Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

I'm an awful mum - I hit my ten year old

486 replies

micpop · 01/05/2023 18:37

I have name changed for obvious reasons. I don't know what happened, I'm usually a very calm and relaxed mum - I very rarely even raise my voice.

Today my ten year old daughter had three of her friends over and I took them to the park and then the shop to get some sweets and then they were outside in the back garden playing and running around. It was a nice day actually and I haven't been feeling stressed or anything.

Tonight I picked my daughter up from dancing and she didn't have her earrings in. Now she has had her ears pierced twice, each time she has begged and promised she will look after them. The first time she didn't and they got infected, this time she has looked after them well but knows it's too early to take them out. She has never taken them out at dancing before but apparently today she was told to take them out.

In the car I tried to put them back in but they were already scabbed over at the back and she was screaming and crying whilst I was trying to get them back in. She said she didn't want her ears pierced anyway and was screaming saying it hurts so I gave up.

I was fuming because I don't have extra money to just keep spending on ear piercing and this is now the second time this has happened. In the car I just stayed quiet but I said that I wasn't taking her to McDonald's as usual after dancing due to this. She then started screaming and crying again.

When we were nearly home she kept saying, 'it's not my fault, it's not my fault' she then said to me, 'you're just being over dramatic' and that's when I just saw red. I pinched her bare leg and then slapped it. I told her to get in the house for a bath and no tv tonight.

I then had to drive away for ten minutes as I was so so angry.

I am back in the house and we haven't spoken. I am still so upset about the earrings but more so the way I behaved. I really lost my self control and I'm now worried I have scarred her in some way.

My mum used to hit me all the time and it's resulted in a lot of trauma and I vowed to never be this way. I also swore at her as well.

I feel so awful and don't want to approach her yet as I don't even know how to make an amends with this. Can this be forgiven? Should I call her dad and ask if she can stay with him tonight? Is this something we can move past? Will this fuck her up?

I am so disappointed in myself.

OP posts:
ladydimitrescu · 01/05/2023 19:16

gettingoldisshit · 01/05/2023 19:15

@wombridgewalkabout well funny enough i have managed to raise four very well balanced dc who are all adults now and all four are very decent adults!

They may be, but you absolutely are not.

NerrSnerr · 01/05/2023 19:16

I don't see where she was being a brat, she was told to take them out during dance class. They wouldn't have healed over but you should have waited until home so you could put them in properly.

I hope you've apologised and spoken to her about it by now.

ladydimitrescu · 01/05/2023 19:15

gettingoldisshit · 01/05/2023 19:12

Imo all the hysteria on here about a minor incident just goes to show why there are so many feral children with absolutely zero respect for anyone else roaming about these days!

Respect? You think you garner respect from smacking a little kid half your size for doing fuck all wrong? If anyone is feral it's you.

gettingoldisshit · 01/05/2023 19:15

@wombridgewalkabout well funny enough i have managed to raise four very well balanced dc who are all adults now and all four are very decent adults!

BatFaceOwl · 01/05/2023 19:15

I can only imagine the response of a man had posted this...

Screaming at her, pinching and slapping her - all because of a pair of earrings

I do understand what it's like to have that loss of control but honestly, you should feel bad about this and apologise to her and then work on next time this happens and how you'll deal with it

SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox · 01/05/2023 19:15

Wow, can't believe someone said she was being a brat.
10 is young to be responsible for the after care of pierced ears which isn't always simple.
Then she resurrected the dance instructors requirement to take them out in class.
Then she cried/made a fuss because it was hurting trying to get them back in.
Then you saw red over the wasted money for a choice that you made which hasn't gone well due to entirely common issues.
Then you hurt her physically and punished her further by banning TV.

None of this is ok and anyone suggesting she was a brat in this situation needs to re-read the op.

But, you are genuinely remorseful. You know you resorted to horrible reactions imprinted from young. You don't want to do this again.

I think you need to show her your remorse. Admit what triggered you (which is not admirable but the only fix here is honesty) it's not her fault, and demonstrate that you know she didn't cause this problem, that you believe she was responding fairly and understandably, and you were in the wrong.

Show her you are willing to admit when you've made a mistake. Tell her you are sorry and mean it. Then accept she might need time to recover from this traumatic episode.

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 01/05/2023 19:15

I feel confused/stressed reading this as an adult. The pinching is the worst bit I think. That was spiteful. I can almost understand a smack out of fear or loss of control, like if DC ran into the road or went to touch something hot or sharp, but a pinch is not like that. Also you seem more annoyed about money, but it's spent now, just don't spend it again. I think you need to apologise to your DD and admit that your behaviour was wrong. I also think you need to 'feel' this as much as you are so that it never happens again.

MiddleParking · 01/05/2023 19:14

If OP was a terrible mother she wouldn't be wracked with guilt posting on here for advice on the matter.

Why do people always say this? That’s just not how morality or emotions work. There aren’t good parents that hit their kids but feel guilty about it and bad parents that hit their kids but feel entirely positive and justified about it. It’s a bit more nuanced than that.

elm26 · 01/05/2023 19:14

gettingoldisshit · 01/05/2023 19:12

Imo all the hysteria on here about a minor incident just goes to show why there are so many feral children with absolutely zero respect for anyone else roaming about these days!

So assaulting a child to make them behave in a way you see fit is okay is it?

The only "feral" things I see here is idiots like you, violence isn't the answer.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 01/05/2023 19:14

elm26 · 01/05/2023 18:50

So you pinched your child? Smacked her? Then swore at her? And all of the previous replies are giving you sympathy. If somebody had posted that a male had done the same to his child, it would be "LTB", "unforgivable", "assault", "a danger to children" etc etc.

FWIW, you should feel bad, you've physically assaulted your child.

I do agree with the double standards. She should be sorry for how she behaved, hopefully the child is at her dads whilst OP calms down and realises a 10 year old child has simply followed instructions to take out her earrings. You need to make sure this doesn't happen again OP.

shysquirrel · 01/05/2023 19:13

Good god; imagine if this was the DF who'd done this. All of the "ah it was only a slap" people would be singing a different tune. Poor kid

ladydimitrescu · 01/05/2023 19:13

How was she being a brat??? She was told to remove them at dance, how on earth is that her fault? It hurt having them put back in, so she cried and was then punished for it. I am utterly gobsmacked that anyone thinks this is ok. Yes you absolutely fucked up. She did nothing wrong, you over reacted and she was upset at being unfairly punished - and you hit her. You pinched her, slapped her and then sent her inside and drove away.
I'm not going to tell you your behaviour is ok because frankly it's atrocious. Clearly you feel awful, so you obviously are remorseful. All you can do is focus on moving forward and reassuring her you'll never do this again. You're the adult, act like it.

Posters acting like this is the child's fault and how it's not a big deal, fucking shocking. Feel deeply sorry for your children.

BeverlyHa · 01/05/2023 19:13

It has been one off, Apologise and don't do it again.

YellowDiamondInTheSky · 01/05/2023 19:13

wombridgewalkabout · 01/05/2023 19:11

The most disturbing thing about this thread is that there are women, presumably mothers, who can read the OP and think the child was being a brat (and not the Mother). The unconscious belief that must underpin this conclusion is surely that young children must always be able to behave in a calm and respectful way, regardless of provocation, injustice and in the face of the raging anger of another, but adults cannot be expected to behave calmly and respectfully in such circumstances.

Everyone calling this child a brat should be deeply, deeply ashamed of themselves.

I suspect those posters have had similar unjustifiable moments with their children and are trying to make themselves feel better. It’s absolutely shocking how many people are calling the child who simply followed instructions and was punished for it a brat, whilst supporting the mum for pinching and slapping her. For me, pinching is much more calculated than a slap.

gettingoldisshit · 01/05/2023 19:12

Imo all the hysteria on here about a minor incident just goes to show why there are so many feral children with absolutely zero respect for anyone else roaming about these days!

Hugasauras · 01/05/2023 19:12

Honestly quite amazed (and shocked) that people who I assume are parents themselves think it's okay to pinch and hurt a 10yo child because they were 'a brat' (which they weren't.) God help your kids if you think this is typical parenting or that the child deserved it.

Innocentsongs · 01/05/2023 19:12

@Eastie77Returns
Are you really justifying a woman using physical violence against her child? The law is quite clear on this and it makes me realise how some mothers appear to think they are above the law.
I await your appearance on threads to defend Dads who pinch and slap their children.

Yerroblemom1923 · 01/05/2023 19:12

Of course your behaviour isn't acceptable, the OP knows this hence she's feeling terrible about it! However she was clearly at the end of her tether and her child had clearly pushed her over the edge with her bratty behaviour. It's all well and dandy people on here pointing out it was wrong and she should've done x, y or z but in the heat of the moment it's not so easy to take a step back and be rational.

You know you've done wrong OP. All you can do now is apologise to your dd, explain what happened, that sometimes we all make mistakes and it won't happen again. But also ensure that she knows screaming and crying and generally bratty behaviour is not acceptable and won't be tolerated.
If OP was a terrible mother she wouldn't be wracked with guilt posting on here for advice on the matter.

swg1 · 01/05/2023 19:11

No, it's not okay. No, she was not being a brat. No, it's not justifiable and those people justifying it need to have a word with themselves.

From her point of view you hurt her until she would have done anything to Make It Stop (I remember similar rows with my mum over her wanting to squeeze my spots or force me to wear mascara). You then got cross with her for not being able to tolerate it, blamed her for needing to remove them, hurt her and then drove away for ten minutes.

No wonder she's not talking to you. She doesn't know if you're still angry and likely to lash out, or packing to leave. She didn't know if you were coming back. Do not make this worse by sending her away. Fix it. Pronto.

wombridgewalkabout · 01/05/2023 19:11

gettingoldisshit · 01/05/2023 19:02

This is spades! You will get labelled a child abuser on here op! These things happen, she was being a brat and you lost it! Not the end of the world and she most definitely won't be mentally damaged for life! Just talk about it calmly and rationally with her, explaining that you were wrong for slapping her but that she was wrong for acting the way she did.

The most disturbing thing about this thread is that there are women, presumably mothers, who can read the OP and think the child was being a brat (and not the Mother). The unconscious belief that must underpin this conclusion is surely that young children must always be able to behave in a calm and respectful way, regardless of provocation, injustice and in the face of the raging anger of another, but adults cannot be expected to behave calmly and respectfully in such circumstances.

Everyone calling this child a brat should be deeply, deeply ashamed of themselves.

Conkersinautumn · 01/05/2023 19:10

I don't understand your rage about this, it seems more about getting your own way than a punishment really. You could try to learn about processing your emotions. Because she's only 10. She's going to hit far closer to the bone with her criticisms over the next 10 years.

YellowDiamondInTheSky · 01/05/2023 19:10

I cannot believe the number of people calling her a brat.

She was told by a teacher she needs to remove her earrings. She followed the instructions. Her mum then got annoyed and punished her for following instructions. And when she tried to justify herself and tell her mum that she is indeed overreacting, she gets physically assaulted by her mum.

And she’s the brat?!

That one incident will stay with her OP, talking from experience. What will help is how you now deal with it. Go and apologise and make it right. You’re the grown up here - act like it.

And all the other PPs who condone OP’s behaviour, blaming the daughter when she absolutely nothing wrong, shame on you. I assume you similarly blame a wife when her husband slaps her?

gettingoldisshit · 01/05/2023 19:09

@WhatWouldHopperDo oh do give over! Stop being so dramatic! The child was a brat and learnt that there were consequences to that 🤷‍♀️. Now its time to move on!

Innocentsongs · 01/05/2023 19:09

I shall remember posters on here who try to justify a woman encouraging another woman to use violence against her child.
In England if your violence towards your child has resulted in any of the following you will be in serious trouble

The Director of Public Prosecutions for England and Wales has produced a charging standard in order to help prosecutors to determine the appropriate offence in a case. This guidance has suggested that common assault is where injuries amount to no more than the following:
grazes;
scratches;
abrasions;
minor bruising;
swellings;
reddening of the skin;
superficial cuts;

Did your attack on your child result in reddening of the skin? Did the pinch cause scratching? It cannot be justified and you will be in trouble if your daughter's school finds out.

TheMouseIsAsGoodAsDeadAlready · 01/05/2023 19:08

First things first OP - you are the adult, you must apologise.

2nd, unless it was done this week, or last week, there's no way a piercing would heal over in the space of a dance class.

When your DD said the pier ing wasn't her choice, us that true, or was she just acting out? Because if it wasn't her fully informed choice to have her ears pierced (again) then it's hard to see how she's being unreasonable.

But ultimately, you're the parent- it's up to you to control your actions, and you shouldn't have pinched or slapped your poor DD.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.