Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Locksmith quoted £50 and charged £351.60

293 replies

Squeezed1 · 02/05/2023 18:06

I got locked out of my new flat today. My autistic son opened the door and made a run for it, I ran out after him and the door shut behind me.

My landlady couldn't find her copy of the key (she has dozens of keys due to her actual job - but she has some pretty serious health problems, so I felt terrible bothering her with it in the first place)

I looked online and found a locksmith company that will come and pick the lock and let you in for £50. Happy days. No pressure on my landlady. She was happy for me to proceed and said ofc the £50 would come off my rent.

Locksmith came and had a 2 second fiddle with the lock and said he couldn't pick that type of lock (standard yale) so he'd have to drill through and replace the lock otherwise I wasn't getting in the flat. I had my 3 kids with me.

He wanted payment there and then and said I'd have to recoup the £ from my Landlady. I asked for the total £351.60

I had no choice but to pay it.

I feel a bit conned. Is this the norm? To advertise a service at a reasonable price and then turn up and quadruple it?

My bank account is pretty much empty now and whilst I'm sure my Landlady will get the money to me somehow, she has said as much and she's a really nice person so wouldn't not help me, it all feels pretty shit.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
EsmeSusanOgg · 02/05/2023 19:31

Oh OP, this is quite a notroious scam move. Advertise and quote a reasonable fee and then charge something excessive. A reputable locksmith would likely have been closer to £150 (and quoted that). Report this dodgy company to Trading Standards.

lilkimm500 · 02/05/2023 19:31

That as well, I agree, its a total racket.

Qilin · 02/05/2023 19:31

As a comparison - we had an issue in the house whilst we were away. Got a family member to go to the house to meet an emergency locksmith on a Sunday evening. He had to spend ages breaking our old lock - which was one of the secure ones so not able to pick and not just a case of drilling through it either. He then changed the lock for another very secure lock. They were there well over an hour or so on a Sunday, out of hours.

We paid slightly over £200 for a much bigger job, involving much tricky and secure locks.

ShowUs · 02/05/2023 19:31

These people need to be arrested.
Surely coning people is a crime!

If I went and robbed someone on the street I would be arrested and this is no different.

I personally would have waited for the landlady to find the spare key but it’s understandable why you’d just rather pay the £50 to get inside with your kids.

This man should be ashamed of himself preying on people who are feeling vulnerable.

Againstmachine · 02/05/2023 19:31

JulianCasa · 02/05/2023 19:12

Because they can’t pick your lock if it’s a Yale lock. So they have to break it completely and replace it which costs a lot more £££. The newer locks on composite doors can be picked more easily, they aren’t as secure.
This exact thing happened to us about 3 years ago. It cost £250 then but that’s the last 3 years for you.

A Yale lock isn't even a proper lock it is just a nightlatch to stop door being opened by random, I hope you also have a mortice lock on the door.

They are most basic thing available and easy to pick and even if not a replacement is about 6-7 quid cost price for the smith to buy.

Guy is pure rip off merchant

ElfAndSafetyBored · 02/05/2023 19:29

I think you’ve got a rogue locksmith. This is a happened to my MIL too. I think she paid well over £400. I’m really sorry it happened to you.

Our door wouldn’t unlock, it cost me £108 in total (inc VAT) and the locksmith was with me within 2 hours. Had to replace a specific bit in the lock. We’re in London.

Toomanylatenightprogs · 02/05/2023 19:28

Squeezed1 · 02/05/2023 18:11

She asked me to get an invoice with her name on it. I'd already paid it so the invoice has my name on. I sent her the invoice to show I'd paid for it and she said she's going to get the money back to me. I didn't actually ask her to pay for it but paying for it has left me skint.

Expensive lesson learned 😔

That’s really kind of your landlady, maybe worth a bunch of flowers or box of chocolates as she not obligated to refund you.
As a pp said, get copies made of the keys and leave with a couple of trusted friends or even invest in a key safe.
These things happen, I locked myself out first week in new house, had to break a window. I got a key safe fitted after that.

YouCould · 02/05/2023 19:28

I know it's too late for you OP but this is a useful guide to spotting rogue locksmiths. HERE

Here is a bbc article about a mega rogue locksmith who was sent to prison.

largeprintagathachristie · 02/05/2023 19:27

OMG - in the reviews they’ve scammed an 80 year old who was saving for a mobility scooter- charged them over a thousand quid.

Qilin · 02/05/2023 19:27

lilkimm500 · 02/05/2023 19:24

He turned up, saw it was more than a quick job, so upped the price. Either you refuse and he doesn’t do it and gets away or he does it, its a pain in the arse but he makes a decent profit. Standard for any trade, when the quote or cost is high or unreasonable its because they don’t want or need to do the work - if you pay that price it takes the sting out of the hassle of doing it, 9 times out of 10 they will be hoping you decline.

I looked at becoming a locksmith because it seemed like a license to print money. Spoke to one and he said the only way to make a decent living from it is to work 24/7 as most jobs come in from the evenings throughout the night - which sounds like a young persons game, and not mine.

Based on the reviews this person is doing something that it is now 'standard' for the profession. It seems like they are going around making more than a bit of profit by scamming vulnerable customers.

OP - hope the bank and the disputes team can help. Don't forget to add to the reviews and follow up the complaint links listed.

Doris86 · 02/05/2023 19:27

£351 for a few minutes work drilling out a lock, and slotting in a standard replacement part, which probably cost him an absolute max of £40?

I’m in the wrong job, and yes you were conned.

Element4056 · 02/05/2023 19:27

When I managed to lock myself out of my flat, the locksmith I found online charged me £60. He arrived and fiddled with the lock for maybe 10 minutes, so luckily no drilling or anything required. I was let in and only paid the £60 quoted. Sorry OP, it must have been a stressful situation with three kids locked out.

Mummyoflittledragon · 02/05/2023 19:26

Legally (I believe) you should also have received a written quote for the work. And if you look at the bill, it said the lock was faulty. It wasn’t faulty. He broke it by drilling through the lock. Did he tell you before he did this so you could give him permission to do so op?

Florenz · 02/05/2023 19:25

£50 is unrealistic but £351 is ridiculous. I'd have expected it to cost £100-200.

lilkimm500 · 02/05/2023 19:24

He turned up, saw it was more than a quick job, so upped the price. Either you refuse and he doesn’t do it and gets away or he does it, its a pain in the arse but he makes a decent profit. Standard for any trade, when the quote or cost is high or unreasonable its because they don’t want or need to do the work - if you pay that price it takes the sting out of the hassle of doing it, 9 times out of 10 they will be hoping you decline.

I looked at becoming a locksmith because it seemed like a license to print money. Spoke to one and he said the only way to make a decent living from it is to work 24/7 as most jobs come in from the evenings throughout the night - which sounds like a young persons game, and not mine.

Florenz · 02/05/2023 19:24

Having a yale lock on the door probably isn't a good idea OP, you'd be better with one that doesn't lock when the door closes behind you.

KTheGrey · 02/05/2023 19:23

Is there no office of fair trading nowadays? Because this is really shocking.

And the landlady should hold a spare key. What if she has to access the property for emergency repairs?

Squeezed1 · 02/05/2023 19:23

I've spoken to my bank. They've told me to dispute the transaction once the money has left my account (still pending atm) and to provide the disputes team with my account of what's happened and the link to those reviews.

She couldn't tell me whether I'll get my money back as that's not her remit and it'll be dealt with my disputes.

I'll have to keep checking my bank to see when it leaves my account, they have until the 10th of May apparently. I'm not even sure how it works I assumed it would clear for them straight away.

OP posts:
GasPanic · 02/05/2023 19:23

JulianCasa · 02/05/2023 19:12

Because they can’t pick your lock if it’s a Yale lock. So they have to break it completely and replace it which costs a lot more £££. The newer locks on composite doors can be picked more easily, they aren’t as secure.
This exact thing happened to us about 3 years ago. It cost £250 then but that’s the last 3 years for you.

Only if you get the crap ones.

I've got Ultion and ATS on my composite doors. They can be picked (you can see people do it on youtube) but its incredibly difficult, much more difficult than a yale. I've been warned that if I lock myself out it's going to be a serious job to get in because I haven't got thumbturns on them either.

First thing I did after fitting them was lodge an emergency key with a close relative.

Dibbydoos · 02/05/2023 19:21

Glad your LL is being so reasonable, OP.

The locking might be £50 to pick tge lock, drilling and replacing barrels is def a big add on cost. But that price is pretty pricey imo. Did they know your LL was paying?
She can write it off against her outfits soits not a full £350 quid to her, but still what a rip off. I'd have expected £150 if I'm honest.

Maybe we should all retrain as locksmiths. £350 for a 20mins job, lol!!

pleasehelpwi3 · 02/05/2023 19:21

Did you pay by credit card? Do a chargeback if so.

YouCould · 02/05/2023 19:20

OP, Make sure you make it clear to your bank that you did not agree to the price beforehand and that you felt intimidated when you paid. There is law against charging crazy high prices for things so you really need to emphasize that you didn't agree to it and that you've reported it to Action fraud.

I'm not an expert in this so it would be good to get others views on it.

Frabbits · 02/05/2023 19:20

Sounds like a scam.

Yale locks are not hard to pick. I got a lockpicking set for Christmas and one of the dummy locks is a Yale, I learnt to pick it in about 30 minutes.

HeckyPeck · 02/05/2023 19:19

FrippEnos · 02/05/2023 19:10

For those praising the LL.
She was supposed to be holding a spare key which she has mislaid.

Yes she sounds decent but if she hadn't mislaid the key the locksmith wouldn't have been required.

just FYI my ex LL charged £30 to come out with the spare as have several agencies.

That's exactly what I was thinking!

Qilin · 02/05/2023 19:19

It does seem expensive for what was needed. That and the dodgy reviews - may be worth following up and/or getting landlady too as well.