Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What standard of living do you think should be the minimum everyone can afford?

331 replies

MondayAgainnn · 01/05/2023 16:35

What do you think the absolute basic minimum should be?

I think everybody should be able to afford:

Decent food
Safe housing
Any extra medical things needed, including dentistry
Internet package as it is completely necessary nowadays
Enough clothes to stay warm, dry, appropriate trainers for exercising etc
Enough for some discretionary spending - obviously this is harder to quantify, but things like Netflix, a coffee, cinema tickets I feel should be a normal attainable part of life for everyone
Enough to save a bit

Whether it is through work or through benefits I feel everyone in society should be able to have a lifestyle that is dignified, basically comfortable and with room for treats. Not just subsistence level.

What do you think the minimum should be?

OP posts:
YourSpleenIsDamp · 01/05/2023 19:11

TreadLight · 01/05/2023 16:59

@MondayAgainnn , what is the justification that someone who doesn't work should have higher income and better quality of life than someone who does work?

There is a moral hazard argument that no benefit should be more than full time NMW.

Yeah, if we give the lazy scroungers too much then we risk them deliberately making themselves disabled 🙄

Locutus2000 · 01/05/2023 19:11

"Benefits should definitely not include money for netflix and holidays ffs, if those children of welfare parents go without they need to have a serious conversation with their parents later in life as to why they did so little to provide for them!"

Just wow.

Resilience · 01/05/2023 19:11

Someone mentioned Finland as a country of higher taxation and someone else then said you can't compare oranges and pairs. I think the real point is that how we view tax is culturally/politically driven. Therefore it can, and does, change. Once you accept that, the conversation changes.

The real question is what is tax for? Most people recognise that its to fund things like schools, roads, the NHS etc. Most people don't recognise that ever single one of us - including the billionaire CEOs - benefit from it. It's not a simple cost-benefit analysis on an individual scale.

The idea that some people pay in more than they take out is a fallacy. Those who pay for private education and health care for example are still benefitting from the universal services facilitated by those taxes. Quite often the service personnel they employ for their privately funded services were educated by the state and kept healthy by the NHS. Luxury items can't be transported without the taxes funding the roads. Most people would be better off paying more tax if the extra money meant better public services.

The other consideration is that if you keep people too poor, despite working hard, eventually you'll also quite likely end up with civil unrest. People have a nasty habit of doing that when they perceive they have nothing left to lose. In a world where social media is exposing just how well some people are living (even if fake Wink) and media regularly reports on the huge profits of companies that somehow manage to avoid paying tax, potential civil unrest is closer than many people would like to believe.

I pay HRT. I'm actually happy to. I see the good it does even when I don't personally benefit. There are lots of very rich donors who support parties with redistribution of wealth policies. It's not true at all to say that if we make life more comfortable for everyone the rich will begrudge paying tax. Only some will, and that says more about their personal perspective than it does economics. The key is balance.

PeloMom · 01/05/2023 19:11

Netflix, coffee out, cinema, holidays are luxuries. There are plenty of streaming sites, YouTube etc to watch. I think dentistry should be free/ heavily subsidized as well as provide at least an annual optician check.

DriedFlowersLiveForever · 01/05/2023 19:10

But why advertise it as a job, there clearly won't be enough graffiti to keep multiple people in a full time role. What happens when the contract ends? Do they just go back to sitting at home getting their money for nothing?
A certain type of benefits claimant has virtually made a career out of doing nothing....they might be inspired to get an actual job if they realise sitting on their arse is no longer an option and some form of work will be expected to receive their benefits.

YourSpleenIsDamp · 01/05/2023 19:09

Botw1 · 01/05/2023 16:53

@MondayAgainnn

Benefits shouldn't provide a better quality of living than working would.

As long as mw is always more than you'd get on benefits (even if disabled)

Wow - so because I'm disabled and can't work, that means I don't deserve enough to survive on? I'd fucking LOVE to be working. But hey, I'm on benefits so I just don't matter, I guess.

TwoFluffyDogsOnMyBed · 01/05/2023 19:09

It would be possible to provide these things if the super rich weren’t hoarding so much money and not paying taxes. I would like there to be a Universal Basic Income.

I hate the Daily Mail attitude to benefits on here. The benefits system isn’t the safety net it once was. PIP is almost impossible to get for anyone with mental health problems/neurodivergence. I’d be living in a camper van from September this year if I didn’t have family helping me.

It feels like the majority of people are killing themselves working and raising children and feel bitter towards anyone who isn’t doing the same. It’s just become normal and I don’t think it was normal twenty years ago. The move from tax credits to universal credit has made life far more difficult.

Locutus2000 · 01/05/2023 19:09

"There is no magic money tree in the back garden of No.11"

Of course there is. It's been demonstrated over and over again.

It is however only available to the few.

OhmygodDont · 01/05/2023 19:07

Gingerkittykat · 01/05/2023 18:24

I would love to see a breakdown of what they receive in benefits because the standard allowance for a couple is £578 a month.

Bad back and voices none of which of probable funnily enough 😉🙃

OhmygodDont · 01/05/2023 19:05

Danikm151 · 01/05/2023 18:08

There’s still the mentality that some will be better off on benefits than working but with UC and the 2 child limit, that’s no longer true.

i work full time and get UC as I have 1 child. The taper rate means that I am better off working full time… if I only worked 16 hours I would be much worse off income wise. I’m on more than NMW but with price rises things are harder than before.

This year I am finally going on holiday for the first time in 5 years. Just a long weekend in skegness but to me it’s going to be great!

But bills are paid, fridge is stocked and we do cheap days out. I have free bus travel through work and nursery is paid for.
my goal is to save for a holiday abroad but that will be a big luxury!

Unless you have a “bad back” like my dad who sometimes hears voices but goes to Mexico lol

can’t work tho clearly.

Arginalia · 01/05/2023 19:05

DriedFlowersLiveForever · 01/05/2023 19:02

@Gingerkittykat the point is they are not 'working' for £2 ph. They are contributing to society in return for their benefits.
If they want more money they could always get a job.....

So advertise the role as a job and pay them to do it as workers, even if only on a temporary contract.

3BSHKATS · 01/05/2023 19:03

Dishwashersaurous · 01/05/2023 18:51

I wonder whether part of the answer is to have the state provide the basic necessary things, rather than money

So all children get access to free clubs and lunches at school. Well stocked libraries with new books.

Free public transport, reliable local buses.

A basic amount of electricity and water and Internet.

Thus the whole of society gets the basic things of life provided.

100% agree with this, then you wouldn't get children suffering because of feckless parents.

DriedFlowersLiveForever · 01/05/2023 19:02

@Gingerkittykat the point is they are not 'working' for £2 ph. They are contributing to society in return for their benefits.
If they want more money they could always get a job.....

3BSHKATS · 01/05/2023 19:01

LakieLady · 01/05/2023 19:00

Rent to private landlords needs to be capped. People are claiming huge amounts of full rent because rent is extortionate.

This. I'd love to know how much of the "benefit bill" ends up in the pockets of private landlords.

Not as much as you might think given most of them won't accept DHSS as it always seems to say in the adverts

Dishwashersaurous · 01/05/2023 19:00

How about a military barracks style provision. So everyone gets food, roof over their head and clothes.

If they want something else then they need to provide it themselves.

But the state provides the roof over everyone head in an emergency

LakieLady · 01/05/2023 19:00

Rent to private landlords needs to be capped. People are claiming huge amounts of full rent because rent is extortionate.

This. I'd love to know how much of the "benefit bill" ends up in the pockets of private landlords.

Madamecastafiore · 01/05/2023 18:59

A decent, secure and well maintained home that is big enough for their household.

Energy, water bills and council tax.

Three decent meals a day each.

Toiletries, nappies, formula milk if needed, cleaning materials etc.

Warm, durable clothing and shoes.

Internet access.

Transport, either public or private if they live somewhere where public transport is poor.

Medical, dental and optical costs.

Some leisure/cultural acitivities.

A modest holiday now and again.

😂😂😂 Lakielady how is this going to be paid for?

LakieLady · 01/05/2023 18:57

A decent, secure and well maintained home that is big enough for their household.

Energy, water bills and council tax.

Three decent meals a day each.

Toiletries, nappies, formula milk if needed, cleaning materials etc.

Warm, durable clothing and shoes.

Internet access.

Transport, either public or private if they live somewhere where public transport is poor.

Medical, dental and optical costs.

Some leisure/cultural acitivities.

A modest holiday now and again.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 01/05/2023 18:57

Everything you said plus:
Access to healthy food and a way to cook it
Education - up to university if they're able enough
Access to a phone to take/make calls
Transport to get around (buses are expensive now).

I think discretionary is on the edge. As technically I'd say they're not basic.

Dishwashersaurous · 01/05/2023 18:55

And we need to build millions of homes to make sure that everyone has a roof over their head.

Recognise that the market isn't working.

Build houses, including ones adapted for wheelchair use etc, and then allocate them to people when they are in need

Workyticket · 01/05/2023 18:52

Wages need to increase. Im 45. My parents had 3 kids. Dad worked in a factory, Mam worked part time in a shop

We had a holiday abroad every year (UK when we were little, went abroad when we were 13, 8 and 7) they bought a house and we had a car

Mam saved the family allowance and we had new clothes from that pot 4 times a year.

Families should be able to survive and thrive on 1.5 wages and do really well on 2

Working should always pay more than (non disabled) benefits. I joined a benefits Facebook page to help a friend - lots of claimants wanting to know the bare minimum they can work to claim maximum benefits. People clearly in relationships with the father of their kids but pretending to live separately to claim maximum amounts

Rent to private landlords needs to be capped. People are claiming huge amounts of full rent because rent is extortionate

Gingerkittykat · 01/05/2023 18:52

DriedFlowersLiveForever · 01/05/2023 18:43

I often wonder why we don't make able bodied people that can work do a few hours a day in a community based role to 'earn' their benefits. For example they could do some litter picking, clean graffiti etc.
Benefits should definitely not include money for netflix and holidays ffs, if those children of welfare parents go without they need to have a serious conversation with their parents later in life as to why they did so little to provide for them!
I am not well paid by any stretch of the imagination but my children attend hobbies and have holidays because I have worked my arse off solidly for years for them to have those things.
Why exactly should able bodied people capable of work expect the same lifestyle on benefits?

They had workfare type jobs where people were forced to work in Wh Smith, Poundland and other big companies for their benefits, I have no idea if these schemes still exist but they would lead to people working for as little as £2 an hour.

If we need graffiti cleaners, litter pickers etc then we should pay people a proper wage for doing those jobs and then they wouldn't need benefits at all.

Arginalia · 01/05/2023 18:51

I often wonder why we don't make able bodied people that can work do a few hours a day in a community based role to 'earn' their benefits. For example they could do some litter picking, clean graffiti etc.

If there is a need for litter pickers and graffiti cleaners, then advertise it as a job and pay someone a proper wage for doing it. If people are doing it to 'earn' benefits then it becomes a way of getting cheap labour, undermining the concept of minimum wage.

Dishwashersaurous · 01/05/2023 18:51

I wonder whether part of the answer is to have the state provide the basic necessary things, rather than money

So all children get access to free clubs and lunches at school. Well stocked libraries with new books.

Free public transport, reliable local buses.

A basic amount of electricity and water and Internet.

Thus the whole of society gets the basic things of life provided.

DriedFlowersLiveForever · 01/05/2023 18:43

I often wonder why we don't make able bodied people that can work do a few hours a day in a community based role to 'earn' their benefits. For example they could do some litter picking, clean graffiti etc.
Benefits should definitely not include money for netflix and holidays ffs, if those children of welfare parents go without they need to have a serious conversation with their parents later in life as to why they did so little to provide for them!
I am not well paid by any stretch of the imagination but my children attend hobbies and have holidays because I have worked my arse off solidly for years for them to have those things.
Why exactly should able bodied people capable of work expect the same lifestyle on benefits?

Swipe left for the next trending thread