Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take only one DC for a weekend away?

206 replies

NarwhalsTusk · 03/05/2023 11:05

I have two DS, aged 6 and 9.

DS9 is fit and has great stamina. DS6 doesn’t - no disabilities etc, but even accounting for him being there years younger he’s just not built the same way.

I love the outdoors and hill walking and both DC are pretty keen but as a family we’re normally limited to what DS6 can manage.

DS9 is easily fit enough now to take on some peaks in Snowdonia. I’d love to take him away for a weekend to tackle a proper mountain. He’d love it. And it’d be nice to have some 1-1 time with him.

But DS6 would be gutted. He thinks (despite all evidence to contrary) he’s as capable as DS9. He’s also very attached to me so would be particularly jealous of me going away with just DS9.

WIBU to take DS9 away on his own?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheseThree · 06/05/2023 20:46

Treating your children equal isn’t the same as treating them fair. In fact it is often unfair as they get older.

DS6 probably doesn’t feel less capable because you all work at his level when together. Let him struggle sometimes (not every trip obviously). When he struggles, have him stay back with your partner (or you) and perhaps deviate to an easier route or go ahead back while you (or partner) and DS9 continue.

You need to spend time with each DS one on one, but DS6 doesn’t need a special big trip just because DS9 gets one. “When you get stronger, I’ll take you alone too if you want. For now, we’ll make time to X together.” (Not if you get stronger, when. Always show confidence in him.)

I know I could be roasted for such, but I’ve seen the difference when siblings are treated equal vs fair. My younger two are very close in age and I hope I can balance the difference well as they get older. I know it will get tricky having watched friends and family.

GoodChat · 05/05/2023 19:08

aSofaNearYou · 05/05/2023 17:44

If DS9 was good at football but DS6 also liked kicking a ball around, I’m not sure anyone would be saying I couldn’t send DS9 to a football camp because DS6 couldn’t go too.

That doesn't sound how you've described it. It sounds more like if they were both equally into football, but you thought DS9 was better at it so you only sent him to football camp.

100% agree

aSofaNearYou · 05/05/2023 17:44

If DS9 was good at football but DS6 also liked kicking a ball around, I’m not sure anyone would be saying I couldn’t send DS9 to a football camp because DS6 couldn’t go too.

That doesn't sound how you've described it. It sounds more like if they were both equally into football, but you thought DS9 was better at it so you only sent him to football camp.

mewkins · 05/05/2023 17:26

NarwhalsTusk · 05/05/2023 13:12

If DS9 was good at football but DS6 also liked kicking a ball around, I’m not sure anyone would be saying I couldn’t send DS9 to a football camp because DS6 couldn’t go too.

But that would be because a football camp would impose age limits. You've imposed your own age limits.

MakesMeFeelSad · 05/05/2023 14:33

Its fine, he cab spend time doing something he likes with his dad

ThursdayLastWeek · 05/05/2023 13:18

Last year I took just my older DC and I to London for a weekend. It was great. He’s an excellent walker - DC2 is not, he’d have been moaning the whole time!

Younger DC is jealous of course but he doesn’t really understand what he’s missing and when he’s older we’ll do something he likes.

AND he got 1 on 1 time with DH

NarwhalsTusk · 05/05/2023 13:12

HoppingPavlova · 04/05/2023 21:38

@HappiDaze It's completely normal that DC will have different interests so yes I would take the older DC and leave the other one behind to do the fun stuff he enjoys

But they have the same interest and the younger one enjoys this as well. That’s the problem. If the younger one wasn’t interested the problem would be solved, but alas.

If DS9 was good at football but DS6 also liked kicking a ball around, I’m not sure anyone would be saying I couldn’t send DS9 to a football camp because DS6 couldn’t go too.

OP posts:
HoppingPavlova · 04/05/2023 21:38

@HappiDaze It's completely normal that DC will have different interests so yes I would take the older DC and leave the other one behind to do the fun stuff he enjoys

But they have the same interest and the younger one enjoys this as well. That’s the problem. If the younger one wasn’t interested the problem would be solved, but alas.

Emmaheather · 04/05/2023 18:43

I think it's totally reasonable and very healthy to do things with children separately. You definitely need to plan something for DC6 before sharing plan with DC9. But learning that it's ok to do things independently of each other is good for siblings. They are their own people.It's not fair for DC9 if he has to wait 3 years longer for everything.

HappiDaze · 04/05/2023 18:22

It's completely normal that DC will have different interests so yes I would take the older DC and leave the other one behind to do the fun stuff he enjoys

SleazyLizzard · 04/05/2023 15:38

Definitely go , have two hiking weekends ,one with each child

NoFault2023 · 04/05/2023 15:09

NarwhalsTusk · 04/05/2023 15:03

Oh a cycling adventure is such a good idea, he would love that @HoneymoonSouvenir - and similar to what @AwaaFaeHom said the idea of taking him first works well. DS9 has an upcoming cubs camp and I was thinking of doing something with DS6 then, so that would work (as DS9 would otherwise be arguing about why he couldn’t come), then I can explain that DS6 has already had a solo adventure with me and now it is DS9’s turn.

Sounds sensible, enjoy both weekends OP.

NarwhalsTusk · 04/05/2023 15:03

Oh a cycling adventure is such a good idea, he would love that @HoneymoonSouvenir - and similar to what @AwaaFaeHom said the idea of taking him first works well. DS9 has an upcoming cubs camp and I was thinking of doing something with DS6 then, so that would work (as DS9 would otherwise be arguing about why he couldn’t come), then I can explain that DS6 has already had a solo adventure with me and now it is DS9’s turn.

OP posts:
HoneymoonSouvenir · 04/05/2023 14:50

We have a similar age gap and dynamic in our family. Whilst, in general, I think whole family activities are best and finding ways to include everyone, I also think occasional 1-2-1 time is important. I notice conversations are different when I am 1-2-1 with the kids. I also remember not being allowed to do certain things myself as a child, because my younger sibling couldn’t cope with it and I felt very held back and that my strengths weren’t celebrated.

I’d suggest that 1-2-1 time is important with both and to do the youngest child’s 1-2-1 time first, because they will have less ability to understand waiting. I wouldn’t promise to do the Snowdon trip when they are are 9, because that is an eternity for a 6 year old (and circumstances might change). Do something now. Ideally, make sure daddy is also treating and having quality time with the child not on an adventure with you.

On the issue of finding something you can enjoy with the younger child, that gives you both some challenge and sense of accomplishment - it takes a bit of lateral thinking, but sometimes you can do both.

I took one of my kids on an overnight cycling trip when she was 6. We did an off-road cycle path, which was only about 20 miles long. Not very long for me, but quite an achievement for my child. We split it in half by camping over night. I had never cycle-camped before, so it was new skills for me. Plus I carried the majority of the stuff, so the extra weight added a bit of challenge. We also took the bikes on the train, which was fairly stressful for me (having not done it recently), but exciting for my child.

AwaaFaeHom · 04/05/2023 14:28

Why not make it really easy - and plan a hike with younger son first, then do the harder one with your older son. That way it's the same activity, just a different level of difficulty, and it's an easier 'sell' - as you can tell them you want to enjoy one on one time with them

NarwhalsTusk · 04/05/2023 12:46

All family dynamics are different and I won’t cast judgement on you but your tone in some of your posts do make it seem like you have little faith in DS6’s abilities… he may surprise you what he’s capable of. Maybe if he starts with long nature walks he can build up to snowdonia

I can see it comes across as a bit blunt in isolation. Believe me that DS6 is absolutely adored. He is funny, creative, clever, affectionate and I couldn’t love him any more. But honestly, when it comes to physical activity DS9 is a Duracell bunny and DS6 isn’t.

That’s not to say I’ve written him off but I’m just realistic about what they’re each capable of.

OP posts:
NarwhalsTusk · 04/05/2023 12:37

thegreylady · 04/05/2023 10:34

I really think it would be a great idea for ds2 to be taken up in the train (pre booked) meet at the cafe then walk down together. The 9 year old would be ready for a slower pace and the 6 year old will have a walk down the mountain with his brother.

Maybe I am projecting because taking the train seems so much like cheating, but I feel like that emphasises the difference in their abilities more than just not taking him or taking him for a different activity in the same area.

OP posts:
Ethny · 04/05/2023 12:27

I was a younger child with the same age gap as your kids. And my grandma took my sister to the trip that she thought wasn't appropriate for my age so I stayed home. Few years later when I was the same age we repeated the trip. And of course my sister was included too this time. It felt very unfair for me. Maybe because we didn't travel much.
I think it's a nice idea to spend some quality time with each child individually. Maybe you should allow them to select the activity they would like.

Maray1967 · 04/05/2023 12:26

milkysmum · 03/05/2023 11:16

When mine were younger and one was more able than the other they both came away with me and then H, but H took the elder up Snowden and me and the younger stayed and did something nice at the bottom whilst they were out. Is that an option?

This is what we did - although the age gap between ours is almost 8 years. Eldest did Catbells with DH, youngest went swimming with me. All did a flat walk and the motorboat the next day.

NarwhalsTusk · 04/05/2023 12:22

Kennykenkencat · 04/05/2023 10:39

When you say they have similar interests is that because they have been to loads of other activities or because you as parents are into hiking and that is all they know.

The 6 year probably hasn’t even started to find out what his interests are.

What else do they do?

I was mainly meaning there isn’t anything obvious that DS6 is into that DS9 isn’t (eg that DS9 has outgrown) - they watch the same films/tv, play with the same toys and games etc. they both swim, cycle. They’ve been climbing, kayaking, paddle boarding, skiing. They do usual team sports at school
.
We give them plenty of exposure to different activities. There’s just nothing yet that really stands out for DS6, but it’s early days of course.

OP posts:
NarwhalsTusk · 04/05/2023 12:09

MammaTo · 04/05/2023 10:05

Do you have to tell the younger one what you’re doing? Can you say you’re doing something else and just keep the little one in the dark.. I know it sounds mean but it saves hurting his feelings.

For many reasons, absolutely no way.

OP posts:
MalagaNights · 04/05/2023 12:09

I think it's fine to do.
Good in fact.

I think saying to DS2 ' this is a very hard hike you're not old enough for yet so DS1 are me are going. When you're 11 you can come with me and do it too.'

There's a clear rationale and he gets the same treatment: doing this hike when he's 11.

I've always done activities with my children individually. I really valued time alone with each of them.

This was equally spread but no one was keeping records and counting, we all just accepted not everything is a whole family event.

I think an obsession with totally equal treatment at all times isn't healthy. Everyone should learn to give and take.

Wenfy · 04/05/2023 12:01

I think you should. This is where a lot of parents with multiple kids fall down - many tend to dumb down or minimise the older child’s experiences to accomodate younger siblings but then when those younger siblings get older they get to do everything they want to and more. It isn’t fair.

NarwhalsTusk · 04/05/2023 12:00

Em308 · 04/05/2023 10:23

How about this? Weekend away all the family - day one you and elder son do your climb, younger son and dad do an activity. Day two you and younger son do a different, gentler climb, older son and dad do an activity. Both children get one to one with each parent and you get to do the harder hike.

Something like this might work, though I can see various ways it’d probably work out differently in practice…DS6 would moan about not being with me, DH would feel hard done by not doing the more strenuous walks. There’s something to be said for me and DS9 being “out of sight out of mind”.

OP posts:
Mummasince22 · 04/05/2023 11:57

By your own logic OP taking only DS9 would be the equivalent to taking one to a theme park without the other. DS6 would still know that you and DS9 have gone off to do something fun without him.
If you were to go ahead and take DS9 away without DS6 and DH you’d have to make sure DS6 had an equally fun weekend with DH.
Maybe you need to set a president for 1 on 1 weekends? The 1st and 3rd weekends of the month being 1 on 1 days/weekends where you and DH alternate the boys with the remaining 2 weekends in the month being family weekends. That way you and DH get quality time with the kids together and separate and you’ll all the the opportunity to explore activities at the skill sets appropriate. It may also take the sting out of you taking DS9 out without DS6 if DS6 knows he’ll be having an equally good time with his Dad and he’ll get to have a different fun weekend/day out with you later in the month.
All family dynamics are different and I won’t cast judgement on you but your tone in some of your posts do make it seem like you have little faith in DS6’s abilities… he may surprise you what he’s capable of. Maybe if he starts with long nature walks he can build up to snowdonia. I hope whatever you decide that both boys get enjoyable experiences.