Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that there would be less anti private school

705 replies

Poopoolittlekitten · 02/05/2023 07:36

sentiment or threads on MN if people using private school were a tiny bit more self aware and didn’t ask for sympathy for rising fees or possible rising fees if Labour take away their false ‘charity’ status?

send your kid private if you want, just don’t come moaning about the costs or claim than anyone can go private if they ‘prioritise’ their child’s education they way you do. Particularly at a time when state school teachers are striking over pay and conditions.
And many, many people are working their socks off just to keep a roof over their family’s head.

YANBU - stop whining and looking for sympathy about your fees!

YABU - my milkman sends his 4 kids private by ‘prioritising’ their education so it’s not just for whiny poshos….

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Another76543 · 26/08/2023 12:44

BibbleandSqwauk · 26/08/2023 12:07

@Lessonstobe so you've extrapolated from your experience of what one school does to assert that "they don't" in relation to charity status. If I post the long list of what my school does with local state schools for free can I then say "yes they do"? Every single thread on this topic just ends up being a mass of anecdata and individual experiences used to try and prove some sort of objective point.

Exactly. Some people are very quick to say that private schools don’t share facilities/teachers etc when this is categorically untrue for some private schools (obviously I can’t speak for all private schools - and in case, many private schools aren’t charities anyway).

BibbleandSqwauk · 26/08/2023 12:07

@Lessonstobe so you've extrapolated from your experience of what one school does to assert that "they don't" in relation to charity status. If I post the long list of what my school does with local state schools for free can I then say "yes they do"? Every single thread on this topic just ends up being a mass of anecdata and individual experiences used to try and prove some sort of objective point.

Lessonstobe · 26/08/2023 11:49

Posted this on a thread about someone complaining that teachers at their DCs private’s school got a discount in fees for their own kids… just as relevant here re charity status:

Interesting article in today’s TImes regarding the claims that private schools should have charity status because they share facilities with state schools and are a ‘benefit’ …

However instead of asking the private schools - they surveyed the state schools instead…

spoiler - they don’t. They rent out some facilities for ££ or use things like a shared Xmas concert or football match to claim they ‘work’ with local
schools.

I have experienced this - kids did a music concert with local private school at a local church and the photos ended up in a newsletter heralding the ‘partnership’ between our schools. There is no partnership. This is the only time there was ever a joint event. Our choir went, their choir went, everyone performed separately..

also have a very famous private school invite our girls to play a football match - a friendly as we play other state schools in the county league, they only play other private schools.
Afterwards they wanted photos etc of the kids all together, we declined.
we don’t do it for other matches and we certainly weren’t going to do it so they could pop that one in their next prospectus either as proof of ‘community’ involvement.

Lessonstobe · 25/08/2023 22:52

‘People are anti private school because the establishment is anti private school.’

The establishment who overwhelmingly went to private schools are now anti- private school? Which is why they now send their kids to the same private schools?
that post absolutely makes sense 😅

Fivethirtyeight · 25/08/2023 18:30

Summerwashout · 25/08/2023 18:23

@Fivethirtyeight
F

Totally agree, parents and children are the customers

Op we are weighing up private schools out of desperation because one dc has some sen and our salary can't cover it, we would have to pool at remortgage or something.
I would have every right to post here "moaning" about labour messing with fees whens schools can still not accommodate sen

Difficult situation. Good luck.
My friend considering online education for similar reasons.

Summerwashout · 25/08/2023 18:23

@Fivethirtyeight
F

Totally agree, parents and children are the customers

Op we are weighing up private schools out of desperation because one dc has some sen and our salary can't cover it, we would have to pool at remortgage or something.
I would have every right to post here "moaning" about labour messing with fees whens schools can still not accommodate sen

Fivethirtyeight · 25/08/2023 18:04

Scaevola · 25/08/2023 17:52

What is a pity, despite the number of threads about it, is that people don't grasp that charitable status (which not all private schools have) is worth about £200 per pupil per head. If it could be easily relinquished, without winding up the charity (selling major assets at proper market rates and donating proceeds to another similarly aimed charity). If there is a new proposal on how this would be effected - because allowing charity assets to just be converted to private ownership is a very slippery slope indeed, almost a charter for abuse - but removing the provision of education as a charitable aim (as is the current legal provision, and alteration of which would impact on all charities which provide education)

VAT on fees is unrelated to charitable status. Since BREXIT, we can set our own sales tax and are no longer bound by "no taxation on education" which is the EU stance.

Both Labour and some elements within the Tory party are in favour of VAT on fees, so I think that will come in. It's just a question of when and at what rate. And what happens to nursery and university fees (currently rely on same exemption)

You are right. But people aren’t going to get that because those who raise the issue don’t want them to think about it.

Tax benefits were removed from ALL charities then schools being charities would stop being an issue.

But then lots of talking heads enjoy the status of working for tax advantages employers who advocate for more tax for everyone else.

Scaevola · 25/08/2023 17:52

What is a pity, despite the number of threads about it, is that people don't grasp that charitable status (which not all private schools have) is worth about £200 per pupil per head. If it could be easily relinquished, without winding up the charity (selling major assets at proper market rates and donating proceeds to another similarly aimed charity). If there is a new proposal on how this would be effected - because allowing charity assets to just be converted to private ownership is a very slippery slope indeed, almost a charter for abuse - but removing the provision of education as a charitable aim (as is the current legal provision, and alteration of which would impact on all charities which provide education)

VAT on fees is unrelated to charitable status. Since BREXIT, we can set our own sales tax and are no longer bound by "no taxation on education" which is the EU stance.

Both Labour and some elements within the Tory party are in favour of VAT on fees, so I think that will come in. It's just a question of when and at what rate. And what happens to nursery and university fees (currently rely on same exemption)

Fivethirtyeight · 25/08/2023 17:45

People are anti private school because the establishment is anti private school.

Nothing to do with the behaviour of anyone.

Fivethirtyeight · 25/08/2023 17:42

Poopoolittlekitten · 02/05/2023 18:14

'Let me take the opportunity to remind you that a healthy independent education sector is a corner stone of a free and liberal society, helping to keep the insidious creep of authoritarianism at bay'

Now that did me laugh 😂

The poster you quote is exactly right.

Govt interfering in education is the most important problem in society today.

Obedience training is good for Govt but bad for citizens (sod being a subject).

Monopolies are always bad. Yes Govt education is a monopoly because most can’t afford to go elsewhere.

Education is the worst monopoly because it’s about control. The Jesuit’s famously knew that.

The parent and the child should be customers, not supplicants, and should be treated as such.

ALL charities should lose tax free status, not just schools. Tax free status for charities is abusive, like tax free aristocrats in pre revolutionary France.

nameitagain · 25/08/2023 17:24

This is just stupid. So no one can complain about their pimple as someone rise suffers from having a facial deformity. Can't complain about their car breaking down because other people don't have the luxury of owning a car. How dare their be a thread about people parking across a driveway when there we people who would only dream of living in a house with a driveway. Ffs. MN is not for only certain socioeconomic groups. If you don't like hearing about someone's 5 star holiday because you can barely afford to go camping then scroll on that thread isn't for you. But it is for others on here. Sheesh. It's not all about you.

Lessonstobe · 25/08/2023 17:09

‘Private school isn't just for 'posh' people’

Mostly though…

Poopoolittlekitten · 28/07/2023 13:15

‘Literally every week it's the same thread / same axe to grind under the guise of a slightly different title.’

no grinding of axes. But it is a frequent topic here for obvious reasons.
just be thankful that it’s not another dog thread…

OP posts:
Fairislefandango · 20/07/2023 20:06

I think the moaning and complaining about fees and the endless 'Whatever shall we do!?' posts are certainly not helping...

But it's irrelevant. Either you're against private schools or you're not. If you're not, then people being a bit pissed off about fees going up is no different from people being a bit pissed off about anything expensive that they are used to being able to afford (which you maybe aren't able to afford). I own a house. If my mortgage payments went up a lot, I'd be pissed off about it. Am I not allowed to say that, on the grounds that not everyone can afford to buy a house?

threemiaowingfaces · 20/07/2023 20:00

Literally every week it's the same thread / same axe to grind under the guise of a slightly different title.

Poopoolittlekitten · 20/07/2023 18:24

' I'm pretty sure that the reason most anti-private-school people are against private schools is because they are against the whole principle of their existence, not because some people moan about fee increases.'

I think the moaning and complaining about fees and the endless 'Whatever shall we do!?' posts are certainly not helping...

OP posts:
TotalllyTireddd · 20/07/2023 17:00

I haven't read the full thread. Got as far as page 3 on my phone and was completely confused! I don't really understand the post or many subsequent ones really!! (and I have a PhD and experienced both state and private!!)

I guess everyone can do what they like! But you do sound a wee bit bitter/rude/angry. Not a great advert for the benefits of state education really..

(my children aren't going private, but I respect the choices of my friends who are sending theirs. And actually, in some ways, I do think private are better - mainly in the extra curricular activities they can offer. But I don't think the solution is the status quo - rather I think state schools should be better funded so they can provide equality of opportunity re extra curricular...)

Fairislefandango · 20/07/2023 16:30

YABU. I'm pretty sure that the reason most anti-private-school people are against private schools is because they are against the whole principle of their existence, not because some people moan about fee increases.

Tulips2507 · 20/07/2023 15:53

Private school isn't just for 'posh' people. Fees outside of London can be just over 10k a year, which is still a lot of money but affordable to many average middle class families. And a large proportion of kids at private schools are on bursaries/scholarships, including those from less well off backgrounds/state schools who wouldn't otherwise be able to go to private school. So YABU to believe all private schools are for the rich and privileged.

tennesseewhiskey1 · 20/07/2023 15:52

this has been done to DEATH. Why cant we just continue on that one....

bogoffeternal · 20/07/2023 15:44

Poopoolittlekitten · 02/05/2023 07:36

sentiment or threads on MN if people using private school were a tiny bit more self aware and didn’t ask for sympathy for rising fees or possible rising fees if Labour take away their false ‘charity’ status?

send your kid private if you want, just don’t come moaning about the costs or claim than anyone can go private if they ‘prioritise’ their child’s education they way you do. Particularly at a time when state school teachers are striking over pay and conditions.
And many, many people are working their socks off just to keep a roof over their family’s head.

YANBU - stop whining and looking for sympathy about your fees!

YABU - my milkman sends his 4 kids private by ‘prioritising’ their education so it’s not just for whiny poshos….

Yes, you are being completely and utterly unreasonable. It's difficult to imagine how entitled you must be to expect others to self-sensor based on whether their socio-economic status conforms to your arbitrary definition which I suspect was based on little more than 'anyone better-off than me'.

bogoffeternal · 20/07/2023 15:31

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 02/05/2023 08:19

I'm amused at all of the posters coming on to tell the OP how boring/tedious her thread is.

Other threads are available if you don't like this one!Grin

The OP is literally moaning about how people discuss things in other threads she doesn't like yet you have no similar advice for her?

Poopoolittlekitten · 17/05/2023 13:14

'I don't mind a 50% payrise if they stop packing the private schools with special needs kids who might slow progress down. '

er, okay. So double the fees you pay just get rid of any SEN kids back into State? nice. Is that you Rees-Mogg??

OP posts:
Intergalacticcatharsis · 17/05/2023 13:06

“We are n't in the EU anymore - and taking away fake charity status isn't the same as levying VAT.”

You don’t need to take away charitable status. You can encourage the hurdle to keep charitable status to become higher - that benefits the local community and the spirit of going more local.

It isn’t a good time to a send a message to the rest of the world that the UK is attacking its already struggling education sector - in a way that is very atypical for a country like the UK. It just means less talent from Asia and Africa will arrive to fill our e.g. vacancies for doctors in the NHS and in tech. Those persons will not take kindly to education not being valued in a country. And that is essentially what this will translate to. And actual attack by government on the private sector.

As you point out @Poopoolittlekitten - private schools are already raising fees etc. Why mount an actual attack on them when the solution is to improve state education, value and pay teachers more, help kids with SEN properly, lower the size of classes. ACTUALLY INVEST IN OUR CHILDREN’S FUTURE. ENSURE THE NHS MEETS THE NEEDS OF CHILDREN. It is not all down to schools. Many people will have put their struggling children into the private sector because of the pandemic. Do not attack these people, it is not going to be worth it.

Poopoolittlekitten · 17/05/2023 10:57

'Levying VAT on school fees would have been a contravention of directly applicable EU law so none of our neighbours do it.'

We are n't in the EU anymore - and taking away fake charity status isn't the same as levying VAT.

Even a lot of Tories think that giving private schools 'charity' status is taking the piss, but I do understand why parents paying fees would prefer not to have to pay more.
It's up to the schools though. They charge what they like - and fees are rising anyway.

OP posts: