Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We’ve lost sight of what is a healthy weight

637 replies

SpringPop · 02/05/2023 08:16

Was chatting to my husband yesterday about getting to a healthy weight.

I am 5ft3 and at start of year I was weighing 80kg (12st 8)

I have hired a PT, workout 3 x weeklyand started eating healthy and now weigh around 72kg (11st 4). I’m not restricting food types or on any fad diet. I’m literally eating a balanced diet and the correct amount to lose up to 1lb a week.

I’ve done a decent start but still want to get to below 10stone where I would be a healthy weight for my height according to BMI.

I literally look like a ball in photos I took at the weekend. So fat.

He thinks I look great and lovely. Which is very kind. I literally don’t get how done people can’t see that I look fat. He’s not just being kind.

we got chatting and I Said to him that people we watch on tv that we think are “normal” (not underweight) and are similar height to me probably weigh between 8-9 stone therefore how could he not see I was overweight and not looking great.

AIBU to think no wonder we are quite an overweight nation. We equate 8stone/9stone as “skinny” but actually isn’t that healthy for someone who is just over 5ft? There should not be any shame in trying to reach a healthy weight. I kinda feel like we have lost sight of what is a healthy weight.

at 11stone/12stone, I’m not my healthiest, I’m not my fittest, I don’t look good. I’m opening myself up to more health conditions. Clothes make me look like a beach ball. I’m quite large chested and instead of making me look sexy/attractive, I just look ridiculous and almost ball shaped.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Catspyjamas17 · 04/05/2023 09:41

Obviously I don't know what they eat, but it has been interesting to see how many steps a day my slimmest friends do via their shared FitBit data online - quite a lot more than me, though I am sometime no 2. out of 10 or more usually no. 3 or no. 4. I do pretty well for steps considering that I work FT in a sedentary job and they work only a few hours a week or do active jobs. I can get 15k+ steps in a day at the weekend but they are able to do that nearly every day- one is a dog walker. I've upped my exercise in the last 6 months but don't always have the time to get all those steps in, especially in winter.

Booklover40 · 04/05/2023 09:35

Swellinyewing · 04/05/2023 09:17

Not at all, that would be a ridiculous suggestion. However one would not be 20 stone and the other one 8. Of course there is fluctuation between people's weights but given the scenario you have given there would not be stones and stones in the difference. Someone who is 5 ft 6 and size 20 does not eat the same as a person who is size 10 and 5 ft 6 regardless of metabolism of frame size.

No one is saying someone who's 5"6" and size 20 eats the same as a size 10 person. But someone with a larger frame and slower metabolism could eat the same as someone with a narrow frame and fast metabolism and there could easily be a few sizes - or a few points in bmi - difference.

Myself and my dsis are both 5"8". She takes after my dm and is slender, with small size 4 feet and thin ankles/wrists. Narrow frame. I'm more like the women on my df's side - wide shouldered and hipped, large hands and size 8 feet. Big boobs. I eat a healthy diet of 1200 calories a day and exercise and am 11 stone, size 10-12. It's really a lot of work for me to stay this size. Dsis eats junk food, never cooks a meal, drinks like a fish and takes no exercise but is a size 8 and struggles to gain weight(my dm is the exact same). So we are from the same gene pool and are wildly different.

Don't you look around you and see how everyone has different frames/sizes/holds fat & muscle in different places?

Of course people have different sized skeletons and organs/skin mass etc. Some people have very active lifestyles or a nervous energy that keeps their metabolism fast, others are more sedentary or may have health issues that make it harder to lose weight.

I don't understand why some people don't seem to get that we are not one homogenous mass who, if we only could be more like them, would be skinny too.

Swellinyewing · 04/05/2023 09:17

Booklover40 · 04/05/2023 09:05

If you don't believe that different frames/sizes/metabolisms are a thing then Swellinyewing may I ask you a question?

Do you think that if you gave all the women in the world the exact same diet for a year and made them do the exact same exercise regime, they would all end up the exact same size/weight?

If not, why not?

Not at all, that would be a ridiculous suggestion. However one would not be 20 stone and the other one 8. Of course there is fluctuation between people's weights but given the scenario you have given there would not be stones and stones in the difference. Someone who is 5 ft 6 and size 20 does not eat the same as a person who is size 10 and 5 ft 6 regardless of metabolism of frame size.

Comedycook · 04/05/2023 09:06

Booklover40 · 04/05/2023 09:05

If you don't believe that different frames/sizes/metabolisms are a thing then Swellinyewing may I ask you a question?

Do you think that if you gave all the women in the world the exact same diet for a year and made them do the exact same exercise regime, they would all end up the exact same size/weight?

If not, why not?

Great question

Booklover40 · 04/05/2023 09:05

If you don't believe that different frames/sizes/metabolisms are a thing then Swellinyewing may I ask you a question?

Do you think that if you gave all the women in the world the exact same diet for a year and made them do the exact same exercise regime, they would all end up the exact same size/weight?

If not, why not?

Swellinyewing · 04/05/2023 08:39

TillyTollyTully · 04/05/2023 07:58

If someone turned round and said "people are only overweight because they eat too much and don't exercise", there'd be a massive push-back, I bet...

People say that all the time. Including on this thread. All over Mumsnet

Because it's true.

The cries of 'yes but what about BODY TYPE! What about BUILD! Swimmers and gymnasts are BROAD! BMI is useless for bodybuilders!' always pop up on weight threads. Yes, because your average person with a too-high BMI is probably just a bodybuilder or Olympic gymnast right? 🤔

Oh and always with the 'I'm 3 stone overweight but I walk 10 miles a day and I'm very fit, fitter than slimmer people'.

It's just total denial.

This!

Always the same old excuses.

I am heavy set.
I have big bones.
I only have to look at a biscuit..
I am curvy.
BMI is total bollox.
I am 20 stone and healthy.
Puppy Fat.
Wide skeleton (best I have heard yet).
I have a bigger frame.
We all put on weight easily in the family, just the way we are made.
Thyroid issues/ no metabolism/ fat genes/ genetically predisposed.

The VAST MAJORITY of people are fat because they eat too much. Fact.

It is also important to realise however that eating addictions/disorders are a huge problem. It is not a simple issue nor is it easy which is why you have people going over to Turkey for weight loss surgery and butchering their bodies to actually physically STOP them from eating so much. It is an addiction just like any other but harder because you have to eat every day, like giving an alcoholic 3 drinks daily and expecting them to be satisfied at that and not want more.

At the end of the day you are fat because you eat too much. In a very small amount of cases it can be a medical problem or medication that is causing weight gain but for the most part it is eating too much. Simple.

Comedycook · 04/05/2023 08:02

Polis · 04/05/2023 07:52

But...I'm not sure this is a sign that they were healthy and we are not. An adult in their twenties and up in the 1970s would have spent part of their childhood living with rationing

Didn’t rationing actually lead to an improvement in overall health? It ensured that adults and children had a properly balanced diet.

It may have been balanced but it wasn't plentiful like it is now. How did rationing affect child development and height/build etc? Compared to children now who have a abundance of food available to them?

TillyTollyTully · 04/05/2023 07:58

If someone turned round and said "people are only overweight because they eat too much and don't exercise", there'd be a massive push-back, I bet...

People say that all the time. Including on this thread. All over Mumsnet

Because it's true.

The cries of 'yes but what about BODY TYPE! What about BUILD! Swimmers and gymnasts are BROAD! BMI is useless for bodybuilders!' always pop up on weight threads. Yes, because your average person with a too-high BMI is probably just a bodybuilder or Olympic gymnast right? 🤔

Oh and always with the 'I'm 3 stone overweight but I walk 10 miles a day and I'm very fit, fitter than slimmer people'.

It's just total denial.

Polis · 04/05/2023 07:52

But...I'm not sure this is a sign that they were healthy and we are not. An adult in their twenties and up in the 1970s would have spent part of their childhood living with rationing

Didn’t rationing actually lead to an improvement in overall health? It ensured that adults and children had a properly balanced diet.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 04/05/2023 07:22

Also, although we have certainly got bigger overall since the 70s...then as now, attractive people were more likely to make it on to TV and the media. Fat wasn't fashionable, especially in women. But my family photos show there were definitely overweight people back then.

Comedycook · 04/05/2023 07:19

I'm not sure they were an advertisement for healthy living

Comedycook · 04/05/2023 07:18

I know when you look back at TV footage from the 1970s, everyone looks absolutely tiny. Very slim waists. But...I'm not sure this is a sign that they were healthy and we are not. An adult in their twenties and up in the 1970s would have spent part of their childhood living with rationing. The UK had rations until 1954... perhaps this affected part of their development and consequently overall size....also most people smoked. I'm not sure

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 03/05/2023 22:52

5128gap · 03/05/2023 21:45

Of course people have different builds. I never said otherwise. What I said was 'slim' is not a build and neither is 'fat'. They are just labels to describe the amount of fat people have, regardless of their (natural) build. A gymnast is not going to be slim for life on account of their build. If they eat more than they burn off they would get fat too.

I have to disagree there, although "slim" is a subjective judgement anyway. But yes, some people do indeed have a slim build and it means that even if they've got the same body fat percentage as a bigger built person, they'll still be visibly slimmer. Even at a healthy weight, I'd never describe myself as "slim"...too broad, too booby, too hippy. Not fat, but just not what I think most people would call "slim".

You can't reliably gauge body fat percentage just by looking at someone anyway. That's why we have methods for it.

5128gap · 03/05/2023 21:45

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 03/05/2023 16:31

How slim a person is is just a way of describing how much body fat they happen to have at that time, which for most people can and does vary throughout their life time.

To an extent. But are you truly trying to say that people don't have different builds? A professional gymnast will have a very different build to a weightlifter, even accounting for their difference in training. Otherwise there really would be only one healthy weight for all people of a certain height with no variation, and even BMI doesn't pretend otherwise.

Of course people have different builds. I never said otherwise. What I said was 'slim' is not a build and neither is 'fat'. They are just labels to describe the amount of fat people have, regardless of their (natural) build. A gymnast is not going to be slim for life on account of their build. If they eat more than they burn off they would get fat too.

WhoppingBigBackside · 03/05/2023 20:19

I did Home Economics at school and from what I remember we didn't cook things like stew. I can't remember much of it other than some dreadful cakes I made. I could bake ok at home, so not sure what went wrong.

The way people eat has changed from my childhood. We had family meals at the table, and I'd not see anyone walking down the street eating. Takeaways and meals out were rare events. A snack would be a piece of fruit or a biscuit.

Angelil · 03/05/2023 20:07

Mirabai · 02/05/2023 13:26

Yes I think this is true.

Take my high street in inner London. In the 80s it had McDs, Wimpey, a couple of pubs with pub food and that was it. Now it’s wall to wall food places - delis, cafes, restaurants, 3 sushi bars, juice bars, sandwich shops, 2 health food shops, gelateria - probably 40-50% of the retail spaces are now serve food in some form.

Whenever you turn on the TV or open a magazine there’s endless cooking shows/recipes.

When you add the explosion of junk and ultra processed food, and the implosion of exercise, it’s not really surprising there’s a problem.

But ironically people are cooking a lot less despite the proliferation of cooking shows. Even the way these shows are ‘packaged’ has changed: much more glitzy/fast paced now (look at Jamie Oliver’s programmes for example) and not designed for you to actually follow the recipe, compared to (say) Delia’s very much more instructional cooking programmes from the 1970s. Do people (as a general/overall population trend) even still know how to cook healthy food, the way that they did back then? Home Economics classes being restyled as Food Technology also didn’t help; people need to actually know how to cook a stew, not how to make a Swiss roll in so many different iterations (from a product design perspective) that you’ve actually ruined it by the end. Most people don’t need to learn about stock rotation and how to design packaging. They need to be taught how to cook. I say this as a 37yo so hardly hailing from the Dark Ages here.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 03/05/2023 18:09

nopuppiesallowed · 03/05/2023 18:06

It's what you get used to....My husband is used to eating only fruit for lunch and I'm now used to eating gluten free (believe me - I'd love a full of gluten baguette!) But sometimes I get a bit frustrated when people tell me that they don't understand why they've put on so much weight when they have a plate full of the quiche and sausage rolls that I'd love to be eating...

I suppose you adapt to an extent, but with no protein I would really not feel sated.

nopuppiesallowed · 03/05/2023 18:06

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 03/05/2023 10:35

I like fruit, but I'd be very unhappy if I had to have only that for lunch. I guess I'd do it if it was necessary to prevent a serious back issue, but I'd be miserable and I wouldn't think anyone was greedy for wanting something more at lunchtime.

It's what you get used to....My husband is used to eating only fruit for lunch and I'm now used to eating gluten free (believe me - I'd love a full of gluten baguette!) But sometimes I get a bit frustrated when people tell me that they don't understand why they've put on so much weight when they have a plate full of the quiche and sausage rolls that I'd love to be eating...

Leftoverssandwich · 03/05/2023 17:51

If someone turned round and said "people are only overweight because they eat too much and don't exercise", there'd be a massive push-back, I bet...

People say that all the time. Including on this thread. All over Mumsnet.

I think plenty of fat people agree that there are thin people who appear to be able to eat quite a lot of calories and remain, um, not fat. And they appear to be quite happy in that state. They presumably have bodies which are extremely efficient at using up the energy they are consuming. My own brother has been very thin all his life and eats an appalling junk food diet (and drinks quite a lot of booze) without doing any exercise, while I am probably twice his size, eating vegetables and seeds and sweating it out in gym classes.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 03/05/2023 17:50

I have huge tits, wide hips, a broad back, long legs and thick ankles and wrists. Big bones and big boobs.

This doesn't mean I can't be a healthy weight; there's no fat on a skeleton and bone is pretty light. But I will never be what is usually regarded as "slim" and I will never be a small person. Plenty of people are healthy at a size 8, but I am not one of them.

Jourdain11 · 03/05/2023 17:42

Exactly. Two people might be the same height and have similar amounts of "flesh on their bones", but be different weights because one has a narrower build and smaller bone structure than the other. In that case, the thinner one is no more "restricting calories to maintain weight" than the other one. Plus, some people do have faster metabolisms than others.

I don't see why some people are so adamant that all slim people must be miserably restricting calories and rushing off to the gym every day. It's almost as though you're trying to prove a point that you can only be thin if you're miserable...

If someone turned around and said, "people are only overweight because they eat too much and don't exercise", there'd be a massive push-back, I bet...

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 03/05/2023 16:54

Seasonofthewitch83 · 03/05/2023 16:51

It just proves the point that its never truly concern about 'health'.

Of course it's not. That's arrant bollocks.

There is a massive perceived moral value to being at a healthy weight, especially among women.

Seasonofthewitch83 · 03/05/2023 16:51

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 03/05/2023 16:34

Yes. This is a similar line of thinking to the earlier poster who said gastric bands were "cheating" and decided that people who have them must always have tons of horrible loose skin as a punishment.

It just proves the point that its never truly concern about 'health'.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 03/05/2023 16:34

Seasonofthewitch83 · 03/05/2023 15:52

I think it was comedian Sofie Hagen who used the term 'Thin tokens'.

Society promises you all sorts of things if you only lost some weight. You will be more confident, more attractive, people will like you more, you will have a better social life etc etc.

So when a fat woman is happily living their life, not hating their body, in a happy relationship, a great career, it makes them FURIOUS. Because they feel like they EARNED those things by going to the gym and dieting and heres this fat woman getting it all for FREE? It completely invalidates their the whole promise.

Yes. This is a similar line of thinking to the earlier poster who said gastric bands were "cheating" and decided that people who have them must always have tons of horrible loose skin as a punishment.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 03/05/2023 16:31

How slim a person is is just a way of describing how much body fat they happen to have at that time, which for most people can and does vary throughout their life time.

To an extent. But are you truly trying to say that people don't have different builds? A professional gymnast will have a very different build to a weightlifter, even accounting for their difference in training. Otherwise there really would be only one healthy weight for all people of a certain height with no variation, and even BMI doesn't pretend otherwise.