Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We’ve lost sight of what is a healthy weight

637 replies

SpringPop · 02/05/2023 08:16

Was chatting to my husband yesterday about getting to a healthy weight.

I am 5ft3 and at start of year I was weighing 80kg (12st 8)

I have hired a PT, workout 3 x weeklyand started eating healthy and now weigh around 72kg (11st 4). I’m not restricting food types or on any fad diet. I’m literally eating a balanced diet and the correct amount to lose up to 1lb a week.

I’ve done a decent start but still want to get to below 10stone where I would be a healthy weight for my height according to BMI.

I literally look like a ball in photos I took at the weekend. So fat.

He thinks I look great and lovely. Which is very kind. I literally don’t get how done people can’t see that I look fat. He’s not just being kind.

we got chatting and I Said to him that people we watch on tv that we think are “normal” (not underweight) and are similar height to me probably weigh between 8-9 stone therefore how could he not see I was overweight and not looking great.

AIBU to think no wonder we are quite an overweight nation. We equate 8stone/9stone as “skinny” but actually isn’t that healthy for someone who is just over 5ft? There should not be any shame in trying to reach a healthy weight. I kinda feel like we have lost sight of what is a healthy weight.

at 11stone/12stone, I’m not my healthiest, I’m not my fittest, I don’t look good. I’m opening myself up to more health conditions. Clothes make me look like a beach ball. I’m quite large chested and instead of making me look sexy/attractive, I just look ridiculous and almost ball shaped.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
VivatVaginaCamilla · 06/05/2023 18:45

@SpringPop I agree with you. I'm 5 foot 2 and a bit under 8 stone. I am not skinny. I'm slimmish. If I weighed 9 stone, I would not be 'normal' - I'd be overweight. People have absolutely lost sight of what normal is.

I also think a lot of women like to tell their overweight friends that they're "fine", because it makes them feel better about their own overweightness.

HowBeOn · 06/05/2023 18:36

I agree with you.

I am the same height as you and currently I am 9 stone 11, usually I’m 9 and a half but it’s been my birthday plus a few other events and general business so I’ve put on a few. Im at the very top end of my BMI, and am a pear so have pretty chunky wobbly thighs and bum, but also quite a big tummy at the moment. I try to be mindful of things like sugar and white carbs but whenever I decline a cake or a second helping of mash or whatever I get eye rolls, told how skinny I am, don’t need to worry about my weight etc. It’s so annoying. I’m not skinny, not at all. And I don’t ‘worry’ about it really - like I said, I’m mindful, but if I really want something I will have it, I just try my best to make good choices as much as I can. I do enjoy meals out, wine etc as much as the next person so I wouldn’t bother trying to get below my 9 and a half stone baseline as it’s not worth it to me- I am happy and healthy as I am. But I wish people would accept that and stop the constant comments! Going on holiday with a few of the culprits this year so I wonder if they will clock my flabby arse and spare tyre and think oh actually she isn’t half as skinny as we thought 😂

Well done you for losing the weight though, it is a real slog when everything is designed to tempt you but it sounds like you are doing great.

AskMeMore · 04/05/2023 17:49

My mother at 7 and a half stone for most of her life had type 2 diabetes. It might be rare but it happens. She got weary of every medic she saw expressing surprise at her diabetes. My brother developed type 2 as well, he is also slim.

Comedycook · 04/05/2023 16:50

Catspyjamas17 · 04/05/2023 16:43

If your BMI is 25 - 27, but you have low to normal blood pressure, cholesterol and blood sugar under control, healthy waist measurement to height ratio, eat a good, varied diet and take plenty of exercise, it is vanishingly unlikely that you will develop a weight-related health condition in the near future. If you have normal BMI but are apple shaped and your height to waist measurement ratio puts you into the unhealthy range, your blood pressure is high, you eat a poor unnutritious diet, your cholesterol is too high and you have blood sugar issues, it is much more likely that you will develop a health condition in the near future. Read a few proper medical articles. It ain't all about BMI.

Yes exactly. My dh has a healthy BMI...he has several medical conditions that are associated with being overweight. It's genetic for him.

Catspyjamas17 · 04/05/2023 16:43

If your BMI is 25 - 27, but you have low to normal blood pressure, cholesterol and blood sugar under control, healthy waist measurement to height ratio, eat a good, varied diet and take plenty of exercise, it is vanishingly unlikely that you will develop a weight-related health condition in the near future. If you have normal BMI but are apple shaped and your height to waist measurement ratio puts you into the unhealthy range, your blood pressure is high, you eat a poor unnutritious diet, your cholesterol is too high and you have blood sugar issues, it is much more likely that you will develop a health condition in the near future. Read a few proper medical articles. It ain't all about BMI.

TheOrigRights · 04/05/2023 16:14

just that BMI might not be the most accurate reflection of a person's weight/health. BMI doesn't take into account age, ethnicity, muscle v fat and various other things.

I don't think anyone is claiming BMI on its own is a reflection of health. It absolutely is a reflection of someone's weight. As I said above it's a tool to help give a picture of overall health.
It's quick, it's free, it's easily accessible.
It does take age and ethnicity into account.
Someone with a healthy BMI is less likely to have conditions associated with being over or underweight.

ferntwist · 04/05/2023 14:48

Aw he loves ya. You are right though OP about our perceptions having changed

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 04/05/2023 14:44

Comedycook · 04/05/2023 14:37

This was a good twenty years ago when I was in my early twenties...and I'm not going to be drawn into this nasty little discussion where you can make passive aggressive digs at me to insinuate I'm a greedy cow....I've seen how these threads go.

But suffice to say it was a normal meal...I didn't go to the chip shop and order one of everything.

But my point is I've been a healthy weight according to the BMI albeit at the top end and to achieve that I've had to skip meals. My friend has a healthy BMI...she slips breakfast and lunch.

I do wish people would stop making out that a healthy BMI is achievable so long as you're not a huge glutton.

I'm not going to be drawn into this nasty little discussion where you can make passive aggressive digs at me to insinuate I'm a greedy cow....I've seen how these threads go.

I'm not trying to draw you into or insinuate anything. I'm not interested in shaming anyone, as you can tell from my previous posts. You volunteered that you were overweight on one meal a day. The obvious next question is "what was it?"

You may be right, but without knowing a person's consumption, we simply don't know. Can't make any statements if we don't have all the information.

For whatever it's worth, although I don't think BMI is total bollocks, I also don't think it's the be all and end all. I think we should positively encourage good eating and exercise even if they don't make you slim, and I certainly don't believe you need a normal BMI to be attractive or live a great life.

Comedycook · 04/05/2023 14:37

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 04/05/2023 14:26

What was the meal?

This was a good twenty years ago when I was in my early twenties...and I'm not going to be drawn into this nasty little discussion where you can make passive aggressive digs at me to insinuate I'm a greedy cow....I've seen how these threads go.

But suffice to say it was a normal meal...I didn't go to the chip shop and order one of everything.

But my point is I've been a healthy weight according to the BMI albeit at the top end and to achieve that I've had to skip meals. My friend has a healthy BMI...she slips breakfast and lunch.

I do wish people would stop making out that a healthy BMI is achievable so long as you're not a huge glutton.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 04/05/2023 14:26

Comedycook · 04/05/2023 14:23

When your BMI is 25, you have a greater chance of developing weight-related health issues and the higher you go, the more likely it is

When my BMI was 25, I basically ate one meal a day. God knows how little I'd actually have to eat to get it lower

What was the meal?

Comedycook · 04/05/2023 14:23

When your BMI is 25, you have a greater chance of developing weight-related health issues and the higher you go, the more likely it is

When my BMI was 25, I basically ate one meal a day. God knows how little I'd actually have to eat to get it lower

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 04/05/2023 14:21

The NHS website accounts for how BMI varies for people from different ethnic groups and muscle being denser than fat. BMI requires a bit of context and obviously there are some outliers, like the All Blacks.

On the whole, though, it works on statistics. When your BMI is 25, you have a greater chance of developing weight-related health issues and the higher you go, the more likely it is.

BMI isn't an indicator of attractiveness or human worth. You can be beautiful and vivacious with a high BMI, or ugly and nasty with a normal one. But it's been kept around so long because statistically, it's a pretty good rough tool, especially when you contextualise it like the NHS does.

nhs.uk

BMI calculator | Check your BMI

Check your BMI and understand your result

https://www.nhs.uk/live-well/healthy-weight/bmi-calculator/

Comedycook · 04/05/2023 14:08

TillyTollyTully · 04/05/2023 14:03

BMI was invented in the 1830s by a mathematician. It's nonsense as far as I'm concerned

It's been adopted by the NHS and as someone said above, it's a bit of a blunt tool - but a very useful one to give a general overview.

Yet you, in all your wisdom, think it's nonsense. Riiigghhht. Have you contacted the NHS to let them know?

I'm sure that there are plenty of people walking around with a BMI of 30 that are just fine and dandy 🤔 Probably the ones who just have wide skeletons right?

No not just me... plenty of people see it as nonsense. That doesn't mean no one can be overweight of obese, just that BMI might not be the most accurate reflection of a person's weight/health. BMI doesn't take into account age, ethnicity, muscle v fat and various other things. It was devised apparently by looking at white men.

TillyTollyTully · 04/05/2023 14:03

BMI was invented in the 1830s by a mathematician. It's nonsense as far as I'm concerned

It's been adopted by the NHS and as someone said above, it's a bit of a blunt tool - but a very useful one to give a general overview.

Yet you, in all your wisdom, think it's nonsense. Riiigghhht. Have you contacted the NHS to let them know?

I'm sure that there are plenty of people walking around with a BMI of 30 that are just fine and dandy 🤔 Probably the ones who just have wide skeletons right?

Angelil · 04/05/2023 13:03

In terms of ‘naturally thin’: my MIL is petite/short and as thin as a rail. She’ll eat almost anything BUT tiny portions. She also actually doesn’t have that much of a sweet tooth naturally. I do think it’s always going to be easier for you if you just don’t like these foods.
My SIL is the same…very petite/short. Slim and athletic. Just doesn’t like sweet foods or even wine that much. Very small portions again.
My FIL on the other hand DOES enjoy sweet foods and will happily drink a few glasses of wine. He is taller and with a more athletic/stocky build and was very sporty when younger (both he and my husband were decent middle distance runners in their youth). HOWEVER, he now has acres of land to maintain and this is his main hobby and joy. He spends all day every day (including weekends and holidays) scrambling up terraces, pruning trees etc. Barely sits down except to eat and usually will fall asleep in front of the TV or over a book.
Finally my husband has been 63kg since he was 15 (he’s about 5’10”, for context). As mentioned he was quite athletic in his youth but he only occasionally does a bit of HIIT or Pilates on YouTube now…no sustained exercise regime at all BUT probably walks for 1-2 hours a day (to/from work plus to/from school when dropping off the eldest). People probably see him and think he works out loads to be that slim but he just doesn’t. He has a tendency towards high cholesterol despite this, but loses too much weight too fast if he tries to diet to correct it and he just doesn’t have the weight to lose. He will eat ANYTHING however and pretty much can constantly eat and it has no effect.
Our eldest son (age 4) has the exact same physique and has done from birth (never had any of those rolls of fat that most babies have and has always been a high percentile for height and low for weight). He also doesn’t much like sweet things (likes the idea of them but takes one nibble and is done! He likes dark chocolate but not icing on cakes, etc).

I on the other hand come from a much shorter/stockier family on average. I also have a demon of a sweet tooth and really have to rein it in (as mentioned, I am sure it is much easier if you just don’t enjoy these foods). I am semi-vegetarian and very active (gym, Pilates, cycling, walking, swimming…) but I also have PCOS and it is a constant struggle to stay under 10st (I am 5’6”). My sister OTOH is 5’4” and the outlier of our family…has always been TINY and despite eating like a horse (she LOVES food and is literally nicknamed the Family Feedbag) she naturally hovers between 8 and 9 stone. She did a 23AndMe thing and there was some sort of genetic marker indicated that basically explains why she is able to eat whatever she likes (I can’t remember what it is! But she is a scientist and interpreted all the data for me at the time).

so ‘naturally thin’? Of course there will always be environmental factors that make it easier or more difficult for some people. But by the same token there are genetic factors that do this as well. So on the whole I do think ‘naturally thin’ and ‘naturally fat’ are real things that do exist.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 04/05/2023 12:13

Comedycook · 04/05/2023 10:59

Actually there has been research done that suggests being very slightly overweight is actually beneficial....note, I say slightly overweight. Have a Google...it's quite interesting.

But anyway, if BMI is nonsense, which I think it is, then what is actually overweight? So a mathematician in 1830 came up with a calculation that said if the number hits 26, we're overweight...hmmm are we?

Well, time was that 27 was the cut off for being classed as overweight, so perhaps they will reconfigure it again one day. I have heard that those figures can be a little skewed by older, frail people who are near the end of their lives losing a lot of weight.

As for what is overweight, I'd say it's the point at which the increased health risks start appearing statistically. (You do concede that there comes a point where weight starts to make a difference to health, and that point begins long before you become really huge.) It doesn't mean that if your BMI is X then you WILL experience them, it just means that you are statistically more likely to.

Wanderingowl · 04/05/2023 12:13

As for the research, I've addressed that twice already on this thread. Actually read it. they studies themselves. None of them stand up to scrutiny. The main one discounts cancer as a cause of mortality. Cancer. You can't discount cancer from a study and then claim it means anything about human health. It's deliberate bullshit.

Wanderingowl · 04/05/2023 12:11

Comedycook · 04/05/2023 10:59

Actually there has been research done that suggests being very slightly overweight is actually beneficial....note, I say slightly overweight. Have a Google...it's quite interesting.

But anyway, if BMI is nonsense, which I think it is, then what is actually overweight? So a mathematician in 1830 came up with a calculation that said if the number hits 26, we're overweight...hmmm are we?

Unless you are very muscular odds are that you are overweight at 24 and 25 too. Your personal healthy weight range is somewhere between 18 and 25 but it isn't throughout it. For the majority of people it will be 20-21 or 21-22 but there are outliers who are naturally healthiest lower and higher than that, so the scale takes them into account. I'm considered very muscular, have large breasts/hips/bum and very dense bones (I got a dexa scan due to family osteoporosis). My ideal is currently about 23, anything above that and I visibly have excess fat. The vast, vast majority of women can take it that they are overweight with a BMI of 26.

TheOrigRights · 04/05/2023 11:39

So a mathematician in 1830 came up with a calculation that said if the number hits 26, we're overweight...hmmm are we?

Probably, yes. For my height there's a 3 stone range of healthy. It's likely that if you fall outside of that you are either over or underweight.

TheOrigRights · 04/05/2023 11:38

Comedycook · 04/05/2023 10:32

BMI was invented in the 1830s by a mathematician. It's nonsense as far as I'm concerned. Of course being hugely obese isn't healthy but do I believe I'm suddenly doomed if my BMI is 26 rather than 25.? no I do not.

You've misunderstood how to use BMI.
It's a tool to help give a picture of overall health.
It's quick, it's free, it's easily accessible.

Comedycook · 04/05/2023 10:59

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 04/05/2023 10:54

No, but BMI wouldn't say you're suddenly doomed at 26. It would just say that statistically, you are at a slightly elevated risk of certain conditions and the higher the score goes, the more that risk increases. If you're counting as overweight because you're actually incredibly muscular, you'll know. Most of us aren't.

It's not a perfect tool - it's a bit blunt - but it's not total bullshit.

Actually there has been research done that suggests being very slightly overweight is actually beneficial....note, I say slightly overweight. Have a Google...it's quite interesting.

But anyway, if BMI is nonsense, which I think it is, then what is actually overweight? So a mathematician in 1830 came up with a calculation that said if the number hits 26, we're overweight...hmmm are we?

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 04/05/2023 10:54

No, but BMI wouldn't say you're suddenly doomed at 26. It would just say that statistically, you are at a slightly elevated risk of certain conditions and the higher the score goes, the more that risk increases. If you're counting as overweight because you're actually incredibly muscular, you'll know. Most of us aren't.

It's not a perfect tool - it's a bit blunt - but it's not total bullshit.

Comedycook · 04/05/2023 10:32

BMI was invented in the 1830s by a mathematician. It's nonsense as far as I'm concerned. Of course being hugely obese isn't healthy but do I believe I'm suddenly doomed if my BMI is 26 rather than 25.? no I do not.

Swellinyewing · 04/05/2023 10:12

Booklover40 · 04/05/2023 09:35

No one is saying someone who's 5"6" and size 20 eats the same as a size 10 person. But someone with a larger frame and slower metabolism could eat the same as someone with a narrow frame and fast metabolism and there could easily be a few sizes - or a few points in bmi - difference.

Myself and my dsis are both 5"8". She takes after my dm and is slender, with small size 4 feet and thin ankles/wrists. Narrow frame. I'm more like the women on my df's side - wide shouldered and hipped, large hands and size 8 feet. Big boobs. I eat a healthy diet of 1200 calories a day and exercise and am 11 stone, size 10-12. It's really a lot of work for me to stay this size. Dsis eats junk food, never cooks a meal, drinks like a fish and takes no exercise but is a size 8 and struggles to gain weight(my dm is the exact same). So we are from the same gene pool and are wildly different.

Don't you look around you and see how everyone has different frames/sizes/holds fat & muscle in different places?

Of course people have different sized skeletons and organs/skin mass etc. Some people have very active lifestyles or a nervous energy that keeps their metabolism fast, others are more sedentary or may have health issues that make it harder to lose weight.

I don't understand why some people don't seem to get that we are not one homogenous mass who, if we only could be more like them, would be skinny too.

Ahh the wide skeleton again....

“Larger bones might account for a few pounds of weight but not 30 or 40,” “It's not going to be the difference between a healthy body mass index (BMI) and being overweight.”

Larger organs? Are you taking the piss?

Larger skin mass? How would the amount of skin that it takes to cover a 6 foot body differ in BMI than the amount of skin that covers a 5 foot body?

The average human skeleton will account for around 12%-15% of total body weight. So, a 200-pound man would have a skeletal weight of 24-30 pounds. A 150-pound woman has a skeletal weight of 18-22.5 pounds. Bone density refers to the concentration of minerals in your bones, yet dense bones may add only a few pounds to your frame. As an adult continually gains weight throughout life, it’s not because their bones become continually bigger and heavier.

An adult’s skeleton weighs more than a child’s. And a 7-foot person’s skeleton weighs more than a 6-foot person’s, who’s skeleton weighs more than a 5-foot person’s skeleton. Beyond this, people are not “big-boned.” The bones in people of the same height are relatively the same weight. Most people who weigh too much for their height typically do so because of excess body fat, though a more-muscular body does indeed weigh more than a less-muscular body.

Seventy-five percent of Americans are now either overweight or obese. Yet, most people aren’t body builders. Our national weight problem is a fat problem, unrelated to too much muscle or too much bone.

AskMeMore · 04/05/2023 10:10

My brother is slim, always has been. I am fat. He is a gamer who walks no further than from his sofa to his car. He also rarely seems to get hungry. He is the kind of person who forgets to eat. At times I do not want to eat but the strong hunger pangs make me eat.

Swipe left for the next trending thread