Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not support stepchild moving in?

832 replies

Fizzy196 · 02/05/2023 12:28

DSS is 12 and has decided he wants to spend more time with us rather than at his mums. DH and his ex seem to have agreed between themselves that as he's getting older he can do as he pleases.

The reason for this, we all know, is because he gets away with a lot more here and has a better set up in his room than at his mums (shares there and no TV in the room whereas he doesn't here and has TV in there which DH lets him use far too much imo but that's not my business).

Me and DH have basically come to a big of loggerheads about this as I work part time and as a result have fallen into the trap of basically doing everything for all the children at home (mine and DHs and DSC). I cook, clean, wash clothes, even take him to school 90% of the time. This is something that winds me up and we have argued about before and I have started to resent having DSC as time as gone on as I feel like a lot is placed on me. He already lives here 50% of the time and I think this is enough especially as there are no serious reasons why he cannot continue to stay at his mums for the other half of the week.

I know full well if he moves in it will just mean even more work for me and I'm basically saying it's not happening. My children are below school age at the moment and I already do more school runs than I'd like to (and have for years), don't ask why he can't make his own way to school yet this is another issue! SS is waited on hand and foot when here and I'm a bit sick of it already, never mind it being even more constant.

I've told DH if he moves in, everything will be up to him. School runs, taking to and from mates, hobbies, school holidays, clothes washing, bed stripping etc..

He thinks I'm unreasonable as I work part time and should support his son moving in (by doing more than his own parents will be!). I've said no.

DH can't, with his work, do what it is he wants me to do i.e. school runs, holiday cover, general running about, so basically SS can't come more often.

OP posts:
girlfriend44 · 03/05/2023 09:55

Who gets the child benefit that's another messy one.
Who pays Who.if he gers to go joke at weekends.
Needs thinking about.
Who picks him up from school.if he's ill?

How does he get to see his mum will he be gone for weekends, if so less work.
Lots of financial things to take into consideration too.

LookItsMeAgain · 03/05/2023 09:36

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 03/05/2023 07:50

Why do people keep telling the OP to remove the tv?

Her DH has ignored her opinions on it until now and is prepared to let his child move home over no tv at his mothers - he’s not going to back that from the OP.

If he was remotely interested in the kid having any restrictions on tv viewing he’d have put them in place already.

The TV being in the child's bedroom is one of the reasons the child wants to move in with their father and the OP.

By removing the TV, you're removing one 'incentive' for the child to want to move in (or at least seeing if the child genuinely wants to be with their father or not).

There isn't a TV in their room in the house they live with their mother, so this would be something to consider.

Ameanstreakamilewide · 03/05/2023 08:39

The kid's allowed to be told 'no', once in a while.

I don't think it's cricket that he can just pick and choose where he lives, simply because the boy's Mum has some house rules that he doesn't like.
Life is full of rules we don't like, but we can't just walk away from them.

If his parents were still married, the idea of moving out wouldn't even occur to him. Where would he go??
So, I don't see how it's any different, now?

I do wonder how his Mum feels about this. Hopefully the OP has a half decent relationship with the boy's mum, so she can speak to her about it.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 03/05/2023 07:50

Why do people keep telling the OP to remove the tv?

Her DH has ignored her opinions on it until now and is prepared to let his child move home over no tv at his mothers - he’s not going to back that from the OP.

If he was remotely interested in the kid having any restrictions on tv viewing he’d have put them in place already.

frazzledasarock · 03/05/2023 07:45

Take the tv out of his bedroom. Make up lists of chores the DSC have to do, eg strip beds, do their own laundry, keep their rooms clean. Etc

tell your H DSS can take himself to school in the morning and the hobby run can be split between H & XW. You know the parents of the child.

Absolutely don’t use up your annual leave to babysit DSC. That’s on their parents also.

if the parents want to baby their 12 & 13 year olds they can. You don’t have to put yourself out.

once the parents actually find themselves having to parent, they might suddenly find they’re a lot less inclined to baby their kids. Having to actually do the drudge work yourself tends to suddenly make people realise they don’t really mind their darlings doing picking up after themselves.

Northernsouloldies · 03/05/2023 06:42

Fizzy196 · 02/05/2023 12:39

If he wanted to come because his mother was a monster that is different. Because he doesn't want to share a bedroom is not the same.

Cushyier life at dad's, own room etc and his mum stricter than dad. That will be real reasons for wanting to stay at dad's. We had a neighbour her child was put to stay with relatives, she had the child back at 14 and it was down to not liking to be told what to do. After not having the child for ten years the first week in child came back drunk. My neighbour said to me laughing what can you do. Child should have been made to stay with relatives.

FeliciteFaff · 03/05/2023 06:00

OP I totally agree. It’s lazy parenting on their behalf. So what if you work PT. Their child is their FT job not yours. Having said that I would remove that TV from his room and see how long it lasts. Secondly people guilting you into step parenthood are pretty shite. Step kids are the responsibility of the parent and you only become more involved if you want to. Absolutely shocking responses here and from your DH.

HollyBerri · 03/05/2023 05:49

apart from the school run how much extra work is actually involved? You are cooking / cleaning/ washing etc for other dcs so 1 more won’t make much difference. Could you get a cleaner to make life a bit easier?
I would cut back on the school run though. He is is old enough to make his own way there or you other half can make arrangements.
This is from experience of step dc coming to love with us at a similar age.
it does sound a bit to me like you are creating barriers.

MsRosley · 03/05/2023 05:12

Aside from anything else - and I do agree with you, OP - this kid's behaviour is really hurtful and insulting to his mother. He shouldn't be allowed to opt out of living with her on a whim, because he's not old enough to understand the impact on her or himself.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 03/05/2023 04:48

Blueblell · 03/05/2023 04:36

You could argue that if his mum isn’t happy for him to a tv in his room at her house why is she happy for him to have it in his room at your house?

of course you shouldn’t be left with all the extra work and he would have to live by your rules in your house so you should definitely set out your boundaries regarding walking to school ect.

Who says the Mum is happy for him to have a Tv?

It’s highly unlikely that she is, given that she’s not backed down despite the threat of him moving out.

The OP doesn’t approve of the tv either, but her DH allows it. If he doesn’t agree, or have any compromise with his current wife the chances of him listening to his ex is tiny.

Blueblell · 03/05/2023 04:36

You could argue that if his mum isn’t happy for him to a tv in his room at her house why is she happy for him to have it in his room at your house?

of course you shouldn’t be left with all the extra work and he would have to live by your rules in your house so you should definitely set out your boundaries regarding walking to school ect.

Liorae · 03/05/2023 02:57

Why won't DH remove the TV from his son's room? Is there a competition between him and his exwife?
There usually is one.

Nanaof1 · 03/05/2023 02:53

Confused5678 · 02/05/2023 18:42

The birth parents are always right and their kids can do no wrong 🙄. Being a step mum is the worst job in the world .

This sentence says it all, "can carry out relatively basic tasks pertaining to themselves". A 12 year old (or older), has THAT as their standard.

I truly feel for the 95% of SMs who have to deal with that type of stance/behavior.

Nanaof1 · 03/05/2023 02:46

Harrypewter · 02/05/2023 18:29

No, I'm a parent who has had a routine in the home since my children were born 12 yrs ago. My ex-wife has her routine in her house. We all communicate regularly and never, ever impose or criticize.
Ex girlfriend on the other hand assumed command or attempted to under the pretence of making my children ship-shape and ready for battle (because she knew better) Er no.
The children are polite, excel at school, and can carry out relatively basic tasks pertaining to themselves. What neither family does is run a military-based operation.

So, your ex-gf had the responsibilities of caring for SC but was not allowed to have any parental authority over them, especially since it didn't totally align with YOUR rules and after all, they are YOUR children. 🙄 Got it. 😬

Thank goodness ex-gf got away from that toxicity!👏👏

user1492757084 · 03/05/2023 02:25

Don't restrict the relationship between SS and his mother.

Teenagers are like toddlers in that they push the boundaries.
Having a TV in his room is not a good enough reason to leave his mother, infact I would make sure that his living arrangemetns mirror those of his other room. I think SS is taking advantage of you.

Why won't DH remove the TV from his son's room? Is there a competition between him and his exwife?
It is not in SS best interest to live with you more than 50% of the time. Tell your husband to be more confident as a father.

He also needs to reassess the burden he places on you for unequal care of all of the children.

Nanaof1 · 03/05/2023 02:11

Coyoacan · 02/05/2023 19:09

Some interesting points coming up. The idea that children can unilaterally decide which parent they live with for example. I have known teenagers who swapped and changed between their parents' houses everytime they didn't like a rule.

This! I have also seen children who use their "presence" in the house as a bargaining chip to play the 2 parents off each other in a game of "who will give me what I want next, first" and choose according to who steps up first.
Now it's a tv, his own room. What's next? Game consoles, shoes, trips, down the line a car?

I am still wondering if every child in the OPs home have their own room or do any share? Who takes them off to school when the other SC stays over?

Nanaof1 · 03/05/2023 02:05

funinthesun19 · 02/05/2023 20:59

The dad gets to play cool parent whilst the women facilitate it all for him.

The mum by being forced to give up her position as RP and has probably done a really good job for her son and now her position all ends over a TV 🙄.

And the OP for just conveniently being there for the dad to make it happen.

Then he gets to skip off out to work leaving it all to the OP, while the mum probably misses her DS.

DSS will think his mum is mean and annoying, will think his dad is amazing for allowing him to have an TV and he won’t even notice the OP doing anything for him. It will all be about how great his dad is and how cool it is living at his dad’s.

Once again the man wins because everyone else bent over backwards for him.

ITA! Disney Daddy will get the accolades and SM and BM will get the short end of the stick and many MNers see nothing wrong with that as long as SC gets his way.

Nanaof1 · 03/05/2023 01:54

Gymnopedie · 02/05/2023 22:33

Probably wise to make some strict house rules of your own (in writing and signed by all three of you) regarding chores and getting yourself to school. Do this before he moves in full time.

I'd like to run an MN sweepstake and I get to go first. To all the PPs saying lay out the ground rules, what are the chances the DH will enforce them? My go - 0%. Right, who wants to take 1%?

Another one, to those PPs saying she should communicate with DH. What are the chances he'll listen? My go - 0%. Anyone for 1%?

What are the chances of the DH supporting taking the TV out of the DSS's room? 0%

Prize for the winner of each sweepstake a MN bottle of fizz.🍾

Since you took my odds, I'll go with a .0000000001% chance.

To me, it sounds like OPs NSDH is being very generous, with the OP's life and time, while assuming his should not change a bit.

I reiterate--the OP is expected to take the responsibility without any parental authority or rights. Not a good bargain in any scenario.

SkyandSurf · 03/05/2023 00:51

funinthesun19 · 02/05/2023 20:59

The dad gets to play cool parent whilst the women facilitate it all for him.

The mum by being forced to give up her position as RP and has probably done a really good job for her son and now her position all ends over a TV 🙄.

And the OP for just conveniently being there for the dad to make it happen.

Then he gets to skip off out to work leaving it all to the OP, while the mum probably misses her DS.

DSS will think his mum is mean and annoying, will think his dad is amazing for allowing him to have an TV and he won’t even notice the OP doing anything for him. It will all be about how great his dad is and how cool it is living at his dad’s.

Once again the man wins because everyone else bent over backwards for him.

I agree with all of this.

Dad gets to be the hero. Women do all the work / feel all the loss.

cocog · 03/05/2023 00:31

You will be doing more parenting than his parents why should you give up time with your preschool children to parent/taxi someone else’s child there babies for a few short years hand the care back to his parents, say it’s already too much with work and your own babies! If partner wants him to come he needs to do the work himself! He’s unable to care for him how they want him looked after because he’s not there too so this isn’t a practical solution right now

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 03/05/2023 00:21

Bansheed · 03/05/2023 00:08

She gets an opinion, not a say, which mirrored the child's power in her marrying the father. The law would take into account the 12 year old's choice. Not the new spouse's. Tough pill to swallow.

I am not sure what you mean by the rest. Are you implying he is merely entitled? In this scenario, he doesn't seem to be a xocklodger, just unrealistic expectations.

As his second wife, I would be frustrated, but the kids ( all of them) come first. Put in your ground rules around chores.But also house rules around parenting.

It could all work out and give the half siblings a chance to become.closer

The law may take into account the child’s wishes, but it wouldn’t say “DSS can move in and the OP has to do all the things her DH has assumed she will”.

He clearly expects the OP to be a parent to his children when it comes to shouldering the work, but expects her to default to him when it comes to rules being set.

Also thr OP hasn’t said he can’t move in. Just that if he moves in for this reason she won’t be willing to do all the work to facilitate it - Oh I'm not saying he can't come in. Just that I'm not going to be doing even more than I already do to facilitate it

As it is the child’s mother doesn’t agree about the tv, and the OP doesn’t agree about the tv. The DH needs to catch himself on - if he actually wanted there to be three equal parents he wouldn’t be overruling two of the others…

NoFault2023 · 03/05/2023 00:17

YANBU OP. You haven’t been consulted in a decision which has the greatest impact on you.

I’d think that anyway. But as an aside IMO working 4 days and being the primary carer for kids isn’t the great benefit it’s cracked up to be. You do 80% of the paid work and probably 80% of the parenting. Whilst the other parent is free to do as much or little as they please. It’s an enormous pressure and that one day. Which is spent doing childcare does little to address that balance.

Bansheed · 03/05/2023 00:08

billy1966 · 02/05/2023 19:40

Well as the OP is contributing financially to the home, she most certainly gets a say in who lives in the home she pays towards.

The OP's partner is clearly a complete loser that found the nearest mug to have more children with so she would house and look after his two existing children.

Regular theme on here.🤷🏻‍♀️

She gets an opinion, not a say, which mirrored the child's power in her marrying the father. The law would take into account the 12 year old's choice. Not the new spouse's. Tough pill to swallow.

I am not sure what you mean by the rest. Are you implying he is merely entitled? In this scenario, he doesn't seem to be a xocklodger, just unrealistic expectations.

As his second wife, I would be frustrated, but the kids ( all of them) come first. Put in your ground rules around chores.But also house rules around parenting.

It could all work out and give the half siblings a chance to become.closer

Liorae · 02/05/2023 23:50

BSB30 · 02/05/2023 23:25

A 12 year old is not capable of seeing the full picture of what they are asking. They just see the immediate results (such as own room and tv).

My concern would be that if your step son lives with you full time, that is going to undermine his relationship with his mum as he won't be spending much time with her. If she isn't abusive and there are no concerns in that respect, I don't think it would benefit a child to suddenly not see one parent on a whim.

My children are older now but if they had wanted to do this at 12, the answer would have been no. It's a big decision and not one I feel should be left with such a young child.

Regards the taking him to school etc, I'm in two minds with it. I'm a step-mum and I do believe that you have to take the child on as if your own to some degree but I also think it's a lot to put on you OP so I'm not sure.

Tell the boy that you won't be driving him to school, but you'll gladly walk him there abd give him a big hug at the school gate.

BSB30 · 02/05/2023 23:25

A 12 year old is not capable of seeing the full picture of what they are asking. They just see the immediate results (such as own room and tv).

My concern would be that if your step son lives with you full time, that is going to undermine his relationship with his mum as he won't be spending much time with her. If she isn't abusive and there are no concerns in that respect, I don't think it would benefit a child to suddenly not see one parent on a whim.

My children are older now but if they had wanted to do this at 12, the answer would have been no. It's a big decision and not one I feel should be left with such a young child.

Regards the taking him to school etc, I'm in two minds with it. I'm a step-mum and I do believe that you have to take the child on as if your own to some degree but I also think it's a lot to put on you OP so I'm not sure.