Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I’m “entitled” for actually being a woman?

129 replies

ThreeblackCats · 02/05/2023 19:07

I was a bit pissed to be referred to as a “cis” female and I stood my ground.

I’m not cis, I’m not a terf, I’m a woman, born a woman, lived a woman for 60 years and Michael called me “entitled” so, am I wrong for defending woman from this BS?

I’m sick of being relegated to third place after men and then trans men.

I’m “entitled” for actually being a woman?
I’m “entitled” for actually being a woman?
I’m “entitled” for actually being a woman?
I’m “entitled” for actually being a woman?
I’m “entitled” for actually being a woman?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Brefugee · 03/05/2023 19:03

Ossification · 03/05/2023 00:44

'Literal violence'?
😆😆😆😆😆😆😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣
Find a dictionary and look up the word literal
And then use it appropriately

are you new to the internet?

Dog Eye Roll GIF by Rover.com
Brefugee · 03/05/2023 19:01

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/05/2023 00:01

I don't especially care what is in people's pants, why are you bringing pants into it?

I care that the historic oppression and disempowerment of female people by male has shaped our culture and society. I believe that because of that history of disempowerment , female people must now have a moral right to maintain their own name, history, voice and resources to respond to, mitigate and eventually overcome that historic disadvantage so we may all, both sexes, live empowered lives and meet our potential as human beings.

A gender-noncoforming man who celebrates finding a new way to be a man is a brave and glorious thing. I stand beside anyone, man or woman, who looks beyond the gender roles our society has created to say "no, a woman or man is not a certain type of personality, or a set of behaviours, or a mental aptitude, or a sexual role - a woman is any personality in a female body, and a man is any personality in a male body".

But a gender-nonconforming man who thinks this makes him not a man at all but a woman reduces and limits both himself and women. He is imposing on all women a definition that he wants them to have for his own needs, for what part of himself he sees reflected in them, rather than seeing them for who they are and can be, entire people in their own right.

I do not stand with anyone who thinks the difference between men and women is in how they think, nor with anyone who would silence female voices or deny female people the right to their own history, female-only spaces and resources, or their own political voice.

👏

StarryCup · 03/05/2023 18:15

I literally have never come across it in RL, only online like here

I hadn't either until fairly recently. I've been aware of the term for a good while, as you say, online. But it's crept in. During a conversation at work with a few women, one of the younger women said to another "You can tell us, we're all cis women here"

It came from nowhere, for no apparent reason. It just went a bit quiet and we looked at her in some surprise (most of us, I expect some didn't even know what it meant) and somebody said "Don't be daft" and then we sort of drifted away.

There has been some mild discussion since but nobody really wants to address it.

StarryCup · 03/05/2023 17:53

it doesn't make me less of a woman. But I am told that I am apparently now a ciswoman so that a transwoman can be a woman instead of me. So it does affect me. Because someone who is biologically a man get to call themself a woman through choice, and I am expected to step aside to respect their feelings. But my feelings are not respected

Exactly what I was going to say, but probably not as succinctly. So will just repeat it.

Aloealoealoevera · 03/05/2023 17:23

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

KimberleyClark · 03/05/2023 17:19

cadburyegg · 02/05/2023 19:21

A cisgender person has a gender identity that matches their sex assigned at birth. If you had spent 2 seconds on google rather than arguing about it then you'd have realised it's not an insult

Surely sex is not assigned at birth, it’s observed. Saying it’s assigned makes it sound like a decision the midwife made.

TheSingingBean · 03/05/2023 17:17

CremeEggQueen · 03/05/2023 08:14

And yes, consent. Important that. Rather odd you consider it so given that you're suggesting that same-sex attracted women have heterosexual sex with a trans woman (we know that the vast majority are penis havers)
Some do want to though.
If you don't want to, then don't.
I just don't get why some people care so much about what others do with their consenting sex life.
If you're a lesbian, then you still are regardless of what others are or aren't doing.

If a lesbian wants to have sex with someone with a penis they're not a lesbian, they're bisexual.

Murdoch1949 · 03/05/2023 17:02

Totally agree with you. It annoys & offends me to see women labelled as Cis or Terf, it's unnecessary. It is the rabid transwomen (men) and their supporters (men) who are just being disruptive to annoy women. I seriously doubt that a large proportion of transwomen are actually transvestites, with no intention of genital surgery focusing on cosmetic surgery instead. Eddie Izzard is a prime example of this. Enjoys wearing women's clothing and make up, but still has his 'boy mode'. The man is a fool. Genuine transwomen just want to live their lives, as do transmen (they keep quiet at all times, it seems).

itwasntmetho · 03/05/2023 15:02

Daffidale · 03/05/2023 11:11

I phrased my original post poorly, and am sorry that offended people. I should have said I use it as as part of a longer phrase like “straight cisgendered middle class white woman” to say I am aware I have many types of privilege which means my experience of discrimination differs from that of women who experience multiple layers of discrimination. This is of course exactly because I conform more closely to what some narrow minded and sexist/racist/classist people might consider a “default” or “standard” woman. I agree with you that such thinking is offensive and discriminatory. I’m sorry my original post caused such offence.

So you use it to denote privilege, this is exactly why people think it is so manipulative. females have been an oppressed class for centuries and now you’ve been handed the language to say that men who say they are us are worse off but if you don’t want to use that language you must be petty or hateful.

SinnerBoy · 03/05/2023 12:34

Swansandcustard · Yesterday 23:43

Everything going on in the world and THIS is what consumes you?

Well, unless one is a 2-D cartoon type of person, it's perfectly possible to be concerned about more than one thing, at any given time.

Also, this thread's subject is the deleterious effects of tranw on women, their own spaces, own society, privacy and dignity.

If you'd rather talk about something else, there is a plethora of threads on a multitude of different subjects.

FarmGirl78 · 03/05/2023 11:52

cadburyegg · 02/05/2023 19:21

A cisgender person has a gender identity that matches their sex assigned at birth. If you had spent 2 seconds on google rather than arguing about it then you'd have realised it's not an insult

You've missed the point of the entire thread.

Daffidale · 03/05/2023 11:11

LateAF · 03/05/2023 09:38

in my circles I and many women I know use it to describe ourselves . I especially use it when discussing my own lived experience of discrimination and how that is different from the lived experience of discrimination other women have - such as women of colour, LGBTQ+ , working class women etc

You might want to stop doing that. Using the descriptor "cis woman" to distinguish yourself from minority ethnic women, LGB women and working class women is placing yourself as the default woman - straight, white, middle class. You're no more a standard female than I am as a black woman, or any other female from a minority or disadvantaged background is.

You also might also find it beneficial to expand your "circles".

I phrased my original post poorly, and am sorry that offended people. I should have said I use it as as part of a longer phrase like “straight cisgendered middle class white woman” to say I am aware I have many types of privilege which means my experience of discrimination differs from that of women who experience multiple layers of discrimination. This is of course exactly because I conform more closely to what some narrow minded and sexist/racist/classist people might consider a “default” or “standard” woman. I agree with you that such thinking is offensive and discriminatory. I’m sorry my original post caused such offence.

CremeEggQueen · 03/05/2023 09:44

I’ve never come across the idea that ”cis” is an insult until I read the MN guidelines . in my circles I and many women I know use it to describe ourselves

I literally have never come across it in RL, only online like here.

CremeEggQueen · 03/05/2023 09:42

You’re not giving up anything by allowing someone else to live their life. You don’t have to become a ciswoman either - it’s just a term used to differentiate when it’s needed and transwomen are not becoming the default women
Exactly

LateAF · 03/05/2023 09:38

Daffidale · 02/05/2023 21:05

I’ve never come across the idea that ”cis” is an insult until I read the MN guidelines . in my circles I and many women I know use it to describe ourselves . I especially use it when discussing my own lived experience of discrimination and how that is different from the lived experience of discrimination other women have - such as women of colour, LGBTQ+ , working class women etc

You may not like the term yourself. If so you are entitled to ask other people not to use it to describe you and to have that request respected. In the same way a trans woman is entitled to ask people to refer to her just as a “woman”. It goes both ways.

but agree with others. that Michael bloke comes across as a right t**t.

in my circles I and many women I know use it to describe ourselves . I especially use it when discussing my own lived experience of discrimination and how that is different from the lived experience of discrimination other women have - such as women of colour, LGBTQ+ , working class women etc

You might want to stop doing that. Using the descriptor "cis woman" to distinguish yourself from minority ethnic women, LGB women and working class women is placing yourself as the default woman - straight, white, middle class. You're no more a standard female than I am as a black woman, or any other female from a minority or disadvantaged background is.

You also might also find it beneficial to expand your "circles".

lifeturnsonadime · 03/05/2023 09:25

You’re not giving up anything by allowing someone else to live their life.

If only. But your version of allowing someone else to live their life has led to -

-Male Rapists in women's prisons

-Males competing and sometimes winning in women's sports (effectively making women's categories redundant)

-Males winning women of the year awards

-Males heading up rape crisis centre telling women who don't want to be in contact with any male to reframe her trauma.

-Lesbians being called bigoted for refusing males in their dating pool.

-Girls not having access to single sex toilets in school

-Girl Guiding and other female only organisations being mix sexed

-Disabled women not being able to request single sex intimate care without fear of being accused of 'bigotry'.

So what you really mean is that males should live exactly as they want and women should ignore the fact that this impinges on our rights and freedoms.

No Thank You.

RandomGeocache · 03/05/2023 09:22

I'd be really insulted by "cis" too.

But I wouldn't get into an argument with a randomer online. Life's too short.

lifeturnsonadime · 03/05/2023 09:19

Who in earth would be attracted to and interested in having sex with someone they knowdoesn't want to have sex with them?

Well quite, there is a word for that isn't there?

And while we are on the subject of consent why are you @CremeEggQueen constantly ignoring the fact that this has been imposed on women without consent. Women haven't consented to be a sub category of our own sex class. Women, mostly, haven't consented to males in our single sex spaces. Female prisoners certainly haven't consented to being incarcerated with males who might rape them.

So if consent is so important to you, why does the informed consent of women matter so little? It only makes sense if you recognise that you know who the women are. It's clear that male privilege is at play here. Crystal clear.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/05/2023 08:55

CremeEggQueen · 03/05/2023 08:16

Just like I'm not any less straight just because some people are in a relationship with trans men right now.

Changing what words mean doesn't change individuals' reality, no.

It can, however, make it harder to name and describe that reality. And in the case of a reality that is historically marginalised and disempowered, for which I'm sure you are thankful that straight is not, losing the words to name ones reality is an act of political disempowerment and social negatation.

Being attracted to people of either sex with a different gender presentational you is valid. Being attracted to only the opposite sex as yourself is valid. There is no reason whatsoever these two things need to have the same name and it lessens our acceptance and understanding of people's real lives and real attractions, and creates needless hurt and conflict, to insist they must.

AudibleEyeroll · 03/05/2023 08:49

HostessTrolley · 03/05/2023 01:32

Why do women have to respect the choices and rights of transwomen, give up the very word woman and become ciswomen, but trans women do not have to respect the right of women to be, well, women?

I am a default woman. I am not going to be a ciswoman so that a transwoman can be the default woman.

I am happy to share the 'female space' with people who genuinely feel misgendered, and are not acting out some fetish. Most of the people in this situation just want to quietly get on with their lives. I am not happy to vacate the 'female space' to facilitate the choice of a few men.

You’re not giving up anything by allowing someone else to live their life. You don’t have to become a ciswoman either - it’s just a term used to differentiate when it’s needed and transwomen are not becoming the default women. I don’t think wanting your identity represented is a fetish either - but the people obsessed with the labels and terminology are rarely transwomen in my experience anyway.

Male101 · 03/05/2023 08:41

The term cisman is used often but nowhere near as often as ciswoman. I think it mainly due to most discussions being about trans woman.

You shouldnt have to prefix the norm. Nobody has an issue with the term transwoman . Except that's not good enough for some tranwoman they would rather just be called woman .

I truly believe most transwoman just want to live a life , with their head down and get on with it.

But theres an extremely loud minority that dont want to do that .

CremeEggQueen · 03/05/2023 08:16

Just like I'm not any less straight just because some people are in a relationship with trans men right now.

CremeEggQueen · 03/05/2023 08:14

And yes, consent. Important that. Rather odd you consider it so given that you're suggesting that same-sex attracted women have heterosexual sex with a trans woman (we know that the vast majority are penis havers)
Some do want to though.
If you don't want to, then don't.
I just don't get why some people care so much about what others do with their consenting sex life.
If you're a lesbian, then you still are regardless of what others are or aren't doing.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/05/2023 07:12

JenniferBarkley · 03/05/2023 06:58

Everyone uses woman. On the very rare occasion a distinction is needed, cis- or transwoman are used as appropriate.

"Eeveryone" does not do that, no. Only people who subscribe to the belief that womanhood is a type of thinking that is found in either sex.

If one finds that belief wrong and offensive, and does not accept being redefined as a person with a "womanny mind" to "match" her female body, trans women are not "just another type of woman" in the first place so the need to make a distinction doesn't arise.

PSNonsense · 03/05/2023 07:08

aperolspritzbasicbitch · 03/05/2023 06:41

Sorry, very new to this discussion -

Is the idea that the terms cis woman and trans woman are both used, or do trans woman use 'woman' and we use 'cis woman'?

Cis is not needed. Full stop. Woman, and transwoman, are just fine.