Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these kids are CFs

82 replies

IsItOnly2023 · 01/05/2023 12:59

Hi all, first post as OP, hope it's not too lengthy.

My DS (15) is running a student company with 14 others under the Young Enterprise Company Programme. He's appointed as "Managing Director" and has esentially single-handedly (with some help from others) turned it into a success.

The company does a few things but one of the things it does is buy sweets/brownies and drinks from cash-and-carry and sell it at the school's weekend sports events. He and the boy who runs that are usually at the events but DS was at Alton Towers with a friend and the other boy had an argument with his dad so couldn't go.

Anyway, 4 people went to the event with £65 worth of stock and came back with £25 and little stock. 1 boy says he tried to keep it under control but the others ate/drank all the stock. DS not impressed, and not entirely sure on what to do. Context: They are going to the Company of the Year competition on Wednesday (which DS wrote the entire entry for!) and have End of Year exams this week. Year 10 so not too bad but still important.

I said DS should get them to pay for new stock and go to the cash and carry themselves (me/DH have tended to drive DS there). Every student had to pay £20 in for share money, so it could be taken off their shares so they get less return after eating £40 of profit! Or even ask teacher to warn them/stop them representing the business at the competition.

What do you think? I am happy to answer any clarifying questions.

OP posts:
IsItOnly2023 · 01/05/2023 16:44

@AgnesX All on the board as such.
@Camablanca @Sewingdufus DS will go to the meeting with plans for future- keeping an inventory, set amounts for staff etc. and propose these. He will also try to ascertain what happened and then present the options to the board: official warning, reduction of shares, buying more, not going on Wednesday, repaying the company.

The only thing he's still not sure on what to do is what to say in the email to the teacher, who is the ultimate arbiter. Obviously ask him to sit in on the meeting but what else? Any suggestions PP?

OP posts:
Commonsensitivity · 01/05/2023 16:43

Really this is part of the learning as you always encounter dicks in real business. Let your son brainstorm some strategies then implement them. Careful about being a helicopter parent about it.

Camablanca · 01/05/2023 16:35

PP have given good suggestion but your 'DS' shouldn't be doing it all. he should get the others on board with agreeing that the thieves need to be punished, and made to replace the stock. They can then decide what action to take...

Sewingdufus · 01/05/2023 16:30

What a horrid situation.

The thieves need to be presented with options to restore the stock or money - pay retail for what they consumed, replace the stock themselves, pay the cost of stock replacement (including petrol costs) for DS to revisit cash-n-carry. A very clear timescale also needs agreeing. Once all agreed the teacher overseeing needs to know what has happened and how they are going to rectify the situation.

GraysPapaya · 01/05/2023 16:28

Moving forward every item that goes out needs to be tallied, so an inventory can be taken after each sale period. Cross reference with money and any thieves will be immediately kicked off the team

AgnesX · 01/05/2023 16:23

Are the others "on the Board" or are they "employees"?

Try that in a proper company (even a start-up) and there's a fair chance they'd be getting some sort of warning.

Appalling and a hard lesson to have to learn for everyone.

SequinsandStilettos · 01/05/2023 16:16

The 4 who went pay £10 each and replace the stock
The other ten, including your son, go on Wednesday - these four don't
Vote of no confidence or written warnings

Testina · 01/05/2023 16:14

@ForTheSakeOfThePenguin “Obviously, you have no children or they are still very young. End of year exams occur at this time of the year for GCSE, A levels, BTECs, a multitude of other qualifications and undergraduate degrees.”

Not obviously at all. In fact, I’ve had 3 go through Y10 (2 of mine and a stepchild) and none had “end of year” exams barely more than 2/3 of the way through the year. He’s Y10, he’s doing a degree 🤣

Dishwashersaurous · 01/05/2023 16:11

And this is why I hate the whole young enterprise thing.

It doesn't actually teach kids about business. Instead it just ends up with one or two children doing everything and various parental subsidies

Blueblell · 01/05/2023 16:06

He needs to get them together and explain that for the competition they need to show a profit. So they need to pay for what they have eaten at the selling price of the event to balance the books.

going forward suggest they buy a small amount of snacks that they keep separate from the stock that they sell for “staff” consumption. For this they could all chip in.

AuntieJune · 01/05/2023 15:59

This is both hilarious and an opportunity for learning.

See if you can find a lawyer who will talk to them about what would happen in a real life scenario. Who is responsible for wrongdoing in a business? How do you calculate what the loss is (is this the basic cost price, or the lost profit if all cakes had been sold)? When is one partner in a business liable for wrongdoing of another? Could they have laid out more consequences to stop this kind of wrongdoing, and what would have been enough to stop it?

They could all learn a valuable lesson from it, if handled in the right way.

AppallinglyReheated · 01/05/2023 15:51

He or they, depending on how many are involved in finance/stock/purchasing directly - need to work out the maths..

Just the figures, what there was, what there should be, what there isn't, etc etc.

Then present that to the full board (ideally with the relevant teacher present!) and ask the full board what the solution is to a/ resolve the immediate problem and b/ avoid this happening again.

Once that is figured out, THEN they can determine exactly who was responsible and who pays for what.

And possibly discuss that in real life, employees would simply be sacked, immediately, for theft of stock or cash.

JMSA · 01/05/2023 15:51

That's so unfair on the conscientious ones like your son! They certainly are cheeky wee sods and YANBU.

ForTheSakeOfThePenguin · 01/05/2023 15:49

Testina · 01/05/2023 14:59

What are your son’s suggestions? He’s 15, he should have some.
I do think it’s fine to come to a parent for advice, but this is hardly a complicated situation.
You will support him best by listening to his ideas.

And random but I’m curious - why is he having end of year exams when it’s not the end of the year? 🤣

Obviously, you have no children or they are still very young. End of year exams occur at this time of the year for GCSE, A levels, BTECs, a multitude of other qualifications and undergraduate degrees.

sofabedsofa · 01/05/2023 15:47

Your son and his friend weren’t there so they don’t have the full picture. It could be that every single child was equally to blame, that it was just a couple of the kids or anything in between.

I think your son needs to email the teacher and ask them to be present during a meeting with everyone there. Once your son, his friend and the teacher have a better idea if exactly what went on they can make decisions about next steps.

At the moment your son doesn’t know exactly what happened. Teacher should def be involved in this. Lots of good learning can be taken from this - it’s an opportunity for reflection and growth not a crisis that your son has to fix single handed.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 01/05/2023 15:44

They replace the stock. Then they're fired.

IsItOnly2023 · 01/05/2023 15:44

@Keepitweird Yes they do. He emailed him but the business advisor is more of a softly softly approach but suggested them not being allowed to represent the company at company of the year competition. He's leaving that to the teacher. As he was in twice last week to help them prepare for the competition, he cannot make it yomorrow. He will be in on Wednesday though for the competition.
@HarrietStyles Either way it's an issue, if it turns out that's the case then... Well I'm not sure. They seem more incompetent than thieving though.

OP posts:
Keepitweird · 01/05/2023 15:38

Do they not have an external business advisor for their team? I have acted in that capacity before for teams of YE and this is the type of scenario I'd expect to be being approached about ref how to handle it within the realms of a 'business scenario' in which case I'd be sitting in on the meeting whilst the MD facilitates the meeting and present the options of replacing the stock and providing the business with the difference in price for full retail value as well (given they ate/drank it at cost price but deprived their business of the ability to sell at retail price) or having the retail value taken from their shareholding........

Piony · 01/05/2023 15:38

OK but my bigger point is that him imposing a "top down" solution on the team is not really appropriate. The suggestions you've come up with - him asking for cost price Vs full whack, him going to the cash and carry, him talking to a teacher - are very much unilateral decisions you are supporting him to make.

I think he should be going to the meeting with questions rather than answers. He'll only alienate them more by going in and telling them what he's decided the next steps are.

HarrietStyles · 01/05/2023 15:37

That seems like a lot of stock for them to have eaten themselves entirely. Are you sure that they didn’t sell it and someone has pocketed some of the profit money?

IsItOnly2023 · 01/05/2023 15:33

@Duckingella It's not an official qualification but yes, it will look good on their CVs. I guess it's just the way life works, you've always got someone who hangs on other people's coat tails.

OP posts:
PuppyMonkey · 01/05/2023 15:33

They snaffled the stuff, they go to cash and carry and replace what they snaffled at their expense.

HipHipCimorene · 01/05/2023 15:29

Throwncrumbs · 01/05/2023 15:27

They are kids playing at being business men…I’m surprised he’s allowed to do this in school tbh.. are the registered in Companies House?

Only needed if it’s LTD or LLB.
There may be other reasons as it’s a Young Enterprise Co aswell but I don’t know.

IsItOnly2023 · 01/05/2023 15:29

@Throwncrumbs It's an official Young Enterprise scheme, technically they are a branch of young enterprise. @HipHipCimorene DS is tempted to agree.

OP posts:
StormInaDcup99 · 01/05/2023 15:28

That's a bit unnecessary.

Like any tricky situation we often ask others for advice. Her son does not need to take the advice......but if it were me, like the OP, I'd like to pass on some hopefully useful advice to my child I a similar scenario

Swipe left for the next trending thread