reform of personal statements. At no point have they said and there is no intention to remove them.

Many universities value them and students ought to too, as it gives the student an opportunity to really explore why they want to study their chosen subject. If they can't do that, then perhaps they have not chosen the right subject.
A student who writes in their personal statement that they have completed DofE, I would suggest doesn't have much interesting to say.

Ah ok. I disagree about D of E not being worthy of mentioning in a personal statement though. These are 18 yo's we're talking about - many of them won't have that much life experience to put in a personal statement! It's definitely an achievement to have completed D of E, especially at gold level.

Not everyone has fantastic opportunities in life - many won't even have had the chance to do D of E, I don't think it's fair to scoff at it.

2bazookas · 03/05/2023 21:39

Needsomepeaceandquiet · 03/05/2023 18:23

Way way back when we were doing our Gold expedition one of the other teams managed to complete their expedition by mostly using the bus. Our jaws dropped when they told us - no idea how they did it and somehow they got away with it. Considering we were on a large island in Scotland and the assessor was local, you’d have thought someone would have noticed a bunch of teenagers with backpacks on a bus rather than in the hills! We were mightily cheesed off too when we got reprimanded by the assessor for taking a large on-road detour one day when we couldn’t get through our planned route.

We were pleased with our achievement. I would like to think that the cheats experience wasn’t quite so fulfilling.

Gold Expeditions are solo. Not a group, no team.

Thundercats77 · 03/05/2023 21:36

wordler · 03/05/2023 16:09

Opened thread to see if it was about Philip or Edward!

Glad I'm not the only one 😜

WordtoYoMumma · 03/05/2023 21:34

My son is doing silver and is doing almost all of it at school. He helps younger years with homework club, he does gym after school, all the expedition stuff is being done at school. He stays late twice a week. He doesn't show off or chat about it at all, I don't think anyone I know would be aware he is doing it.

I don't know how much harder gold is though.

2bazookas · 03/05/2023 21:34

Thekirit · 03/05/2023 16:37

Our kids had this. One group on their expedition took a short cut because they got lost. However they left their phone on and d of e instructor heard them all discussing it.
The main organiser of this behaviour was the deputy heads kid.
They all got off and passed.

The DoE Gold expedition is a solo expedition. Alone. No group.

jgw1 · 03/05/2023 21:33

Booklover40 · 03/05/2023 21:29

I was told that personal statements are being stopped? To make it a more even playing field.

UCAS are conducting a consultation on reform of personal statements. At no point have they said and there is no intention to remove them.

Many universities value them and students ought to too, as it gives the student an opportunity to really explore why they want to study their chosen subject. If they can't do that, then perhaps they have not chosen the right subject.
A student who writes in their personal statement that they have completed DofE, I would suggest doesn't have much interesting to say.

Booklover40 · 03/05/2023 21:31

ArcticSkewer · 03/05/2023 21:22

No, the main point is to do a mad walk carrying loads of heavy stuff and live in the wilderness.

Well, according to my son anyway.

Who did all the requirements for DoE Gold but couldn't be arsed submitting it because it was about the experience not the paperwork or the 'big day out in London' for him.

No idea why op thinks it would be thrilling to cheat on something like that. It's a bit like when my kids swam a mile for their certificate. I'm pretty sure they put their feet down ... a fail ... but really, who give a toss? They swam a mile and possibly shouldn't have definitely passed. Who cares?

Oh, i agree absolutely! Mine did silver but then didn't complete the volunteering bit (was during covid and nowhere was allowing teens to do bloody anything!). However they did quite enjoy the trek.

Winterday1991 · 03/05/2023 21:31

I voted YABU as I opened this thread thinking it was about Edward having an affair