Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how a biological male has won a women's cycling race?

242 replies

houseselling · 01/05/2023 17:42

Seriously why are the sporting organisations so slow to stop biological men from entering the world of women's sport that they so predictably end up winning and stealing titles and opportunities from biological women.

The mind boggles in rage.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
9
changedforanswer · 25/05/2023 13:59

Whatsnewpussyhat · 01/05/2023 18:06

Because he's a cheating man who's fantasy has been allowed to override female reality.
Full on male privilege and entitlement.

Bet he got a large dose of 'gender euphoria' beating all the actual women.

Still fucking baffles me that some women actually go along with misogynistic bullshit.

Oh dear another man walking all over women. Happening all the time and many are blind to it.

nothingcomestonothing · 03/05/2023 15:15

DisquietintheRanks · 03/05/2023 14:05

Of course its overwhelmingly women working to fix this. When have I or anyone else on here suggested otherwise? What I am suggesting, which you are taking exception to, is that the protest needs to be led by the female athletes (in this case cyclists) who are most affected by it.

Well I must have misunderstood then, because when you write

women are happy to just go along with it.

and

Yes. Have you seen what happens when they don't?(speak out)

and

Good luck with waiting quietly for men to realise they're treating you unfairly though.

It sounded like you were blaming women for not tackling this issue. It didn't sound like you were saying that women are working to fix this. And expecting the women directly affected to lead the protests is like expecting women who are currently in abusive relationships to spearhead campaigns against DV. Other women should be and are protesting this, the women affected by this can protest other instances more safely.

DisquietintheRanks · 03/05/2023 14:05

Of course its overwhelmingly women working to fix this. When have I or anyone else on here suggested otherwise? What I am suggesting, which you are taking exception to, is that the protest needs to be led by the female athletes (in this case cyclists) who are most affected by it.

nothingcomestonothing · 03/05/2023 13:41

Good luck with waiting quietly for men to realise they're treating you unfairly though.

No one on the thread has advocated for that, have they? But expecting the women involved to fix it is unfair. Just as I as an NHS employee, would be risking disciplinary action and reporting to the police for a hate crime if I say that there is a man in the women's bay, if that man has special feelings (yes really, that is the policy). So in that situation other women speak out, who aren't risking their career doing so. And I speak out for other women, when it's not me on the line. Stop blaming the women, or suggesting women aren't working from change this, it's overwhelmingly women working to change things. Suggesting that women are waiting quietly for the men to fix it is just insulting.

Thelnebriati · 03/05/2023 12:09

In a situation where the victim is penalised for speaking out, its up to the regulating body and the rest of us to step up.
Blaming the victim is not acceptable.

DisquietintheRanks · 03/05/2023 12:07

As I said, we'll have to agree to disagree. Good luck with waiting quietly for men to realise they're treating you unfairly though.

nothingcomestonothing · 03/05/2023 12:00

DisquietintheRanks · 03/05/2023 11:42

Have you seen what happens to women who speak out?

Yes. Have you seen what happens when they don't?

I guess we'll have to agree to disagree on this one.

Again, that's victim blaming. The women didn't cause this. This isn't what happens when women don't speak out, this is what happens when males cheat and the institutions let them. This is not the women's fault, and it's not in their hands to fix. I'd love it if all the actual female competitors told the sport to go fuck themselves and the whole thing went bankrupt, but it's not that simple for the women who are directly affected and it's not fair to put it on them to sort a problem they didn't invent, didn't agree to and don't have the power to solve. Absolutely women as a sex class should speak up, but the ones directly affected are not the ones who should have to take real risks to point out that that man is a cheat and their sporting body allows him to cheat.

DisquietintheRanks · 03/05/2023 11:42

Have you seen what happens to women who speak out?

Yes. Have you seen what happens when they don't?

I guess we'll have to agree to disagree on this one.

lifeturnsonadime · 03/05/2023 11:41

DisquietintheRanks · 03/05/2023 11:11

@nothingcomestonothing I think (no offense) that you are missing the point. Yes the governing body bodies should prevent this but, as they haven't, who does that leave? Those that care - and that should include the female athletes affected. If they aren't happy to speak out the I can only conclude that the problem is not so bad, so better to spend my time lobbying on behalf of women who can't speak out (like those in prison).

Its really hard to convince the general public that this is a real and serious problem whilst women are happy to just go along with it.

I think you are being too simplistic.

Lots of women and parents want to speak out but if they love and have trained hard in their chosen sport speaking out means not being selected for team sports or to represent.

Putting the onus on the athletes is not the correct response. The sporting bodies owe it to female athletes to use their power to put an end to it.

nothingcomestonothing · 03/05/2023 11:32

DisquietintheRanks · 03/05/2023 11:11

@nothingcomestonothing I think (no offense) that you are missing the point. Yes the governing body bodies should prevent this but, as they haven't, who does that leave? Those that care - and that should include the female athletes affected. If they aren't happy to speak out the I can only conclude that the problem is not so bad, so better to spend my time lobbying on behalf of women who can't speak out (like those in prison).

Its really hard to convince the general public that this is a real and serious problem whilst women are happy to just go along with it.

I just don't agree. Have you seen what happens to women who speak out? The onus should be on the governing bodies of sports, and everyone should be shaming them, not the women who have to suck it up or lose their sponsorships, which may be their livelihoods, not to mention being threatened, harassed, smeared as bigots. To me that's akin to saying that women who don't speak up against abusers are 'happy to go along with it' or they'd leave, it's victim blaming. The women affected didn't cause this and it shouldn't be on them to fix it. I think it's really unfair to suggest that they must be fine with it if they won't risk their safety or their career to speak out.

DisquietintheRanks · 03/05/2023 11:11

@nothingcomestonothing I think (no offense) that you are missing the point. Yes the governing body bodies should prevent this but, as they haven't, who does that leave? Those that care - and that should include the female athletes affected. If they aren't happy to speak out the I can only conclude that the problem is not so bad, so better to spend my time lobbying on behalf of women who can't speak out (like those in prison).

Its really hard to convince the general public that this is a real and serious problem whilst women are happy to just go along with it.

lifeturnsonadime · 03/05/2023 10:40

https://twitter.com/AudreySuffolk/status/1653498193882107932

Another thread on why this is discrimination.

https://twitter.com/AudreySuffolk/status/1653498193882107932

Fizbosshoes · 03/05/2023 10:39

@nothingcomestonothing

Agree. And in your example asking kids to sit out the race wouldn't make it fairer it would mean they missed the experience of sports day (that is probably a once a year event) and the chance to compete with their peers.
With the RL example in the OP, these kind of races need to be entered in advance, you don't just pitch up on the day with £5, like its the village fun run. There would definitely be stages of application where teams and names would have to be submitted. And at no point is it flagged that this isn't a female athlete.

lifeturnsonadime · 03/05/2023 10:36

ClareBlue · 03/05/2023 10:13

Seriously.
Not employing her is not preventing access to a service. It is not employing her and is subject to any employment contract she might have.
If you think that a manager of a venue at the fringe can replace their staff who have made a stand on perceived trans rights with other staff, you not seeing the reality of today. The venue would be picketed and shut down and any staff that might be prepared to work subject to vile abuse. Particularly at the fringe where the audience is more likely to do these things. This is happening daily. If you think that an organisation can just sack staff for supporting a trans agenda without serious consequences to their business then you are wrong. Universities don't even employ their students and they are scared shitless of addressing extreme activism by a small minority on campus.

Why do you think that discrimination laws only apply in employment situations? Why do you think that the venue was going to employer her? It wasn't it was just hosting her as it does others.

You can't refuse a service for a protected characteristic. .

And who is going to be violent? Surely you are not suggesting that a lesbian KC is going to be violent? It's really not a good look for a venue to not be able to host an event on H&S grounds.

Is this the world you want to live in? One where women, lesbian women are refused an audience because some violent men think lesbians can have penises and want to shut up a middle age lesbian who says that this is lesbian erasure?

I hope that they have their asses sued off and if they state that they couldn't keep people safe and that comes out in evidence well at least it will show who are the violent ones and why.

And yes in the main hospitality staff are casual staff. If they refuse to work because they have bigoted beliefs what normally happens is that the venue doesn't require them again. They might try to bring a claim that they are being 'discriminated against' but they really are not, they are refusing to work due to a person's protected characteristic. They don't have to listen they just have to work. I mean try that on in any retail environment, refusing to serve for a protected characteristic. It won't wash. And any argument that the venue can't keep them safe should lead to the venue being closed for H&S grounds rather than being discriminatory.

In fact the staff who refuse to work can also be personally sued for discrimination should Joanna Cherry want to.

And as for Universities they should be expelling TRAs who are violent towards women. They should be the epicentres of free speech. As it is they are allowing women to be silenced in favour of males who are violent. If you think that this is acceptable in any way you clearly don't believe that free speech matters.

There are several threads on twitter where experienced barristers discuss this. The club and the staff are clearly in the wrong here.

https://twitter.com/RoddyQC/status/1653215267487461376

https://twitter.com/RoddyQC/status/1653215267487461376

ClareBlue · 03/05/2023 10:13

lifeturnsonadime · 02/05/2023 11:18

This just doesn't happen.

I have an employment law background.

Employers don't bow down to demands of employees, they find staff who will work instead. Especially in the hospitality industry.

The Forstarter case confirmed that gender critical beliefs are valid and that a person cannot be discriminated against for holding them. There is also a possibility a claim can be made on the basis of other protected characteristics of Sex and Sexual Orientation.

Part of the issue that TRAS have with Joanna Cherry is that she is a lesbian who believes that lesbians are ONLY single sex attracted women. There is an argument to be heard that she has been deplatformed for being a single sex attracted woman who is trying to protect her right to say that only women can be lesbians.

The service being refused is the fact that she was scheduled to perform and now is not.

Seriously.
Not employing her is not preventing access to a service. It is not employing her and is subject to any employment contract she might have.
If you think that a manager of a venue at the fringe can replace their staff who have made a stand on perceived trans rights with other staff, you not seeing the reality of today. The venue would be picketed and shut down and any staff that might be prepared to work subject to vile abuse. Particularly at the fringe where the audience is more likely to do these things. This is happening daily. If you think that an organisation can just sack staff for supporting a trans agenda without serious consequences to their business then you are wrong. Universities don't even employ their students and they are scared shitless of addressing extreme activism by a small minority on campus.

RosaBonheur · 03/05/2023 09:20

nothingcomestonothing · 03/05/2023 09:14

Posters who think that the female athletes should make a stand and risk their sponsorship etc are missing the point. The participants shouldn't have to do anything to prevent this, the governing body should prevent it, what else are they for? If I decide to join key stage one sports day and smash all the records (probably wouldn't anyway, I'm v unfit), is it up to my 7 year old rivals to deal with me or lose out? No, the school should stop me getting on the start line in the first place. The governing bodies willing to pretend that men on medication are women are the ones who need to grow some fucking ovaries and do their jobs instead of selling women out.

This.

SeriousFaffing · 03/05/2023 09:20

@nothingcomestonothing Agree.

nothingcomestonothing · 03/05/2023 09:14

Posters who think that the female athletes should make a stand and risk their sponsorship etc are missing the point. The participants shouldn't have to do anything to prevent this, the governing body should prevent it, what else are they for? If I decide to join key stage one sports day and smash all the records (probably wouldn't anyway, I'm v unfit), is it up to my 7 year old rivals to deal with me or lose out? No, the school should stop me getting on the start line in the first place. The governing bodies willing to pretend that men on medication are women are the ones who need to grow some fucking ovaries and do their jobs instead of selling women out.

SeriousFaffing · 03/05/2023 09:03

YANBU.

I think that the likely solution is an offshoot category, sort of like what Formula E is to Formula 1… Only, I think it will actually be the biological women who compete in the new categories…

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 03/05/2023 07:47

Fizbosshoes · 02/05/2023 23:49

The female participants would lose out though if their sponsorship deal includes taking part in those events.

They lose out already, they can’t speak out for fear of being called a transphobe which would hugely reduce any sponsorship look at the abuse sally gunnell gets

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 03/05/2023 07:46

maddening · 03/05/2023 00:05

They already ruled a paralympian man who runs on leg blades cannot run in mainstream against able bodied men as he would have an unfair advantage!

Didn’t Oscar pistorious run in the Olympics?
I remember there was a lot of discussion around the fairness. In the Paralympics the blades are heavily regulated to ensure some sort of fairness

UWhatNow · 03/05/2023 00:16

houseselling · 02/05/2023 22:00

Why are so many people able to blindly accept that trans women are women.

When they are clearly not.

Is it about women being quiet little people pleasers being hash tag kind?

Do people think it is harmless so go with the live and let live view?

Is there not enough mainstream coverage of the issue?

What can normal folk do to raise awareness is a non threatening peaceful manner?

Yep totally. Sad little people pleasers who can’t bear that some men will feel ‘sad’ that they can’t dominate and diminish women. So the people pleasers would rather appease than face the reality of what male privilege and misogyny does to their sisters.

maddening · 03/05/2023 00:05

ShowUs · 01/05/2023 18:56

I wonder if I claim to identify as disabled they’ll let me compete in the Paralympics 🤔

It doesn’t matter if I’ll have a massive advantage over everyone else that’s playing and I would be offended and complain if I’m not allowed.

They already ruled a paralympian man who runs on leg blades cannot run in mainstream against able bodied men as he would have an unfair advantage!

Fizbosshoes · 02/05/2023 23:49

JudgeJ · 02/05/2023 22:08

Maybe for the next big cycling event, or other sporting event, where men pretending to be women are allowed to compete all the proper women should refuse to participate, let him race against himself and win. The organisers will face such losses of revenue they may have a rethink.

The female participants would lose out though if their sponsorship deal includes taking part in those events.

Swipe left for the next trending thread