Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What standard of living do you think should be the minimum everyone can afford?

331 replies

MondayAgainnn · 01/05/2023 16:35

What do you think the absolute basic minimum should be?

I think everybody should be able to afford:

Decent food
Safe housing
Any extra medical things needed, including dentistry
Internet package as it is completely necessary nowadays
Enough clothes to stay warm, dry, appropriate trainers for exercising etc
Enough for some discretionary spending - obviously this is harder to quantify, but things like Netflix, a coffee, cinema tickets I feel should be a normal attainable part of life for everyone
Enough to save a bit

Whether it is through work or through benefits I feel everyone in society should be able to have a lifestyle that is dignified, basically comfortable and with room for treats. Not just subsistence level.

What do you think the minimum should be?

OP posts:
Reality25 · 02/05/2023 16:24

Jellycatspyjamas · 02/05/2023 14:52

After 5 years without further crimes, they are permitted to join British society via a new legal 10-year visa route (starting at year 1 when they leave the centre) if they can pass CEFR A1 English.

I assume by “illegal immigrants” you mean asylum seekers, or possibly those who have been trafficked?

Anyone who has broken our immigration laws.

If they are a genuine victim of being trafficked against their will they should be treated as a victim of crime instead. They will be able to cooperate with authorities here and in their country of origin to prove their identity and be able to return to their country of origin free of charge.

Reality25 · 02/05/2023 16:08

Jellycatspyjamas · 02/05/2023 14:50

*3) Looked after children who become adults.

  • Full state support equivalent to full-time minimum wage until they leave full-time education (inclusive of student maintenance loan if applicable).
  • After that they go to section 1) or 2)*
This completely ignores the impact of care experience on children and young people who often have very disrupted education particularly in high school and for whom there are significant barriers into further/higher education. It also ignores the impact of trauma which impacts learning capacity and executive functioning - it also doesn’t consider that many care experienced young people need a lot of practical help to learn how to live independently which impacts employment prospects.

You can easily have care experienced young people leaving full time education but not able to sustain employment for some time afterwards, money is only the start of their needs and they will need financial support beyond a one year limit.

As mentioned, if they have a severe mental impairment they move to Section 1) and get continued funding. Logically funds for special equipment mentioned can also be used for things like assisted living etc.

Jellycatspyjamas · 02/05/2023 14:52

After 5 years without further crimes, they are permitted to join British society via a new legal 10-year visa route (starting at year 1 when they leave the centre) if they can pass CEFR A1 English.

I assume by “illegal immigrants” you mean asylum seekers, or possibly those who have been trafficked?

Jellycatspyjamas · 02/05/2023 14:50

*3) Looked after children who become adults.

  • Full state support equivalent to full-time minimum wage until they leave full-time education (inclusive of student maintenance loan if applicable).
  • After that they go to section 1) or 2)*
This completely ignores the impact of care experience on children and young people who often have very disrupted education particularly in high school and for whom there are significant barriers into further/higher education. It also ignores the impact of trauma which impacts learning capacity and executive functioning - it also doesn’t consider that many care experienced young people need a lot of practical help to learn how to live independently which impacts employment prospects.

You can easily have care experienced young people leaving full time education but not able to sustain employment for some time afterwards, money is only the start of their needs and they will need financial support beyond a one year limit.

Reality25 · 02/05/2023 13:29

Interesting question.

Me personally:

  1. Physically or mentally unable to work due to severe disability/impairment.
  • Full state support equivalent to full-time minimum wage. No housing benefit.
  • No time limit unless impairment/disability overcome.
  • Reviewed annually for eligibility.
  • Relocation loan is available and will be deducted evenly from next 6 pay periods.
  • Funds available for specialist equipment if applicable, on case by case basis.
  1. Able-body and mind but lost job.
  • Full state support equivalent to full-time minimum wage for 3 months. No housing benefit.
  • Basic state support equivalent to 1/3 full-time minimum wage for 3 further months.
  • Zero regular financial support beyond 6 months. Job-seeking support in the form of CV and interview practice, and local job adverts will always be available.
  • Relocation loan is available and will be deducted evenly from first 6 pay periods of new job.
  • Refreshing future eligibility requires 5 years of paying tax above a threshold level.
  • If ineligible due to e.g. repeat job losses in quick succession then still eligible for basic state support (1/3 full-time min wage) for 3 months.
  • If still unemployed and have no money they can choose to live in centralised job-seeker accommodation instead of being homeless.
  1. Looked after children who become adults.
  • Full state support equivalent to full-time minimum wage until they leave full-time education (inclusive of student maintenance loan if applicable).
  • After that they go to section 1) or 2).
  1. Illegal immigrants.
  • Zero regular financial support.
  • Offshore immigration centre in Jersey/Isle of Wight/Isle of Man.
  • Basic food, water, clothing and room provided (military barracks-style). English, Maths and Science books provided up to A-Levels. British culture and history books also provided.
  • Deportation to country of origin if origin country accepts them back.
  • After 5 years without further crimes, they are permitted to join British society via a new legal 10-year visa route (starting at year 1 when they leave the centre) if they can pass CEFR A1 English. Access to job-seeking support and relocation loan will be provided. If after 12 months they are not in paid employment they can live in centralised job-seeker accommodation instead of being homeless.
  • Flight ticket always offered back to country of origin to encourage them to find their passport or identity documents.

The above is imo a good balance between compassion and empathy, encouraging responsible behaviour/self-improvement, and minimising the burden on net contributors.

Neededanewuserhandle · 02/05/2023 13:17

Partyandbullshit · 02/05/2023 12:59

Just look at America, an American UHNWI (and all US citizens for that matter) is required pay US taxes no matter where they reside in the world or where that wealth is earned. If they want to stop paying US taxes, they first need to renounce their US citizenship and deal with all the implications that incurs (especially when trying to run a business in the US). Even then the US have inserted specific clauses in their tax law that seeks to ensure anyone who does relinquish their citizenship for tax purposes may still be subject to certain tax and reporting obligations including being subject to an exit tax as if they’ve sold all assets and being required to file certain tax returns for up to 10 years.
The net result of that policy is that so few UHNWIs have left America that it doesn’t even register. A similar policy in the UK would take care of the tiny portion of UK citizens who would want to leave to avoid tax.

This is flawed. UHNWIs don’t fall into the category of citizenship and taxation like other people do. They strike individual deals with the IRS and government (directly or through lobbying) in order to pay less tax as a % than the middle classes and retain the same privileges as the rest of us (I live in the US).

Renouncing citizenship is for the “hoi polloi”: it takes a little time, the exit tax is around $30,000 last time I looked, and it’s meant to capture people with tens of millions only. The USA has close by tax havens which tailor bespoke deals for people with more than that but not enough to lobby government: Bermuda, the Bahamas, Cayman, USVI etc.

There was an article in the guardian a couple of weeks ago (sorry on phone, can’t link it) about the relative exodus of billionaires from Finland. Punitive taxes do lead to a brain and wealth drain. If they’re not leaving, it’s because it’s worth their while to stay. The EU will make it very difficult for member states to tailor their legislation like the US. The US is not a comparator for the EU, and the UK, only now coming out of the shadow of the EU, is going to go the way of the US. Almost the worst income (and health and educational etc) disparity of any developed nation in earth.

This is a moral issue. Taxation is just a representation of our beliefs and values. We all get the societies we deserve/vote for.

Our electoral system means the majority of us don't get what we voted for.

Neededanewuserhandle · 02/05/2023 13:13

JudgeRudy · 01/05/2023 17:08

Yes I hear people complain about someone 'poor' having the audacity to own a £200 smart phone, yet in the 70s/80s the cost of a TV was huge compared to now but every household had one. In fact some rented a TV because it was so expensive. Nobody thought those families should be ostracised from society.

I got a free Black and White TV from a neighbour in the early 1980s. We weren't all buying £300+ colour TVs - and many people (my parents included) rented their TVs.

Thesharkradar · 02/05/2023 13:08

Viviennemary · 02/05/2023 13:03

Benefits are far far too high compared to wages. Benefit top ups have contributed to employers paying lower wages and house price increases.

I agree wages are too low and house prices are too high.
We are now trapped in the situation where we can't recruit people to do essential work because the pay and conditions are not enough to incentivize people to do the work

Viviennemary · 02/05/2023 13:03

Benefits are far far too high compared to wages. Benefit top ups have contributed to employers paying lower wages and house price increases.

Partyandbullshit · 02/05/2023 12:59

Just look at America, an American UHNWI (and all US citizens for that matter) is required pay US taxes no matter where they reside in the world or where that wealth is earned. If they want to stop paying US taxes, they first need to renounce their US citizenship and deal with all the implications that incurs (especially when trying to run a business in the US). Even then the US have inserted specific clauses in their tax law that seeks to ensure anyone who does relinquish their citizenship for tax purposes may still be subject to certain tax and reporting obligations including being subject to an exit tax as if they’ve sold all assets and being required to file certain tax returns for up to 10 years.
The net result of that policy is that so few UHNWIs have left America that it doesn’t even register. A similar policy in the UK would take care of the tiny portion of UK citizens who would want to leave to avoid tax.

This is flawed. UHNWIs don’t fall into the category of citizenship and taxation like other people do. They strike individual deals with the IRS and government (directly or through lobbying) in order to pay less tax as a % than the middle classes and retain the same privileges as the rest of us (I live in the US).

Renouncing citizenship is for the “hoi polloi”: it takes a little time, the exit tax is around $30,000 last time I looked, and it’s meant to capture people with tens of millions only. The USA has close by tax havens which tailor bespoke deals for people with more than that but not enough to lobby government: Bermuda, the Bahamas, Cayman, USVI etc.

There was an article in the guardian a couple of weeks ago (sorry on phone, can’t link it) about the relative exodus of billionaires from Finland. Punitive taxes do lead to a brain and wealth drain. If they’re not leaving, it’s because it’s worth their while to stay. The EU will make it very difficult for member states to tailor their legislation like the US. The US is not a comparator for the EU, and the UK, only now coming out of the shadow of the EU, is going to go the way of the US. Almost the worst income (and health and educational etc) disparity of any developed nation in earth.

This is a moral issue. Taxation is just a representation of our beliefs and values. We all get the societies we deserve/vote for.

Thesharkradar · 02/05/2023 12:46

And this idea that if you try to recapture some of that wealth and redistribute it to the population, they’ll all just leave is also complete nonsense
They don't want to give up all the advantages that the UK gives them ...if they did that they'd lose even more of their wealth and income!

Thesharkradar · 02/05/2023 12:44

Great post@Thebestwaytoscareatory
and thank you for taking the time to make it 🙏

Blossomtoes · 02/05/2023 12:17

Spot on @Thebestwaytoscareatory. As you say, if the US can do it so can we.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/05/2023 11:51

Noontimes · 02/05/2023 10:29

Taxing the wealthy more raises very little tax because the ladder curve really does exist. People do leave if you increase their taxes, mainly cause the very wealthy are more likely to be international workers. If we want to raise this sort of money we cannot do so by raising taxes paid for by ‘people that are not me’ (ie the wealthy, or corporation tax). If we want to provide free Netflix to the world and cinema etc we would have to increase the basic rate of income tax by approx 10% and ditch the nil rate band. Still want to give everyone Netflix and a gym membership?

I honestly don’t think you appreciate just how big the gap between the top 1% and the rest is. You could absolutely, 100%, no questions asked, raise that sort of money from people who “are not me” or you for that matter. It’s this very consistently perpetuated myth that has allowed the situation to develop the way it has in the first place.

Since 2020 there has been around $42,000,000,000,000 worth of new wealth created globally. Of that $42,000,000,000,000; $28,000,000,000,000 has been captured by the top 1% of people or around 66%. That’s reflected across nations. In the UK the number of billionaires has increased by over 20% over the same time, and those billionaires have seen their total wealth increase by over 1000% since 1990. We now have a situation in the UK where 68,000 people control enough wealth to eradicate the entire UK national debt of £2,400,000,000,000 and STILL have enough money left over for each of them to have £15,000,000 (that’s more than someone on £30,000 pa will earn in 500 years by the way).

You cannot seriously sit here and seriously argue that a) this is a good or desirable situation to be in and b) that those poor UHNW individuals can’t possibly afford to have some of their wealth removed.

And this idea that if you try to recapture some of that wealth and redistribute it to the population, they’ll all just leave is also complete nonsense. Only about 5% of UHNWI relocate after they become successful and 84% of all billionaires live in the country of their birth. Yes, the Laffer curve provides a theoretical representation between taxation and government revenue but the impact of tax rates on UHNWI differs massively from the impact on other income groups due to their unique financial circumstances and ability to take advantage of tax planning strategies. Policies that seek to ensure UHNWI’s pay more into the system will not result in a mass exodus, especially if you implement said policies properly.

Just look at America, an American UHNWI (and all US citizens for that matter) is required pay US taxes no matter where they reside in the world or where that wealth is earned. If they want to stop paying US taxes, they first need to renounce their US citizenship and deal with all the implications that incurs (especially when trying to run a business in the US). Even then the US have inserted specific clauses in their tax law that seeks to ensure anyone who does relinquish their citizenship for tax purposes may still be subject to certain tax and reporting obligations including being subject to an exit tax as if they’ve sold all assets and being required to file certain tax returns for up to 10 years.
The net result of that policy is that so few UHNWIs have left America that it doesn’t even register. A similar policy in the UK would take care of the tiny portion of UK citizens who would want to leave to avoid tax.

Bumpitybumper · 02/05/2023 11:16

HistoryFanatic · 02/05/2023 11:02

Affordable and more available childcare so that those of us who receive top ups can work more and therefore not need those top ups.

Waiting for the "well you shouldn't have had children" comments. 😊

The issue of childcare is also a complex one.

Children aged under two in nursery have a ratio of one adult to three children. Add in the cost of premises, utilities, insurance, materials etc and unless you are paying nursery workers absolute peanuts (which to be fair we are doing this as a society already) then it is easy to see that childcare for those children is inherently expensive.

Not everyone has careers that will be adversely impacted by cutting hours for a few years and it could reasonably be more cost efficient in the short, medium and long term for many families to actually have the benefits topped up for a while and one parent look after the children for at least some of the working week rather than the state massively subsidising childcare only for a parent to go and stack shelves in a supermarket for a few extra hours.

It is nuanced and not one size fits all but it is important the people realise that heavily subsidised childcare still costs money and whilst the individual parents may feel like they are supporting themselves the financial burden they place on the state could actually be the same or greater.

HistoryFanatic · 02/05/2023 11:02

Affordable and more available childcare so that those of us who receive top ups can work more and therefore not need those top ups.

Waiting for the "well you shouldn't have had children" comments. 😊

Jellycatspyjamas · 02/05/2023 10:59

I'd much rather see properly funded services. And more support to allow disabled people to work where possible.

I agree more support is needed to make work accessible, it’s ridiculous that there are people who could work but for the lack of flexible, accessible employment. It doesn’t however address the question of living standards for those who cannot work either because of caring responsibilities or due to their own disability.

SouthCountryGirl · 02/05/2023 10:50

h3ll0o · 02/05/2023 06:58

It is currently believed that 1 in 5 are disabled, however, the number of people diagnosed with disabilities ismincreasing at a staggering rate. As a disabled person, I’m conscious that the government didn’t cause my disabilities and I do not expect them to provide me with extra money due to my ill health. I would much prefer these funds to be used to improve access to assessment and treatments.I would like to see access to high quality training to improve the employment prospects for disabled individuals and those on UC.

I believe the basic standard of living should cover shelter, heat and food. There should also be free bus passes and access to leisure services, including the library and swimming.

When my parents where both made redundant in the 90s our free bus pass and access to free swimming were invaluable.

How would those of us who need equipment fund it? I also wouldn't be able to pay someone to help me for a few hours a week.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 02/05/2023 10:39

I don't think anybody should collect more thana minimum full time wage in benefits unless they have extra expenses because of a disability.

And if a couple on full time minimum wage isn't enough to afford even one child? Should those who care for our elderly (for example) not be allowed to reproduce?

Emotionalstorm · 02/05/2023 10:37

nomoredrivingytu · 02/05/2023 04:09

@Emotionalstorm or walk, or skip, or do outdoor aerobics, pr squats, burpees or use one of the free outdoor exercise equipment in the park?

Or stuff like this www.healthline.com/nutrition/outdoor-workout-ideas#outdoor-hiit-workouts

You do realise that people stay fit and healthy without the use of a gym?

1000s of people manage this every single day!

Yes and babies didn't die she we didn't offer free nursery hours and we worked it out in the past but it doesn't mean we shouldn't do it does it?

What do you have against offering public leisure centres with gym and pool. I don't think this concept is completely outrageous.

Bumpitybumper · 02/05/2023 10:36

Nereides · 02/05/2023 09:42

The harsh fact is, people in the UK reducing their standard of living to give money to other countries would not benefit the poor in those countries. It would simply lead to the elite in those countries lining their own pockets while the poor remain as poor as ever. We cannot affect economic decisions or policies in other countries, so I find it reasonable to just focus on inequality within our own country.

And talking about how the rich should share their money but those who are poorer don’t - surely it’s about the amount of excess you have? The rich have more than they need - everyone else doesn’t. Ok maybe the average person has a tiny bit more than they need, but not much.

It goes back to the basic acceptable standard of living. Not many people have much beyond that. Those who do are quite rightly expected to be charitable.

That's an easy get out clause for not giving money to other countries. If you gave to a cause like Give Directly that pays cash directly to the people in need then you would bypass many concerns about corruption etc. So if you can't hide behind the corruption argument, how else can you morally justify focussing on British citizens only?

Also the idea of 'excess' isn't as clearcut as you imply. Compared to poorest in the world, the poorest in the UK enjoy excess in many areas of life. Many on this thread are suggesting that Netflix, holidays and gym memberships are a basic standard of living whilst to other people they are luxuries that they choose to go without. My point is there is no objective measure of what is 'enough' and what is 'excess

I also think this thread ignores the fact that people have autonomy over the money they are given. Just because you are poor it doesn't mean that you are frugal or make smart choices with the money you have. Plenty of people prioritise their spending in a way that affords them luxuries but means they can't afford the basics e.g. fags over food. The only way you could ensure everyone has a universal basic standard of living would be if the state spent the money on behalf of the recipients but this would go down like a lead balloon.

It's all very complicated and messy!

Noontimes · 02/05/2023 10:29

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/05/2023 10:10

This has been answered umpteen times.

  1. First you have to look at the reason 1% of the population have been able to acquire more wealth than 70% of the population combined. Then you implement polices that seek to prevent this from continuing to happen, along with one's that begin to redress that balance. For example, if the richest in society are making their money predominantly through selling shares & assets you would raise capital gains tax, not income tax and then add in a wealth tax to equalise the levels of disparity between top and bottom. This also isn't an all or nothing scenario that people who oppose increase taxes seem to think it has to be. We are trying to target a very select few individuals who have acquired obscene levels of wealth, not everyone who earns £100k, £200k, even £1m pa.

In the case of the UK you are talking about around 68,000 individuals who have more wealth than 47,500,000 people. We already have a graded/banded tax system in place and there's absolutely no reason we couldn't extend this to target UHNW individuals without impacting on everyone else (other than the UHNW individuals don't want this and have the ear of the government).

  1. In short no, the link between wealth and health is well established, with poorer people suffering more ill health than wealthy people. This is particular acute for children raised in poverty, who go on to suffer from a wide range of health-damaging impacts, negative educational outcomes and adverse long-term social and psychological outcomes. Providing a universal good standard of living for everyone would increase the health and education of the nation, reduce strain on public services, including the NHS, freeing up budget and resources to tackle other issues, and in the long-term would improve the overall wealth of the country. Helping people to a better standard of living, even if that means giving them money for Netflix or Holidays, would be a better long-term investment than just putting more money into trying to deal with the after effects of poverty.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0277953616307201

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2666776221002659

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0277953617307347

https://adc.bmj.com/content/101/8/759.short

https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/10/3/e032376.abstract

(You might need to request permission to view some of those papers).

Taxing the wealthy more raises very little tax because the ladder curve really does exist. People do leave if you increase their taxes, mainly cause the very wealthy are more likely to be international workers. If we want to raise this sort of money we cannot do so by raising taxes paid for by ‘people that are not me’ (ie the wealthy, or corporation tax). If we want to provide free Netflix to the world and cinema etc we would have to increase the basic rate of income tax by approx 10% and ditch the nil rate band. Still want to give everyone Netflix and a gym membership?

Wisterical · 02/05/2023 10:20

@Florenz Full time minimum wage is barely enough to live on these days and you think benefit should pay half of this? So have half as much food as they need, pay only half their bills... that is a disgusting attitude. Benefits should cover all the basics - if you want people in work to be 'significantly better off' then the minimum wage should be much higher than it is.

Florenz · 02/05/2023 10:13

Viviennemary · 02/05/2023 10:06

I don't think anybody should collect more thana minimum full time wage in benefits unless they have extra expenses because of a disability.

I don't think anyone should collect more than half of a minimum full time wage in benefits! Full stop. People who work full time should significantly better off than those that don't work at all. Even people that work part time should be somewhat better off than those who don't work at all.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/05/2023 10:10

Noontimes · 01/05/2023 20:48

In order to defend raising the benefits to fund this level of spend you must first ask 2 questions:

  1. what taxes would i increase / spend would I cut to fund this, and;

  2. if you were going to raise this money, could that money be spend more wisely elsewhere, such as by improving the nhs services to treat people who’s I’ll health is preventing them from working.

I think funding public services such as the nhs properly is more important than ensuring everyone can afford Netflix and a holiday.

This has been answered umpteen times.

  1. First you have to look at the reason 1% of the population have been able to acquire more wealth than 70% of the population combined. Then you implement polices that seek to prevent this from continuing to happen, along with one's that begin to redress that balance. For example, if the richest in society are making their money predominantly through selling shares & assets you would raise capital gains tax, not income tax and then add in a wealth tax to equalise the levels of disparity between top and bottom. This also isn't an all or nothing scenario that people who oppose increase taxes seem to think it has to be. We are trying to target a very select few individuals who have acquired obscene levels of wealth, not everyone who earns £100k, £200k, even £1m pa.

In the case of the UK you are talking about around 68,000 individuals who have more wealth than 47,500,000 people. We already have a graded/banded tax system in place and there's absolutely no reason we couldn't extend this to target UHNW individuals without impacting on everyone else (other than the UHNW individuals don't want this and have the ear of the government).

  1. In short no, the link between wealth and health is well established, with poorer people suffering more ill health than wealthy people. This is particular acute for children raised in poverty, who go on to suffer from a wide range of health-damaging impacts, negative educational outcomes and adverse long-term social and psychological outcomes. Providing a universal good standard of living for everyone would increase the health and education of the nation, reduce strain on public services, including the NHS, freeing up budget and resources to tackle other issues, and in the long-term would improve the overall wealth of the country. Helping people to a better standard of living, even if that means giving them money for Netflix or Holidays, would be a better long-term investment than just putting more money into trying to deal with the after effects of poverty.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0277953616307201

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2666776221002659

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0277953617307347

https://adc.bmj.com/content/101/8/759.short

https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/10/3/e032376.abstract

(You might need to request permission to view some of those papers).

https://adc.bmj.com/content/101/8/759.short