Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What standard of living do you think should be the minimum everyone can afford?

331 replies

MondayAgainnn · 01/05/2023 16:35

What do you think the absolute basic minimum should be?

I think everybody should be able to afford:

Decent food
Safe housing
Any extra medical things needed, including dentistry
Internet package as it is completely necessary nowadays
Enough clothes to stay warm, dry, appropriate trainers for exercising etc
Enough for some discretionary spending - obviously this is harder to quantify, but things like Netflix, a coffee, cinema tickets I feel should be a normal attainable part of life for everyone
Enough to save a bit

Whether it is through work or through benefits I feel everyone in society should be able to have a lifestyle that is dignified, basically comfortable and with room for treats. Not just subsistence level.

What do you think the minimum should be?

OP posts:
SouthCountryGirl · 03/05/2023 14:00

TreadLight · 03/05/2023 12:58

I pay tens of thousands of pounds in tax a year and have the inconvenience of having to work a couple of thousands hours for the privilege of paying it.

If you are on disability benefits you are given tens of thousands of pounds a year and don't think you should face a slight inconvenience of an annual assessment.

In terms of hourly pay, it must amount to thousands of pounds per hour.

"slight inconvenience"? Yes it's really sightly inconvenient when you're assessed by someone who has no experience of your condition and you get your money stopped because they think they know better than your medically qualified consultant who has access to your notes.

This happened to me. No PIP (switched from DLA) for 3 months which meant I lost £60 a week ESA (as you can get extra if on mid / high care or PIP care, live alone and no one claims carers for you) plus about £70 a week DLA.

How given that I lost around £130 a week do I pay for the care and equipment I need?

TreadLight · 03/05/2023 12:58

I pay tens of thousands of pounds in tax a year and have the inconvenience of having to work a couple of thousands hours for the privilege of paying it.

If you are on disability benefits you are given tens of thousands of pounds a year and don't think you should face a slight inconvenience of an annual assessment.

In terms of hourly pay, it must amount to thousands of pounds per hour.

Florenz · 03/05/2023 12:52

Blossomtoes · 03/05/2023 12:48

You determine that from one assessment and clinical opinion. A degenerative condition isn’t going to get better, is it?

You can't do it that way. A lifetime of benefits can run to millions. It'd leave the assessors open to bribery (or the fraudsters getting one of their own within the system) if one assessment was enough for benefits for life. It'd destroy the entire system in the long run as the public would lose confidence if they saw it being abused to that extent.

SouthCountryGirl · 03/05/2023 12:50

Can you please explain the point of assessing those of us who were born with our disabilities? After 34 years it's extremely unlikely that I'm going to wake up one day and be cured.

Blossomtoes · 03/05/2023 12:48

You determine that from one assessment and clinical opinion. A degenerative condition isn’t going to get better, is it?

Florenz · 03/05/2023 12:46

Blossomtoes · 03/05/2023 12:43

What part of lifelong and degenerative are you having trouble understanding?

But how do you determine that? From one assessment? A lifetime of benefits is a lot of money. You can't make the system so weak because fraudsters will ruthlessly exploit any weakness.

How do you even make sure the recipient is still alive if there are no checks? They could have a family member claiming for them for years.

There has to be stringent and frequent checks. Otherwise the whole thing just falls apart.

Porkandbeans1 · 03/05/2023 12:45

Florenz · 03/05/2023 10:55

It's the way that works best for everyone. You can't have a system where people get checked once, and if they can fool the assessor or bribe the assessor, they get benefits for life with no further checks. That would be insane. The system has to work best for everyone, so not just the people receiving the benefits, but the people paying for them as well. And to me, attending an assessment once a year in return for a year's money, isn't really that unreasonable or stressful.

I completely disagree. I used to work in a care home that supported adults with learning difficulties who had very challenging behaviour. These were people who were non verbal, violent, incontinent and unable in just about every way to take care of themselves. They would have to have their benefit entitlement reassessed. What an utter waste of money.

Blossomtoes · 03/05/2023 12:43

What part of lifelong and degenerative are you having trouble understanding?

Florenz · 03/05/2023 12:39

Blossomtoes · 03/05/2023 12:30

I’ve literally just said who doesn’t need annual assessment.

Why do they not need annual assessment?

Do you not think it leaves the system massively open to fraud if one assessment unlocks a lifetime of benefits? How much are those benefits worth?

Blossomtoes · 03/05/2023 12:30

I’ve literally just said who doesn’t need annual assessment.

Florenz · 03/05/2023 11:54

Blossomtoes · 03/05/2023 11:07

You can have a system where people who quite obviously have a lifeline degenerative disability don’t have to go through a wasteful, stressful, pointless process. It doesn’t matter what you think about the stress, this process has caused people to commit suicide.

I don't think you can, The system has to be the same for everyone otherwise it doesn't work. If it's not the same for everyone, who decides who it's not the same for and how do you ensure they are infallible?

SouthCountryGirl · 03/05/2023 11:10

Florenz · 03/05/2023 10:55

It's the way that works best for everyone. You can't have a system where people get checked once, and if they can fool the assessor or bribe the assessor, they get benefits for life with no further checks. That would be insane. The system has to work best for everyone, so not just the people receiving the benefits, but the people paying for them as well. And to me, attending an assessment once a year in return for a year's money, isn't really that unreasonable or stressful.

As you've clearly been through the bullshit that is the PIP assessment, (I was "lucky" to be assessed for ESA on paper) you'd know how unreasonable and stressful those assessments are.

Blossomtoes · 03/05/2023 11:07

Lifelong, ffs!

Blossomtoes · 03/05/2023 11:07

You can have a system where people who quite obviously have a lifeline degenerative disability don’t have to go through a wasteful, stressful, pointless process. It doesn’t matter what you think about the stress, this process has caused people to commit suicide.

Florenz · 03/05/2023 10:55

SouthCountryGirl · 03/05/2023 10:32

But it also wastes a lot of money and people's time. How does that work best for everyone?

It's the way that works best for everyone. You can't have a system where people get checked once, and if they can fool the assessor or bribe the assessor, they get benefits for life with no further checks. That would be insane. The system has to work best for everyone, so not just the people receiving the benefits, but the people paying for them as well. And to me, attending an assessment once a year in return for a year's money, isn't really that unreasonable or stressful.

Blossomtoes · 03/05/2023 10:47

SouthCountryGirl · 03/05/2023 10:32

But it also wastes a lot of money and people's time. How does that work best for everyone?

It’s not best for anyone. It’s absolutely shocking. The amount of stress it causes and the money it wastes are appalling.

SouthCountryGirl · 03/05/2023 10:32

Florenz · 02/05/2023 21:38

Because there has to be one system that works the best for everyone involved, and assessing everyone annually stops people from fooling the assessors just once and being able to access benefits for life with no further checks needed.

But it also wastes a lot of money and people's time. How does that work best for everyone?

OnlyTheBravest · 03/05/2023 02:19

I think a full time minimum wage salay should cover
Enough to rent a decent studio/1 bed flat,
Utilities including broadband and mobile phone,
Council tax,
Food,
Travel,
And a small disposable income for clothes and entertainment.

For families 1 full and one part time worker should be able to cover above but be able to rent a 2 bed flat minimum .

I would like to see full time workers be able to have the basics without having to claim top ups. It would probably require employers to pay their staff more, massive amounts of social housing to be built with controlled rent set to a third of average pay for the local area and free childcare from 9 months including nights and weekends for shift workers.

Florenz · 02/05/2023 21:38

Sweetladyjane · 02/05/2023 19:27

Why would I need to be assessed annually for a health condition that isn’t going to change?

Because there has to be one system that works the best for everyone involved, and assessing everyone annually stops people from fooling the assessors just once and being able to access benefits for life with no further checks needed.

Sweetladyjane · 02/05/2023 19:27

Why would I need to be assessed annually for a health condition that isn’t going to change?

Reality25 · 02/05/2023 16:47

Jellycatspyjamas · 02/05/2023 16:28

As mentioned, if they have a severe mental impairment they move to Section 1) and get continued funding. Logically funds for special equipment mentioned can also be used for things like assisted living etc.

Tell me you know nothing about looked after children without saying you know nothing about looked after children.

Ah yes, resorting to being disrespectful in a discussion - it's just a matter of time for the left-leaning demographic!

Not that it really matters but I do happen to have personal first-hand experience of looked after children and their transition into adult life.

Noontimes · 02/05/2023 16:37

It’s not a crime to claim asylum, it’s just our vile government claims that it is. Don’t fall for their lies.

Noontimes · 02/05/2023 16:36

Reality25 · 02/05/2023 13:29

Interesting question.

Me personally:

  1. Physically or mentally unable to work due to severe disability/impairment.
  • Full state support equivalent to full-time minimum wage. No housing benefit.
  • No time limit unless impairment/disability overcome.
  • Reviewed annually for eligibility.
  • Relocation loan is available and will be deducted evenly from next 6 pay periods.
  • Funds available for specialist equipment if applicable, on case by case basis.
  1. Able-body and mind but lost job.
  • Full state support equivalent to full-time minimum wage for 3 months. No housing benefit.
  • Basic state support equivalent to 1/3 full-time minimum wage for 3 further months.
  • Zero regular financial support beyond 6 months. Job-seeking support in the form of CV and interview practice, and local job adverts will always be available.
  • Relocation loan is available and will be deducted evenly from first 6 pay periods of new job.
  • Refreshing future eligibility requires 5 years of paying tax above a threshold level.
  • If ineligible due to e.g. repeat job losses in quick succession then still eligible for basic state support (1/3 full-time min wage) for 3 months.
  • If still unemployed and have no money they can choose to live in centralised job-seeker accommodation instead of being homeless.
  1. Looked after children who become adults.
  • Full state support equivalent to full-time minimum wage until they leave full-time education (inclusive of student maintenance loan if applicable).
  • After that they go to section 1) or 2).
  1. Illegal immigrants.
  • Zero regular financial support.
  • Offshore immigration centre in Jersey/Isle of Wight/Isle of Man.
  • Basic food, water, clothing and room provided (military barracks-style). English, Maths and Science books provided up to A-Levels. British culture and history books also provided.
  • Deportation to country of origin if origin country accepts them back.
  • After 5 years without further crimes, they are permitted to join British society via a new legal 10-year visa route (starting at year 1 when they leave the centre) if they can pass CEFR A1 English. Access to job-seeking support and relocation loan will be provided. If after 12 months they are not in paid employment they can live in centralised job-seeker accommodation instead of being homeless.
  • Flight ticket always offered back to country of origin to encourage them to find their passport or identity documents.

The above is imo a good balance between compassion and empathy, encouraging responsible behaviour/self-improvement, and minimising the burden on net contributors.

Blimey! You do know that this country makes it impossible for refugees from e.g. Sudan to claim asylum legally dont you? So someone fleeing fighting Sudan gets here on a small boat (there is no other route, airlines will not take them as they do not have a visa, and the UK government provides no means for Sudanese refugees to get here)and gets treated no better than a dog??? Jeez!

SouthCountryGirl · 02/05/2023 16:30

What's the point of assessing those of us annually who have incurable disabilities?

Jellycatspyjamas · 02/05/2023 16:28

As mentioned, if they have a severe mental impairment they move to Section 1) and get continued funding. Logically funds for special equipment mentioned can also be used for things like assisted living etc.

Tell me you know nothing about looked after children without saying you know nothing about looked after children.

Swipe left for the next trending thread