Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We’ve lost sight of what is a healthy weight

637 replies

SpringPop · 02/05/2023 08:16

Was chatting to my husband yesterday about getting to a healthy weight.

I am 5ft3 and at start of year I was weighing 80kg (12st 8)

I have hired a PT, workout 3 x weeklyand started eating healthy and now weigh around 72kg (11st 4). I’m not restricting food types or on any fad diet. I’m literally eating a balanced diet and the correct amount to lose up to 1lb a week.

I’ve done a decent start but still want to get to below 10stone where I would be a healthy weight for my height according to BMI.

I literally look like a ball in photos I took at the weekend. So fat.

He thinks I look great and lovely. Which is very kind. I literally don’t get how done people can’t see that I look fat. He’s not just being kind.

we got chatting and I Said to him that people we watch on tv that we think are “normal” (not underweight) and are similar height to me probably weigh between 8-9 stone therefore how could he not see I was overweight and not looking great.

AIBU to think no wonder we are quite an overweight nation. We equate 8stone/9stone as “skinny” but actually isn’t that healthy for someone who is just over 5ft? There should not be any shame in trying to reach a healthy weight. I kinda feel like we have lost sight of what is a healthy weight.

at 11stone/12stone, I’m not my healthiest, I’m not my fittest, I don’t look good. I’m opening myself up to more health conditions. Clothes make me look like a beach ball. I’m quite large chested and instead of making me look sexy/attractive, I just look ridiculous and almost ball shaped.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
KittyAlfred · 02/05/2023 14:26

Enfys1982 · 02/05/2023 13:58

Its not normal or healthy to be a size four or six if you are a grown adult who has gone through puberty. Seriously if you are that emaciated I’d suggest getting urgent help.

isn't a current size 4 or 6 about equivalent to a size 8-10 back in the 80s? If so, that's just slim, not emaciated. Which kind of proves the OP's point.

Mirabai · 02/05/2023 14:25

Kolakalia · 02/05/2023 14:10

Those aren’t accurate. A U.K. 8 is a French 36, an Italian 40, and a US 4.

KittyAlfred · 02/05/2023 14:23

RichardHeed · 02/05/2023 08:24

Do I think society has “lost” what a “healthy” weight is? Possibly.

Do I think this was a goady as fuck thread and your language is incredibly hyperbolic? Abso-fucking-lutely

what is your point exactly?

MintJulia · 02/05/2023 14:22

YANBU I had someone at ds' swimming class seriously suggest that I wasn't feeding him properly. Suggest I take him to a doctor. 😳

He's a skinny 14yo with all his ribs visible. But he eats more than me, is the healthiest person I know and is growing about a cm a month. When I was a kid, almost all 14yos were like that. now it's rare.

I'm 59, 5'8" and ten stone 10lb (68kg). I feel fat, I lumber, I have a good roll of flab around my belly, I don't need to check my BMI to know I'm overweight. Thankfully summer is almost here and my appetite will disappear with the cold weather. I can't wait to get back to normal.

Mirabai · 02/05/2023 14:20

@PurpleWisteria1

My argument is not referring to over eating and binge eating patterns - I’m talking about a healthy balanced diet. If people have to limit carbs to stop them over-eating them - that is a separate problem.

Pasta has existed in some form since ancient China, Greece and Africa. In Italy pasta goes back to the Etruscans - and by the early renaissance (13c) it was a staple - which is not far off 1000 years.

I don’t personally like pasta but eaten in reasonable quantities won’t do anyone harm. The problem is the explosion in quantities in which people eat them.

”Bread as we know it” has existed since the dawn of time. I’ve never eaten packet bread and it’s only one section of the market.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 02/05/2023 14:19

Wow, congratulations on your weight loss!! 💐

I believe that many people have issues in regards to body image.

Whether we look at insta models and their perfectly posed pics with the correct light etc. if they're "natural" (let's not even get into filters, touch ups etc) and hate ourselves for not looking like that.

Or we may look at very overweight people and don't even realise it anymore, yes.

However: I once read that overweight men have about the same amount of body confidence as women considered to be in the ideal bmi range! This is something that does seem to apply to the people I know (and am close enough to talk about this). I think that is something you (you =OP) and the rest of us should sometimes remember.

ShitFacedOnRetsina · 02/05/2023 14:18

It is now recognised that high cholesterol is a red herring and there is no documents that state that meat consumption is related to cancer. Communities that eat primarily meat or exclusively meat such as the Inuit and tribes in Africa that live on meat, blood and milk only, don't get dental problems, cancer or illnesses related to gut dysbiosis.

DragonScreeches · 02/05/2023 14:17

Kolakalia · 02/05/2023 14:10

That is really interesting. I'd be between a 12 and a 14 which seems about right to me and in line with clothes sizes as they were about 30 years ago. But these days I fit into 8, 10, 12 depending on the vanity of the shop sizing.

AskMeMore · 02/05/2023 14:17

YABU. You are fat.
Your DH loves you so of course he thinks you are beautiful.

Kolakalia · 02/05/2023 14:10

Onegingerhead · 02/05/2023 14:09

Anyone can comment on what shop/s don't do vanity sizing? I would really love to know what my real size is.

https://ukft.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/17111332/UKFT-International-Sizing-Chart.pdf
Better to measure yourself than try go by any shops.

https://ukft.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/17111332/UKFT-International-Sizing-Chart.pdf

PurpleWisteria1 · 02/05/2023 14:10

ShitFacedOnRetsina · 02/05/2023 13:53

People have eaten bread etc for a long time but the health of these people have steadily declined. They also don't eat the vast quantity of it that people in the west do. A portion of rice that comes with a Chinese dish would be three days worth to the average Japanese villager so we have the double whammy of it being a low nutrition food containing phytins that a lot of people cannot process and in vast quantity.

There is also the phenomenon of 'skinny fat' where people look relatively normal weight but have fatty livers and a huge amount of fat throughout their body but because they have no muscle, their BMI is low and they look relatively normal. This is widespread in India among the poorest people for example.

The Japanese and the like eat rice because it is easy to grow in their climate etc. but it is of relatively low nutritional value compared with the rest of their diet. Looking at just the rice consumption and assuming they are healthy doesn't cover half of what needs to be looked at.

If everyone ate meat in variety, veggies that grow above ground with the exception of legumes, cut their fruit and dairy consumption in half, stopped drinking and had extra virgin olive oil and ate a fair amount of animal fat, we would all be healthier. Everything is designed the opposite and it's all about money.

Completely agree. It’s a problem right at the top. Huge changes need to be made at the top levels or nothing will ever change! It’s worrying.

Enfys1982 · 02/05/2023 14:10

Five foot is very small for an adult though isn’t it? That’s childlike proportions. Most adults are much taller and would look horrendous if they were that thin. I’m 5’8 and would look like the walking dead. I’m a size ten to twelve. I know that makes me a right heifer in MN land but I run several times a week and am in good shape.

Onegingerhead · 02/05/2023 14:09

Anyone can comment on what shop/s don't do vanity sizing? I would really love to know what my real size is.

Swellinyewing · 02/05/2023 14:07

Enfys1982 · 02/05/2023 13:58

Its not normal or healthy to be a size four or six if you are a grown adult who has gone through puberty. Seriously if you are that emaciated I’d suggest getting urgent help.

My daughter is 23, 5 foot and a perfect size 6.

She is normal.
She is healthy.
She is not emaciated.

What a stupid statement.

Mirabai · 02/05/2023 14:06

ShitFacedOnRetsina · 02/05/2023 13:53

People have eaten bread etc for a long time but the health of these people have steadily declined. They also don't eat the vast quantity of it that people in the west do. A portion of rice that comes with a Chinese dish would be three days worth to the average Japanese villager so we have the double whammy of it being a low nutrition food containing phytins that a lot of people cannot process and in vast quantity.

There is also the phenomenon of 'skinny fat' where people look relatively normal weight but have fatty livers and a huge amount of fat throughout their body but because they have no muscle, their BMI is low and they look relatively normal. This is widespread in India among the poorest people for example.

The Japanese and the like eat rice because it is easy to grow in their climate etc. but it is of relatively low nutritional value compared with the rest of their diet. Looking at just the rice consumption and assuming they are healthy doesn't cover half of what needs to be looked at.

If everyone ate meat in variety, veggies that grow above ground with the exception of legumes, cut their fruit and dairy consumption in half, stopped drinking and had extra virgin olive oil and ate a fair amount of animal fat, we would all be healthier. Everything is designed the opposite and it's all about money.

Health has both improved and declined over time. Longevity now is far higher than in the past.

I’m not sure why you’re referencing apparently poor agricultural workers in China or Japan - millions live in cities with normal food consumption levels.

I didn’t comment on the healthiness of rice just pointing out that rice consumption doesn’t make people fat.

Im not sure why you’re proposing your apparent preferred diet as some kind of cure all. The link between red meat and cancer is well documented. As is the link between saturated animal fat and high cholesterol. Many people don’t like meat. Fruit is perfectly healthy in moderation and indeed forms a key part of the Mediterranean diet, which is generally regarded by medics as the most healthy.

PurpleWisteria1 · 02/05/2023 14:06

Tinybrother · 02/05/2023 14:02

i can’t tell if this is real or parody

if real you need to think about fucked-up you are to need fat people to say this to you before you will listen to them. I know you’ll just dismiss this (and you probably think I’m fat too, and therefore doubly dismissible), but just to state the message, this is a fucked-up way to think about fat people

But why? Arnt those things are true?
If someone gave you a magic wand and said if you wave this everyone on Earth will be in a healthy weight range now and forever wouldn’t you do it? If not why not?

PurpleWisteria1 · 02/05/2023 14:04

Mirabai · 02/05/2023 13:36

I really disagree and I think the demonising of carbs is part of a disordered approach to diet.

We all need carbs as part of a balanced diet. Refined and processed carbs are not good but complex carbs are absolutely fine and necessary.

Humanity has lived on bread, pasta and rice for around 1000 years and it had not previously led to obesity.

Indeed if you look at the size of Asian peoples - Chinese, Japanese, Korean, Indian - where the predominant grain is rice - it is clear that rice does not make people fat.

Low carb diets have become popular because people find weight loss easier on them. That’s fine, but a tool that is useful for short term weight loss should not be confused with an optimal healthy full time diet.

I will have to disagree for a couple of reasons.
Unprocessed carbs fine.
Even processed carbs are ok in small amounts. The problem is in 2023 generally we are not eating them in small amounts and that’s where your argument falls apart. In moderation. Yes but they are being consumed so far out of moderation it’s shocking.
Bread and pasta particularly where it’s not unusual for someone to have a wheat breakfast of cereal or toast, a sandwich or roll for lunch and then pizza or pasta for dinner. Added in with some biscuits or cake for dessert. Wheat wheat wheat. All day every day.
Rice may not make you put on weight as easily but if you know anything about nutrition, you will know that it is almost entirely empty of any goodness / nutrients and beside filling you up (which is why it’s been used for 1000’s years) it does nothing positive for your health.
The reason people in the countries you mentioned (who eat traditionally) have better health is the lack of high processed sugary factory make foods (and bread / pasta!) and the inclusion of far more fresh fish and vegetables than we have in western diets. It’s nothing to do with the nutritious content of rice.
oh and no, we haven’t been eating pasta for 1000’s years. Certainly in the Uk. It’s only become a heavy staple in the last 40 / 50 years or so. If you are over 40, it’s very unlikely that your grandmother would have been cooking pasta for dinner.
Bread as we know it has only been around since the invention of sliced bread 80- 100 years ago. Before that it was fresh baked bread and it certainly wasn’t eaten in the quantities we do today.
Besides which, the wheat that was used 100 year ago is not the same wheat as we eat now. The gluten level is raised making it worse for many people.

Tinybrother · 02/05/2023 14:02

Stravaig · 02/05/2023 12:51

If only all the people objecting on this thread were instead saying —

'I am overweight, I am obese, I am morbidly obese. It is harmful for me, it is harmful for my family, it is harmful for society. These are the ways I am taking responsiblity for tackling it.'

Then we might get somewhere. Instead we minimise and normalise and even glamourise unhealthy bodies. Anything to avoid facing reality.🤷‍♀️

i can’t tell if this is real or parody

if real you need to think about fucked-up you are to need fat people to say this to you before you will listen to them. I know you’ll just dismiss this (and you probably think I’m fat too, and therefore doubly dismissible), but just to state the message, this is a fucked-up way to think about fat people

Enfys1982 · 02/05/2023 13:58

Its not normal or healthy to be a size four or six if you are a grown adult who has gone through puberty. Seriously if you are that emaciated I’d suggest getting urgent help.

Cornchip · 02/05/2023 13:56

PracticallyFlooredZero · 02/05/2023 13:50

Before I had dc3 I lost 3 stone taking me down from almost obese to the upper end of a healthy BMI. Before I lost the weight lots of people told me I didn’t need to lose weight, that I looked fine. When I lost the weight I had lots of people telling me I was too skinny, I’d lost too much weight, almost begging me to stop. I was still the upper end of a healthy BMI! I think nowadays people see normal weight as skinny, overweight as normal and obese as a bit overweight.

Im overweight again after the birth of dc3. I want to get down to middle of a healthy BMI and I’m keeping quiet about it this time!

To be fair, I’ve noticed that more often than not people telling you that you’ve lost “too much weight” are often overweight themselves and it’s easier for their self esteem if everyone is overweight rather than just them.

Obviously this isn’t the case if you’re now underweight, but it’s an observation. Humans don’t tend to like seeing others do well, especially if your success is something that they see in themselves as a weakness.

It’s not just weight loss though. I see it all the time with promotions in work and whatnot. Some people can’t stand to see you do well so they’d try to put you off doing something that will enrich and further you. It’s easier for them if they can try to make you doubt yourself so you don’t apply for the job, rather than just being supportive.

Mirabai · 02/05/2023 13:55

I can see that’s very confusing OP. I would stick to what you know in your heart, what your scales and mirror tell you, and what the doctor says. Everything else can be filtered out.

As to the mode of weight loss - just go with what suits you. Whatever you’re doing is working well thus far, so if it ain’t broke don’t fix it. Some people seem to prefer to limit carbs some to limit protein - but it all boils down to eating less and moving around more.

Do have to say that your DH is a keeper!

ShitFacedOnRetsina · 02/05/2023 13:53

Mirabai · 02/05/2023 13:36

I really disagree and I think the demonising of carbs is part of a disordered approach to diet.

We all need carbs as part of a balanced diet. Refined and processed carbs are not good but complex carbs are absolutely fine and necessary.

Humanity has lived on bread, pasta and rice for around 1000 years and it had not previously led to obesity.

Indeed if you look at the size of Asian peoples - Chinese, Japanese, Korean, Indian - where the predominant grain is rice - it is clear that rice does not make people fat.

Low carb diets have become popular because people find weight loss easier on them. That’s fine, but a tool that is useful for short term weight loss should not be confused with an optimal healthy full time diet.

People have eaten bread etc for a long time but the health of these people have steadily declined. They also don't eat the vast quantity of it that people in the west do. A portion of rice that comes with a Chinese dish would be three days worth to the average Japanese villager so we have the double whammy of it being a low nutrition food containing phytins that a lot of people cannot process and in vast quantity.

There is also the phenomenon of 'skinny fat' where people look relatively normal weight but have fatty livers and a huge amount of fat throughout their body but because they have no muscle, their BMI is low and they look relatively normal. This is widespread in India among the poorest people for example.

The Japanese and the like eat rice because it is easy to grow in their climate etc. but it is of relatively low nutritional value compared with the rest of their diet. Looking at just the rice consumption and assuming they are healthy doesn't cover half of what needs to be looked at.

If everyone ate meat in variety, veggies that grow above ground with the exception of legumes, cut their fruit and dairy consumption in half, stopped drinking and had extra virgin olive oil and ate a fair amount of animal fat, we would all be healthier. Everything is designed the opposite and it's all about money.

Swellinyewing · 02/05/2023 13:52

I was a lot thinner and still had a ‘wide skeleton’. Is 8.5 stone at 5’6 an acceptable weight for you? Because that’s how much I once weighed, with my wide frame. I looked gaunt and ill because of my build vs my weight

It's actually at the very lower side or normal for your height.

So you are saying that you have a wide skeleton and are 5 ft 6 so someone who the exact same height and weight as you can look normal but you look literally like a wide skeleton...because you have a wide skeleton?

PracticallyFlooredZero · 02/05/2023 13:50

Before I had dc3 I lost 3 stone taking me down from almost obese to the upper end of a healthy BMI. Before I lost the weight lots of people told me I didn’t need to lose weight, that I looked fine. When I lost the weight I had lots of people telling me I was too skinny, I’d lost too much weight, almost begging me to stop. I was still the upper end of a healthy BMI! I think nowadays people see normal weight as skinny, overweight as normal and obese as a bit overweight.

Im overweight again after the birth of dc3. I want to get down to middle of a healthy BMI and I’m keeping quiet about it this time!

Botw1 · 02/05/2023 13:49

@SpringPop

Your oh can think you look lovely even if you're over weight and you don't