Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take only one DC for a weekend away?

206 replies

NarwhalsTusk · 03/05/2023 11:05

I have two DS, aged 6 and 9.

DS9 is fit and has great stamina. DS6 doesn’t - no disabilities etc, but even accounting for him being there years younger he’s just not built the same way.

I love the outdoors and hill walking and both DC are pretty keen but as a family we’re normally limited to what DS6 can manage.

DS9 is easily fit enough now to take on some peaks in Snowdonia. I’d love to take him away for a weekend to tackle a proper mountain. He’d love it. And it’d be nice to have some 1-1 time with him.

But DS6 would be gutted. He thinks (despite all evidence to contrary) he’s as capable as DS9. He’s also very attached to me so would be particularly jealous of me going away with just DS9.

WIBU to take DS9 away on his own?

OP posts:
moleeye · 04/05/2023 04:35

I have 2 children of a similar age and capabilities and the younger would be devastated at being left out.

Placating with a cookery lesson would not cut the mustard

Nobodytellsmenothin · 04/05/2023 04:22

Unless you take them both away for a separate weekend then no, absolutely not! But if you can do it for both then absolutely yes, as you said it will strengthen your relationship with both of them and would be a lovely gesture.

I’ll be honest it sounds like you have a favourite child- be careful there, it can destroy their relationship and cause a lot of problems

ThinWomansBrain · 03/05/2023 22:31

It would be unreasonable to take one child away and not offer a similar opportunity to the other.
Does DS9 actually want to go mountain walking? You sound very keen.
Ask them both what they'd each like to do,
DS9 might be really p'd off if DS6 gets to choose a theme park but he gets no options on what he'd like to do.

AwaaFaeHom · 03/05/2023 22:22

NarwhalsTusk · 03/05/2023 16:07

if you’re implying it’s favouritism as I’ve said before it’s absolutely nothing of the sort.

There’s a perfectly good reason for not taking the younger one on a serious mountain hike - that being he couldn’t do it and wouldn’t enjoy it (though he would enjoy a something less strenuous).

To the extent it’s age related, that seems fair enough to me (“DS9 is going on this trip because he is older, you can do it too when you’re his age”).

Excluding DS9 from something he would be able to do and enjoy doing simply to level the playing field seems somewhat unjust.

DS6 gets way more opportunities than DS9 did at the same age by virtue of being the youngest as most things we do are age-appropriate for him.

I didn't imply anything. I asked a fairly straightforward question.

I think you need to stop letting your perception of what is fair get in the way of what is going to feel fair to your children.

Do you think that cooking is going to seem like an equivalent weekend away to your younger son? It seems unlikely, but I don't know him.

2bazookas · 03/05/2023 22:02

All our kids had solo weekends away with a parent; they loved it . To have that one-to-one time is so special.

6 yr old can have a different "just him" trip geared to his own interests.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/05/2023 20:20

I think you’re too fixated on “at the same age”, OP. A 6 yo isn’t going to get that. He doesn’t care what his brother did or didn’t get to do three years ago. He cares about now.

I think it’s only fine if you can give the 6 yo a trip if equal merit first (as in shortly before hand).

Im an eldest child myself and can remember the mentality I had as a child that what each of us had done “at the same age” was what mattered, and that “at the same time” didn’t count for anything. Now I’m a parent myself, I can see that it isn’t as simple as that, and that it’s unfair to the younger child.

No, they don’t need the same trip at the same time - settling the “at the same age” point as they could have it in three years time. But they need something nice “at the same time”.

MILLYmo0se · 03/05/2023 20:11

I dont think its a problem to do this particular activity with just the 9 year old. He didnt get to do it when he was 6 and the opportunity can be offered to DS2 when he is 9 if its something he is interested in. Obviously the parent staying home with him will organise something fun to do over that weekend too.

Stompythedinosaur · 03/05/2023 18:50

I think, whatever spin you put on this, what both dc will remember is that you took dc1 on holiday and you didn't take dc2 on holiday.

There are plenty of holidays I'd love to go on that would be cheaper to only take one family member, but we are a family of 4 so we save up until all four of us can go.

I think doing this as a day's activity within a family holiday is not too bad, as long as the other parent does something nice with dc2, but excluding a dc from a holiday is pretty bad.

LeFeu · 03/05/2023 18:39

My DH does this - takes one daughter walking, but then takes the other away for the weekend to spend doing a different hobby the two of them share. It’s fine if you do something nice with both, but just doing the one is only going to breed resentment tbh.

FinallyHere · 03/05/2023 18:32

I would absolutely do this but, I'd find a weekend away to do with the younger one first and only then take the elder away.

As the six year younger child, in retrospect I recognise that this happened a lot in our family. It made me feel special to go away first and probably a tad patronising when encouraging my elder sister to have her 'turn'.

It's much easier for the elder sibling to understand what is going on in this circumstance.

Keep an eye out for age appropriate experiences, possibly alongside another friend, for company. Activity clubs can be a good source of suitable activities.

Secondwindplease · 03/05/2023 17:52

So far you have managed to

  • Justify why you should take DS9 and not DS6 on a weekend away
  • Justify why you shouldn’t take DS6 on an equivalent trip without DS9
  • Justify why, in fact, DS6 is the luckiest of them all

I don’t really think you need our input, do you?

mewkins · 03/05/2023 17:43

I am on board with doing one to one things with the kids who have different interests etc and I've done it with my own. But if the other kids REALLY wants to join in and would be excited to take part then it's a different matter and could really upset the dynamic between the brothers (and the self- image of the younger brother).

Multipleexclamationmarks · 03/05/2023 17:13

I have 2 weekends away booked with ds(13) this summer because we both love airshows. Dd(15) hates them and would hate it so she isn't coming. (She'll stay home with her dad, they'll probably go into the city and get a curry/go shopping).I love spendi g one to one time with just one of them.
I've never taken dd away alone because we don't have an interest in common that requires a weekend away but I've taken her to other things she loves (big concerts/gigs/shopping) just the two of us.
I think as long as both kids get to do stuff they love and both get special one to one time it's fine.

GoodChat · 03/05/2023 16:56

Your decision is obviously made. Have a nice time. I hope your little one understands.

ItIsWhatItIsTillItIsnt · 03/05/2023 16:34

I wouldn't do this no

aSofaNearYou · 03/05/2023 16:20

I do think that if you're willing to upset DS6 by not taking him, you should be willing to say to DS9 he can't come on a different day out because it's to cheer DS6 up from the walking trip.

But I do also think you have a convenient excuse in the age thing - you can just say you'll do the same with DS6 when he's that age. Why don't you do it when DS9 is 10? It's a neat age and makes it seem like a rite of passage.

NarwhalsTusk · 03/05/2023 16:15

Just off the top of my head things that DS6 has done which DS9 hadn’t add the same age:
-has his own tablet
-been on sleepovers
-been skiing
-been to the theatre and cinema many times
-been on multiple foreign holidays
-plays video games
-been paddleboarding
-drunk fizzy drinks
-been to theme parks

He’s not exactly hard done by, bring the youngest has its advantages.

OP posts:
NarwhalsTusk · 03/05/2023 16:07

AwaaFaeHom · 03/05/2023 15:11

What strikes me is - you are happy to take your older child away on a weekend to do something that the younger one would want to do - but it doesn't seem like you are happy to take your younger child away to do something that your older child would want to do.

Why is that?

if you’re implying it’s favouritism as I’ve said before it’s absolutely nothing of the sort.

There’s a perfectly good reason for not taking the younger one on a serious mountain hike - that being he couldn’t do it and wouldn’t enjoy it (though he would enjoy a something less strenuous).

To the extent it’s age related, that seems fair enough to me (“DS9 is going on this trip because he is older, you can do it too when you’re his age”).

Excluding DS9 from something he would be able to do and enjoy doing simply to level the playing field seems somewhat unjust.

DS6 gets way more opportunities than DS9 did at the same age by virtue of being the youngest as most things we do are age-appropriate for him.

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 03/05/2023 15:15

AwaaFaeHom · 03/05/2023 15:11

What strikes me is - you are happy to take your older child away on a weekend to do something that the younger one would want to do - but it doesn't seem like you are happy to take your younger child away to do something that your older child would want to do.

Why is that?

Yes that's exactly what I thought.

AwaaFaeHom · 03/05/2023 15:11

What strikes me is - you are happy to take your older child away on a weekend to do something that the younger one would want to do - but it doesn't seem like you are happy to take your younger child away to do something that your older child would want to do.

Why is that?

Wtafis · 03/05/2023 15:09

Tell DS6 you’ll take him when he’s 9, and stick
to it

BecauseLifecanBeHard · 03/05/2023 15:04

We have the situation: DC1 has been able to hiking up anything since he could walk (slight hyperbole). DC2 likes hiking but finds it harder.

We go all together and then DC1 will do a hiking with DH on one/two of the days. That way everyone is happy.

I think taking just one when the other one likes the activity too is shitty.

NarwhalsTusk · 03/05/2023 14:56

There must be some activities that you don’t really do with him because they’re too young for DS1

I‘ve just had a brainwave that DS9 only eats beige food whereas DS6 has slightly more adventurous tastes (and I’m a keen cook) so there’s maybe something in that which would lend itself to an activity we can do together - a cookery class or something. It fits the same mould as trying to share my passions with the DC - which may come across as self-interested but (as it did with my dad) I think it’s good to try find an shared interest that connects you.

OP posts:
Glio · 03/05/2023 14:44

We have a similar age gap but try to do as much as we can as a family. If we were doing this trip we'd probably do what a pp suggested, one parent taking the train with the younger one. We've taken them to theme parks when only the eldest could go on most of the rides and it was fine! The youngest was happy to watch and do the few rides they could manage. Plus you have the evening time as shared family time, just the experience of staying somewhere together, and the journey there and back.

I'm sure in the future we'll have to split activities more, but for us it's really important to experience as much family time together as we can - otherwise we end up just having separate lives while living in the same house, like housemates.

Mrsjayy · 03/05/2023 14:09

NarwhalsTusk · 03/05/2023 14:01

My dad was a really keen hiker and I picked it up from him and carried it on as an interest I shared with him into adulthood. My siblings weren’t as interested.

So yeah I’m excited that DS9 is showing an aptitude and interest. It’s something I’ve always loved and hoped I’d be able pass down to my children as my dad did with me.

Dh doesn't hill walk much now, but my Dd does and she has a partner who equally enjoys its lovely that you shared that with your dad and now your son.

You can have loving equal and fair relationships with children and not take them out together all the time.