Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not support stepchild moving in?

832 replies

Fizzy196 · 02/05/2023 12:28

DSS is 12 and has decided he wants to spend more time with us rather than at his mums. DH and his ex seem to have agreed between themselves that as he's getting older he can do as he pleases.

The reason for this, we all know, is because he gets away with a lot more here and has a better set up in his room than at his mums (shares there and no TV in the room whereas he doesn't here and has TV in there which DH lets him use far too much imo but that's not my business).

Me and DH have basically come to a big of loggerheads about this as I work part time and as a result have fallen into the trap of basically doing everything for all the children at home (mine and DHs and DSC). I cook, clean, wash clothes, even take him to school 90% of the time. This is something that winds me up and we have argued about before and I have started to resent having DSC as time as gone on as I feel like a lot is placed on me. He already lives here 50% of the time and I think this is enough especially as there are no serious reasons why he cannot continue to stay at his mums for the other half of the week.

I know full well if he moves in it will just mean even more work for me and I'm basically saying it's not happening. My children are below school age at the moment and I already do more school runs than I'd like to (and have for years), don't ask why he can't make his own way to school yet this is another issue! SS is waited on hand and foot when here and I'm a bit sick of it already, never mind it being even more constant.

I've told DH if he moves in, everything will be up to him. School runs, taking to and from mates, hobbies, school holidays, clothes washing, bed stripping etc..

He thinks I'm unreasonable as I work part time and should support his son moving in (by doing more than his own parents will be!). I've said no.

DH can't, with his work, do what it is he wants me to do i.e. school runs, holiday cover, general running about, so basically SS can't come more often.

OP posts:
ItsCalledAConversation · 02/05/2023 17:24

JenniferBooth · 02/05/2023 14:50

@ItsCalledAConversation I asked whether YOU THOUGHT Child Support should be reduced. You dont have to be an expert to have an opinion
However I already have my answer. Your obfuscation made it clear!

@JenniferBooth honestly not sure what’s going on here! It feels rather like you’re having a conversation with yourself. Obv I’ve not been able to answer your questions, sorry.

Mumsanetta · 02/05/2023 17:23

There is a workable solution here. It just takes communication and a willingness. You don't seem willing to be honest.

@Callyem by should she be willing given how it’s been handled? And why is your comment focussed on the OP and not on her DH who has tried to make a unilateral decision without discussing with OP first when she is the one who will be impacted by it? You seem to be requiring a much higher standard of behaviour from OP than from her DH.

RafaistheKingofClay · 02/05/2023 17:23

BlackeyedSusan · 02/05/2023 17:10

We'll, he might not like how yours is run either if he has to get himself to school! And contribute more to running it. Problem solved.

I’m fairly surprised that most people seem to be ok with their 12 year old moving out because they don’t like the boundary of a reasonable house rule.

But I suppose it’ll be a reasonable test of decisions having consequences as long as the OP sticks to not picking up all the extra slack.

Callyem · 02/05/2023 17:20

The problem is the way it is being handled. Your DP agreeing and assuming you'll take on the work and you throwing your toys out your pram instead of discussing a workable arrangment.

DSS should be taking himself to and from school and keeping his room tidy, including stripping the beds.
The extra washing will be minimal.
Cooking for 1 extra will be minimal.

There is a workable solution here. It just takes communication and a willingness. You don't seem willing to be honest.

HadalyEve · 02/05/2023 17:16

I’d love to hear the step-sons reasons for wanting to live with his dad full time. I doubt he would say it’s because he can have a TV as the OP seems fixated on.

It’s as common for boys to want to live with their dad as they reach the teen years, as it is common for girls to want to live with their mum as they reach the teen years. It’s embarrassing enough being a teen without having to go to someone of the opposite sex on advice about puberty and adulthood.

I think your own bedroom which OP also mentioned is a likely factor but then it is well known that having a private space at this age is good not only for teen mental health but also for their academic achievement as they have a place to study for GCSEs and A levels.

OP says her house is better run, and I do believe her. Perhaps she is underestimating the negative impact of a chaotic house on children?

It seems like it would be the best thing for the step-son to live with his dad, and I can’t help but feel that the OPs ultimatum approach of “ok, but I’m not lifting a finger” is really a “not a chance in hell” reaction.

I think as he’s already there 50% of the time that the wrinkles could be worked out? She makes a good point that he should be able to walk to/from school. I think that is perfectly reasonable. As cleaning/laundry/washing up will increase, why not assign him a few household chores to do? 12 is a good age to take over washing dishes and learning to wash your own clothes for example.

Perhaps a discussion with OP taking the position of “how can we make this work for everyone” approach would not have them at loggerheads?

wildlifeintegration · 02/05/2023 17:16

Fizzy196 · 02/05/2023 13:58

Why is it odd? I'm not talking about my other DSC. They aren't the one asking to move in..

She did. she said on the op that the kid shares a room at home mums so he wants to move to his dads to have his own room with a TV full time.

Sure the kid could be sharing with a separate child that's not ops hisbamds but she did mention another child. It's not weird it's just a post on mumsnet and the other child wants to stay put, so isn't a huge part of this story

Bansheed · 02/05/2023 17:15

Why not take a step back a d think about the ways you anticipate a 12 year old contributing at home? Beds washing,, dishwasher etc. And make sure your DCs do the same when they are older. Work around what you have.

cooldarkroom · 02/05/2023 17:15

I would not agree either, both kids are too young to quit living primarily with their Mum.
They will then have their own rooms, one will have TV, the other wont.
This is dividing the two brothers.
You did not sign up for bringing up another child whilst the real parents sit back & make the rules.
I would also not be taking them to school
I would remove the TV.
I would not be a nanny to SC throughout the holidays
You are not their unpaid servant

Nordicrain · 02/05/2023 17:12

Fizzy196 · 02/05/2023 13:01

I already do live with him half the week, and I practically do everything for him during that time.

I'm just saying I'm not going to do it all the time. Not for such a trivial reason.

To be those are two different things. Saying cannot move in would not, in my book, be ok. Saying you are not doing everything if he does is of course ok.

itwasntmetho · 02/05/2023 17:11

People are using the OP working part time like a gotcha, she only works one day less and that makes them as a household better off financially because of childcare costs.

OP would you take your own children to school at that age? because I wouldn't, my ten year old walks home from school a mile away and will use the bus from secondary onwards, like fuck would I ferry someone elses twelve year old around in the name of parenting, parenting is dry running the bus route a couple of times so you know they are confident that they wont miss their stop.

Your DP has won a popularity game for shallow reasons, even if he wasn't deliberately playing one. He will be aware that if that boy isn't kept suitably sweet and in the level of comfort he desires then he will be back to his Mums slagging off your home.

I think you are right and the only adult in the room right now.

BlackeyedSusan · 02/05/2023 17:10

Fizzy196 · 02/05/2023 12:46

I also think it's shit to allow this because of really trivial things. He doesn't like how his mums house (reasonably) is run so he can just decide not to be there.

We'll, he might not like how yours is run either if he has to get himself to school! And contribute more to running it. Problem solved.

Olive19741205 · 02/05/2023 17:09

Agree with this. Are you saying you wont be taking your other children to school? No. So you’re singling out the step son stating that. YABU and worse than that, not a very nice step mum. You should treat all your children the same: biological and ‘step’.

FFS this thread is so frustrating. How can the OP treat the DSC the same as her own when she's not allowed to make decisions. If the DSC was her own, he'd be walking to school by himself...both parents won't have this so it's now being left for OP to facilitate the school run while BOTH parents just don't bother. How on earth can you defend that?

And by the way, I don't treat my DSC the 'same' as my own...because they're not my children. Their 2 parents make the decisions and do the parenting. Why would I try and parent other peoples children? That's just weird and I'm sure DSCs mother would have something to say about it.

RafaistheKingofClay · 02/05/2023 17:09

Oh forgot that. May need to raise a complaint with my mum and stepdad about that though.

DrMarciaFieldstone · 02/05/2023 17:08

RafaistheKingofClay · 02/05/2023 17:04

Are you suggesting that every secondary school child that walks to school is not parented?

Noooo, children whose parents are still together are lucky to have two parents who live together, so they can walk.

DSC’s must be ferried back and forward as they’ve had so much change in their lives, therefore they can’t use their legs.

Aweebitpainful · 02/05/2023 17:05

your OH needs to step up!

RafaistheKingofClay · 02/05/2023 17:04

3BSHKATS · 02/05/2023 16:59

I feel sorry for the kid, 3 adults and nobody wants to parent him.
Life changing decisions like extra siblings pilled into all available spaces, fine but a lift to school is a step too far ?

Are you suggesting that every secondary school child that walks to school is not parented?

Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 02/05/2023 17:04

He is old enough to take responsibility for his own bedroom and bed making and laundry. He is also old enough to get himself to and from school and if for some reason he cannot then his parents need to make the necessary arrangements to do so. If he is coming more then his parents need to facilitate that. Will you be given his child benefit etc towards your increased costs? Or is mummy dearest palming the kid off and keeping the money?

Olive19741205 · 02/05/2023 17:03

adriftabroad · 02/05/2023 16:42

You have a teenage boy about to move in. Your husbands DS. Not much you can do...

Enjoy.

What do you mean "not much you can do"? Can you clarify this please?

aSofaNearYou · 02/05/2023 17:03

Life changing decisions like extra siblings pilled into all available spaces, fine but a lift to school is a step too far ?

Heaven forbid people have their own children rather than focusing on providing services for other people's.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 02/05/2023 17:02

Goldbar · 02/05/2023 16:56

As pp have said, the problem isn't your DSS and whether or not he lives with you. The problem is that you're married to a Disney Dad incapable of saying no and who doesn't value your contribution to the household but views you as a resource at his disposal rather than a person. No one who values another person would volunteer their labour without asking them and checking with them that what is proposed is acceptable. But he's prepared to throw you under the bus rather than be the meany saying no.

Pretty much sums it up.

nopuppiesallowed · 02/05/2023 17:00

Of course the dear stepson is going to prefer a home with his personal TV, but the important thing in this instance is not what he prefers - it's what is good for him and for everyone else in this blended family. I was a truly horrible mum. Our children were not allowed a TV in their rooms until their 16th birthday...and then they had to buy it themselves. We had the usual moans of "but everyone else has one" with the usual good humoured rebuttals. Parents are the adults in families....😏They'll have to work it out in a sensible way by discussing what's best for the child and singing from the same hymn sheet.

3BSHKATS · 02/05/2023 16:59

MoroccanRoseHChurch · 02/05/2023 16:55

I’m sad for this child because his parents are reaching him zero resilience by making huge life changes to facilitate his every wish. Sounds very babied and spoilt indeed.

I feel sorry for the kid, 3 adults and nobody wants to parent him.
Life changing decisions like extra siblings pilled into all available spaces, fine but a lift to school is a step too far ?

RafaistheKingofClay · 02/05/2023 16:56

Oxbridgetitans · 02/05/2023 16:47

Agree with this. Are you saying you wont be taking your other children to school? No. So you’re singling out the step son stating that. YABU and worse than that, not a very nice step mum. You should treat all your children the same: biological and ‘step’.

Her other children are not school age so there is no school run. And by the time they are secondary school age she probably won’t be taking them to a school that is a 20min walk away with no other school drop off because that is unnecessary and they should be doing it by themselves unless there are other reasons for them not to be.

I don’t think this particular decision is about DSC vs DC. The vast majority of children (although possibly not on MN) make their way to secondary school on their own. It’s weirder not to but the parents get to make that decision because they aren’t the ones doing the leg work. It’s not like all the children are similar ages but OP gives hers a lift but leaves DC out.

I think I’d probably stop doing the school run from next year anyway OP. If the parents don’t think they are mature enough for it they’ll need to sort something out themselves. Quite reasonable to say they are too old at this point and not do it.

Dontcallmescarface · 02/05/2023 16:56

Oxbridgetitans · 02/05/2023 16:47

Agree with this. Are you saying you wont be taking your other children to school? No. So you’re singling out the step son stating that. YABU and worse than that, not a very nice step mum. You should treat all your children the same: biological and ‘step’.

The OP clearly states that she does the school run for the SS 90% of the time and is expected to do more because neither of the boy's parents don't want to... but it's the SM who is "not very nice". Righto.

Goldbar · 02/05/2023 16:56

As pp have said, the problem isn't your DSS and whether or not he lives with you. The problem is that you're married to a Disney Dad incapable of saying no and who doesn't value your contribution to the household but views you as a resource at his disposal rather than a person. No one who values another person would volunteer their labour without asking them and checking with them that what is proposed is acceptable. But he's prepared to throw you under the bus rather than be the meany saying no.