Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We’ve lost sight of what is a healthy weight

637 replies

SpringPop · 02/05/2023 08:16

Was chatting to my husband yesterday about getting to a healthy weight.

I am 5ft3 and at start of year I was weighing 80kg (12st 8)

I have hired a PT, workout 3 x weeklyand started eating healthy and now weigh around 72kg (11st 4). I’m not restricting food types or on any fad diet. I’m literally eating a balanced diet and the correct amount to lose up to 1lb a week.

I’ve done a decent start but still want to get to below 10stone where I would be a healthy weight for my height according to BMI.

I literally look like a ball in photos I took at the weekend. So fat.

He thinks I look great and lovely. Which is very kind. I literally don’t get how done people can’t see that I look fat. He’s not just being kind.

we got chatting and I Said to him that people we watch on tv that we think are “normal” (not underweight) and are similar height to me probably weigh between 8-9 stone therefore how could he not see I was overweight and not looking great.

AIBU to think no wonder we are quite an overweight nation. We equate 8stone/9stone as “skinny” but actually isn’t that healthy for someone who is just over 5ft? There should not be any shame in trying to reach a healthy weight. I kinda feel like we have lost sight of what is a healthy weight.

at 11stone/12stone, I’m not my healthiest, I’m not my fittest, I don’t look good. I’m opening myself up to more health conditions. Clothes make me look like a beach ball. I’m quite large chested and instead of making me look sexy/attractive, I just look ridiculous and almost ball shaped.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Siameasy · 02/05/2023 10:18

Not only looks better but is more comfortable to be slim. After having DD I was in the obese range 13st and I was very keen to lose it as I was out of breath, things didn’t fit properly and my thighs rubbed together.

Bagsundermyeyestoday · 02/05/2023 10:17

Doesn't society really dictate size? Think rubenesque? Different cultures find different things attractive and this also changes over time. "Size" is a social construct. If suddenly obese people was marketed as attractive, then everyone would want to do that. Pubic hair is a great example of social trend!!!

daisymoonlight · 02/05/2023 10:16

this weekend I’ve been told “you don’t eat enough” “go on just have one wine, it won’t hurt” “are you sure you don’t want a sweet?! Go on” “you look fine as you are” etc etc etc by people other than my husband

I dont think this is about them genuinely worrying about you becoming anorexic, I suspect this is just the usual attitude you get from people when you make any positive changes. I have noticed this attitude multiple times from others whenever I have embarked on any kind of self improvement- people dont like it. They want you to stay as you are because it causes them to perhaps look at aspects of their lives that they arent happy with and you making a change causes them to look at their own lifestyle (even if you dont make a huge thing of it). Its sad but unfortunately not everyone will support you making a positive change. I dont think its about jealousy per se but its definitely a thing that happens to lots of people when they try to self improve. Lots of youtube videos on this - its a real phenomenon.

Iliketulips · 02/05/2023 10:15

A few years ago DD was admitted to hospital for emergency surgery. One question I was asked was if she was a her usual weight (which she was). With everything else going on, I wasn't thinking and asked if there was an issue with her weight. Doctor said her weight was just weight, but he'd asked because many young patients were carrying extra weight, and he just wanted to check DD hadn't lost lots of weight recently.

Ladysquamy · 02/05/2023 10:15

I do think people look better at a lower weight - slim. There's no question that it looks better, aesthetically. However, I think it's a mistake to equate slim automatically with healthy. Slim people can have very bad diets and lifestyles too and we're all going to die, no matter what we look like. I've always been middle of the road. Slim when younger and about a 12 now. I think I'm healthier now than when I was very slim. I drink way less and don't smoke and my diet is better.

Wanderingowl · 02/05/2023 10:14

Highdaysandholidays1 · 02/05/2023 09:47

I don't think calling yourself fat, a ball (and thereby other people the same weight the same) is helping anything. What do you expect them to say?! Of course you probably look better than you do and if you are working out and have lost weight you will be trimmer and more shaplier, even if you are still in the overweight BMI category.

I'm your height and weight and am neither fat or a ball. I'm a middle aged slightly overweight lady who looks fine in normal clothes, with a bit of a tyre round my middle. Nothing to find disgusting or awful or write a diatribe about.

In fact, I'm the best weight possible to live the longest and so are you. Slightly overweight people do the best in terms of longevity/mortality. It's called the 'obesity' paradox. Living longer than those who are normal or underweight BMI. Pretty obvious why if you are elderly and get sick if you have ever seen how thin many people get.

If you are obese then it may affect your current everyday health, but on that height and weight you are not obese, and you are exercising, you are near (ish) to a normal BMI and so all this self-loathing and indignation anyone payed you a compliment isn't needed.

The obesity paradox is bullshit science. It comes from a study that deliberately excludes cancer as a cause of mortality. So everyone in the study who died of cancer was removed. As being overweight can contribute to both getting cancer and dying of cancer, removing cancer from the results shows at best, that the study is worthless and at worst, deliberately manipulated to bring about a particular conclusion. Either way it's bollocks.

As for the OP's weight, she was soundly in the obese weight range when she decided to lose weight and while out of it now, still has a BMI over 28, which is in the upper-end of over-weight. This isn't intended to be mean. It just is what it is. I know I needed to be aware of that when I went from obese to the strong, athletic woman I am now. Pretending I was fine when I wasn't made me unhealthy and frankly, old before my time.

potniatheron · 02/05/2023 10:14

Calibrachoa · 02/05/2023 09:04

Here you go for those with a rosy view of the past.

The so-called 'gin craze' needs to be seen within the socio-economic context of the era, which is that working class people had been lured/forced into overcrowded cities by the industrial revolution and the increasing oligopolisation of the countryside and were being worked to death for next to no pay. Getting drunk was an escape.

Although the extent of the so-called 'gin craze' was exaggerated due to deeply entrenched misgynistic outrage at the idea of working class women daring to enjoy alcohol ('Gine Lane' painting a good example.)

Likewise, the current obesity epidemic needs to be seen in the context of our times, in which big tech and oligopolies plus an ever more demanding work culture force us to live increasingly diembodied lives of spending all day at a desk and seeking out quick dopamine hits from social media - none of which involves using our bodies to do what they are evolved to do, ie MOVE, RUN and WALK.

In a world which is becoming ever more stressful and isolated the big food companies then tell us the answer is hyper processed hyper palatable rubbish like refined carbs, vegan meat substitutes and ready prepared food.

Oh yes and then women are shouted at and mocked for daring to inveitably gain a bit of weight.

PurpleWisteria1 · 02/05/2023 10:14

BungleandGeorge · 02/05/2023 10:03

@PurpleWisteria1 shes actually not wrong that clinical evidence found slightly overweight women had the best outcome. Women put weight on in middle age naturally for a reason-oestrogen is stored in fat. She’s not talking about being in the obese category. Some people have conditions that put homeostasis out but most people would be better listening to their body, the problems come when people want to be thinner than their natural weight or they overeat for comfort or are problem drinkers etc etc. restriction of calories leads to bingeing so you have to be very careful when trying to change weight

But the trouble with that is slightly overweight is actually being seen as skinny now. Slightly overweight is about a 12-14 in clothes size.
I am middle aged and at the top of my BMI. I am a 12-14. My friendship group are all overweight and trying to lose but consider me skinny. I’m not. Another couple of pounds in and I would be in the overweight category.
I don’t have a spare tyre. Am able to wear vest tops as my arms are ok. Never get chub rub. My collar bones stick out. Yet I am almost in the obese category.
This is what this thread is about. As so many people are overweight it’s now the new normal. So being at the very top of the BMI healthy range seems fine.
There is very strong evidence that being overweight at all has a damaging effect on your health. So many problems arise from even being a little overweight. Which is why it’s pushed so heavily by the NHS to get in that healthy weight band.
Women put on weight in middle age yes, and if it was a few pounds not so bad but getting a spare tyre means you have excess fat in the most dangerous place around your organs putting you at risk from all sorts of nasty illnesses.
There is no need for middle age women to gain weight if they don’t want to. It’s NOT inevitable. Calorie deficit will always work. No matter the age.

Dedodee · 02/05/2023 10:13

CupEmpty · 02/05/2023 08:38

These threads never go well. FWIW I completely agree with you, but most of MN won’t as they are likely to be able overweight themselves (statistically as most of the general population are). I’m 5’7 and 68kg and about a stone over weight (just had a baby and breastfeeding). I feel huge altho my bmi is probably only about 23 (haven’t calculated it- just a guess) but I have a good stone + to lose at some point, but people keep saying the same to me.

This. ^^
I'm 5ft4" and 8 stone.
Yes, I am slim but I'm not underweight.
Also how a body looks has a lot to do with age, muscle tone and general fitness.
If I was 10st at my age I would look like a bag full of loose stuffing. 30 years ago I would probably have looked OK.
So many pp's who are obviously overweight and accuse those who are slim of having ed or being competitive under eaters. My dsil told my dm I must be anorexic.
Love your body but don't abuse it by pretending that as long as you are presentable your weight isn't an issue. Health wise it really is.

Creditcrunch2243 · 02/05/2023 10:13

I’m on this journey too. I am 5ft1 and was 11st10 at the start of the year. I’m 9st12 today and still feel like I have a way to go. I think the biggest problem is what has become an acceptable portion size. It’s taken me 4 months to get used to eating smaller portions of my food, it’s been really hard. I think we all know what is healthy but it’s when you realise it doesn’t matter what you eat, if you eat more cals than you burn you gain weight. X

3BSHKATS · 02/05/2023 10:11

Isn't something like 60% of the NHS's budget is being spent on obsessity related illness ? Joint repair, type 2 diabetes, heart disease, cancer

Iwasafool · 02/05/2023 10:10

SpringPop · 02/05/2023 08:25

@Handsnotwands i have had a few other well meaning comments about looking good. I just can’t see it. I look awful in photos I saw at weekend.

my insta is also full of body positivity. Love your curves. You can still be fit if you weigh this much etc… it’s very much a trend these days.

I get that it’s important to love your body and have some positivity but truth is… I’m fat. I look silly. And I’m not as fit as I was.

Don't you think they are being positive about your weight loss? I mean you have lost over a stone and probably look like you've lost more due to the exercise so they are saying you look good with that weight loss. It doesn't mean they won't be just as positive if you lose another stone.

hockerydockerydick · 02/05/2023 10:09

you couldn’t have chosen a more mumsnet cliche for a title 🤣

Viviennemary · 02/05/2023 10:09

That is still far too heavy for your height. You need to lose at least another stone.

Iwouldliketogotosweden · 02/05/2023 10:08

YANBU I’m the same height as you and at my heaviest was 13.3. i lost weight to get to a healthy BMI but then had a baby so trying to lose again! Although I never got above that weigh even when 39/40.
im now 11.10 so very much overweight, I ran a half marathon yesterday so I could kid myself I’m healthy. friends and family comment who
healthy I am. But I do need to to lose weight.

Tinpanalley · 02/05/2023 10:08

nopuppiesallowed · 02/05/2023 09:52

Well done, OP. You have grasped the bull by the horns and you're doing really well. I'm post menopausal, 5ft 3 inches and 55 kilo. I don't want to add any weight as it goes straight to my stomach. And it just wouldn't be good for me or the country. Our health service is buckling as it is (underfunded), so shouldn't we all be doing what we can to help it? Being overweight means knee and hip replacements, type 2 diabetes, cholesterol problems, strokes and heart problems. Those mean medical interventions. Money is better spent on cancer research and treatment. Yes - being underweight because of not eating well means you're at greater risk of bone problems, but I also know fat women with osteoporosis because they eat rubbish food. 'Love your curves'? It's better to love yourself - and keep off the crisps!

Great post!

LumpySpaceGoddess · 02/05/2023 10:07

I think a lot of people have but it’s not new.

I was always a super skinny child but I became a bit chubby when my period started, everyone kept saying it was “puppy fat” but it wasn’t, it was a mixture of hormones and the fact no one monitored what I was eating and I didn’t have a clue about healthy eating or how bad crisps were for you etc so I could easily eat several bags a day and tons of bread etc.

I remember how much I hated my weight and when I was 11/12 I started to skip meals and developed an ED and became underweight very quickly because I had no idea how to lose the weight safely/properly.

I’ve seen a few posts recently from parents saying their child is upset at their weight and can everyone please tell them how beautiful and perfect they are but their child IS overweight, it really upsets me to see people are still dismissing their children when the voice how upset they are, surely they should listen, sit down and tell them it’s ok and support them to gain a healthier lifestyle by looking at their diet and exercise and seeing what needs to change.

For my own children I’ve not been super strict with food, they can have treats but it’s all in moderation and it’s balanced, neither of them have had any weight issues and are both super active and healthy, I’m really pleased I’ve helped them avoid what I went though.

SpringPop · 02/05/2023 10:05

Yes of course my DH is mindful of my feelings and I am grateful to have him. He is pretty good at things like this. He always makes me feel good about myself which is one reason I love him.

I guess I just found it interesting our conversation.

im certainly not suggesting we go round telling people they are fat. They probably already know. I certainly do!

but when they are taking steps to be healthier saying things like “don’t get too skinny” “you looked fine as you were” etc is it helpful?

Fatface jeans being baggy at size 12 yet when I go into H&M a size 16 won’t even cover my fat rolls…. It’s just not useful any of it.

I don’t want to go back to the heroin chic days of the 90s. But I think where we are as a society isn’t helping either. It’s a shame we can’t find a middle ground of what healthy looks/feels like.

I know there will always be some people at each end of the spectrum that weigh as they do due to health reasons but for me… I just didn’t move as much as I should and ate too much.

where we are today… I think we are heading for trouble. Kids on screens, deliveroo, people sitting at home watching one of the million streaming services instead of being active, kids not playing out like we did on the 90s. People using wine as a way to relieve the stress of busy day. Junk food EVERYWHERE. And right now for me the constant putting down of anyone trying to improve health.

this weekend I’ve been told “you don’t eat enough” “go on just have one wine, it won’t hurt” “are you sure you don’t want a sweet?! Go on” “you look fine as you are” etc etc etc by people other than my husband.

OP posts:
AlbaDT · 02/05/2023 10:04

I think this thread proves your point OP!

BreviloquentBastard · 02/05/2023 10:04

I agree with you. I'm 5'6" and at the beginning of this year weighed 196lbs. This made me clinically obese, but the number of people I had say "oh but you're a healthy weight, you don't need to lose that much!" was actually shocking. People thought I was healthy when I was obese, because when we hear "obese" we think the kind of obesity on My 600lb Life, no one would consider an average height size 14 woman obese. But I was.

I'm lucky in that I do seem to carry it well, but I look and feel a damn sight better when I'm not this heavy. I'm 30lbs down with at least another 30 to go and people keep telling me I'm aiming to lose too much, I'm a healthy weight now I don't need to lose more etc. Even though the 130lbs I'm aiming for is a perfectly healthy weight for my height, and the 160lbs I am now is very much still overweight.

daisymoonlight · 02/05/2023 10:03

YANBU. I agree with you. I fully support the idea that you can be attractive and overweight, and I agree that being overweight carries an unhealthy stigma and there should be more plus size models etc.

However, I dont like the fact that health seems to have been forgotten in all of this. It is not healthy to be carrying around lots of extra weight and I dont get the outrage I have seen on here when GPs dare to mention it. Obviously it should be approached in a kind and supportive manner but it is not wrong to address the fact that obesity increases the risk of cancer and various other illnesses along with joint problems and heart problems etc. I feel like the push towards affirming that you can be attractive at a larger weight has completely obliterated the idea that from a health perspective its not good for anyone. Both can be true at the same time. Being attractive is not an indicator of health and that goes for both obesity and being very underweight too.

BungleandGeorge · 02/05/2023 10:03

@PurpleWisteria1 shes actually not wrong that clinical evidence found slightly overweight women had the best outcome. Women put weight on in middle age naturally for a reason-oestrogen is stored in fat. She’s not talking about being in the obese category. Some people have conditions that put homeostasis out but most people would be better listening to their body, the problems come when people want to be thinner than their natural weight or they overeat for comfort or are problem drinkers etc etc. restriction of calories leads to bingeing so you have to be very careful when trying to change weight

Thepeopleversuswork · 02/05/2023 10:03

Deluded. 🤦‍♀️ No wonder we have an obesity epidemic.
No that ‘tyre’ won’t keep you safe in old age. Quite the reverse.

But I don't think most people are arguing that it's healthy or even normal.

The point is to ask whether there is anything to be gained from making your loved ones feel shit about being overweight.

Swellinyewing · 02/05/2023 10:02

Highdaysandholidays1 · 02/05/2023 09:47

I don't think calling yourself fat, a ball (and thereby other people the same weight the same) is helping anything. What do you expect them to say?! Of course you probably look better than you do and if you are working out and have lost weight you will be trimmer and more shaplier, even if you are still in the overweight BMI category.

I'm your height and weight and am neither fat or a ball. I'm a middle aged slightly overweight lady who looks fine in normal clothes, with a bit of a tyre round my middle. Nothing to find disgusting or awful or write a diatribe about.

In fact, I'm the best weight possible to live the longest and so are you. Slightly overweight people do the best in terms of longevity/mortality. It's called the 'obesity' paradox. Living longer than those who are normal or underweight BMI. Pretty obvious why if you are elderly and get sick if you have ever seen how thin many people get.

If you are obese then it may affect your current everyday health, but on that height and weight you are not obese, and you are exercising, you are near (ish) to a normal BMI and so all this self-loathing and indignation anyone payed you a compliment isn't needed.

Redic. FFS.

Wanderingowl · 02/05/2023 10:02

Mephisneon · 02/05/2023 08:34

There's been loads of debunking of bmi and it's origins. Do some research. I'm surprised so many people just accept it. Things take a long time to move forward in the medical profession due to teaching etc but the info is oy there.

No there really, really hasn't been. BMI is an excellent guideline for the vast, vast majority of people. The number one main problem with BMI is that it is far too broad a metric to be completely relied upon. 7 points of 'healthy weight' from 18-25 is too much, it's that our healthy weight is within that region but not throughout it. For most people it's at 21-22 but depending on our body shape, bone density and muscularity some people will be healthiest at 19-20 others at 23-24. For a handful of extremely muscular people it can be over 25 but if you have that kind of muscularity, you work damned hard for it and know you aren't overweight.

BMI is also adjusted for people of Asian ethnicities because they generally have a lower threshold for weight related health issues. And that's it, for everyone it's a good basic guide of the parameters you should ideally stay within, but even at that, we should be working out what our individual healthy guidelines weight is, almost always within the general guides.

Swipe left for the next trending thread