Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I’m “entitled” for actually being a woman?

129 replies

ThreeblackCats · 02/05/2023 19:07

I was a bit pissed to be referred to as a “cis” female and I stood my ground.

I’m not cis, I’m not a terf, I’m a woman, born a woman, lived a woman for 60 years and Michael called me “entitled” so, am I wrong for defending woman from this BS?

I’m sick of being relegated to third place after men and then trans men.

I’m “entitled” for actually being a woman?
I’m “entitled” for actually being a woman?
I’m “entitled” for actually being a woman?
I’m “entitled” for actually being a woman?
I’m “entitled” for actually being a woman?
OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 02/05/2023 23:56

AudibleEyeroll · 02/05/2023 23:44

Honestly listen to yourself. Why do you care so much what’s in people’s pants? If you personally don’t want to be called cis that’s fine but then you need to respect transwomen that want to be called women because you don’t agree with the differentiation. Cis- is literally just for that. Differentiation. No different to homosexual / heterosexual. Etymology is an ever changing science, get with the times or stay where you are but the world is thankfully becoming a more diverse and tolerant place whether you like it or not.

but then you need to respect transwomen that want to be called women because you don’t agree with the differentiation

Sorry but no. No woman has to 'respect' a man who is imposing himself on women in this way.

Etymology is an ever changing science, get with the times or stay where you are but the world is thankfully becoming a more diverse and tolerant place whether you like it or not.

At what point, and please do be specific, does a man who claims to be a woman become an adult human female?

Please be VERY specific about this?

At what point does he cease to be a male and how?

Because is science is changing, that's cool, we just need to understand the specifics.

AudibleEyeroll · 02/05/2023 23:44

FlirtsWithRhinos · 02/05/2023 23:39

  1. The application of it to gender is at most a handful of decades old, and only been pushed into "common" use in the last 10 years or so via the deliberate, conscious effort of genderist activists. In this usage it is both newfangled and artificial.

  2. It is used to suppport the appropriation of the word "women" by men who wish to use this sleight of hand to assert the dishonest claim that, since they have redefined the word woman to include them, this somehow gives them a moral claim on the resources, rights and spaces set up for a completely different set of people who happen to use the same word even thought "woman" meant something totally different when these things were created than the meaning these men now claim it has.

  3. When you adopt the constructions of "trans" and "cis woman" you are accepting that womanhood is a state of mind - that "women" think in a way which is different to "men". Many of us think this idea of "woman's minds" and "men's minds" is just the old sexist, regressive bullshit that has been used to restrict female potential and agency forever. We reject utterly being labelled "cis" because we reject the assertion that our minds are limited to genderised norms.

Honestly listen to yourself. Why do you care so much what’s in people’s pants? If you personally don’t want to be called cis that’s fine but then you need to respect transwomen that want to be called women because you don’t agree with the differentiation. Cis- is literally just for that. Differentiation. No different to homosexual / heterosexual. Etymology is an ever changing science, get with the times or stay where you are but the world is thankfully becoming a more diverse and tolerant place whether you like it or not.

Swansandcustard · 02/05/2023 23:43

Everything going on in the world and THIS is what consumes you? You must live a lovely privileged life if this is all you have to worry about.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 02/05/2023 23:39

AudibleEyeroll · 02/05/2023 20:47

Cis- as a prefix is the Latin opposite of trans-, hence its use here. It’s not some woke, newfangled expression.

  1. The application of it to gender is at most a handful of decades old, and only been pushed into "common" use in the last 10 years or so via the deliberate, conscious effort of genderist activists. In this usage it is both newfangled and artificial.

  2. It is used to suppport the appropriation of the word "women" by men who wish to use this sleight of hand to assert the dishonest claim that, since they have redefined the word woman to include them, this somehow gives them a moral claim on the resources, rights and spaces set up for a completely different set of people who happen to use the same word even thought "woman" meant something totally different when these things were created than the meaning these men now claim it has.

  3. When you adopt the constructions of "trans" and "cis woman" you are accepting that womanhood is a state of mind - that "women" think in a way which is different to "men". Many of us think this idea of "woman's minds" and "men's minds" is just the old sexist, regressive bullshit that has been used to restrict female potential and agency forever. We reject utterly being labelled "cis" because we reject the assertion that our minds are limited to genderised norms.

Rainbowshit · 02/05/2023 23:31

cadburyegg · 02/05/2023 19:21

A cisgender person has a gender identity that matches their sex assigned at birth. If you had spent 2 seconds on google rather than arguing about it then you'd have realised it's not an insult

And if you'd spent 2 seconds on google you'd have found that plenty of people consider cis to be a slur.

CarpetSlipper · 02/05/2023 22:45

Michael clearly hates women, his goady shite about “who do you expect to pay for it” is presumably because he thinks men pay for everything and have all the power. I understand the points you were making (I don’t identify as anything, I’m female because I am in the same way I don’t need to identify as having a particular eye colour, they’re just the colour they are and I never think about it) but do think you were unnecessarily aggressive. If I were you I’d stay away from forums like that and try not to get riled up by him as he’s probably enjoyed it.

sHREDDIES19 · 02/05/2023 22:45

Op try not to let it get you down. In the actual real world, pretty much everyone is on the side of biology, rational thought, critical thinking and reality. I have literally never heard anyone refer to me as a cis or a terf! These internet trans activists are imploding as they come to the realisation that the world is awake to their insanity and are not accepting it.

SidewaysOtter · 02/05/2023 22:36

You may not like the term yourself. If so you are entitled to ask other people not to use it to describe you and to have that request respected. In the same way a trans woman is entitled to ask people to refer to her just as a “woman”. It goes both ways.

No it doesn’t. A trans woman is not a woman. To say otherwise would be a lie so I will not pander to the “entitlement” when a man demands to be called a woman.

BreadInCaptivity · 02/05/2023 22:34

Good for you OP.

Far too many people expect to be able to peddle this nonsense without being challenged.

Gender identity is a social construct that is designed to enable men to publicly engage in a sexual fetish at the expense of women.

There is nothing that's sacred in their pursuit of this. Our language, our spaces, our sports and worst of all our children.

There is nothing remotely progressive about it nor anything remotely kind.

People who believe in this either haven't done their homework or have some stake in enabling men's oppression of women and the harm being done to children for whom medical transition means a loss of sexual function, fertility and a lifetime of medical complications and dependency.

It's an absolute bloody scandal happening in plain sight and yet some people still remain wilfully blind to what's happening because they refuse to look at the reputable evidence.

keeponandonandon · 02/05/2023 22:21

PSNonsense · 02/05/2023 19:25

To steal from another poster, Cis is like inventing a word for someone who doesn't collect stamps.

Agreed!! A bunch of people have made up and bunch of words and then have the audacity to decide that in order for me to authentically identify as an adult human female with a womb I've now got to add CIS - my view is anyone who wants to push this nonsense on me can 'CIS off'

TheNestedIf · 02/05/2023 22:20

SinnerBoy · 02/05/2023 22:03

@TheNestedIf

racking of brains until actual women identified themselves as "cis."

I think it was trans extremist zealots who foisted it upon women. Either way, if a group of people say that a word used to describe them is offensive, then it is offensive.

I totally agree. It is offensive. I was trying to point out why it's also redundant.

lifeturnsonadime · 02/05/2023 22:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

FOJN · 02/05/2023 22:03

Daffidale · 02/05/2023 21:05

I’ve never come across the idea that ”cis” is an insult until I read the MN guidelines . in my circles I and many women I know use it to describe ourselves . I especially use it when discussing my own lived experience of discrimination and how that is different from the lived experience of discrimination other women have - such as women of colour, LGBTQ+ , working class women etc

You may not like the term yourself. If so you are entitled to ask other people not to use it to describe you and to have that request respected. In the same way a trans woman is entitled to ask people to refer to her just as a “woman”. It goes both ways.

but agree with others. that Michael bloke comes across as a right t**t.

How does adding cis contribute anything to a discussion about discrimination? The groups of women you have identified may all be discriminated against for different reasons in addition to also being female.

I know many people seem to think lived experience trumps all else these days but there are nearly 8 billion lived experiences on earth and it's a tad tricky to make effective policy which also accommodates all that uniqueness.

A transwoman is not entitled to demand I lie so you have not given an example of respect going both ways. Women are asking for nothing more than recognition of reality and transwomen are demanding I lie to protect their feelings, something I would have been happy to do once upon a time but not anymore.

SinnerBoy · 02/05/2023 22:03

@TheNestedIf

racking of brains until actual women identified themselves as "cis."

I think it was trans extremist zealots who foisted it upon women. Either way, if a group of people say that a word used to describe them is offensive, then it is offensive.

Wonford · 02/05/2023 21:55

If I'm doing this at 60 I'll feel like a failure. Go and read a book or something. Arguing on the internet is not good for your soul.

ManuelBensonsLeftBoot · 02/05/2023 21:53

Michael clearly isn't the brightest bulb in the string of fairy lights as he doesn't appear aware that there are already male and female categories in most sports.

FOJN · 02/05/2023 21:50

cadburyegg · 02/05/2023 19:21

A cisgender person has a gender identity that matches their sex assigned at birth. If you had spent 2 seconds on google rather than arguing about it then you'd have realised it's not an insult

Who made you arbiter of what women are permitted to find insulting?

We all know what is means and many of us reject it. Call yourself what you like but don't assume other people will welcome the rebrand.

JudgeJ · 02/05/2023 21:45

BluebellBlueballs · 02/05/2023 19:17

Terf has pretty much been reclaimed now

Most GC I know use the term proudly

Not saying everyone has to but its not the slur they want it to be

Thought 'terf' was what I needed for the bald spots in my lawn! Really couldn't care less.

Buffypaws · 02/05/2023 21:45

cadburyegg · 02/05/2023 19:21

A cisgender person has a gender identity that matches their sex assigned at birth. If you had spent 2 seconds on google rather than arguing about it then you'd have realised it's not an insult

what a load of old shit

itwasntmetho · 02/05/2023 21:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Holly60 · 02/05/2023 21:38

ThreeblackCats · 02/05/2023 21:11

@Popcorn121 you seem to have missed the point but hey ho!

Lots of women on here seem to disagree with my argument. We, as women stand no chance if we can’t even get real women on our side.

I’m a woman, I will not respond to anyone who refers to me as cis.

I shouldn't imagine you will be referred to as 'cis' to your face in the real world. If you do, just a polite 'oh no I prefer people not to use that term in relation to me, thanks' is fine. I'm sure the conversation will move on in a very British way.

As to the rest, as other PP have suggested - just don't engage with the argument online. You are bound to come across the most entrenched and extreme beliefs there. It can't be doing anything for your sense of peace.

IcakethereforeIam · 02/05/2023 21:35

I'm not cis, I don't subscribe to gender ideology or any other religion.

OP as PPs have said arguing with twats on the Internet is usually a waste of time but good on you for trying. Also sign petitions, write to your MP and Councillor, if you get canvassed tell them how you feel about this.

IcakethereforeIam · 02/05/2023 21:34

I'm not cis, I don't subscribe to gender ideology or any other religion.

OP as PPs have said arguing with twats on te Internet is usually a waste of time but good on you for trying. Also sign petitions, write to your MP and Councillor, if you get canvassed tell them how you feel about this.

SidewaysOtter · 02/05/2023 21:28

Facts are not entitlement

Quite. There is no such thing as a “cis woman”, there are women (defined as adult human biological females) and transwomen. No woman has a penis. No man has a vagina. No one can change their biological sex.

Truth Will Always Matter.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 02/05/2023 21:26

Iwrote · 02/05/2023 19:52

Why are you spending time and energy arguing with eejits on the Internet!?!?

But yes OP really not worth the energy on an idiot like him.