Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What standard of living do you think should be the minimum everyone can afford?

331 replies

MondayAgainnn · 01/05/2023 16:35

What do you think the absolute basic minimum should be?

I think everybody should be able to afford:

Decent food
Safe housing
Any extra medical things needed, including dentistry
Internet package as it is completely necessary nowadays
Enough clothes to stay warm, dry, appropriate trainers for exercising etc
Enough for some discretionary spending - obviously this is harder to quantify, but things like Netflix, a coffee, cinema tickets I feel should be a normal attainable part of life for everyone
Enough to save a bit

Whether it is through work or through benefits I feel everyone in society should be able to have a lifestyle that is dignified, basically comfortable and with room for treats. Not just subsistence level.

What do you think the minimum should be?

OP posts:
nomoredrivingytu · 02/05/2023 04:09

@Emotionalstorm or walk, or skip, or do outdoor aerobics, pr squats, burpees or use one of the free outdoor exercise equipment in the park?

Or stuff like this www.healthline.com/nutrition/outdoor-workout-ideas#outdoor-hiit-workouts

You do realise that people stay fit and healthy without the use of a gym?

1000s of people manage this every single day!

Emotionalstorm · 02/05/2023 04:03

nomoredrivingytu · 02/05/2023 03:25

Why a gym? We have outdoor space where people can exercise.

So they can stay healthy. Not everyone wants to jog.

nomoredrivingytu · 02/05/2023 03:25

Emotionalstorm · 01/05/2023 23:27

Everyone should also have access to a smart phone and gym.

Why a gym? We have outdoor space where people can exercise.

Partyandbullshit · 02/05/2023 03:00

Shelter (housing, electricity, running water, clothing)
Food
Healthcare from cradle to grave
Wifi
Education to 18
Pension / right to retire late 60s
Freedom to vote
Clean air
Freedom from discrimination
Freedom of information

Nor Netflix, coffee, holidays and savings ffs 🙄

stayathomer · 02/05/2023 02:57

I think every home should be insulated and heating affordable for all, also food and clothing. The people saying Netflix shouldn’t be affordable to people on benefits- you don’t think people should have access to a spare tenner a month?! And depends what people mean by a holiday- for years we stayed in crumbly hostels in non touristy (but still great) areas or went on day trips to places that were free. I’d still have said we were going on holiday!

Willyoujustbequiet · 02/05/2023 01:40

justgettingthroughtheday · 01/05/2023 17:00

Wow!!! I'm disgusted by your views. Do you have any idea how expensive it can be to be disabled?
Absolutely vile comment

Agreed. Some people are plain ignorant.

Willyoujustbequiet · 02/05/2023 01:37

Botw1 · 01/05/2023 16:53

@MondayAgainnn

Benefits shouldn't provide a better quality of living than working would.

As long as mw is always more than you'd get on benefits (even if disabled)

That's a shocking thing to say regarding the disabled. Disgusting.

Emotionalstorm · 01/05/2023 23:27

Everyone should also have access to a smart phone and gym.

Emotionalstorm · 01/05/2023 23:26

I think childminders and childcare should be free and also enrichment activities for kids like sports, music or language lessons.

Citadel8 · 01/05/2023 23:07

Food
shelter
warmth
water
electricity
clothing

Yogameup · 01/05/2023 23:07

I'd add on dentistry and glasses. They're unaffordable to many people now.

Gingerkittykat · 01/05/2023 23:02

OhmygodDont · 01/05/2023 19:05

Unless you have a “bad back” like my dad who sometimes hears voices but goes to Mexico lol

can’t work tho clearly.

So you are saying they are committing benefit fraud by pretending to be disabled? Even disability benefits are not enough money to constantly go on constant long haul holidays.

IntheATeam · 01/05/2023 22:53

Finland had a trial for a universal basic income
$600 per month no strings attached
I assume that this was on top of accommodation

Camablanca · 01/05/2023 22:21

StarbucksSmarterSister · 01/05/2023 21:28

how about a military barracks style provision. So everyone gets food, roof over their head and clothes. If they want something else then they need to provide it themselves. But the state provides the roof over everyone head in an emergency.

Ah, the workhouse. Something right wing politicians have apparently expressed approval of.

military barracks style

And let's separate men, women and children and break up the family. Which is what often happened in such places.

You do realise that families live in military barracks, right? Like this one.
https://forceschildrenseducation.org.uk/base/glencorse

The wording may be emotive, but the idea isn't. Assisted living, retirement flats etc already exist. What about family sized flats?

For some reason British people are obsessed with 'outdoor space'. While simultaneously complaining about the shit weather. Everyone must have a 3 bed semi with a garden, or they're living like battery hens.

Other countries like Singapore (also a tiny island!) have well-designed, social housing flats. In London a lot of other nationalities are also happy to live in them.

Glencorse Barracks, Midlothian | Forces Children’s Education

Getting it right for forces families by the Association of Directors of Education in Scotland

https://forceschildrenseducation.org.uk/base/glencorse

XenoBitch · 01/05/2023 21:40

I agree with you, OP.

A few treats (coffee, cinema) should be part of the minimum, otherwise what is the point?
The benefit bashers on MN want to see anyone claiming benefits to be eating gruel in sack cloth and staring at bare walls. Meets their minimum of housing, clothing and food.

I am on benefits, and I live for my coffees with friends. It gives me a reason to get up and out. And if I am struggling to do that, then I can find something on Netflix.

Emotionalstorm · 01/05/2023 21:39

I think everyone should have as a minimum:

Universal childcare free at point of use from the age of 0 to start of full time education
Free access to summer schools for kids
Free education up to level of masters with bursaries/stipend if you are poor
Affordable non-processed and healthy food
Secure accommodation (either they own a home or have good tenancy protections & affordable rent)
Free access to medical treatment
Free access to dental treatment
A laptop and internet
A smart phone
Access to affordable leisure centres, gym and exercise class
A minimum of one holiday a year if you have kids
Affordable access or free access to enrichment activities for kids like music lessons, sports, dance, crafts etc

Jellycatspyjamas · 01/05/2023 21:37

Cases such as ours and that of your friend are not as rare as some might think.😘

Indeed they aren’t that rare, a colleagues wife had a stroke aged 35 which effectively ended her working life - she was previously fit and healthy.

Folk are good at suggesting others live to a much lower standard than they would want for themselves. We’re all one life changing event away from being reliant on the state and while some folk can make provision for the unforeseen, few could make enough provision to cover them in the event of not being able to work permanently. I’d like to think folk with disabilities/caring responsibilities deserve more than subsistence level support.

Rafferty10 · 01/05/2023 21:32

Noontimes · Today 20:48
In order to defend raising the benefits to fund this level of spend you must first ask 2 questions:

  1. what taxes would i increase / spend would I cut to fund this, and;
  2. * *
  3. if you were going to raise this money, could that money be spend more wisely elsewhere, such as by improving the nhs services to treat people who’s I’ll health is preventing them from working.
  4. * *
  5. I think funding public services such as the nhs properly is more important than ensuring everyone can afford Netflix and a holiday.

THIS ^

StarbucksSmarterSister · 01/05/2023 21:28

how about a military barracks style provision. So everyone gets food, roof over their head and clothes. If they want something else then they need to provide it themselves. But the state provides the roof over everyone head in an emergency.

Ah, the workhouse. Something right wing politicians have apparently expressed approval of.

military barracks style

And let's separate men, women and children and break up the family. Which is what often happened in such places.

StarbucksSmarterSister · 01/05/2023 21:23

Jellycatspyjamas · 01/05/2023 19:16

No one should bring children into the world without working out how they are going to pay and support them. Including if circumstances change.

A good friend has a child with significant physical and cognitive disabilities. She needs 24 hour care, will never live independently. In the space of 3 years my friend went from being married, having a successful career and a nice home in a nice area to being a single parent (dad decided he couldn’t cope and left), in an adapted council house, unable to work because there’s is no childcare that can accommodate her daughters need and she has multiple appointments for her daughter that no employer would accommodate. She will have a place in a special school next year, but less than standard school hours, so still unable to work.

How could she possibly have predicted that and planned accordingly?

It’s very easy from the comfort of your home to judge how people live their lives, much less easy when life hands you a curve ball. The benefits system needs to be agile enough to give meaningful support to those who need it. The whole furlough scheme is evidence that it’s not fit for purpose, if it was there would have been no need to effectively change the benefits system over lockdown.

Exactly. When I was at primary school my father contracted a rare illness and became disabled. My mother had to become his carer so we had no income. I wonder how many years salary the PP thinks they should have had in the bank in order to prepare for such an eventuality? 12, because that was how long he lived? 6? 3?

Cases such as ours and that of your friend are not as rare as some might think.

Scottishskifun · 01/05/2023 21:20

Jellycatspyjamas · 01/05/2023 21:00

Once all schools are equally filled with pupils from a variety of backgrounds people will make more fuss about underperforming schools and underfunded education because they won't be able to buy their way out of it.

Believe me, plenty of parents buy their way into good catchment areas in Scotland - East Renfrewshire and East Dumbartonshire houses prices reflect this. Generally speaking schools tend to have a relatively mixed demographic but there’s still a degree of buying your way into a nice catchment.

Yep happens in the North East as well!
There is a secondary in Aberdeen and all new housing estates around it have to sign a form saying they won't be in the catchment for it as its already oversubscribed with parents moving to be in catchment!
You can also apply to an out of catchment school you have to make a case for it but siblings attendance or childcare are reasons so a eutopia of the Scottish school system is a bit of rose tinted specs

HaroldeVwilliam · 01/05/2023 21:19

Unfortunately our country is wet and damp but I think an absolute basic should be to anyone living in mould and sorting out mould should like like a natinal amnesty.

Shinyandnew1 · 01/05/2023 21:04

Going to the cinema now and again is not a luxury.

I think it is. Along with buying coffees out, paying for Netflix/Sky/Disney Plus and upgrading to the newest iPhone.

We are not particularly hard up at the moment, but back in our more skint days, we didn’t do any of those things as they would have caned through our monthly money very quickly.

Jellycatspyjamas · 01/05/2023 21:00

Once all schools are equally filled with pupils from a variety of backgrounds people will make more fuss about underperforming schools and underfunded education because they won't be able to buy their way out of it.

Believe me, plenty of parents buy their way into good catchment areas in Scotland - East Renfrewshire and East Dumbartonshire houses prices reflect this. Generally speaking schools tend to have a relatively mixed demographic but there’s still a degree of buying your way into a nice catchment.