Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Locksmith quoted £50 and charged £351.60

293 replies

Squeezed1 · 02/05/2023 18:06

I got locked out of my new flat today. My autistic son opened the door and made a run for it, I ran out after him and the door shut behind me.

My landlady couldn't find her copy of the key (she has dozens of keys due to her actual job - but she has some pretty serious health problems, so I felt terrible bothering her with it in the first place)

I looked online and found a locksmith company that will come and pick the lock and let you in for £50. Happy days. No pressure on my landlady. She was happy for me to proceed and said ofc the £50 would come off my rent.

Locksmith came and had a 2 second fiddle with the lock and said he couldn't pick that type of lock (standard yale) so he'd have to drill through and replace the lock otherwise I wasn't getting in the flat. I had my 3 kids with me.

He wanted payment there and then and said I'd have to recoup the £ from my Landlady. I asked for the total £351.60

I had no choice but to pay it.

I feel a bit conned. Is this the norm? To advertise a service at a reasonable price and then turn up and quadruple it?

My bank account is pretty much empty now and whilst I'm sure my Landlady will get the money to me somehow, she has said as much and she's a really nice person so wouldn't not help me, it all feels pretty shit.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
potatohead1 · 03/05/2023 07:16

Reallyareyousure · 02/05/2023 18:08

Why would your landlady pay for it? It's absolutely nothing to do with her. You can't even ask her.

Because had the LL not lost her copy there wouldn't be a problem

YouCould · 03/05/2023 00:58

S0upertrooper · 02/05/2023 22:31

@Squeezed1 I haven't made any snipes, everything I've said is fact. The only part that is my opinion is that I think you are immature and naive, which I stand by.

You seem to think it's ok to put this guy's info on a public forum (he's clearly trouble and knows where you live). I'd say that's naive and potentially puts you and your children in danger.

Even if you believe your post to be true what is the purpose of you posting it. You could have just suggested removing the photo if you had wanted to be helpful but for some reason you wanted to hurt the OP and make her more upset? Why would you do that? It's a weird and pathetic thing to do. I presume you get a kick out of it or you wouldn't have doubled down on your snide comments.

NoSquirrels · 02/05/2023 23:25

I didn't realise they'd already been investigated! How on earth are they still in business?

OP, do not feel bad. Similar thing happened to us in London years ago in a rented property, with a spammy plumbing company. Pressured to pay and left to explain the sorry affair to the landlady.

Once we realised, I checked the website my DH had googled. There was a Trading Standards warning notice displayed, saying this business was linked to a banned business - but, crucially, so low down the hierarchy on the page it wouldn’t be seen unless you scrolled and scrolled and scrolled.

We reported them to Trading Standards again, and they confirmed they had them under investigation in this name etc.

It was just one of those (fucking awful at the time) things. Do report them.

Mirabai · 02/05/2023 23:23

*potentially necessary = potentially un-necessary.

Doris86 · 02/05/2023 23:19

Mirabai · 02/05/2023 21:06

This is a standard cost OP. It’s £50+ VAT call out (that’s actually cheap). If they can open it ok, but if not they have to replace the whole lock and front door locks are really expensive. If they replace your lock with a cheap one that’s easily pickable and you get burgled - that’s no benefit to you.

The locksmith has replaced the lock with a cheap one, that can be bought for £15 on E bay. Then he has charged £351 for it - along with the 10 mins work to drill out and and replace the lock.

ChocChipHandbag · 02/05/2023 23:19

CC4712 · 02/05/2023 21:28

He took the old key and snapped it in half in the lock

What old key??? You ran outside WITHOUT the key, so what key did he shove in the lock and snap off??? This makes no sense.

He shoved it in the lock and snapped it off after he drilled it out and let her in.

Mirabai · 02/05/2023 23:18

OnlyFannys · 02/05/2023 22:05

But that would be assuming that the locksmith was being honest that the lock needed to be changed, the reviews show that this is the tactic they use on every customer by lying and saying it cannot be picked after initially quoting for picking it so I dont agree that any of the charges are fair.

Sure, but none of this is the bank’s problem. If the company can show that the Labour was done and the lock changed, neither of which the OP is disputing, then OP will be expected to pay for that. Simply being overcharged by a scammy company for work that it’s potentially necessary - the bank will not refund for that.

Disputed transactions refund if the transaction itself is fraudulent or the goods or service paid for were not received.

OP would have to take it up with the company and argue it out in the small claims court.

ChocChipHandbag · 02/05/2023 23:07

Sadly he was just mentioning insurance so you were conned into accepting the charge, thinking that it was all recoverable anyway. In reality, (even for a valid claim) there would be an excess on the insurance, so the landlady would at best have to pay about £100 of the charge, quite possibly the whole thing. At worst she's get done for insurance fraud.

ladyofshertonabbas · 02/05/2023 23:05

That is really high. We paid £97 for emergency call out and new locks last year. (South west England). This was 5.30 on a Friday.

ChocChipHandbag · 02/05/2023 23:01

lilkimm500 · 02/05/2023 19:24

He turned up, saw it was more than a quick job, so upped the price. Either you refuse and he doesn’t do it and gets away or he does it, its a pain in the arse but he makes a decent profit. Standard for any trade, when the quote or cost is high or unreasonable its because they don’t want or need to do the work - if you pay that price it takes the sting out of the hassle of doing it, 9 times out of 10 they will be hoping you decline.

I looked at becoming a locksmith because it seemed like a license to print money. Spoke to one and he said the only way to make a decent living from it is to work 24/7 as most jobs come in from the evenings throughout the night - which sounds like a young persons game, and not mine.

That theory unfortunately falls down if you read OP's posts properly and see that he only told her it was £350 AFTER he'd drilled it out.

ChocChipHandbag · 02/05/2023 22:58

Stopthatknocking · 02/05/2023 19:12

He charged you £249 for drilling the lock and £49 for labour? What is drilling the lock if not labour?

But I can understand why you paid, with a child with autism you just need to get it sorted and calm the situation.
I hope you can get some of this refunded.
Good luck.

I was just coming on to say that -drilling out the lock IS labour.

Ans you can see he's put (faulty lock) in brackets as a "helpful" way to justify your landlady paying/claiming her insurance.

You were a sitting duck OP, so sorry this happened to you. Hope you can get a credit card charge back.

Squeezed1 · 02/05/2023 22:36

S0upertrooper · 02/05/2023 22:31

@Squeezed1 I haven't made any snipes, everything I've said is fact. The only part that is my opinion is that I think you are immature and naive, which I stand by.

You seem to think it's ok to put this guy's info on a public forum (he's clearly trouble and knows where you live). I'd say that's naive and potentially puts you and your children in danger.

You know exactly what you were doing and so does everybody else. You were sticking the boot in. I'm not sure why you felt now was a good time to do that as you can see from my posts I'm upset. I can only conclude you wanted to make me feel worse.

You haven't succeeded btw. I have a 'mumsnet thick skin' after years on the website rolling my eyes at people like you.

I do hope you're less hard faced to those around you IRL.

So yes do better, which I stand by.

OP posts:
S0upertrooper · 02/05/2023 22:31

@Squeezed1 I haven't made any snipes, everything I've said is fact. The only part that is my opinion is that I think you are immature and naive, which I stand by.

You seem to think it's ok to put this guy's info on a public forum (he's clearly trouble and knows where you live). I'd say that's naive and potentially puts you and your children in danger.

Squeezed1 · 02/05/2023 22:31

I really appreciate all of the advice and posts thank you. It can only help my case that it's a recognised scam, even if the bank do think I've been naive and immature (like the delightful poster on the last page suggested) they'll be able to see that they have form for doing the same, and worse.

OP posts:
Peterpiperpickedapeckof · 02/05/2023 22:30

I got ripped off in exactly the same way once. Feels awful doesn’t it?

Squeezed1 · 02/05/2023 22:27

I don't expect the landlady to pay, atleast not now that I'm aware she (probably?) isn't responsible for the changing of the locks at the property whilst I'm a tenant.

I thought that was a landlords responsibility, I can see I may have been wrong.

I'm going to attempt to get my money back through my bank and hope for the best but I don't know how long I'll be waiting. The scammers have until 10th of this month for my £351 to clear and then the disputes department at my bank have another 10 days to look at the claim so I'm fucked for now either way 😔

OP posts:
Advicerequest · 02/05/2023 22:24

Btw - this isn't just 'one man' - there are a large network of 'locksmiths' working for these interlinked companies.
anyone can pay for the locksmith training' which is presented as if it's a legitimate training programme in London but appears to be linked to the scam.
fyi they'll 'locksmiths' rock up in unmarked cars (ie no logo). Could be Uber drivers with rubbish vehicles. The locksmith who came round to my flat was also Eastern European.

also the 24/7 adds flood the Google results and appear as region specific
not sure how they game that but it's hard to find even consumer action stories about them as they are buried past the ads

thse locksmiths also game Google and Facebook reviews. Only trust pilot tells the truth. the scam is modelled on a long established IS scam.

1Raisedeyebrow · 02/05/2023 22:21

It’s a lesson learned for both you and you the landlord. You’re blessed to have a landlord that is willing to accept her responsibility by not having the spare available. It’s shitty but at least you are all safe at home.

If the landlord does pay maybe offer to pay half or all of the cost (if your budget can stretch it) over x amount of months if you feel this would help you feel better about the incident.

SomePig · 02/05/2023 22:20

This locksmith scam operates worldwide. Here's an article from the New York Times which shows how they manipulate Google Maps results so that they look legitimate (and also local), but aren't: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/31/business/fake-online-locksmiths-may-be-out-to-pick-your-pocket-too.html.

There's also a good episode of the (now defunct) podcast Reply All about this, which is even called 'Very Quickly To the Drill': https://gimletmedia.com/shows/reply-all/o2ho87

Sorry this has happened to you OP Flowers

#78 Very Quickly to the Drill | Reply All

Alex and PJ chase down the strangest scams from our Weird Ads tip line.

https://gimletmedia.com/shows/reply-all/o2ho87

YouCould · 02/05/2023 22:19

@WombatChocolate The OP isn't asking if the landlord should pay. The landlord offered and the OP hasn't realised that was unusual.

Mossstitch · 02/05/2023 22:19

You've been scammed! You can get your bank to reclaim the money. My son had an incident with plumbing leak few months ago, called someone out who made a large hole in his wall, told him he was going to get some copper pipe, got him to sign a piece of paper as he left and never came back. £200 went out of his bank account but his bank claimed it back when he contacted them. He got another plumber in on recommendation from someone I knew who cured the problem for £60.

WombatChocolate · 02/05/2023 22:12

Surely we can agree that OP has been scammed. The company are doing it constantly.

The real question is about whether it is reasonable to ask/expect/allow the LL to pay the cost of the scam.

I don’t think it is reasonable. That scam that OP fell for could have been £1k. It could have been £2k or £5k. Would anyone be suggesting the LL should pay?

We are all sorry for OP. We are all angry with the scammers. However, when you get scammed, you often do bear the cost yourself….it can’t always be passed onto someone else. The LL is not responsible for a limitless bill.

RJ2023 · 02/05/2023 22:07

I feel really sorry for you - I had a similar scenario a couple of years ago where an "emergency electrician" ripped me off for hundreds of pounds when I was desperate... :(

I will never trust the top results that Google provides ever again!

I am probably being naive but is there any way that you can contact Google / other search engines to ensure that company aren't popping up at the top of their search results again using the evidence in this thread? That would do so much more damage to their business than anything else you could do.

Sorry again that this happened to you. :(

OnlyFannys · 02/05/2023 22:05

Mirabai · 02/05/2023 21:58

The charges on the invoice - £95 for a lock and £49 for Labour is fair enough regardless of nature of the firm.

If OP had been charged and no-one showed up that’s easy enough to dispute the transaction.

But that would be assuming that the locksmith was being honest that the lock needed to be changed, the reviews show that this is the tactic they use on every customer by lying and saying it cannot be picked after initially quoting for picking it so I dont agree that any of the charges are fair.

ElfAndSafetyBored · 02/05/2023 22:05

I just checked and it’s the same ‘company’ my MIL used. He actually charged her £566 (inc VAT).
£189 for the lock and 5 keys
£189 to drill out the old lock
£49 lock change labour
£45 call out fee
£94 VAT.

They should be stopped. She wouldn’t let us complain to trading standards though.