Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that there would be less anti private school

705 replies

Poopoolittlekitten · 02/05/2023 07:36

sentiment or threads on MN if people using private school were a tiny bit more self aware and didn’t ask for sympathy for rising fees or possible rising fees if Labour take away their false ‘charity’ status?

send your kid private if you want, just don’t come moaning about the costs or claim than anyone can go private if they ‘prioritise’ their child’s education they way you do. Particularly at a time when state school teachers are striking over pay and conditions.
And many, many people are working their socks off just to keep a roof over their family’s head.

YANBU - stop whining and looking for sympathy about your fees!

YABU - my milkman sends his 4 kids private by ‘prioritising’ their education so it’s not just for whiny poshos….

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
izimbra · 08/05/2023 18:02

"So, all these “spoon-fed” privately educated children with immoral, selfish parents are going to improve the state schools if they move to them?"

First off - the most powerful and influential people within the establishment of this country are deeply invested in maintaining the currently hideously unfair education system, because by and large their children benefit from it.

And that includes many people on the left, particularly in the arts and media.

So it won't change.

And it won't change because it's not just about schools. It's about wider society and the economy. The UK is a very, very unequal country. Socially. Economically. Geographically.

We have vast and growing wealth inequality, and vast and growing health inequality.

And our education system is an expression of that.

But at the very least we shouldn't be bolstering educational inequality through our tax system. Private schools should not have charitable status.

And for those people arguing that it'll cost the tax payer more if some kids leave private schools because their parents can no longer pay fees - well state schools in most of the SE and SW are currently experiencing falling rolls, which is impacting negatively on school budgets and in some places resulting in schools having to close. More pupils = more money, because the money follows the child.

And more middle class kids pushes schools up local league tables, which in makes it easier for a school to recruit and maintain quality staff. Schools are communities - children don't just benefit from the input of teachers, they also learn from each other. The more social and educational capital there is in the student body, the faster the pace of learning. In addition middle class parents raise money for schools and contribute to running of the school through their voluntary work. https://www.theguardian.com/education/2019/jul/14/wealthy-parents-stoke-school-divide

Revealed: how wealthy parents widen cash gap between state schools

Huge sums are raised by PTAs in affluent areas but headteachers in less well-off districts still struggle for funds

https://www.theguardian.com/education/2019/jul/14/wealthy-parents-stoke-school-divide

Barbadossunset · 08/05/2023 18:01

Izimbra what else do you think should be banned on grounds of unfairness?

izimbra · 08/05/2023 17:47

"What has made you so certain that your opinion is right that you can't bring yourself to keep an open mind?"

Oh please - go ahead and explain the justice you see in the best supported, financially best off and usually most able children having vastly more resources invested in their education than 93% of other children.

Please.

Endlesssummer2022 · 08/05/2023 17:21

I do agree with a lot of the latter posts and said as much earlier on. You can punish the private school sector as much as you want but that won’t fix anything. There’s a large anti education element in the UK.

I’ve said earlier in the thread that I have DC in both state and private. One reason I moved one of them to private is there was a large cohort of parents apparently obsessed with kids playing. All attempts by the school to get the kids to do more homework were met with furious WhatsApps about ‘playing’. It’s my view that there is plenty of time for children to play over 24hrs. I don’t send my kids to school to play. I send them to be educated. I supported the school and DC did all of their homework but I was made to feel like a freak by some of the parents so I moved DC1 to a private school. Since then I’ve had many a snipe about DC1 being at a private school and some of those presents are probably on here campaigning to make it more expensive in order to punish me for my choices. It’s ridiculous.

I’m half 1st generation British (one immigrant parent). I know from my DM what it is to genuinely have nothing. So many multi gen native Brits don’t know how good they have it and are so willing to waste it. At school I was called a ‘boff’ because I wanted to learn and some of those same people who laughed at me for being a boff complain that people like me have more than them. I don’t want the same for my DC.

The developing worlds children will not skip a beat and those are the kids my kids will have to compete with for good jobs. They will be studying during the day and playing at the weekend and a bit after school. Homework will be done and I want the school and teachers to have the same high expectations I do.

threemiaowingfaces · 08/05/2023 16:47

I do agree that there are cultural (as well as economic) factors at play here. I was not born British, my DH came here very young (his family were asylum seekers). Its no coincidence that a huge proportion of children in the most selective London schools (state and independent) are Indian or SE Asian. In fact, I would say hardly any children have two white British parents.

I do think there is a general malaise / blame culture in the U.K. and I'm not sure what can be done about it. Maybe it's a side effect of a declining Western nation as other countries are overtaking. When my DD (briefly) attended a London comp, the teachers were so busy dealing with 'attendance targets' (and obnoxious, disinterested parents), you would think that was all there was to school - just managing to show up! Getting 8 GCSEs at 4 and above was seen as 'success'. They put reasonably able children in the 'gifted and talented' stream - they still came out with 6s and maybe the odd 7. How is it helpful to tell children they are 'gifted and talented' when they are just broadly average. So many kids have reasons they can't sit exams or attend certain lessons - 'mental health,' 'micro aggressions' and god knows what. Teachers were more like social workers and constantly having to pander to all this, with no support from families.

I remember the first state primary I looked at when DD was 4. The head said, 'I'll have to let you out the back exit because we have issues with vicious dogs at the main gate." She also said, 'If you do have the means to go elsewhere, I would explore those options..' That was the head!

whumpthereitis · 08/05/2023 16:18

Barbadossunset · 08/05/2023 16:05

the government can try to remove charitable status, but doing so is not only unlikely to succeed, but cost a substantial amount in regards to time and (public) money.

I agree but if it’s a class war issue then Labour don’t care how much time and money is wasted.

I don’t actually think there is the political will there to see it though. Keir Starmer knows he has to play to the base (see the vote in January, that he knew full well Labour would lose. Great optics though), but he’s a long way from being Jeremy Corbyn. He’s already walked back his statement on private schools in part, and explicitly praised their existence.

Barbadossunset · 08/05/2023 16:05

the government can try to remove charitable status, but doing so is not only unlikely to succeed, but cost a substantial amount in regards to time and (public) money.

I agree but if it’s a class war issue then Labour don’t care how much time and money is wasted.

Intergalacticcatharsis · 08/05/2023 14:55

https://journals.lww.com/apjoo/Fulltext/2022/02000/China_Turns_to_School_Reform_to_Control_the_Myopia.6.aspx

“There is now indisputable evidence of an epidemic of myopia and high myopia in parts of East and Southeast Asia, including mainland China, Hong Kong and Macau, Chinese Taipei (commonly called Taiwan), South Korea, Japan, and Singapore. In these locations, around 80% of students completing secondary schooling are myopic and need correction, while 10% to 20% of them are highly myopic,2,5,6 and are thus at high risk of developing potentially blinding pathological myopia.”

Too much reading, including of music, hours spent indoors, not enough time in daylight is detrimental to children’s sight.

So no, we should not be copying China in that regard.

Another76543 · 08/05/2023 14:53

Dobby123456 · 08/05/2023 14:17

Are you suggesting that getting an education involves actual effort?? Don't be ridiculous. The only way to get an education in this country is buy one that's 'spoon fed' to you. Nobody else has any chance at all - and that's ALL down to the immoral, unaware, selfish people who send their kids to private school because they just DON'T CARE about everybody else's children and want to buy their own children an ADVANTAGE! If they sent their own children to state school, the state schools would all improve because education is something you breathe in through the air.

So, all these “spoon-fed” privately educated children with immoral, selfish parents are going to improve the state schools if they move to them?

whumpthereitis · 08/05/2023 14:53

Intergalacticcatharsis · 08/05/2023 14:33

whumpthereitis - some private schools will voluntarily give up charitable status if they are whacked separately with a 20 VAT bill.

And the court cases would commence. it isn’t as simple as ‘adding VAT’ and/or ‘removing charitable status’.

————————-

Also interesting to read:

“This paper has shown that the removal of charitable status from “private” independent schools and/or the redistribution of their assets to other schools may be possible, but would be fraught with legal difficulties. It would clearly require legislation, and fundamental changes to the law of charity, the law of property and/or the legal status of at least some existing non-”private” schools as well as “private” ones themselves. It may also violate the European Convention on Human Rights, particularly if the removal of charitable status and/or redistribution of assets would in substance prevent independent schools’ continued operation. But the ECHR implications are not, according to the analysis undertaken in this paper, nearly as clear-cut as some previous commentators have suggested. If any future Government (Labour or otherwise) were to remain wedded both to a policy of redistributing schools’ assets and to one of remaining a party to the Convention, that Government would in any case have to act very cautiously indeed.
The removal of certain benefits of charitable status, falling fairly considerably short of removing the status altogether, would be significantly easier, in the sense that it would necessitate fewer fundamental changes charity or education law and reduce the scope for challenge. But it would still require legislation and risk violating the European Convention unless carried out very carefully. Ultimately, this paper has cast light on dangerous uncertainty not only in the Labour Party’s 2019 proposal, but also in the law of charities and the European Convention.”

https://api.repository.cam.ac.uk/server/api/core/bitstreams/ca3f6629-73f0-48e6-ab6b-e857094d31f0/content

Parsley1234 · 08/05/2023 14:42

@notfromheregoggles totally right in your observations the UK is so chippy lowest common denominator wins it really is a race to the bottom

Intergalacticcatharsis · 08/05/2023 14:40

@notfromheregoggles - I agree with you that parenting is quite determinative. However, I disagree that all children have to be pushed academically all the way. I look up to some other countries like Switzerland and Scandinavian countries that have the balance right - good quality state education tailored to different types of children and a good work ethic. Good apprenticeships rather than making university the be and and end all.

If you can make a good living wage as a plumber, electrician or chef, command decent respect in society and enjoy it, that should be just as much of an aspired to path for some children as becoming a doctor or an academic.

I actually think primary education in the UK is pretty good and aspiration/expectations from teachers are quite high compared to many other European countries. Where things tend to go wrong is at secondary level.

Intergalacticcatharsis · 08/05/2023 14:33

whumpthereitis - some private schools will voluntarily give up charitable status if they are whacked separately with a 20 VAT bill.

whumpthereitis · 08/05/2023 14:26

Dobby123456 · 08/05/2023 14:17

Are you suggesting that getting an education involves actual effort?? Don't be ridiculous. The only way to get an education in this country is buy one that's 'spoon fed' to you. Nobody else has any chance at all - and that's ALL down to the immoral, unaware, selfish people who send their kids to private school because they just DON'T CARE about everybody else's children and want to buy their own children an ADVANTAGE! If they sent their own children to state school, the state schools would all improve because education is something you breathe in through the air.

Parents in ‘prioritise their own children’ shocker! No shit. Those are the children they’re actually responsible for.

and by ‘spoon feeding’ you presumably mean ‘give pupils the required support to realize their potential’. Interesting that you’re framing this as a bad thing, yet want all children to benefit from it. What is it that you want? To improve the quality of state education, or worsen the education of those going private?

whumpthereitis · 08/05/2023 14:21

Pottedpalm · 08/05/2023 13:58

@whumpthereitis That’s very interesting! So when Labour say they will abolish the tax break if/when elected, they can’t actually do that? Where can I learn more about this?

These are worth a read:
https://ukhumanrightsblog.com/2011/10/18/independent-schools-are-still-charities-says-tribunal/amp/

https://www.counselmagazine.co.uk/articles/abolishing-private-schools-and-redistributing-their-assets-social-justice-at-the-expense-of-human-rights

the government can try to remove charitable status, but doing so is not only unlikely to succeed, but cost a substantial amount in regards to time and (public) money.

Dobby123456 · 08/05/2023 14:17

notfromheregoggles · 08/05/2023 11:30

Yes, barely any benefits so if you don't get a decent job as an adult you will not be able to afford anything. Only the very poor and disabled get subsidies so this is a very small percentage of people who get aid. There are state and private schools but the state schools aren't free either, so parents (from all walks!) tend to demand more of their children since they are paying to educate them.

There's a high focus on education in the culture as it's seen as a way to improve one's circumstances. There's no way a kid is bringing a knife to school - the parents of that child would be mortified and embarrassed. That would not be tolerated by the other children either.

Inequality exists in every culture. Rich parents exist in all countries we can't change that but education is a great way to level up. And if you can't afford a tutor you can watch YouTube videos, download previous exam papers etc and practice.

Parents need to be more responsible for their own children, the laid back attitude here surprises me! I don't think increasing tax on private schools will solve inequality but parents regardless of their socioeconomic standing applying pressure on their own children to get a good education will make a difference!

Are you suggesting that getting an education involves actual effort?? Don't be ridiculous. The only way to get an education in this country is buy one that's 'spoon fed' to you. Nobody else has any chance at all - and that's ALL down to the immoral, unaware, selfish people who send their kids to private school because they just DON'T CARE about everybody else's children and want to buy their own children an ADVANTAGE! If they sent their own children to state school, the state schools would all improve because education is something you breathe in through the air.

notfromheregoggles · 08/05/2023 14:12

izimbra · 08/05/2023 13:54

"You're very rude."

I can't help it - it's my instinctive response to someone defending a grotesque injustice towards children.

I'm not defending, I'm saying whether a tax is imposed or not it won't make an impact if people don't change their attitudes and prioritize education.

notfromheregoggles · 08/05/2023 14:08

@whumpthereitis I think you've made the point that I'm trying to
, very eloquently! Grin

Pottedpalm · 08/05/2023 13:58

@whumpthereitis That’s very interesting! So when Labour say they will abolish the tax break if/when elected, they can’t actually do that? Where can I learn more about this?

whumpthereitis · 08/05/2023 13:57

izimbra · 08/05/2023 13:52

"The majority of parents in the UK state educate their children, and they would be better served agitating for change within the sector they use, rather than focusing on one they don’t."

I agree.

We should lobby to remove the charitable status from private schools until they start offering places to the children most in need of educational charity - disadvantaged children currently failing in the state sector.

This would also take pressure of state schools who are struggling to provide the type of holistic and individualised support for these needy pupils that private schools market themselves as excelling in.

And then we should place an expectation on all publicly funded institutions - universities, government, the judiciary, the civil service - that the educational background of their employees at every level is representative of society. If 93% of people in this country are state educated, there's no justification for the upper echelons of the judiciary, government and the civil service to come from private schools.

😂😂😂😂

fucking hell. Are you being deliberately obtuse? It’s got nothing to do with lobbying. The government doesn’t have the power to strip private schools of charity status.

No, what parents can do is focus on improving the state sector, instead of distracting themselves with the private sector that isn’t going anywhere, and/or expecting those that privately educate to solve the issues for them.

notfromheregoggles · 08/05/2023 13:56

izimbra · 08/05/2023 13:54

"You're very rude."

I can't help it - it's my instinctive response to someone defending a grotesque injustice towards children.

What has made you so certain that your opinion is right that you can't bring yourself to keep an open mind?

izimbra · 08/05/2023 13:54

"You're very rude."

I can't help it - it's my instinctive response to someone defending a grotesque injustice towards children.

izimbra · 08/05/2023 13:52

"The majority of parents in the UK state educate their children, and they would be better served agitating for change within the sector they use, rather than focusing on one they don’t."

I agree.

We should lobby to remove the charitable status from private schools until they start offering places to the children most in need of educational charity - disadvantaged children currently failing in the state sector.

This would also take pressure of state schools who are struggling to provide the type of holistic and individualised support for these needy pupils that private schools market themselves as excelling in.

And then we should place an expectation on all publicly funded institutions - universities, government, the judiciary, the civil service - that the educational background of their employees at every level is representative of society. If 93% of people in this country are state educated, there's no justification for the upper echelons of the judiciary, government and the civil service to come from private schools.

notfromheregoggles · 08/05/2023 13:51

izimbra · 08/05/2023 13:41

"You're not even acknowledging my main point that parents need to take more responsibility and that education isn't given as much emphasis in the UK as it is in other countries like Asia !"

I agree - that if we could wave a wand over the UK and change all the social mores that have evolved over centuries, and English people would be magically culturally transformed so that they have identical values to Asian people raised in a different social setting, then it would be educationally beneficial for children.

But I'm dealing with reality, not fantasy.

You're very rude.

whumpthereitis · 08/05/2023 13:41

izimbra · 08/05/2023 13:29

"I don't think increasing tax on private schools will solve inequality"

Of course not - and nobody's suggesting it will, so that's a bad faith argument.

But awarding charitable status to schools whose primary role is to magnify and entrench the privilege of those children least in need of educational charity, is a contributory factor to structural inequality in our education system, and on those grounds should be removed.

It’s up to the Charity Commission to remove it if they find reason to do so. The government isn’t the one that gets to make that call, and it also isn’t a decision that is based on the opinions of the public.

There was a court case in 2011 that laid this all out.