Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed off with SIL?

156 replies

FanFareMax · 03/05/2023 07:53

So DN (DH’s sister’s daughter) is 6. She’s obsessed with our DD, 10 months. When I was pregnant, SIL went on and on at DN about how I was carrying her cousin and how they’re going to be best friends once the baby is born, getting her to hug my bump constantly (which I wasn’t keen on but didn’t seem to be given a choice) just really trying to generate excitement in DN. I get why, but it was a lot at the time (or felt it, perhaps it was pregnancy hormones)

We live nearly 200 miles from SIL and her family so only see them every few months.

Since DD has been born, it’s been so intense with DN every time we see them. We went to visit them for a couple of days last weekend and I left feeling really cross at SIL and also DH.

It’s no exaggeration to say from the minute we arrived to the minute we left, we barely got a moments peace from DN. She was glued to my side and in my and my DD’s face constantly, pulling DD around, following me every single time I tried to put her down for a nap or to change or feed her. She kept saying to SIL ‘she’s like one of my dolls’ and SIL kept saying ‘yes she is like your dolls’ I really wanted to say, she’s not a fucking doll.

SIL kept asking could DN feed and change DD, I didn’t feel like I could say no as she asked right in front of DN, neither the feeding or the nappy changing went well (I think because DD was getting more and more grumpy and tired) DD was getting so fed up of being pulled around, she’s teething so hadn’t slept well the night before and was so overstimulated and grumpy that after a while she had the biggest meltdown she’s ever had and neither DH nor I could console her for nearly an hour. Noone could hear themselves think so I said I’d try putting her in the pram and take her for a walk to try and get her to sleep, que DN saying ‘I want to come and push the pram.’ I just wanted 5 minutes bloody peace, I looked at SIL and was about to say ‘I think it’s probably best I go on my own’ when SIL jumped in and said ‘of course you can, I’m sure FanFare will let you push the pram as well’

It carried on like that for the whole weekend, I left feeling exhausted as felt like I’d had two children the whole weekend with DN just constantly bloody THERE.

When we got home, DH said ‘DN was pretty intense this weekend wasn’t she, I could sense some tension at one point and could tell you were getting really pissed off’ I said ‘So why didn’t you say something then? It’s your bloody family!’ And he said ‘I wanted to but I knew it would piss SIL off, I didn’t think she’d take it very well if I said DN was being a bit much, you know what she can be like’ (backstory, SIL is incredibly precious and cannot take any form of criticism towards her or her family, she’s also the ‘princess’ of DH’s family and we are all genuinely expected to pander to her otherwise MIL and FIL get cross!)

I’m so cross, I feel like DH shoved me and DD under the bus so as not to annoy SIL. It’s okay for me to be annoyed though?

What’s prompted this thread is it’s MIL’s birthday next month and we are all going to a cottage for the weekend to celebrate so we have to stay under the same roof as DN for 2 days. On Monday we get sent a video from SIL, it’s of DN singing a countdown song to the number of days until she gets to see DD again. I got one yesterday and now again this morning. SIL said DN is going to do one every day for the next month until she sees DD again. I’m honestly really struggling with all this, it feels so bloody intense and suffocating and I can’t imagine having this much interest in someone else’s baby! SIL has zero self awareness that other people might not want DN in their face all the time and never calls her away. How on earth am I going to cope with it for 2 days under the same roof? I’m dreading it.

AIBU here? Is it actually all really ‘cute’ and I just need to accept it all? To me it just feels intense and obsessive.

OP posts:
JudgeJ · 03/05/2023 10:29

Tell the niece to pester her mother for a sibling that she can play with.

Mabelface · 03/05/2023 10:29

"Just like you when you were a baby, dd sometimes needs some quiet time/just mummy etc, so I'm going to do this as just dd and I. You can help with xxxx later if you'd like, as dd loves it when you xxx"

Every time your dd needs time out. You're acknowledging that dn is a big girl and can think in big girl ways. If it doesn't work, then a firm "as I said, not this time" and let her mother deal with the fallout. Sil will make herself look like a dick if she kicks off.

SavBlancTonight · 03/05/2023 10:27

The dynamic is tricky but I think you're letting your long term, legitimate resentment, of SIL colour your view here somewhat. The behaviour she is encouraging in DN is totally not okay. But it does not require a full sit down discussion. it requires all the suggestions made on this thread about firm but kind boundaries being drawn on an ongoing basis. Yes, SIL won't be happy and she might even try to overrule you, but you need to stick to it and calmly but firmly reiterate the boundary and, if necessary, remind her that you are looking out for your dd.

We had a somewhat similar situation. the interesting thing was that when DH and I decided to absolutely assert the boundary. SIL was NOT happy. But, we calmly repeated it and left the party as we'd agreed to do if certain behaviour continued. SIL hasn't learnt her lesson at all but interestingly, her DC has and a lot of the behaviour has stopped. It's a win from me.

JenniferBarkley · 03/05/2023 10:27

Sorry OP, have only read your posts so probably repeating others. I have a similarly tricky character in my family and have disengaged and avoid conflict now, it's just not worth it.

While you're there, big up DN (poor kid isn't going to have it easy in life, but it's not your job to parent her). "Oh DN, DD loves you so much! I think she just finds you too exciting to sleep though, so I'd best take her out for a sleep in the buggy and then you two can play when she wakes up".

Lots of talk to anyone who'll listen about how DD is getting overstimulated so easily these days and so you've had to change your routine to feed and change her in a quiet room by herself - this will get you time away, whether in your bedroom or out for a walk. In your shoes, I'd be saying she's started only napping in the pram and going out for lots of loooooong walks by myself Blush

Get DH on side with all of this - make it crystal clear that if this doesn't work, you will be telling SIL to get DN to back off and he can live with the consequences.

You could consider an advance warning to SIL about DD needing more calm and that she might want to prepare DN for that, but tbh I think that would just create drama. Bright, firm, breezy, cheerful is the way to handle this.

Hankunamatata · 03/05/2023 10:25

Also perhaps get firm routine for dd. And say she has a nap at x time and take her up while dh asks dn to watch cartoons or play a game

Iwishicouldflyhigh · 03/05/2023 10:23

FanFareMax · 03/05/2023 10:18

But realistically, how close are they actually going to be throughout life? There’s a 6 year age gap and 200 mile distance, with the parents not being particularly close either.

Great if they are close growing up, but I can’t really see it happening, there’s too much of an age gap and too much distance IMO.

Well that's true - the age gap between my cousins and i is a few years.....but we don't live close to each other.

But that aside, my children have that age gap with their cousins and they are still close.......and literally my children followed them around (and so i got some peace from them). I do think that the niece sounds full on though, and i would definitely manage it but saying something like i''ll wipe DD's bottom and put the nappy on and you can stick on the velcro'. Or 'i'll change her and then you can have a little cuddle whilst i go to the loo.' Or, 'i think that XXX needs a chill out now, so i'm going to go and sit over there and then when she wakes up, she'll be happy and ready to have another cuddle'. And i wouldn't have any hesitation in doing that in front of SIL as it's not unreasonable and if she thinks that it is, it's her issue and not mine!!

HaggisBurger · 03/05/2023 10:23

You’re totally right to be hacked off with all of this. Your baby is NOT a doll.
And whilst I do get it is your DH’s family - I think at various points you needed to speak up as you were the one experiencing the irritation and overwhelm (during pg, before the walk etc). It sounds as though you’re inability to speak up at those moments has greatly added to your resentment.

That said - create a plan with your DH for him to advocate on your and your baby’s behalf at this weekend. Don’t hand your baby over to be played with (as a PP suggested). And use your own voice calmly and as necessary to explain to DN and her batshit mother that you need some time on your own with you baby and that babies need quiet time.

good luck!

Hankunamatata · 03/05/2023 10:22

Gently start redirecting dn. Get her a doll that she can feed and wets etc and encourage her to do with her lovely new doll what you are doing with your baby. Also get dh to get some toys or games and arrange a signal for him to engage with dn and distract her

cpphelp · 03/05/2023 10:22

@FanFareMax speaking as a maternal
Auntie who is obsessed with my niece.... she's been very annoying to my boys as babies! My niece is now 8, and couldn't give a monkeys about them, unless it's to get them to bed quicker so she can do grown up stuff.

It was awkward with my sister at first, but I just kept having to put in boundaries, as my kids come first. I ADORE my niece, but she's not mine, my kids are.

Can I urge you to stand up for your child in a polite way to your DN? "Thank you so much for offering sweetheart, but baby is exhausted and just needs quiet time to get to bed, kiss baby now so they know you love them. See you when baby in bed"!
"That's so kind of you to offer to push pram darling, but sometimes baby just wants me or your uncle. You were the same as a tiny baby! I remember when you did XYZ"

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 03/05/2023 10:20

SecondtimeMama29 · 03/05/2023 10:11

You sound very mean to your niece. She's being kind and showing an interest.

You live 200 miles away, this is hardly a pop in weekly situation. You need to give your head a wobble.

Imagine if it was the opposite? And there was zero interest. I think it's lovely and how sweet that she loved her new cousin?

Oh cut it out, that’s not interest, that a spoilt child with no boundaries.

Whats sweet about someone being so hectic and in your face tk the extend the baby is having tantrums from being exhausted and tired?

FanFareMax · 03/05/2023 10:18

Iwishicouldflyhigh · 03/05/2023 10:16

In my opinion, the relationship between cousins is very lovely. My cousins and i are really close - we go on holiday together and days out. Your DD will be a baby for a very short time and then she'll be a toddler and will idealise DN and will follow her around (with the added bonus that you'll get a break). Foster the relationship between them and get DN really involved. It sounds like you see them infrequently and for relatively short periods.

She is a little girl, in love with her baby niece.

But realistically, how close are they actually going to be throughout life? There’s a 6 year age gap and 200 mile distance, with the parents not being particularly close either.

Great if they are close growing up, but I can’t really see it happening, there’s too much of an age gap and too much distance IMO.

OP posts:
Cantstandbullshitanymore · 03/05/2023 10:18

FanFareMax · 03/05/2023 08:26

This is brilliant advice and what I would normally do if it were anyone else’s child, but I know if I say these things, however gently to DN, that SIL’s head will fall off, and then MIL and FIL’s will too. You’re not allowed to tell her children no, they’re not allowed to be disappointed.

And why are you so opposed to MIL and FIL getting upset? Do they pay your bills? Are you dependent on them for money?

If not then you should set boundaries once and for all. You’ve pussyfooted for 11 years and how has that worked out? Standing your growing once would have sorted all this out ages ago.

FanFareMax · 03/05/2023 10:16

SecondtimeMama29 · 03/05/2023 10:11

You sound very mean to your niece. She's being kind and showing an interest.

You live 200 miles away, this is hardly a pop in weekly situation. You need to give your head a wobble.

Imagine if it was the opposite? And there was zero interest. I think it's lovely and how sweet that she loved her new cousin?

There’s showing interest and then being absolutely suffocating. The latter I have a problem with. It’s not DN’s fault, she’s not being parented.

And actually, it really wouldn’t bother me one bit if DN wasn’t interested in DD to be honest, I’m not entitled enough to think that everyone is going to have a massive interest in my child. So long as DH and I have an interest in her, anyone else is a bonus.

OP posts:
EatYourVegetables · 03/05/2023 10:16

Stop dropping hints and just speak up. Tell DN no, loud and clear, in front of SIL.

You will need boundaries as a parent...

Iwishicouldflyhigh · 03/05/2023 10:16

In my opinion, the relationship between cousins is very lovely. My cousins and i are really close - we go on holiday together and days out. Your DD will be a baby for a very short time and then she'll be a toddler and will idealise DN and will follow her around (with the added bonus that you'll get a break). Foster the relationship between them and get DN really involved. It sounds like you see them infrequently and for relatively short periods.

She is a little girl, in love with her baby niece.

Maddy70 · 03/05/2023 10:16

Yabu

Just say to dn baby needs some quiet time now

Why can't you stand up for yourself?

No idea why you are so annoyed with a child. Just set boundaries

Mochinated · 03/05/2023 10:13

YABU because you haven't spoken up at all!

Set calm and clear boundaries, parent your child! Recognise your and baby's needs and say so.

SIL is being a total dick, don't pander

SecondtimeMama29 · 03/05/2023 10:11

You sound very mean to your niece. She's being kind and showing an interest.

You live 200 miles away, this is hardly a pop in weekly situation. You need to give your head a wobble.

Imagine if it was the opposite? And there was zero interest. I think it's lovely and how sweet that she loved her new cousin?

StopMindlesslyScrolling · 03/05/2023 10:10

Why are you going to MILs do?

Let DH take the baby and you stay home and do something with your mates instead; you'll have a much better time.

DH will be the one having to deal with his family and he can either put some boundaries in or deal with the stress that's caused by the lack of boundaries.

As for SIL not being invited to yours, that really isn't your problem. Don't worry yourself about it. Your DH isn't rushing to invite her, you know you won't enjoy it if she comes, so why would you?

Honestly, life is far too short for all the drama, so just avoid it and let your DH deal with his own family; you chose him, not them.

MammaTo · 03/05/2023 10:08

I do understand your frustrations im sort of in the same boat with my partners family, but you live so far away and don’t see each other all the time I don’t know whether it would bother me if it was just on special occasions.
I think either yourself or your husband should speak up a bit more about letting the baby have a minute to chill or maybe don’t announce when you’re going for a walk for example - just sneak out like i do haha!
I hope you find some middle ground soon, hooefully your niece may grow out of the excitement soon.

coconutpie · 03/05/2023 10:05

All this pandering to SIL so as not to cause upset to SIL and your MIL/FIL at the expense of upsetting your DD and yourself is just ridiculous. You do not need DH to "step in". You simply say no yourself. You are going to have to deal with conflict and advocate for your DD plenty of times, you cannot be a doormat for fear of upsetting someone. It is time to start now and not expect your DH to deal with it.

I can't believe you stood back and allowed a 6yo change your baby's nappy, etc because you didn't feel you could say no just because SIL asked in front of your DN!!! Honestly OP, put your big girl pants on, you need to put your DD first. "No SIL/DN, DD is not a doll. No, you will not be changing her. No DN, DD is upset now, go and play with your toys for a while". Who gives a crap if SIL gets upset?! No wonder she gets away with all this, you all let her. What's the worst that will happen? She throws a tantrum? I sure as hell would prefer SIL throwing a tantrum than my own baby being upset. You need to put in VERY firm boundaries here. Yes, SIL/DN/PIL will try their best to push them but do not give an inch.

Also, if SIL complains about not getting to visit you in your home, say a breezy, sorry we are just too busy to have house guests right now.

gamerchick · 03/05/2023 10:01

IncompleteSenten · 03/05/2023 07:57

If you've ruled out telling her straight then I suggest the baby comes down with last minute I'm not dealing with this shititis.

Exactly what I would do. Last minute illness and send husband off on his own and a stern if he complains then he can fucking stay with his family.

WandaWonder · 03/05/2023 09:59

I have to admit although the intenseness would drive me up the wall I would leave my child with her and go 'great you can babysit I need to go out and do a few things'

FanFareMax · 03/05/2023 09:58

Lamelie · 03/05/2023 09:53

“I’m going to have a word with DH when he gets home from work this evening and get him to promise me that if the same thing happens again next month, he MUST step in and say something, or I will and it won’t be pretty if it comes from me as I do have form for going from 0-100.”
Oh for goodness sake. Again with the simpering non adulting. DH should have your back of course but not speak in your place. How about you don’t go 0-100 but just use your words to sil and niece? 🤦🏻‍♀️

There’s just too much water under the bridge with SIL and I and too much past resentment there from me for me to compartmentalise in the moment I think. If she gets argumentative or starts throwing a tantrum, I’m going to really struggle to not bring up stuff that I’ve been wanting to say for years!

Ultimately if DH won’t say anything then I will, and I will of course try and keep it kind and civil but I don’t have the patience of a saint and if SIL reacts badly I’m not sure I have the self control to not react badly back, I’m human, not a robot.

OP posts:
Cakeorchocolate · 03/05/2023 09:54

FanFareMax · 03/05/2023 08:26

This is brilliant advice and what I would normally do if it were anyone else’s child, but I know if I say these things, however gently to DN, that SIL’s head will fall off, and then MIL and FIL’s will too. You’re not allowed to tell her children no, they’re not allowed to be disappointed.

You absolutely can say these things.

You have to put yours and your child's needs first, which means saying "not this time" sometimes to DN and SIL.

You can make it sound better, "DD really needs a sleep so she's not grumpy, if you come and push DN she won't be able to sleep because she'll be too interested in looking at you. We can take her for another walk together later when she's had a sleep maybe." (Speaking from experience here.)

You don't have to let DN + SIL get everything they want. Goes for feeds and changes too.

Yes it's lovely that she likes DD but doesn't trump what your child needs at any time.

Be assertive. Sod whatever unwritten rule there seems to be around SIL.