Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that there would be less anti private school

705 replies

Poopoolittlekitten · 02/05/2023 07:36

sentiment or threads on MN if people using private school were a tiny bit more self aware and didn’t ask for sympathy for rising fees or possible rising fees if Labour take away their false ‘charity’ status?

send your kid private if you want, just don’t come moaning about the costs or claim than anyone can go private if they ‘prioritise’ their child’s education they way you do. Particularly at a time when state school teachers are striking over pay and conditions.
And many, many people are working their socks off just to keep a roof over their family’s head.

YANBU - stop whining and looking for sympathy about your fees!

YABU - my milkman sends his 4 kids private by ‘prioritising’ their education so it’s not just for whiny poshos….

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
ichundich · 13/05/2023 08:41

lavenderlou · 13/05/2023 08:13

Personally I don't have an issue with parents choosing private schools if that's what they want, although systemically it would be better if we could have decent well-funded schools available to all.

I do find it annoying when some private school parents seem completely blind to their own privilege by making out that they are superior parents because they "sacrifice" foreign holidays and new cars to send their kids abroad when the vast majority of parents could (and do) "sacrifice" such things and still be nowhere near capable of affording private school things. They seem completely unaware of how other people live.

The hand-wringing about contextual offers is also irritating, as if they are being given to students of the leafy grammar school down the road rather than the reality of bright kids from far less privileged backgrounds who are probably equally or more capable than some of their private-school counterparts but have lacked educational and cultural opportunities because of the circumstances of their birth. As I said, excellent, properly-funded schools for all would be far preferable.

But what is the cost of the average foreign holiday these days? Anything between 2 and 6k, I would imagine. A new car costs 20k and over; even if you lease it it's around 4k per year. That's not nothing, and if you can afford those things you shouldn't moan about parents who would rather spend that money on education.

lavenderlou · 13/05/2023 08:13

Personally I don't have an issue with parents choosing private schools if that's what they want, although systemically it would be better if we could have decent well-funded schools available to all.

I do find it annoying when some private school parents seem completely blind to their own privilege by making out that they are superior parents because they "sacrifice" foreign holidays and new cars to send their kids abroad when the vast majority of parents could (and do) "sacrifice" such things and still be nowhere near capable of affording private school things. They seem completely unaware of how other people live.

The hand-wringing about contextual offers is also irritating, as if they are being given to students of the leafy grammar school down the road rather than the reality of bright kids from far less privileged backgrounds who are probably equally or more capable than some of their private-school counterparts but have lacked educational and cultural opportunities because of the circumstances of their birth. As I said, excellent, properly-funded schools for all would be far preferable.

Intergalacticcatharsis · 13/05/2023 08:09

It is the Labour’s party’s equivalent of Brexit for the Tories - the idea has been there since the 60s or even earlier. It is a way to get some of the far left in the party on board with Starmer’s other more centrist policies. Apparently it is “fully costed” which is rubbish.
Nobody gives a hoot about impact on children as a result of the policy. It is very much like Brexit and we all saw what happened there. It is not costed, it has not been thought through at all and it makes no sense on a rational level whatsoever.

CMZ2018 · 13/05/2023 07:17

Parents who send their children to private schools subsidise state education. Dry your eyes

Dobby123456 · 13/05/2023 07:15

AccountantMum · 12/05/2023 16:35

My daughter was in a state school and we moved her to an independent school in Year 3 and have since sent her younger brother and sister - it works so much better for her and our family she's happier, healthier and doing a lot better across the board.

I cannot understand why people who aren't using / don't want to use independent schools would come online to spend there spare time trying to get support to make it more difficult for children / families to have this opportunity or choice? All similar services have the same tax advantages I don't know why people feel so strongly about trying to remove this choice from some families.

Competition for opportunities is global not just in the UK - doesn't it make more sense to spend effort in trying to improve areas of education where there are issues instead of putting effort in to making it difficult for children who are happy where they are?

I can't see any real benefit to anyone but some children will be really negatively impacted if the changes you want go ahead

I have a friend who's a teacher who grew up in a different part of Europe. She's confused as to why people here see education as a competition. She claims where she grew up they were on this educational journey together. Children worked more in groups and not so exam focused. Here everybody worries about how we'll everybody else is doing and gets upset that they're not getting higher grades even though they didn't turn up to class.

AccountantMum · 12/05/2023 16:35

My daughter was in a state school and we moved her to an independent school in Year 3 and have since sent her younger brother and sister - it works so much better for her and our family she's happier, healthier and doing a lot better across the board.

I cannot understand why people who aren't using / don't want to use independent schools would come online to spend there spare time trying to get support to make it more difficult for children / families to have this opportunity or choice? All similar services have the same tax advantages I don't know why people feel so strongly about trying to remove this choice from some families.

Competition for opportunities is global not just in the UK - doesn't it make more sense to spend effort in trying to improve areas of education where there are issues instead of putting effort in to making it difficult for children who are happy where they are?

I can't see any real benefit to anyone but some children will be really negatively impacted if the changes you want go ahead

CurlewKate · 12/05/2023 15:48

@Intergalacticcatharsis Yep. "certain persons" who, having no principles themselves, automatically ascribe unpleasant self serving motives to anyone who does.

Intergalacticcatharsis · 12/05/2023 15:23

It is not a conspiracy theory at all. It has emanated from many a discussion with certain persons.

CurlewKate · 12/05/2023 14:59

@Intergalacticcatharsis Blimey-talk to
me about the other conspiracy theories you espouse!

Intergalacticcatharsis · 12/05/2023 14:37

In fact, I am increasingly thinking this whole anti private school thing is an attack by the cultural elite on the aspirational types who happened to have made some money and can send their DC to private schools these days, whilst many of the former can no longer afford to do so. And are not even being offered bursaries.

It is being sold as pro equality but it is in fact the opposite when you dwell deeper. Especially in places like London where independent schools are full of driven children from Asian communities.

Intergalacticcatharsis · 12/05/2023 13:48

We are happy with state because we did 11 plus and went to church.

Friends who were themselves privately educated but can’t now afford it for their own DC but chose “ethical” jobs in eg ehem journalism, charity sector, public sector, NHS etc tend to be the most vocal anti private school ones. Because their DC do struggle to fit in some state schools even the posher comps especially in London. I kind of understand why they are annoyed. However, I was also told by the same persons that I was scarring my DC mentally for making them go to church and do 11 plus. Plus I was also told at uni I was selling out for going to a corporate law firm.

Honestly, if anyone in the above category tells me one more time they are anti private schools, I will tell them it isn’t too late to retrain as a lawyer and go do 12-14 hour days.
Plus anyone complaining who is clever enough to tutor at home or hire tutors to get to GCSE level also needs to check their privilege. Many successful schools are selective at Sixth Form anyway so if your DC does well, move or move them!

NNat · 12/05/2023 13:23

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request

Barbadossunset · 12/05/2023 13:07

This is what it boils down to. A lot of posters on here would be happy just to tax the private sector out of existence just so everyone is equal.

Yes. I wonder how they would prevent children from being sent to school abroad since there are a number of public schools which have opened schools overseas, or home schooled.

Another76543 · 12/05/2023 09:26

grass321 · 12/05/2023 08:35

You do not need to attack private schools to improve state education. The top 5% of the country (1.6 million) with income of £70,000 or above pay 48% of all tax in the U.K. That includes those evil private school parents who are paying for an education they're not actually using.

Inequality in society is ultimately a function of wealth. The state school parents I know can also afford music lessons, private tutoring and educational resources. There's plenty of privilege way beyond private schools.

And your solution is to put pressure on already creaking state school budgets and create an influx of ex private school kids? It might initially feel good if you're a green-eyed type but it would be a hollow victory if the quality of education suffers.

It might initially feel good if you're a green-eyed type but it would be a hollow victory if the quality of education suffers.

This is what it boils down to. A lot of posters on here would be happy just to tax the private sector out of existence just so everyone is equal. They would be happy to drag everyone down to the same level rather than trying to pull everyone up to a better level. As long as everyone is “equal” it doesn’t seem to matter if that level of equality offers a poor level of education. It’s no wonder the UK economy is falling behind others with this kind of attitude.

I can’t understand why people aren’t as vocal about trying to improve the state system for 93% of children as they are about dismantling the private system for the 7%. If the state system was improved, people are less likely to want to use the private sector.

grass321 · 12/05/2023 08:35

You do not need to attack private schools to improve state education. The top 5% of the country (1.6 million) with income of £70,000 or above pay 48% of all tax in the U.K. That includes those evil private school parents who are paying for an education they're not actually using.

Inequality in society is ultimately a function of wealth. The state school parents I know can also afford music lessons, private tutoring and educational resources. There's plenty of privilege way beyond private schools.

And your solution is to put pressure on already creaking state school budgets and create an influx of ex private school kids? It might initially feel good if you're a green-eyed type but it would be a hollow victory if the quality of education suffers.

ichundich · 12/05/2023 08:26

izimbra · 11/05/2023 20:04

"if both Alleyn and Charter School North Dulwich are correctly identified by the previous posters and you see that Alleyn offers superior education to the one your kids receive - have you tried applying via bursary route?"

My son is extremely hard working. He has good teachers. He's intelligent. He's well supported by me. He's predicted 3A's at A level, and if he gets them he's earned them in fair competition to the other 93% of A level students in the UK.

Why do you think me paying/someone else paying, for my already extremely lucky son to have a massive and very expensive educational leg up would somehow extinguish my ethical objections the deep unfairness towards children that private schools represent?

It's so bizarre. It's like people have a massive blind spot on this issue.

So you live in Dulwich, with tons of educational, employment, arts, sports facilities, great transport, easy connections to the rest of the world. A lot of us have had to move out of London and even the London commuter belt because it has become unaffordable. Some of the money we've since been saving we are spending on our kids' education. Not sure who is more privileged here.

Spendonsend · 12/05/2023 08:20

izimbra · 11/05/2023 22:02

"Eton advertise 1250 music lessons a week with 78 music teachers providing them."

Unimaginable levels of privilege.

Its not that unimaginable.

I can imagine each boy at the school having one instrument lesson a week and this isnt even each boy at the school as they have more pupils that that. Theres probably some boys learning two instruments or voice and others learning none.

Another76543 · 12/05/2023 08:02

Poopoolittlekitten · 12/05/2023 07:45

‘A lot of professional musicians, for example, also rely on teaching in private schools’

and a lot of parents who children are state educated also pay for their child to leant to play music. As do schools.
it’s sweet that you’re worried about the staff of private schools but taking away charity stairs shouldn’t actual affect them.

So those privileged children at state school whose parents are lucky enough to be able to afford music fees (or where the state funds it) wouldn’t have VAT levied on their music fees, but those at private school would?

Poopoolittlekitten · 12/05/2023 07:45

‘A lot of professional musicians, for example, also rely on teaching in private schools’

and a lot of parents who children are state educated also pay for their child to leant to play music. As do schools.
it’s sweet that you’re worried about the staff of private schools but taking away charity stairs shouldn’t actual affect them.

OP posts:
BibbleandSqwauk · 12/05/2023 07:27

@izimbra but what money? Fee paying parents already contribute the tax they're going to. The government already have it. At the moment, as it's not needed for Johnny's state school it's being spent elsewhere on being lumped in to pay for Freddie's state schooling. If Johnny also then joins the state school, where does the extra come from? The biggest fallacy about this whole argument is that abolishing private schools or massively impacting them with VAT will improve state education for all. It might achieve a levelling down goal of "fair but a bit crap" for many, but will fail utterly in achieving what some people seem to think it will that suddenly all state schools will be awash with cash, more teachers and motivated kids and parents who will have a transformative effect. I'm not saying all state schools are a bit crap, or that no stare pupils are motivated, of course that is not the case and there are many who outperform fee paying schools but that is not the only concern. Ultimate outcome is not why I am beggaring myself to keep mine in private, but the safe and small, nurturing environment they need. When the state can provide that I'll happily use it.

Intergalacticcatharsis · 12/05/2023 07:09

“We're in competition with other countries that manage to produce educated people. We need to put the effort into actually educating, rather than 'levelling' the next generation.”

Totally agree with this point. We need to make sure those who struggle are given extra attention to achieve a basic level of education, but we also need to make sure that those are really able are suitably stretched. Every child deserves to reach their full potential academically at school and should not be shamed or failed if their full potential is at either end. I think the private sector is better at dealing with some of this so why attack it if there are parents in it willing to pay?

Ladykryptonite · 12/05/2023 06:49

Or just do both

Dobby123456 · 12/05/2023 06:46

izimbra · 11/05/2023 20:04

"if both Alleyn and Charter School North Dulwich are correctly identified by the previous posters and you see that Alleyn offers superior education to the one your kids receive - have you tried applying via bursary route?"

My son is extremely hard working. He has good teachers. He's intelligent. He's well supported by me. He's predicted 3A's at A level, and if he gets them he's earned them in fair competition to the other 93% of A level students in the UK.

Why do you think me paying/someone else paying, for my already extremely lucky son to have a massive and very expensive educational leg up would somehow extinguish my ethical objections the deep unfairness towards children that private schools represent?

It's so bizarre. It's like people have a massive blind spot on this issue.

Blind spot, or maybe a recognition that dragging everybody else down isn't going to make the system more fair. My friend went to a selective private school on auric scholarship. Her brother went to the local comprehensive. He would have hated the pressure of the selective school. Is that unfair?

My neighbours send their dyslexic child to a private school because he was being bullied at the state. Their other children are still at the state school, doing well. Is that unfair?

We're in competition with other countries that manage to produce educated people. We need to put the effort into actually educating, rather than 'levelling' the next generation.

izimbra · 11/05/2023 22:02

"Eton advertise 1250 music lessons a week with 78 music teachers providing them."

Unimaginable levels of privilege.

izimbra · 11/05/2023 21:54

"Who is going to fund schemes like this? It’s not as if state schools are awash with funds."

They'd have more money if they had more students, as the money follows the child.

Falling rolls are a growing financial problem for London schools in particular.

https://schoolsweek.co.uk/school-places-londons-challenge-could-soon-be-everyones/

London's school places challenge should worry everyone

A new report reveals that a surplus of school places could cause massive disruption to London's schools, says Ian Edwards, and a policy vacuum only risks making it worse

https://schoolsweek.co.uk/school-places-londons-challenge-could-soon-be-everyones

Swipe left for the next trending thread