Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to despair about DofE cheating

283 replies

WhatTheHeckIsIt · 03/05/2023 15:47

Someone I know very well is the teacher who leads the Duke of Edinburgh at a school. Their teen is going to Buckingham Palace to receive their gold award. There is no way on this planet the teen has completed any of the activities - it's a stitch up.

It's made me feel really sad.

a) I expected more of this person
b) I expected more of their child
c) how could you let your child accept an award amongst people who have worked really hard to achieve it
d) it devalues everyone else's award
e) it's just shit

Rant over - but there's nothing I can do is there?

OP posts:
Nereides · 04/05/2023 09:09

You’d be surprised how many teens don’t complete the necessary work for any award, not just the DofE. I quit working at college because they repeatedly forced me to falsify paperwork saying teens had completed work and I had misplaced it, when in fact they hadn’t completed it. Because funding is based on them having done the work.

Iwasafool · 04/05/2023 09:06

drinkeatsmile · 04/05/2023 08:53

You see even the min wage job ds did where he was treated badly taught him a lot about people - he didn’t hang around for long.
Dd wasn’t given paid holidays and at one stage her wage fell below min - she asked for a rise - her boss laughed and made fun of her but she got her raise and she grew a few inches in the process - my very shy Dd learned to start standing up for herself. We watched and advised both of them on how to handle interactions and they practiced these skills in an environment that had no impact on their future. We helped them turn negative experiences into positive learning experiences.

That's great but she could do that and DofE, DofE doesn't stop them doing other things I don't know why it is being made an either/or thing.

Iwasafool · 04/05/2023 09:04

drinkeatsmile · 04/05/2023 08:47

Better to do it for interest rather than cv building - ds’s group was full of kids who were forced to do it - none of them made much of a contribution to the planning of the expedition- ds did most of it - which was good experience for him on planning but would have been better to have been more of a team experience

That's a shame. I suppose GS is lucky that he is in a group of like minded people who all enjoy what they are doing, I suppose the only bit he wouldn't have done otherwise was the skill and it is something that will be very use for him in life.

itsjustnotok · 04/05/2023 09:03

DD is undertaking the bronze level. She is doing hers through St John Ambulance. They are dealing with the expedition element and she is volunteering though them to provide cover at weekends at events. The rest is all down through school. She is learning a skill through a club at lunch every week and has joined sports clubs for the physical stuff. It would quite easy to do most of it through school.

Booklover40 · 04/05/2023 08:58

drinkeatsmile · 04/05/2023 08:53

You see even the min wage job ds did where he was treated badly taught him a lot about people - he didn’t hang around for long.
Dd wasn’t given paid holidays and at one stage her wage fell below min - she asked for a rise - her boss laughed and made fun of her but she got her raise and she grew a few inches in the process - my very shy Dd learned to start standing up for herself. We watched and advised both of them on how to handle interactions and they practiced these skills in an environment that had no impact on their future. We helped them turn negative experiences into positive learning experiences.

Agree 100%. Dd left her first job as the boss was horrible, even though it was better paid than most weekend jobs and she enjoyed the work. She has a strong sense of her self worth and won't accept bad treatment and I think that is another important life skill!

hotdiggetydog · 04/05/2023 08:55

Cheating to get a pat on the head by a so called member of royalty.

That's bad but considering grassing on them is even worse.

drinkeatsmile · 04/05/2023 08:53

Carmelalefou · 04/05/2023 08:47

I'm not sure about that. My dd was that stereotypical child - they treated her like shit at the pub she worked at hen she was 17 including sexual harassment. She certainly didn't mention it on her ps! She ended up not working at all through uni and was supported by me. Graduated straight into a good job which she still has 5 years later.

You see even the min wage job ds did where he was treated badly taught him a lot about people - he didn’t hang around for long.
Dd wasn’t given paid holidays and at one stage her wage fell below min - she asked for a rise - her boss laughed and made fun of her but she got her raise and she grew a few inches in the process - my very shy Dd learned to start standing up for herself. We watched and advised both of them on how to handle interactions and they practiced these skills in an environment that had no impact on their future. We helped them turn negative experiences into positive learning experiences.

Blossomtoes · 04/05/2023 08:53

wordler · 03/05/2023 16:09

Opened thread to see if it was about Philip or Edward!

You weren’t the only one!

Booklover40 · 04/05/2023 08:52

jgw1 · 04/05/2023 08:44

Certainly does. For a stereotypical middle class child who is a prefect, has done DofE, plays the violin and piano and does debating, a job a corner shop or a local pub would be far more valuable experience.

I agree that having a job is extremely important, both my teens have weekend jobs and I'm very proud of this as they were completely self motivated in finding and securing them. I was a very unconfident teen - I always dreamt of having a Saturday job but was too scared to apply!

Carmelalefou · 04/05/2023 08:50

I never really pay much attention to what Oxbridge says. My teens have always had their own interests which take up a lot of time and weren't necessarily at all impressive to university (horse riding for example!) so they've done things they loved not necessarily what they think universities want!

jgw1 · 04/05/2023 08:47

WordtoYoMumma · 04/05/2023 07:51

Depends how you write it! Just saying "I've got bronze D of E" doesn't make a huge impact but if you can extrapolate what you learned from it and how you think those skills are transferable then it's definitely good on a personal statement.

Then it is about the skills one has which one could have gained in a myriad of different ways and not about DofE.

If anyone wants a better idea of what competitive universities are looking for in supra-curricular activities this is a pretty good resource.

https://www.worc.ox.ac.uk/applying/access-and-outreach/resources/guide-supercurriculars

Guide to supercurriculars | Worcester College

https://www.worc.ox.ac.uk/applying/access-and-outreach/resources/guide-supercurriculars

drinkeatsmile · 04/05/2023 08:47

Iwasafool · 04/05/2023 08:40

It really doesn't take that much time if kids have been involved in sport before, in my experience anyway. GS carried on doing his sport, volunteered to help with younger kids for his volunteering element but really at his level that is sort of going to happen anyway, his skill was something he did at home that is useful for his future. Apart from that he did one 5 day residential and as he didn't have another holiday last year I think that was reasonable for him to have a fun break. All he has left to do is his expedition which again he will enjoy going off and having an adventure with his friends at the end of A levels.

He's done his EPQ so it didn't prevent that, has done extra stuff related to his A levels in holidays/at weekends.

He hasn't done it for uni though, he's done it because he has lots of energy, likes outdoors stuff and has enjoyed it.

Better to do it for interest rather than cv building - ds’s group was full of kids who were forced to do it - none of them made much of a contribution to the planning of the expedition- ds did most of it - which was good experience for him on planning but would have been better to have been more of a team experience

Carmelalefou · 04/05/2023 08:47

jgw1 · 04/05/2023 08:44

Certainly does. For a stereotypical middle class child who is a prefect, has done DofE, plays the violin and piano and does debating, a job a corner shop or a local pub would be far more valuable experience.

I'm not sure about that. My dd was that stereotypical child - they treated her like shit at the pub she worked at hen she was 17 including sexual harassment. She certainly didn't mention it on her ps! She ended up not working at all through uni and was supported by me. Graduated straight into a good job which she still has 5 years later.

jgw1 · 04/05/2023 08:44

drinkeatsmile · 04/05/2023 08:38

And having a job does wonders for kid’s soft skills - I’ve seen it over and over again - teenagers benefit enormously by employment- I’d make it compulsory if I could.

Certainly does. For a stereotypical middle class child who is a prefect, has done DofE, plays the violin and piano and does debating, a job a corner shop or a local pub would be far more valuable experience.

Iwasafool · 04/05/2023 08:42

drinkeatsmile · 04/05/2023 08:38

And having a job does wonders for kid’s soft skills - I’ve seen it over and over again - teenagers benefit enormously by employment- I’d make it compulsory if I could.

Doing DofE doesn't stop them doing a job. I don't know how much time people imagine it takes if they think they can't work or do EPQs etc. It certainly hasn't stopped GS and his friends doing any of that.

Iwasafool · 04/05/2023 08:40

TheaBrandt · 04/05/2023 08:18

It’s self starting super curricular stuff showing a particular interest in your subject which is relevant apparently. Thankfully as neither of mine will have done DofE!

Dd1 all over additional lectures attending stuff connected to the career she wants and relevant EPQ. She would not have time to do gold plus she has a job. Maybe perceived as more relevant than hiking.

It really doesn't take that much time if kids have been involved in sport before, in my experience anyway. GS carried on doing his sport, volunteered to help with younger kids for his volunteering element but really at his level that is sort of going to happen anyway, his skill was something he did at home that is useful for his future. Apart from that he did one 5 day residential and as he didn't have another holiday last year I think that was reasonable for him to have a fun break. All he has left to do is his expedition which again he will enjoy going off and having an adventure with his friends at the end of A levels.

He's done his EPQ so it didn't prevent that, has done extra stuff related to his A levels in holidays/at weekends.

He hasn't done it for uni though, he's done it because he has lots of energy, likes outdoors stuff and has enjoyed it.

drinkeatsmile · 04/05/2023 08:38

TheaBrandt · 04/05/2023 08:18

It’s self starting super curricular stuff showing a particular interest in your subject which is relevant apparently. Thankfully as neither of mine will have done DofE!

Dd1 all over additional lectures attending stuff connected to the career she wants and relevant EPQ. She would not have time to do gold plus she has a job. Maybe perceived as more relevant than hiking.

And having a job does wonders for kid’s soft skills - I’ve seen it over and over again - teenagers benefit enormously by employment- I’d make it compulsory if I could.

TheaBrandt · 04/05/2023 08:18

It’s self starting super curricular stuff showing a particular interest in your subject which is relevant apparently. Thankfully as neither of mine will have done DofE!

Dd1 all over additional lectures attending stuff connected to the career she wants and relevant EPQ. She would not have time to do gold plus she has a job. Maybe perceived as more relevant than hiking.

drinkeatsmile · 04/05/2023 07:58

jgw1 · 04/05/2023 07:17

People can disagree all you like, until I hear it from university admissions professionals that the prescence or absence of DofE will make any difference on an application makes any difference I will keep pointing that out.

We went to an admissions event at Cambridge a few years ago and they were at pains to point out that they do not take DofE into account - unless a component of it was connected to the course you were interested in. They discarded music exams too. All signs of wealthy schooling and involved parenting but not of raw talent. They said they expected their talented student to have diverse interests but it was not for them to judge those extra curricular interests as worthy or otherwise. I was really impressed by their fairer approach to these things.

Carmelalefou · 04/05/2023 07:55

(for personal statements)

Carmelalefou · 04/05/2023 07:55

The only one worth doing is gold IMO, and that's such a massive time sink you are better off doing an epq.

WordtoYoMumma · 04/05/2023 07:51

jgw1 · 04/05/2023 07:17

People can disagree all you like, until I hear it from university admissions professionals that the prescence or absence of DofE will make any difference on an application makes any difference I will keep pointing that out.

Depends how you write it! Just saying "I've got bronze D of E" doesn't make a huge impact but if you can extrapolate what you learned from it and how you think those skills are transferable then it's definitely good on a personal statement.

jgw1 · 04/05/2023 07:17

Booklover40 · 03/05/2023 21:39

Ah ok. I disagree about D of E not being worthy of mentioning in a personal statement though. These are 18 yo's we're talking about - many of them won't have that much life experience to put in a personal statement! It's definitely an achievement to have completed D of E, especially at gold level.

Not everyone has fantastic opportunities in life - many won't even have had the chance to do D of E, I don't think it's fair to scoff at it.

People can disagree all you like, until I hear it from university admissions professionals that the prescence or absence of DofE will make any difference on an application makes any difference I will keep pointing that out.

jgw1 · 04/05/2023 07:15

Booklover40 · 03/05/2023 21:42

I don't know if this was true for your dc's but it wasn't for my dc's school. They just completed the gold trek last week and it was 100% done in a group. Not my dc's personally but their friends.

One of the 20 conditions is that the expedition is completed in a group of between 4 and 7 people (8 if it is a tandem mode of travel).

thecatsthecats · 03/05/2023 22:22

ArcticSkewer · 03/05/2023 21:59

No it isn't.

Noone is mad enough to send a lone teen hiking in the mountains for days on end.

Tbh, I lived in a rural area growing up, and we were first responders for scraping DoE gold expeditions off the hillside.

They would never advocate sending people out alone.