Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What standard of living do you think should be the minimum everyone can afford?

331 replies

MondayAgainnn · 01/05/2023 16:35

What do you think the absolute basic minimum should be?

I think everybody should be able to afford:

Decent food
Safe housing
Any extra medical things needed, including dentistry
Internet package as it is completely necessary nowadays
Enough clothes to stay warm, dry, appropriate trainers for exercising etc
Enough for some discretionary spending - obviously this is harder to quantify, but things like Netflix, a coffee, cinema tickets I feel should be a normal attainable part of life for everyone
Enough to save a bit

Whether it is through work or through benefits I feel everyone in society should be able to have a lifestyle that is dignified, basically comfortable and with room for treats. Not just subsistence level.

What do you think the minimum should be?

OP posts:
Tumbleweed101 · 01/05/2023 17:14

Anyone working full time should be earning at a rate that covers average housing, bills, transport, food, medical, basic holiday and some for savings for emergencies. The min wage should be enough to provide all the above without top ups, even if you are a single working adult.

Benefits should only be needed if you're not working, not as a top up to a full time wage.

Everyone who works should be able to be comfortable for their labours. The higher the wage the more luxuries you can buy, bigger home etc. But everyone should start on being able to manage a basic, simple life without getting into debt or needing a food bank or needing top ups.

MondayAgainnn · 01/05/2023 17:12

It's all very well to say that holidays or the odd trip to the cinema are luxuries - yes, they are, but should we really expect people to lead entirely bleak lives with never a treat, not even on a birthday?

Exactly.

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 01/05/2023 17:12

Reugny · 01/05/2023 16:48

What for children?

Remember children can be taken away by school or some group like scouts on a holiday.

Or do you think it is ok for a child to never see the sea, countryside or a city if they live rurally?

I don't think an annual holiday is a necessity, but maybe 4 or 5 holidays through out your life time.

JaninaDuszejko · 01/05/2023 17:11

Do you mean basics for a single person working FT, a family where both parents work FT, the basics for someone who can't work FT because they are too old or disabled to work (so will never work again or can only work PT) or the basics for someone unemployed but in good health and fit to work? Because I do think those things are different. Full time wages should be enough to pay bills and have a bit more for savings and treats and should mean you don't have to rely on benefits. Not sure if that's possible, e.g. four single people on NMW living in a house share can live on less individually than a family with children with 2 wages and childcare costs.

Holidays aren't essentials but I think day trips probably are.

Arginalia · 01/05/2023 17:11

TreadLight · 01/05/2023 17:08

@Arginalia It's all very well to say that holidays or the odd trip to the cinema are luxuries - yes, they are, but should we really expect people to lead entirely bleak lives with never a treat, not even on a birthday? That kind of lifestyle is what drives some people to anti-social behaviour or crime - because they have to 'get their kicks' somehow.

I think we should expect people to get a job so they can support themselves and then they can afford holidays or the odd trip to the cinema. It is better for them and it is better for society.

I haven't said they shouldn't. The OP asked what the minimum lifestyle expectation should be. The question of whether the current benefits system is fit for purpose is another matter.

Shinyandnew1 · 01/05/2023 17:10

Meals out, television subscriptions, takeaways and cinema trips are luxuries. They are nice, but if you can’t afford them-they go. If we are skint, then I wouldn’t expect to have a meal out once a month, have the hearing on a day, get takeaways, upgrade my phone etc I would shop for cheaper dinners, wouldn’t buy books or have coffees out. I would plan cheap days out with the kids, eg days at the beach, park, woods with sandwiches rather than going to theme parks, cinema, bowling etc

Lots of the things I mentioned aren’t basics.

rainraingoawaay · 01/05/2023 17:09

I think the absolute basic minimum would be

  • a home
  • heating / electricity / gas
  • food
  • technology to a point (eg. A phone but not necessarily the latest iPhone)
  • healthcare

Holidays / savings / treats / subscriptions are all above the basic minimum imo - the whole idea of basic minimum is the bare essentials surely?

OhmygodDont · 01/05/2023 17:09

I agree the internet and a way to access it is a requirement these days. Homework is set online schools email not write etc.

JudgeRudy · 01/05/2023 17:08

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 01/05/2023 16:43

Despite certain demographics in society thinking it’s 1998, a smart phone/ device with internet is vital to everything.

Yes I hear people complain about someone 'poor' having the audacity to own a £200 smart phone, yet in the 70s/80s the cost of a TV was huge compared to now but every household had one. In fact some rented a TV because it was so expensive. Nobody thought those families should be ostracised from society.

TreadLight · 01/05/2023 17:08

@Arginalia It's all very well to say that holidays or the odd trip to the cinema are luxuries - yes, they are, but should we really expect people to lead entirely bleak lives with never a treat, not even on a birthday? That kind of lifestyle is what drives some people to anti-social behaviour or crime - because they have to 'get their kicks' somehow.

I think we should expect people to get a job so they can support themselves and then they can afford holidays or the odd trip to the cinema. It is better for them and it is better for society.

OhmygodDont · 01/05/2023 17:07

3BSHKATS · 01/05/2023 17:05

People very rarely tell the whole truth or paint an accurate picture - my parents went on holiday to florida whilst on benefits - working cash in hand too obviously. But if anyone asked it was entirely funded by benefits

So benefit fraud which mn doesn’t believe exists remember.

sylvandweller · 01/05/2023 17:07

MondayAgainnn · 01/05/2023 16:35

What do you think the absolute basic minimum should be?

I think everybody should be able to afford:

Decent food
Safe housing
Any extra medical things needed, including dentistry
Internet package as it is completely necessary nowadays
Enough clothes to stay warm, dry, appropriate trainers for exercising etc
Enough for some discretionary spending - obviously this is harder to quantify, but things like Netflix, a coffee, cinema tickets I feel should be a normal attainable part of life for everyone
Enough to save a bit

Whether it is through work or through benefits I feel everyone in society should be able to have a lifestyle that is dignified, basically comfortable and with room for treats. Not just subsistence level.

What do you think the minimum should be?

Clean air
Outside space for play and exercise
A library

MondayAgainnn · 01/05/2023 17:07

ok not ol

OP posts:
MondayAgainnn · 01/05/2023 17:07

Ah ol @Botw1 I misunderstood then I apologise.

Agree in general that wages need to be much higher, the wage stagnation of the last twenty years has been so destructive.

OP posts:
Arginalia · 01/05/2023 17:05

I pretty much agree with you, OP, and with pps who have mentioned a holiday - one week's modest annual holiday, e.g. camping or self-catering static caravan type of thing.

It's all very well to say that holidays or the odd trip to the cinema are luxuries - yes, they are, but should we really expect people to lead entirely bleak lives with never a treat, not even on a birthday? That kind of lifestyle is what drives some people to anti-social behaviour or crime - because they have to 'get their kicks' somehow.

MondayAgainnn · 01/05/2023 17:05

I would consider dentistry as a standard medical need, not an extra medical need.

Well, yes I agree but unfortunately it has become something of a luxury.

Before the pandemic I think I had to pay about 1200 quid for my root canal to a private dentist, for example.

OP posts:
3BSHKATS · 01/05/2023 17:05

People very rarely tell the whole truth or paint an accurate picture - my parents went on holiday to florida whilst on benefits - working cash in hand too obviously. But if anyone asked it was entirely funded by benefits

CantFindTheBeat · 01/05/2023 17:03

There could well be a time when a universal basic income is needed as many lower paid but non-manual jobs will become automated or eradicated.

I think your list is pretty good, OP and I would expect a universal income to cover those things - maybe not the cinema as that is a niche luxury.

I'd also include adequate heating, and possibly basic gym membership.

Botw1 · 01/05/2023 17:03

@MondayAgainnn

No.

I'm suggesting that wages should never be subsitence. That they should be much higher than they currently are.

And that benefits should be a bit less than what you can earn on a wage but still cover what you described in your op

I thought that's what we were discussing?

Your hypothetical scenario, not reality?

thecatsthecats · 01/05/2023 17:02

I would redesign it all from the ground up, around the old English entitlements.

Wood, water, stone.

Aka, energy (heat and light), water, and shelter.

Nobody should have to pay for those things. I'd add wifi because it's 2023.

I think it's good for the vast majority of people to employ themselves, to exercise and to make their own creative endeavours - much healthier mentally than sitting on your arse watching Netflix.

Food would all be local and organic, and price capped to minimum profits.

There would be a lot of localised labour in this, a healthier population, and fewer mental health problems, and a better environment. You can have literally anything else manufactured/provided, but you have to earn it.

I think the vast majority would be pretty happy with the simple life, spending time in a rich local community. Better than the utter mess that is late stage capitalism.

JMSA · 01/05/2023 17:01

Rent and bills. I wouldn't even manage that on my salary alone, despite working full-time.

OhmygodDont · 01/05/2023 17:01

Incase anyone else misunderstood. My
only holidays abroad where as a child. Where paid for by my benefit claiming parents. Hope that helps 🙄

Botw1 · 01/05/2023 17:01

Are people misreading what I'm saying?

SpringOn · 01/05/2023 17:01

Wisterical · 01/05/2023 16:51

Smart phone (or phone and some type of computer) and transport costs are necessities these days. I don't think savings comes under an 'absolute basic'.

Saying benefits should NOT provide for the basics, as @SpringOn did, is obscene.

I didn’t say that! I said minimum wage jobs should pay more than they currently do so that all those things in the OP could be covered. And that benefits, for those who were able to work, should be a little less than that, to make working worthwhile.

Perhaps we disagree on what the basics are?

justgettingthroughtheday · 01/05/2023 17:01

2bazookas · 01/05/2023 16:54

Internet package as it is completely necessary nowadays

Not to the 1.5 million UK homes that have no internet access.

  • Enough for some discretionary spending - obviously this is harder to quantify, but things like Netflix, a coffee, cinema tickets I feel should be a normal attainable part of life for everyone.

Enough to save a bit*

None of those are absolute minimum basic essentials in my view.

The vast majority of homes without internet are the elderly. They virtually all have landlines however so the costs are still there