Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to despair about DofE cheating

283 replies

WhatTheHeckIsIt · 03/05/2023 15:47

Someone I know very well is the teacher who leads the Duke of Edinburgh at a school. Their teen is going to Buckingham Palace to receive their gold award. There is no way on this planet the teen has completed any of the activities - it's a stitch up.

It's made me feel really sad.

a) I expected more of this person
b) I expected more of their child
c) how could you let your child accept an award amongst people who have worked really hard to achieve it
d) it devalues everyone else's award
e) it's just shit

Rant over - but there's nothing I can do is there?

OP posts:
grass321 · 15/05/2023 07:35

Speaking with my assessor hat on, it can be challenging to set an appropriate level that you're willing to sign off on. It's not a GCSE or A level with a set standard.

On my skills courses, some of the kids produce outstandingly good tasks, most have a decent stab at it and some struggle to meet even the bare minimum. That said, some of the courses are quite technical/mathsy and students have different capabilities. And the standard of a 17 year old is different from a 13 year old.

There's a lot of different variables and there will also be students who fully embrace the award and push themselves. And those that do the least possible. That's life and you have to accept it's meant to be inclusive.

drinkeatsmile · 14/05/2023 23:05

NotReallyBotheredByThis · 13/05/2023 22:17

DofE has lost it's way. I was a Leader/Supervisor/Assessor for over 10 years, it's all marketed to the kids as "it'll look great on your CV". Mum & Dad take this on board & pay for them to do it - and the kids become customers.

It's very hard for the DofE Administrators to tell paying customers that they can't have what they've paid for - especially when it's related to Expeditions.

I've had nasty, lazy, rude & incompetent kids in my teams where they're not interested & are just blagging it.

Dare to try to put a "Fail" in & it all becomes "political"...

The administrators don't want to upset the paying customers (parents), mitigations are made & the little angels pass the Expedition sections anyway...

That's why, as an Employer, I don't take a lot of notice of DofE on a CV - I'll ask some probing questions, but the whole DofE thing is diminished generally...

I think the whole "looking good on your CV" backfires. Is it a signal of someone who wants to do more than the bare minimum - someone who is willing to put themselves out there, to explore, to learn, to try something new, to help in a selfless way?
When you start off from the position of CV building it is absolutely going to go downhill from there. The problem here is that it was ever a thing that people should be impressed by - it should be a thing you impress yourself with - not other people - it should never have been a thing for a CV.

NotReallyBotheredByThis · 14/05/2023 22:27

I didn't say it was "all". I had a lot more "good" kids than I did "bad" and enjoyed myself generally, but I didn't like the direction it was going (rubber stamping it) so chose to move on.

LilylilyDaisy · 14/05/2023 07:13

^^ genuine question, not meant to be snarky.

LilylilyDaisy · 14/05/2023 07:11

Surely though, NotReally, as well as "nasty, lazy, rude & incompetent kids" you'll also have seen some polite, amazing, dedicated kids who completed the expedition properly and fairly.

How can you, as an ex-leader, tar all the students with the same brush?

NotReallyBotheredByThis · 13/05/2023 22:17

DofE has lost it's way. I was a Leader/Supervisor/Assessor for over 10 years, it's all marketed to the kids as "it'll look great on your CV". Mum & Dad take this on board & pay for them to do it - and the kids become customers.

It's very hard for the DofE Administrators to tell paying customers that they can't have what they've paid for - especially when it's related to Expeditions.

I've had nasty, lazy, rude & incompetent kids in my teams where they're not interested & are just blagging it.

Dare to try to put a "Fail" in & it all becomes "political"...

The administrators don't want to upset the paying customers (parents), mitigations are made & the little angels pass the Expedition sections anyway...

That's why, as an Employer, I don't take a lot of notice of DofE on a CV - I'll ask some probing questions, but the whole DofE thing is diminished generally...

SkiingIsHeaven · 13/05/2023 11:21

You wouldn't have expected my kids to have done it but they did. I don't think I told people about it while they were doing it.

MumToTooManyBoys · 13/05/2023 11:09

commonground · 03/05/2023 16:29

I would think of it as a perk of the job, tbh. It must be pretty relentless and time-consuming to be a DofE leader AND a teacher. You probably see more of other people's kids than your own. Not to mention all that freeze-dried food you have to consume on camps.

(Plus it's the age of the Nepo baby, so they are bang on trend.)

They do get paid for there time or time off classes.

Iwasafool · 13/05/2023 10:51

drinkeatsmile · 13/05/2023 07:57

I remember a poster coming on here a few years ago extolling the virtues of the DoE - he talked about how challenging it was for the kids to get through the programme he ran and this was bronze he was referring to. My two kids were doing bronze and it was a breeze for them, he couldn't understand why they didn't find it challenging - it was like the two experiences were not related. Certainly had it been challenging they might have found it worthwhile but the day they finally got their certificate -almost a year after they did the expedition - they didn't feel any sense of pride or achievement, it was all a bit of a joke.

I think for some it is the commitment that is the challenge. So 12 months of a weekly volunteering or fitness is easy for some as they pretty well do it anyway but hard for others. Same with the expedition if they are used to camping and are active it isn't going to be that challenging but for others it will be.

For my GS just coming to the end of it I would say the biggest challenge for him has been keeping all his records of what he's done, he does a few hours of sport a week and help with the younger children so to him that is just normal and easy to forget to record it and get it signed off. He's done his practice expeditions and thoroughly enjoyed them (even though one was in appalling weather) and he'd do it for fun if he wasn't doing Gold. He's looking forward to his expedition as a bit of a treat at the end of A levels, he knows a couple of very non sporty people who have found the practice expeditions very difficult and aren't looking forward to the real thing. It varies.

Maybe the kids who find it easy aren't really the ones who are going to benefit most from it.

drinkeatsmile · 13/05/2023 07:57

I remember a poster coming on here a few years ago extolling the virtues of the DoE - he talked about how challenging it was for the kids to get through the programme he ran and this was bronze he was referring to. My two kids were doing bronze and it was a breeze for them, he couldn't understand why they didn't find it challenging - it was like the two experiences were not related. Certainly had it been challenging they might have found it worthwhile but the day they finally got their certificate -almost a year after they did the expedition - they didn't feel any sense of pride or achievement, it was all a bit of a joke.

jgw1 · 13/05/2023 07:20

weightymatters73 · 13/05/2023 07:10

https://www.dofe.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/DofE-Expeditions-from-2023.pdf

It's listed here as a "permanent change from 2023".

"Getting themselves to the expedition" was definitely there as a requirement pre-2020, and possibly pre-2021....

It was a bronze summer/autumn 2020 expedition that was using a coach to get there and back home (twice) and not camping as the camping element was suspended in 2020...

I'll chat to the leader as it looks like it's fine now!

DofE expeditions are assessed against 20 conditions. For at least the last 25 years how one has got to the start or home from the finish has not been part of those 20 conditions.

weightymatters73 · 13/05/2023 07:10

jgw1 · 12/05/2023 21:10

What utter tosh.

No where in anything DofE says is there any indication about how participants should get to the start of their expedition.

https://www.dofe.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/DofE-Expeditions-from-2023.pdf

It's listed here as a "permanent change from 2023".

"Getting themselves to the expedition" was definitely there as a requirement pre-2020, and possibly pre-2021....

It was a bronze summer/autumn 2020 expedition that was using a coach to get there and back home (twice) and not camping as the camping element was suspended in 2020...

I'll chat to the leader as it looks like it's fine now!

https://www.dofe.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/DofE-Expeditions-from-2023.pdf

weightymatters73 · 13/05/2023 06:37

grass321 · 12/05/2023 20:24

I think it's been a temporary flexibility more or less since the pandemic started but can't swear to it.

yes I found it on the d of E website in a PDF but it doesn't have a date on it.

jgw1 · 12/05/2023 21:10

weightymatters73 · 12/05/2023 10:06

Its interesting, but at my kids (private) school, they were reprimanded by the DofE people for bussing the kids to the start of the walk....I can't see them getting away with signing it off if people don't do it properly...

I'm wondering if "times have changed" as a lot of people are quoting what happened at their school, probably 20 years ago. it would be quite hard to cheat nowadays...

What utter tosh.

No where in anything DofE says is there any indication about how participants should get to the start of their expedition.

Coasterfan · 12/05/2023 20:52

My DD did bronze last year, we spend weekends and holidays super busy as a family and my friends know this. DD did volunteering an hour a week after school Friday, went ice skating (and still does) after school Wednesday and learnt Finnish on her phone! The practice and assessed expeditions were the only things she had to do at the weekend. I know there is more to the gold but anyone who knows this would wonder where DD got the time, so it is perfectly plausible this person did do their gold in my opinion!
Though her friend did forge my signature at one point 😀I would have signed anyway but I didn’t get round to it and she wanted to send off her evidence!

grass321 · 12/05/2023 20:24

I think it's been a temporary flexibility more or less since the pandemic started but can't swear to it.

weightymatters73 · 12/05/2023 19:10

grass321 · 12/05/2023 13:08

Its interesting, but at my kids (private) school, they were reprimanded by the DofE people for bussing the kids to the start of the walk....I can't see them getting away with signing it off if people don't do it properly...

That's odd as it's explicitly allowed under the current rules for expeditions.

They were told the kids were "expected to make their own way" to the start and home again. , I have found what you are talking about is that a very new thing? This was a 2021 summer expedition. Neither of my two did any in 2022, but 2023 they were sent on the train.

grass321 · 12/05/2023 13:08

Its interesting, but at my kids (private) school, they were reprimanded by the DofE people for bussing the kids to the start of the walk....I can't see them getting away with signing it off if people don't do it properly...

That's odd as it's explicitly allowed under the current rules for expeditions.

weightymatters73 · 12/05/2023 10:06

HauntedLady · 05/05/2023 23:18

@jgw1 how would you like people to prove that it wasn’t properly completed? When I was at school it was an open secret that some teachers would sign it off for you and for many years Torquay Boys Grammar openly cheated at Ten Tors which is why so many tried to do it through them. It absolutely happens and you’re naive if you think otherwise.

Its interesting, but at my kids (private) school, they were reprimanded by the DofE people for bussing the kids to the start of the walk....I can't see them getting away with signing it off if people don't do it properly...

I'm wondering if "times have changed" as a lot of people are quoting what happened at their school, probably 20 years ago. it would be quite hard to cheat nowadays...

dig135 · 06/05/2023 06:50

When I was at school it was an open secret that some teachers would sign it off for you and for many years Torquay Boys Grammar openly cheated at Ten Tors which is why so many tried to do it through them.

Our school failed two groups on a bronze expedition (private school with more than its fair share of high maintenance parents).

Speaking from the other side (I'm an approved activity provider for D of E courses), the rule changes have changed the award significantly. I don't run expeditions but I think you can go home overnight currently.

Some changes are positive. You don't have to do an hour a week on the other sections, for example, you could do a block of four hours in a month. A number of my students do this, particularly the gold ones also juggling A levels. And you can do back to back practice and qualifying expeditions.

jgw1 · 06/05/2023 06:48

HauntedLady · 05/05/2023 23:18

@jgw1 how would you like people to prove that it wasn’t properly completed? When I was at school it was an open secret that some teachers would sign it off for you and for many years Torquay Boys Grammar openly cheated at Ten Tors which is why so many tried to do it through them. It absolutely happens and you’re naive if you think otherwise.

Well perhaps by stating which of the requirements wasn't achieved and why.
There was some discussion in the middle of the thread about a group that allegedly didn't complete the expedition requirements, but the person arguing that seemed unaware of the 20 conditions for expeditions and found it hard to say which one had not been met.

Florenz · 06/05/2023 01:28

DofE need to have a phone line or email address where whistleblowers can report cheating.

Anonymouslyikes · 05/05/2023 23:25

How did they cheat? Sneaky 4x4s? Helicopter?
(idle curiosity - one of mine has just done it)

HauntedLady · 05/05/2023 23:18

@jgw1 how would you like people to prove that it wasn’t properly completed? When I was at school it was an open secret that some teachers would sign it off for you and for many years Torquay Boys Grammar openly cheated at Ten Tors which is why so many tried to do it through them. It absolutely happens and you’re naive if you think otherwise.

KitKatLove · 05/05/2023 23:02

Personally I only concerned myself with my own child completing the necessary tasks. I’m not interested in the DofE of the children of others.