Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

I'm an awful mum - I hit my ten year old

486 replies

micpop · 01/05/2023 18:37

I have name changed for obvious reasons. I don't know what happened, I'm usually a very calm and relaxed mum - I very rarely even raise my voice.

Today my ten year old daughter had three of her friends over and I took them to the park and then the shop to get some sweets and then they were outside in the back garden playing and running around. It was a nice day actually and I haven't been feeling stressed or anything.

Tonight I picked my daughter up from dancing and she didn't have her earrings in. Now she has had her ears pierced twice, each time she has begged and promised she will look after them. The first time she didn't and they got infected, this time she has looked after them well but knows it's too early to take them out. She has never taken them out at dancing before but apparently today she was told to take them out.

In the car I tried to put them back in but they were already scabbed over at the back and she was screaming and crying whilst I was trying to get them back in. She said she didn't want her ears pierced anyway and was screaming saying it hurts so I gave up.

I was fuming because I don't have extra money to just keep spending on ear piercing and this is now the second time this has happened. In the car I just stayed quiet but I said that I wasn't taking her to McDonald's as usual after dancing due to this. She then started screaming and crying again.

When we were nearly home she kept saying, 'it's not my fault, it's not my fault' she then said to me, 'you're just being over dramatic' and that's when I just saw red. I pinched her bare leg and then slapped it. I told her to get in the house for a bath and no tv tonight.

I then had to drive away for ten minutes as I was so so angry.

I am back in the house and we haven't spoken. I am still so upset about the earrings but more so the way I behaved. I really lost my self control and I'm now worried I have scarred her in some way.

My mum used to hit me all the time and it's resulted in a lot of trauma and I vowed to never be this way. I also swore at her as well.

I feel so awful and don't want to approach her yet as I don't even know how to make an amends with this. Can this be forgiven? Should I call her dad and ask if she can stay with him tonight? Is this something we can move past? Will this fuck her up?

I am so disappointed in myself.

OP posts:
DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 01/05/2023 20:34

micpop · 01/05/2023 20:30

To be absolutely honest I am on the verge of reporting myself to the police to let them decide how to handle this. I can't stop crying. Daughter is brushing her teeth getting ready to go up and seems fine. I feel horrendous and have told her she can discuss this with whoever she wants to if she needs to speak about this. I just need to take whatever punishment.

It's not illegal, although it should be, so they won't do anything.

Will you tell her father?

AuntieJune · 01/05/2023 20:34

depre · 01/05/2023 20:31

@AuntieJune

This is why smacking isn't illegal - because even good, decent, responsible parents who are trying their very hardest slip sometimes. It's not 'ok' but it's not exactly unusual either. Being a parent is very hard. Calling this kind of situation abuse doesn't really help anyone.

It's illegal where I live. Don't be fooled into thinking hitting children is acceptable because the government are shite.

I bet there's a fairly high bar to actually taking police action though, and that OP wouldn't be prosecuted for her actions. Because it's not in the public interest to punish a parent who is trying their best and generally doing a good job.

Flyingsparks · 01/05/2023 20:33

micpop · 01/05/2023 20:30

To be absolutely honest I am on the verge of reporting myself to the police to let them decide how to handle this. I can't stop crying. Daughter is brushing her teeth getting ready to go up and seems fine. I feel horrendous and have told her she can discuss this with whoever she wants to if she needs to speak about this. I just need to take whatever punishment.

OP - I think you need to step away from this thread. It’s not doing you any good.

there’s some good constructive advice on here. Ignore the pitchforks.

Focus on making amends with your daughter. Speak to a therapist if it helps.

Snugglemonkey · 01/05/2023 20:33

wombridgewalkabout · 01/05/2023 19:11

The most disturbing thing about this thread is that there are women, presumably mothers, who can read the OP and think the child was being a brat (and not the Mother). The unconscious belief that must underpin this conclusion is surely that young children must always be able to behave in a calm and respectful way, regardless of provocation, injustice and in the face of the raging anger of another, but adults cannot be expected to behave calmly and respectfully in such circumstances.

Everyone calling this child a brat should be deeply, deeply ashamed of themselves.

This is actually a really upsetting thread to read. So many people ok with an assault in a young child, blaming her for the mother being out of control. Nobody would be ok with a man pinching and slapping a child and it is disgusting that anyone is ok with it because it was a woman.

AuntieJune · 01/05/2023 20:33

WeeblesWobbled · 01/05/2023 20:25

After experiencing domestic violence in the past if someone pinched then slapped me even once that would be it for me. Unfortunately, kids are at the mercy of us adults and can’t leave. I really hope dd is ok, and that mum can get help for her issues.

It's a bit different though isn't it @WeeblesWobbled

All relationships should be based on trust and respect but between romantic partners, you're equals. Parent-child you're not equals, you're responsible for your child, you need to get them to follow the rules you set. Sometimes you need to physically restrain your child in a way that you don't a romantic partner. Kids can be violent and are often hitting/kicking/throwing things at parents. That doesn't make violence ok but it's a different situation.

Movingonupi · 01/05/2023 20:32

Normally in these threads I would say it doesn’t matter, we all loose our shit (I have!) and just apologise and move on. However, I don’t really get why you were cross? Her dance teacher told her to take them out? So it’s not her fault? I would have just said sorry and next time explain to the teacher at the beginning of the lesson? I know me at that age and my DD would probably have obeyed the teacher. Forcing them back in must have been painful as well.

AllOfThemWitches · 01/05/2023 20:32

micpop · 01/05/2023 20:30

To be absolutely honest I am on the verge of reporting myself to the police to let them decide how to handle this. I can't stop crying. Daughter is brushing her teeth getting ready to go up and seems fine. I feel horrendous and have told her she can discuss this with whoever she wants to if she needs to speak about this. I just need to take whatever punishment.

Well you've made a good start posting here.

depre · 01/05/2023 20:31

@AuntieJune

This is why smacking isn't illegal - because even good, decent, responsible parents who are trying their very hardest slip sometimes. It's not 'ok' but it's not exactly unusual either. Being a parent is very hard. Calling this kind of situation abuse doesn't really help anyone.

It's illegal where I live. Don't be fooled into thinking hitting children is acceptable because the government are shite.

WooWooWinnie · 01/05/2023 20:31

Snugglemonkey · 01/05/2023 20:28

Fuck money. Your child's respect is worth a million times more and this is the type of thing that can lose that respect altogether, or for a long time. No amount of money is ever worth assaulting a child over.

Bloody hell I know, that’s why I said the most important thing to do was apologise and repair the relationship.

bumgripes · 01/05/2023 20:31

@SeeYaPals I’m not saying she deserves to be hit. I’m saying a loving mum losing her rag ONCE does not deserve to be pilloried in the most unforgiving terms for child abuse. Hitting may technically be abusive but what earthly use are all these deranged people in the comments screaming and swearing (at least in the case of @IchVersteheNicht ) and calling her a monster? None of you actually care about the issue at hand. If you cared you would not be making ludicrous outsize accusations that convince no-one. You just want to be sadistic to a stranger on an anonymous message board. It’s obvious to everyone.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 01/05/2023 20:30

This is why smacking isn't illegal - because even good, decent, responsible parents who are trying their very hardest slip sometimes.

Then why would it be illegal if the child had been an adult partner?

ExpatInSlavikLand · 01/05/2023 20:30

elm26 · 01/05/2023 18:50

So you pinched your child? Smacked her? Then swore at her? And all of the previous replies are giving you sympathy. If somebody had posted that a male had done the same to his child, it would be "LTB", "unforgivable", "assault", "a danger to children" etc etc.

FWIW, you should feel bad, you've physically assaulted your child.

This.

And why on earth did you keep trying to push the earrings in when your daughter kept crying that you were hurting her??

micpop · 01/05/2023 20:30

To be absolutely honest I am on the verge of reporting myself to the police to let them decide how to handle this. I can't stop crying. Daughter is brushing her teeth getting ready to go up and seems fine. I feel horrendous and have told her she can discuss this with whoever she wants to if she needs to speak about this. I just need to take whatever punishment.

OP posts:
ThingsthatgoBumpintheDay · 01/05/2023 20:30

PaperwhiteTheGhost · 01/05/2023 20:20

Hugs for you. I'm sorry for what you went through ❤

Thank you. I got my revenge by being the mother she never could be & that outweighs it all. Thanks again x

Flyingsparks · 01/05/2023 20:29

We’ll said @AuntieJune

CleverLilViper · 01/05/2023 20:29

Oof.

No, she wasn’t being a brat. She was following instructions from her dance teacher and if I remember rightly I always had to either put plasters over my earrings or take them out during PE.

If you were that precious about the piercings you should have ensured you placed plasters over them before taking her to class.

you know you messed up badly. Poor kid. She was right you were being dramatic. You didn’t just see red- you lost your temper over nothing. You’ve punished her three times for simply following orders.

Seeing red implies a total loss of control- would you say pinching her leg was that? That seems very deliberate and thought out.

You need to apologise and be clear about what you’re apologising for. Promise to never do it again and say that you shouldn’t have done it at all.

PPs are right- if this was about a DF hitting his DC he wouldn’t get an ounce of sympathy or understanding. So you shouldn’t either.

AuntieJune · 01/05/2023 20:28

It was unacceptable but it was also one incident in what is presumably an otherwise loving relationship. Put it in perspective.

Learn from it, work out exactly what was going on that pushed your buttons and made you respond as you did. Discuss it with your daughter, apologise but you don't need to grovel.

This is why smacking isn't illegal - because even good, decent, responsible parents who are trying their very hardest slip sometimes. It's not 'ok' but it's not exactly unusual either. Being a parent is very hard. Calling this kind of situation abuse doesn't really help anyone.

Flyingsparks · 01/05/2023 20:28

IchVersteheNicht · 01/05/2023 19:44

Everyone does?

I don't slap, pinch and swear at my child.

If you re-read my post you will see that I said everyone makes mistakes.

Im anti-smacking and have never hit my kids, but I’ve made plenty of parenting mistakes. Haven’t you?

I think the kind of hate the OP is getting is OTT and counter productive. Lots of people on here actually giving OP good advice on how she can make amends and avoid doing it again.

People just won’t post on here if they’re going to be vilified.

what do you suggest? The child gets put into care? It’s the logical conclusion to your stance, isn’t it? This woman - by your standards- is beyond forgiveness. so what now? Jail? That’ll be really great for her 10 year old

ehb102 · 01/05/2023 20:28

micpop · 01/05/2023 20:00

I'm honesty in a really good place at the moment that's why this reaction is so surprising as it came from literally no where.

There will be something that has happened before that triggered you. If you made the conscious decision to pinch and slap a child, that makes you a special kind of nasty but you wouldn't be so upset. I bet you didn't though. I bet you reacted and some program, some memory from the past started running and you had to follow it through to the end. Reflection may uncover why. It could be a carbon copy of an incident, but more likely there will be a theme, such as not being listened to or not having your efforts considered.

Snugglemonkey · 01/05/2023 20:28

WooWooWinnie · 01/05/2023 19:01

Things cost MONEY.

Fuck money. Your child's respect is worth a million times more and this is the type of thing that can lose that respect altogether, or for a long time. No amount of money is ever worth assaulting a child over.

Museya15 · 01/05/2023 20:27

BSB30 · 01/05/2023 20:06

A social worker has already posted on here saying they would likely close the case for a one off so it's not really helpful to go scaring the OP for no reason.

Yes, but they have form for "closing a case"

QuackMooBaaOink · 01/05/2023 20:26

This makes for very uncomfortable reading. Your behaviour was far worse than your daughters. She followed the instructions she was given at dancing, you then forceably tried to shove earrings back in her scabbed ears, then punished her for following the instruction by denying her mcd, then pinched and slapped her when she got upset about that?!! Jesus. She's 10.
You are the one who let her get them pierced. You also let her have them re-pierced when she had already shown she wasn't able to be responsible for them yet. You are the adult. I'm sorry to be harsh but you behaved appallingly. You need to apologise profusely but I guarantee you this will be something she remembers.

thedancingbear · 01/05/2023 20:26

JMSA · 01/05/2023 20:24

You're a good parent, OP. A shit one wouldn't be feeling bad about the situation. Onwards and upwards.

Well, that must make me a great husband, because I feel terrible after I punch my wife.

what bullshit.

WeeblesWobbled · 01/05/2023 20:25

After experiencing domestic violence in the past if someone pinched then slapped me even once that would be it for me. Unfortunately, kids are at the mercy of us adults and can’t leave. I really hope dd is ok, and that mum can get help for her issues.

Sometimeswinning · 01/05/2023 20:24

bumgripes · 01/05/2023 20:08

@IchVersteheNicht 😂😂😂 settle down darling. I actually was abused as a child. I can tell the difference between that, and what the OP is describing. And yes, screaming and shouting in the car because you’re not getting McDonalds is brattish behaviour!

Just because it's not abuse as you would recognise it does not make it OK.

It's the pinch which bothers me the most.

Sorry op but that was completely underhand and nasty. You tried to inflict so much pain on her. She was a royal pain in the ass but that's all she's guilty of. You don't deserve all the understanding you've had on this thread. Feel guilty. She won't forget it.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.