Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We’ve lost sight of what is a healthy weight

637 replies

SpringPop · 02/05/2023 08:16

Was chatting to my husband yesterday about getting to a healthy weight.

I am 5ft3 and at start of year I was weighing 80kg (12st 8)

I have hired a PT, workout 3 x weeklyand started eating healthy and now weigh around 72kg (11st 4). I’m not restricting food types or on any fad diet. I’m literally eating a balanced diet and the correct amount to lose up to 1lb a week.

I’ve done a decent start but still want to get to below 10stone where I would be a healthy weight for my height according to BMI.

I literally look like a ball in photos I took at the weekend. So fat.

He thinks I look great and lovely. Which is very kind. I literally don’t get how done people can’t see that I look fat. He’s not just being kind.

we got chatting and I Said to him that people we watch on tv that we think are “normal” (not underweight) and are similar height to me probably weigh between 8-9 stone therefore how could he not see I was overweight and not looking great.

AIBU to think no wonder we are quite an overweight nation. We equate 8stone/9stone as “skinny” but actually isn’t that healthy for someone who is just over 5ft? There should not be any shame in trying to reach a healthy weight. I kinda feel like we have lost sight of what is a healthy weight.

at 11stone/12stone, I’m not my healthiest, I’m not my fittest, I don’t look good. I’m opening myself up to more health conditions. Clothes make me look like a beach ball. I’m quite large chested and instead of making me look sexy/attractive, I just look ridiculous and almost ball shaped.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Botw1 · 03/05/2023 09:11

@TheOrigRights

You've just answered your own question.

Yes, I think people who say they are 'naturally' thin modify their eating or exercise habits in order to stay slim. Like you do.

DragonScreeches · 03/05/2023 09:09

KimberleyClark · 03/05/2023 08:56

To get fat you have to consistently eat more calories than your body needs or can cope with

or you have to have a faulty metabolism caused by an underactive thyroid which predisposes your body to store fat rather than burn it off.

The right dose of thyroxine should sort that out though in most cases. All the females in my family have this and none of us are overweight except me (by a few pounds) and if I cut out the wine and chocolate I do lose weight.

TheOrigRights · 03/05/2023 09:04

Botw1 · 03/05/2023 08:37

@SallyWD

I think if they exist they are exceptionally rare.

Why do you think this?
There are plenty of slim people walking around. Do you think most of them are consciously controlling what they eat or have unhealthy eating patterns?

I would regard myself as naturally slim. I have weighed the same pretty much all my adult life, and it's at the bottom of the BMI range. I am lean. I do love my sport (running) but is that because I am naturally good at it because of my shape or does the running keep me slim? I think the former because in periods where I have not run I don't put weight on, I think I naturally adapt my food intake to only consume what I need.
After a period of eating more than I might normally (Christmas, weddings, parties) I naturally eat less in the days following, not because I know I have to in order to control my weight, I just feel less hungry.

I believe there is research to back up this up.

KimberleyClark · 03/05/2023 08:56

To get fat you have to consistently eat more calories than your body needs or can cope with

or you have to have a faulty metabolism caused by an underactive thyroid which predisposes your body to store fat rather than burn it off.

KimberleyClark · 03/05/2023 08:54

Comedycook · 02/05/2023 20:35

So they're not naturally thin is what you're saying? They eat healthy food because thats what they like...in that case, their food choices are the reason they're slim.

Where’s the virtue in eating healthy foods you happen to like? I really wish I liked fish and seafood. I’ve tried but I find them completely unpalatable - taste, texture, smell everything. Cod makes me actually ill. I can manage a couple of fish fingers but that’s it, and I don’t really enjoy them.

SallyWD · 03/05/2023 08:39

Botw1 · 03/05/2023 08:37

@SallyWD

I think if they exist they are exceptionally rare.

I agree! I meant to add that both the women I me tioned have very lean mums (who also seem to eat a lot) so I do think it's genetic.

Botw1 · 03/05/2023 08:37

@SallyWD

I think if they exist they are exceptionally rare.

SallyWD · 03/05/2023 08:35

Botw1 · 03/05/2023 08:01

There's research to show that 'naturally' thin people modify their diets and appetites.

They aren't eating 4000 calories a day and staying slim.

They're eating small amounts of calories (sometimes in a disordered way) or using a lot of calories (sometimes in a disordered way)

They just don't really think about it so think it happens naturally

Yes I'm sure that's true generally but there ARE some people who have super metabolisms and do eat in excess of 3000 calories a day - and remain slim.
I mentioned before about my very slender friend who has to eat 3 large meals a day to stop herself losing weight (and she also eats tablespoons of oil between meals so she doesn't lose weight).
I've just remembered my friend from school. I've known her since I was 5 and I'm now 48. We've spent much time together and had numerous holidays so I know her eating habits well. She eats LOADS. Three big meals a day, often a Macdonalds or a full cream tea between meals. Definitely between 3000 and 4000 calories a day. She's always eaten like this and never been bigger than a size 8. However she was recently diagnosed with gallstones and a fatty liver. So despite the fact her body doesn't store fat and she looks incredibly healthy - she's not! She's suffering the effects of eating too much fatty food. She's just started a low fat diet (doctors orders) and lost lots of weight which she couldn't afford to lose. She now looks gaunt and unhealthy, despite the fact she needed to change her diet.
I realise the 2 friends I mention above are the exceptions. Most slim people definitely don't consume too many calories, of course.

speakout · 03/05/2023 08:20

They just don't really think about it so think it happens naturally

That's an important point.

We call them "naturally thin" because they don't have to diet.
Another individual may be the same size, but constantly watching every mouthful.
Naturally thin people don't think about calorie intake- they may still have healthy or unhealthy diets.
They just follow their appetites, not in denial over whether or not to eat something.

Mirabai · 03/05/2023 08:16

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 03/05/2023 07:09

Yes, I do know this. But I'm not the one trying to analyse why someone might feel a desire to eat too much of something nice because it's apparently such a strange concept to me...except that it's not.

As I said it’s a question of extent - I understand a desire to eat too much of something just not a whole pie.

Botw1 · 03/05/2023 08:01

There's research to show that 'naturally' thin people modify their diets and appetites.

They aren't eating 4000 calories a day and staying slim.

They're eating small amounts of calories (sometimes in a disordered way) or using a lot of calories (sometimes in a disordered way)

They just don't really think about it so think it happens naturally

JustDanceAddict · 03/05/2023 07:12

Agree, I’m 5ft4 and look best at around 8st5. I’m very slim built though & that makes a difference.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 03/05/2023 07:09

Mirabai · 02/05/2023 23:03

Obese people eat far too much food, this is not rocket science. But it’s complicated by disordered eating - bingeing, compulsive, emotional eating, poor education on food etc.

Alcoholics don’t down bottles merely because they like the taste of whisky.

Which presumably actually you know…

Yes, I do know this. But I'm not the one trying to analyse why someone might feel a desire to eat too much of something nice because it's apparently such a strange concept to me...except that it's not.

speakout · 03/05/2023 07:09

5128gap · 03/05/2023 06:32

There's vanishingly few of those. Most people aren't thin at all. Most people who are thin are so because they don't eat as much as people who aren't, or are more active. Perhaps there are people with science defying metabolisns, and certainly with health conditions that predispose them (to some extent) to be thinner, but they are outliers, and don't exist in anywhere near the numbers these threads would suggest. The vast majority of people are the weight you'd expect for their diet, activity level and age.

I agree.
I don't think our body weight is determined by nature, hormones or metabolism.
There are some rare illnesses or medications that cause obesity, but 99% of the time it is determined by the calories we eat and the activity we do.
During WW2 obesity was rare.

People are not "naturally" thin, just some people who have lower appetites, don't crave sweet foods.
Psychology plays a part too I think. food plays a part in comfort, for babies food and comfort are very intertwined, a meal of warm milk will send most babies into slumberland, and toddlers can be pacified by a dummy, giving similar mouth feel stimuli and induce calm.

I think most of us retain that asscociation to adulthood in some degree, it feels good to some degree, particularly so if we are stessed, anxious, have low mood we can gain comfort from eating, particularly if accompianed by a pleasant sugar rush.

Perhaps naturally thin people don't have that same connection, or connect in different ways.
I am a naturally thin person, if I am stressed, anxious or feeling down my appetite slows down. If I am going through a difficult time I have to force myself to eat, because I have no appetite.
I know others who find solace in food during stressful times.

Fizbosshoes · 03/05/2023 07:05

I have a friend who is naturally thin, her bmi is 17 or 18. I know her family and they are all thin with a small frame.

TheOrigRights · 03/05/2023 07:00

What size are you all defining as 'naturally thin'. For the sake of argument, give me a BMI.

5128gap · 03/05/2023 06:32

KimberleyClark · 02/05/2023 22:48

Ok, but people who are naturally thin are not really in a position to lecture others about their weight.

There's vanishingly few of those. Most people aren't thin at all. Most people who are thin are so because they don't eat as much as people who aren't, or are more active. Perhaps there are people with science defying metabolisns, and certainly with health conditions that predispose them (to some extent) to be thinner, but they are outliers, and don't exist in anywhere near the numbers these threads would suggest. The vast majority of people are the weight you'd expect for their diet, activity level and age.

5128gap · 03/05/2023 06:24

I don't think people who eat a family sized cheesecake are representative either. Most people would lose their appetite for something so sweet and rich, or their stomach would rebel long before it was finished. Sadly, and especially when the metabolism slows, the difference between healthy weight and OW comes down to a single slice of cheesecake every night.
If it were the difference between eating huge amounts, far beyond the average appetite, and not, far fewer people would struggle. Unfortunately the amount of food needed to remain at a healthy weight is far less than most of us would choose. So unless you have an unusually small appetite or are extremely active, it tends to boil down to a choice between how much you'd prefer to eat, and how much you'd prefer to weigh.

Jourdain11 · 02/05/2023 23:11

KimberleyClark · 02/05/2023 22:49

And if you can be naturally thin it follows you can be naturally fat.

Yeah, the whole point I was making was that people are naturally different shapes and sizes. And I haven't lectured anyone.

Mirabai · 02/05/2023 23:03

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 02/05/2023 22:35

At some point, if they're that big, they're going to be eating the equivalent of a whole cheesecake in too short a time one way or another, on a regular basis. That's how it happens.

Yes, of course they're thinking of taste and not nourishment. If people thought only of nourishment, obesity wouldn't exist. People enjoy pleasurable sensations even when they're not healthy and sometimes find it hard to regulate. Stop the presses.

You do actually know all this, of course.

Obese people eat far too much food, this is not rocket science. But it’s complicated by disordered eating - bingeing, compulsive, emotional eating, poor education on food etc.

Alcoholics don’t down bottles merely because they like the taste of whisky.

Which presumably actually you know…

KimberleyClark · 02/05/2023 22:49

And if you can be naturally thin it follows you can be naturally fat.

KimberleyClark · 02/05/2023 22:48

Jourdain11 · 02/05/2023 19:54

They could be - why not?

Ok, but people who are naturally thin are not really in a position to lecture others about their weight.

Mirabai · 02/05/2023 22:46

Comedycook · 02/05/2023 22:37

You commented on my bodily functions.. apparently my nausea or satiety receptors or something are not working...🙄

Interest in your comment about the desire to eat a whole cheesecake in the abstract is not the same as caring what you as a person do. It’s nothing to do with me.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 02/05/2023 22:40

I've heard that it can actually be harder to lose weight long term than give up hard drugs. The drugs are not necessary for life, but food is, so you can never avoid it completely. Given that people with binge eating disorders get the same sort of high as drug addicts, it really isn't hard to see why it's so hard for them. How many drug addicts could give it up if they had to take a few hits every day to survive?

Comedycook · 02/05/2023 22:37

Mirabai · 02/05/2023 22:35

I haven’t given you any advice and why would I care what you do?

You commented on my bodily functions.. apparently my nausea or satiety receptors or something are not working...🙄