Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

I'm an awful mum - I hit my ten year old

486 replies

micpop · 01/05/2023 18:37

I have name changed for obvious reasons. I don't know what happened, I'm usually a very calm and relaxed mum - I very rarely even raise my voice.

Today my ten year old daughter had three of her friends over and I took them to the park and then the shop to get some sweets and then they were outside in the back garden playing and running around. It was a nice day actually and I haven't been feeling stressed or anything.

Tonight I picked my daughter up from dancing and she didn't have her earrings in. Now she has had her ears pierced twice, each time she has begged and promised she will look after them. The first time she didn't and they got infected, this time she has looked after them well but knows it's too early to take them out. She has never taken them out at dancing before but apparently today she was told to take them out.

In the car I tried to put them back in but they were already scabbed over at the back and she was screaming and crying whilst I was trying to get them back in. She said she didn't want her ears pierced anyway and was screaming saying it hurts so I gave up.

I was fuming because I don't have extra money to just keep spending on ear piercing and this is now the second time this has happened. In the car I just stayed quiet but I said that I wasn't taking her to McDonald's as usual after dancing due to this. She then started screaming and crying again.

When we were nearly home she kept saying, 'it's not my fault, it's not my fault' she then said to me, 'you're just being over dramatic' and that's when I just saw red. I pinched her bare leg and then slapped it. I told her to get in the house for a bath and no tv tonight.

I then had to drive away for ten minutes as I was so so angry.

I am back in the house and we haven't spoken. I am still so upset about the earrings but more so the way I behaved. I really lost my self control and I'm now worried I have scarred her in some way.

My mum used to hit me all the time and it's resulted in a lot of trauma and I vowed to never be this way. I also swore at her as well.

I feel so awful and don't want to approach her yet as I don't even know how to make an amends with this. Can this be forgiven? Should I call her dad and ask if she can stay with him tonight? Is this something we can move past? Will this fuck her up?

I am so disappointed in myself.

OP posts:
Cherrysherbet · 01/05/2023 19:00

You must have really lost control to pinch, slap and swear at a child.

She was told to do something by the adult in charge. She did as she was told. Pushing earrings into a scabbed over hole is going to hurt. Then you tell her she can’t go to McDonald’s as usual, which you knew would escalate things.

I don’t think she was being a brat. I think she was feeling out of her depth and her emotions were getting the better of her.

You were very wrong to do this to her.

I honestly don’t know what I would do now in your situation. I’m shocked tbh.

SorePaw · 01/05/2023 19:00

TrashyPanda · 01/05/2023 18:40

Please don’t panic

she was being a brat and you reacted because she pushed you to your limit

You are only human. Nobody is perfect and we all make mistakes

a brat????

how exactly did you come to that conclusion???

TooOldForThisNonsense · 01/05/2023 19:00

Oof.

it was an awful thing for you to do, but you know that. I’m sure as a one off it won’t fuck her up for life. My mum used to smack me back when it was acceptable in the 70s, not frequently or hard but still, and despite the fact I disapprove vehemently of smacking children, I’ve been OK.

you need to apologise and make sure you learn from it so you don’t do it again. And leave the bloody ear piercing. If she still wants it done when she’s old enough to go herself she can get it done then.

Showersugar · 01/05/2023 19:00

You're certainly not an awful mum or an awful person, but this was awful behaviour that you are sensibly taking responsibility for. The fact you're so upset by your behaviour speaks volumes about how much you love her.

If your daughter was told to take her earrings out (perhaps by a new teacher or because they were doing some new moves maybe?) then how horribly unjust must this all feel to her? She can't help her skin scabbing over - it's such a strange thing to lose your cool over. Yes her comment was rude but at 10 she will be pushing boundaries, you're really going to have to think about how you manage those kind of comments again in future as this is certain not to be the last time.

The fact you pinched then slapped her is also really concerning, an immediate impulsive slap is not illegal in England and would often be viewed by professionals as lawful chastisement - but two acts in quick succession speaks of something else and is harder to defend. Might it have triggered some learned behaviour from your own childhood? I'm so sorry you had those painful experiences, you didn't deserve them. Might it be time to get some therapy if you haven't already, not just for your daughters benefit but for your own?

Today was a bad day, apologise, send her to her Dad's if she wants space - but beyond that please don't waste time beating yourself up, your energy will be much better spent thinking constructively about how to stop this happening again.

Bbq1 · 01/05/2023 18:59

You punished your daughter in 3 different ways for something that wasn't her fault.

SorePaw · 01/05/2023 18:59

Her ear piercing would not heal over in the space of a dance class. You should have waited until you got home, bathed them & put them back in gently, not fannied about doing it in the car without bathing them.

she was correct, you were being over dramatic.

you need to look at what made you SO angry that you pinched & slapped her. It really was very OTT fir what happened.

it wasn't her fault! Someone in authority made her remove them. You should have said you'd speak to the ballet teacher & tell her that she's not allowed to remove them for x more weeks.

it's unsurprising she was upset at being in trouble for just doing what her ballet teacher told her, then no treat on the way home, no TV either...

Jesus, she was doing as her teacher told her & she removed her earrings for a hour or two.

irrespective of what she'd done, even if it had been something 'naughty', pinching her is nasty, what on earth made you pinch your child?

If she'd called you a horrible fucking bitch or something, I could have almost understood the slap on her leg, but pinching????

I think you need to sincerely apologise to her for pinching her and the slap. Apologise for your massive over reaction.

poor kid didn't do anything wrong.

help her to bathe them & put whatever care cream she has on them,, then ask her if she wants to put them back in or if she wants your help If you promise to be gentle!!

don't send her to her Dads unless she asks to go.

AllosaurusMum · 01/05/2023 18:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Innocentsongs · 01/05/2023 18:58

I agree about the pinching being worse. If you have left a mark it is a police matter. If you are in Scotland or Wales , smacking a child is against the law. Some posters seem to be telling you that it is ok but it is not. If you have done it once the odds are you will do it again. Do look into ways that you can access help so that it doesn't happen again.
For some unknown reason some MN posters dismiss physical violence from a mother. A mother last week posted that her daughter's father had hit her and the girl reported him at school to her Head of Year. You cannot make excuses for your behaviour.
Apologise openly and honestly and take steps to make sure it never happens again.

Bbq1 · 01/05/2023 18:57

But your poor daughter told you that she was made to take her earrings out at dance. If you were angry with anybody it should have been the adult who ordered her to remove then not a child who just did as she was told. Did you want her to argue with the dance teacher? Firstly, she was punished for something that she had little control over by being denied McDonald's, she kept saying it wasn't her fault and then finally you pinched and hit her. The pinch followed by a slap is really unpleasant tbh. Whst adult pinches their child's leg deliberately? It sounds quite thought out. All said I don't think you're a bad mother at all but you mustn't do this again and don't blame your child for things she is unable to control. Try listening to her or you will really struggle when she's a teen. You're obviously normally a kind, caring, good mother so next time keep calm or walk away. I'm sure this one incident won't scar her but it might be good to apologise to her.

FusionChefGeoff · 01/05/2023 18:57

Huge and sincere apology from you to her.

Alter your expectations in the future as I agree you set her up to fail really. She's already messed up one piercing yet you allowed another and you sent her to dancing without any tips on what to do / say if they asked to remove them (highly likely I would have thought).

She's only 10 so if you expect less of her you should find it easier to manage your emotions when things happen as it will be more 'oh yes I thought this could be a problem never mind' rather than 'for Gods sake why didn't you do XYZ'

purpleme12 · 01/05/2023 18:57

Like one PP said, it's the pinching that almost feels more calculated and intended and malicious.

You need to say sorry.
And think about ways to stop this reaction again

elm26 · 01/05/2023 18:56

@goinginsaneinthemembrane sometimes I think I live in a parallel universe when I read some of the stuff on here.

The utter outrage, and rightly so, that would be posted if a man had done this.

Sorry to hear you were slapped, I was too by my poor excuse of a Mother. Once, she slapped the back of my legs and called me a "little cunt" for waking her up aged 7 because she'd fallen asleep with a cigarette. I'll never forget it. Ever.

batsandeggs · 01/05/2023 18:56

I wouldn’t send her anywhere. You both really need to reconnect and speak openly about this. I would start the conversation with a simply sorry. Explains that yes you saw red, you overreacted and you should not have pinched / slapped her. Acknowledge that no matter how upset you are hitting isn’t ok. She’ll remember this but she’ll also remember your response.

when you’re apologising, it’s also an opportunity to open it up and talk about her feelings. I wouldn’t recommending saying something like “I’m sorry, I shouldn’t have acted that way, but…” and turning the conversation about her behaviour. There’s a time and place for that, and it absolutely should be discussed, but for the here and now just own what you did, apologise, and cuddle your girl.

PuffinPuffinPenguin · 01/05/2023 18:55

You punished her for something that wasn't her fault. She was told by the adult responsible for her at the time that she had to take them out. Take out your anger on the dance teacher who told her to do something she shouldn't have been told to do.

It's just earrings. Of all the hills to die on this wasn't the thing to ever lose it like that over.

Hug her tight, apologise to her, tell her you love her, resolve not to do anything like this again. And mean it.

wombridgewalkabout · 01/05/2023 18:55

but equally her behaviour was not acceptable

She's ten, One adult in authority over her told her to do one thing. Then another got angry at her for doing the thing she was told to do and punished her for doing the thing the other adult told her to do. When she tried to explain to the adult parent, that parent did not listen. This was a child who tried to do what was right, tried to explain and was still punished. Someone above said OP was pushed beyond her limits, but actually, it was the ten year old who was. No wonder she kicked off. Where else did the adult leave her to go? It was the parent who shut down the path of reasonable discussion.

None of this is the child's fault and she is right to feel that this is deeply unfair. OP needs to totally own this one. That's the only way to repair this. The child was treated unfairly and badly and she knows it. OP trying to shift some blame onto the child when she speaks to her will damage any attempt at repair. And this really needs repair.

TheLightSideOfTheMoon · 01/05/2023 18:54

And this is why body modifications should be illegal for under 18s.

All of this because a CHILD didn’t look after piercings. Children aren’t meant to look after wounds. That’s an adult’s job.

You’ve behaved appallingly.

Imagine a poster saying her husband did this to her. What would your advice be?

goinginsaneinthemembrane · 01/05/2023 18:53

We are bringing up unfortunately a generation of over entitled brats -when they become parents they will not be selfless and will struggle to cope as they have been over entitled and indulged their whole lives.

Let's pinch, hit and swear at them. That'll teach em!

Reugny · 01/05/2023 18:52

Bobbybobbins · 01/05/2023 18:47

You need to apologise and not go it again. She needs to not be allowed any more ear piercings as she is obviously not able to look after them.

This.

Next time she wants her ears pierced she will need to be old enough to both pay for them and consent to them on her own without your help.

Idontgiveagriffindamn · 01/05/2023 18:52

I feel quite sick reading this. For some reason it’s the pinching that’s done that not the slapping. But I’m not going to make you feel worse.
You do need to go in now and apologise to her and mean it! It’s never ok to hit someone and she needs to know that and that you won’t do it again.

goinginsaneinthemembrane · 01/05/2023 18:52

elm26 · 01/05/2023 18:50

So you pinched your child? Smacked her? Then swore at her? And all of the previous replies are giving you sympathy. If somebody had posted that a male had done the same to his child, it would be "LTB", "unforgivable", "assault", "a danger to children" etc etc.

FWIW, you should feel bad, you've physically assaulted your child.

Yep, because her daughter did what she was told to do at a dance class and followed instructions.

My mum slapped me at 11 and I still remember it. Awful behaviour.

Pebstk · 01/05/2023 18:51

You slapped her leg when she was a brat - this isn’t the right place to post as people on here will label you a near serial killer. Don’t worry about it, give yourself a break and move on. Apologise and explain it was the right way to react but you were frustrated.

In the real world I don’t know anybody who would have a fit about it but you will be judged on here within an inch of your life. Nobody is traumatised from being slapped in the leg once when they were naughty Children are dealing with prolonged physical, mental, sexual abuse, neglect, parental addiction etc - this is really nothing.

We are bringing up unfortunately a generation of over entitled brats -when they become parents they will not be selfless and will struggle to cope as they have been over entitled and indulged their whole lives. Society will then change again and it will be all about strict boundaries for children!

Quartz2208 · 01/05/2023 18:51

You need to talk to her - dancing often does require earrings taken out so I am unsure where she was being a brat - forcing earrings in is going to hurt.

elm26 · 01/05/2023 18:50

So you pinched your child? Smacked her? Then swore at her? And all of the previous replies are giving you sympathy. If somebody had posted that a male had done the same to his child, it would be "LTB", "unforgivable", "assault", "a danger to children" etc etc.

FWIW, you should feel bad, you've physically assaulted your child.

Saffronn · 01/05/2023 18:50

I remember one incident like this. My mum completely lost it (I don’t remember why) and I was utterly scared of her for a while.

ElmTree22 · 01/05/2023 18:49

You've done well to get to 10 without losing it. Apologise and explain why you got mad and also explain why it was wrong. Kids are resilient and it was a rare occurrence, i actually think this a good opportunity for you to teach her accountability.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.