Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Canada’s euthanasia for the mentally ill

342 replies

Noicant · 01/05/2023 08:34

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

Canada is in the process of introducing the option of Euthanasia for the mentally ill. It looks like this has been delayed for the time being but AIBU to find this concerning?

Just to be clear I fully support euthanasia as an option for people with terminal or chronic conditions. I think it’s human to offer people a peaceful death when there is no chance of things improving.

BUT this seems utterly mad to me. I’ve suffered from poor mental health in the past and only started feeling better after going through a few therapists and finding the right one. There were many times over 20years where I would have happily signed up for death. If someone is so ill that they are very impaired by their condition are they truly competent to make a decision like this and if it’s milder isn’t there a possibility of recovery?

It seems utterly dystopian. I guess I’m looking for someone to help me understand if I’ve missed something or not understood something that will help me understand why anyone would think this is a good idea.

Expansion of assisted dying for mental illness to be delayed until 2024 in new bill - National | Globalnews.ca

Justice Minister David Lametti has said the delay is needed after the federal government heard concerns that Canada's health-care system might not be prepared for the expansion.

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
StressedToTheMaxxx · 01/05/2023 12:24

MrsEdnaWelthorpe · 01/05/2023 11:04

Yes , you do seem like a person who has spent years working on inpatient units- the total lack of respect for my concerns about how terrifying this is for a person with schizophrenia to read shows you must fit in really well on the wards. But yeah, reading about how people who I have to "work" with think I should be subjected to their decisions about whether my life is worth living is "arrogant". Thanks for that.

Your arrogance to think that you speak for every person with the same diagnosis as you is utterly astounding. You clearly don't have treatment resistant schizophrenia. Some do, including my lovely ex father in law who has spent most of his days in and out of hospitals. Who has had pretty much every treatment and therapy under the sun over the decades. And a person who has suffered from treatment resistant mental illness who has (in their opinion) no quality of life, well I'll take their point of view about how they should be treated over your opinion on how that person should be treated.

Seeing as you're so caught up and unable to see the issue and what I'm saying objectively because of your own lived experience, let me give you a scenario. Do you think that John with late stage motor neurone disease, who suffers greatly and doesn't want to be alive anymore shouldn't be allowed to be considered for euthanasia just because Jane, who also suffers from motor neuron disease, doesn't think that euthanasia should be allowed for their condition?

I don't have any respect for your opinion because my opinion wasn't that you should be euthanized - that's just you trying to play the victim, sitting there with crocodile tears and wide eyes saying 'you think I should die?'. Why do you think you have the right to deny people the consideration of euthanasia if they have suffered for years and years, their whole adult life, when in their opinion, there is no quality of life for them? If you don't want to consider euthanasia for yourself then don't. But don't try and force people to live their lives in accordance with your beliefs and prevent them from making that choice.

SunnieShine · 01/05/2023 12:15

Flowerly · 01/05/2023 10:16

Everyone should have the right to end their lives painlessly and at the time of their choosing. If you disagree with this then don't choose to do it.

I am hoping that the UK sees sense on this very soon.

Me, too. I would enjoy the rest of my life much more if I knew I had control of when it ended.

user4567890754 · 01/05/2023 12:15

LakeTiticaca · 01/05/2023 09:26

OH and I had this discussion a while back when it was in the news.
We both asked the question why those with a terminal condition, ie: cancer etc, have the right to decline further treatment yet those who suffer years and years of debilitating depressive illnesses that just can't be cured, are expected to suffer.

Everyone has the right to decline medical treatment, whether fir MH or any other conditions. Everyone has the freedom to kill themselves if they choose. What we don’t permit is anyone “helping” anyone else to kill themselves, or in other words, it is not possible to consent to being murdered. That is an important legal protection for everyone in society, particularly the vulnerable.

user4567890754 · 01/05/2023 12:07

SleepyRich · 01/05/2023 08:51

Isn't it the expansion of an existing bill to include mental illness as opposed to targeting people with mental illness? I suspect this would be severely life limiting mental illness that the person no longer wanted to live with. It's specifically not for use in cases of depression/suicidal ideation. So a suicidal person would never be offered this under the law,

This makes absolutely no sense. By definition, anyone asking for an assisted suicide is suicidal. And suicidal ideation is one of the diagnostic indicators of depression.

MrsEdnaWelthorpe · 01/05/2023 12:04

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 11:38

Personally I believe in body autonomy, your body your right to make an informed decision.

Thats all well and good when you have full mental capacity, but if you suffer a mental health condition that periodically takes away your mental capacity so you have no real autonomy, such that you can’t even trust your own decisions. You are also especially vulnerable to coercion regardless of intention, well meaning or no.

When I’m sectioned, I cannot refuse treatment. I lose my right to bodily autonomy. Rightfully so as I am too unwell to have the mental capacity to choose what I want or need.

The thing is, I then have to have absolute trust in whatever doctors are on duty to decide what is best for me while I am psychotic.

If euthanasia is legalised, what is stopping doctors from making that decision for me? There was a case in the Netherlands where a woman was held down and euthanised. They put sedative in her tea. They then went to inject her, she kicked the syringe out of the doctors hand. The doctor had her held down and then euthanised her. All because when unwell the woman had made comments about wishing to die when the time is right. They went by what she said at her lowest moments, but ignored her desperate physical struggles when they went to euthanise her. To me that was murder.

I just wanted to comment on this, I think if you have never been sectioned, you won't appreciate how completely vulnerable you are. You have no say over what medication you are given, and cannot refuse to take it, no matter what side effects you get from it (antipsychotics can come with unpleasant ones). You really have to trust that they are acting with your best interests in mind.

It's really in the context of that vulnerability that I have found some of the contributions from MH staff on this thread so terrifying - particularly one who seems to have contempt for a "patient" who dares to disagree with them- apparently I have problems with reading comprehension and have " had a little outburst".

It's made me realise that actually, they could well not care about my welfare when so unwell I am in hospital. I just hope I never get sectioned again, some of these posts have been worrying.

LovePoppy · 01/05/2023 12:02

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 09:26

Yes. There was a man on benefits due to disability and when his rent was raised and no housing available and no increase to his benefits, he went to the local government to say he couldn’t survive homeless on the streets and was offered euthanasia.

https://toronto.citynews.ca/2022/10/13/medical-assistance-death-maid-canada/amp/

you mean this? Where HE asked for MAiD?

Ontario man applying for medically-assisted death as alternative to being homeless

A 54-year-old St. Catharines man is in the process of applying for medical assistance in dying (MAiD), not because he wants to die, but because social supports are failing him and he fears he may have no other choice.

https://toronto.citynews.ca/2022/10/13/medical-assistance-death-maid-canada/amp/

OP posts:
EmmaEmerald · 01/05/2023 11:48

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 11:38

Personally I believe in body autonomy, your body your right to make an informed decision.

Thats all well and good when you have full mental capacity, but if you suffer a mental health condition that periodically takes away your mental capacity so you have no real autonomy, such that you can’t even trust your own decisions. You are also especially vulnerable to coercion regardless of intention, well meaning or no.

When I’m sectioned, I cannot refuse treatment. I lose my right to bodily autonomy. Rightfully so as I am too unwell to have the mental capacity to choose what I want or need.

The thing is, I then have to have absolute trust in whatever doctors are on duty to decide what is best for me while I am psychotic.

If euthanasia is legalised, what is stopping doctors from making that decision for me? There was a case in the Netherlands where a woman was held down and euthanised. They put sedative in her tea. They then went to inject her, she kicked the syringe out of the doctors hand. The doctor had her held down and then euthanised her. All because when unwell the woman had made comments about wishing to die when the time is right. They went by what she said at her lowest moments, but ignored her desperate physical struggles when they went to euthanise her. To me that was murder.

I can't help wondering if these are the real facts.

I am in favour of assisted dying and I would think it awful to be denied the option due to my mental health.

I completely understand why doctors don't want to do it, but what's described in the article is unclear tbh. Often press reports contain zero information about the actual law so overall, I'm confused.

ChaosOnTheCoast · 01/05/2023 11:43

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 11:38

Personally I believe in body autonomy, your body your right to make an informed decision.

Thats all well and good when you have full mental capacity, but if you suffer a mental health condition that periodically takes away your mental capacity so you have no real autonomy, such that you can’t even trust your own decisions. You are also especially vulnerable to coercion regardless of intention, well meaning or no.

When I’m sectioned, I cannot refuse treatment. I lose my right to bodily autonomy. Rightfully so as I am too unwell to have the mental capacity to choose what I want or need.

The thing is, I then have to have absolute trust in whatever doctors are on duty to decide what is best for me while I am psychotic.

If euthanasia is legalised, what is stopping doctors from making that decision for me? There was a case in the Netherlands where a woman was held down and euthanised. They put sedative in her tea. They then went to inject her, she kicked the syringe out of the doctors hand. The doctor had her held down and then euthanised her. All because when unwell the woman had made comments about wishing to die when the time is right. They went by what she said at her lowest moments, but ignored her desperate physical struggles when they went to euthanise her. To me that was murder.

Sounds like murder from those facts to me too. Shocking.

DisquietintheRanks · 01/05/2023 11:43

Noicant · 01/05/2023 11:05

Just so I don’t misrepresent your position you believe that suicide is fine but you can do it yourself? (Just to be clear I don’t think of suicide as a moral issue)

Would you try to stop someone who expressed intent to kill themselves?

It's not so much I think suicide fine, it's that I think it's generally a personal choice and sometimes (or in certain circumstances often) an understandable decision.

As to whether I'd try and actively stop someone taking their own life, that would depend on the situation. I can think of many circumstances in which I would try and prevent it and others where I'd be willing to assist (taking someone with muscular dystrophy to Dignitas fe) or at least turn a blind eye.

ChaosOnTheCoast · 01/05/2023 11:41

MrsEdnaWelthorpe · 01/05/2023 11:24

People may not get "better", but they may be able to be supported to live an ok life. I am currently not "well" exactly (still some symptoms) but am relatively content. I think if people with schizophrenia were generally treated with more compassion, and more respect, more of us would find the world a comfortable place to live in.

Interestingly, it’s not the patients with psychosis that came to my mind. It was the ones with intractable OCD, PTSD and anxiety that I was thinking of. I have met treatment-resistant patients whose inner life is a living hell. And all the support in the world from friends, family and services does not seem to help them escape the pain.

I am not condoning euthanasia but I definitely understand the sentiment. My heart breaks for some of my patients and I lie awake thinking of them.

MrsEdnaWelthorpe · 01/05/2023 11:40

StressedToTheMaxxx · 01/05/2023 10:57

I don't need to get a different job, I'm actually very good at it going by feedback from staff and patients alike. I'm not sure if you have problems with reading but that's not what my post said at all. Clearly you're letting your own personal experiences cloud your little outburst there.

Tell your patients that you think you should be allowed to help them decide whether they would be a suitable candidate for euthanasia, and see how they feel.

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 11:38

Personally I believe in body autonomy, your body your right to make an informed decision.

Thats all well and good when you have full mental capacity, but if you suffer a mental health condition that periodically takes away your mental capacity so you have no real autonomy, such that you can’t even trust your own decisions. You are also especially vulnerable to coercion regardless of intention, well meaning or no.

When I’m sectioned, I cannot refuse treatment. I lose my right to bodily autonomy. Rightfully so as I am too unwell to have the mental capacity to choose what I want or need.

The thing is, I then have to have absolute trust in whatever doctors are on duty to decide what is best for me while I am psychotic.

If euthanasia is legalised, what is stopping doctors from making that decision for me? There was a case in the Netherlands where a woman was held down and euthanised. They put sedative in her tea. They then went to inject her, she kicked the syringe out of the doctors hand. The doctor had her held down and then euthanised her. All because when unwell the woman had made comments about wishing to die when the time is right. They went by what she said at her lowest moments, but ignored her desperate physical struggles when they went to euthanise her. To me that was murder.

Hbh17 · 01/05/2023 11:29

Well, I think euthanasia should be legal in any and all circumstances. If I wish to end my life in a civilised way, I think it's barbaric that the state has a right to stop me. So I would prefer a total relaxation of assisted suicide laws. Personal choice matters.

maddening · 01/05/2023 11:29

pointythings · 01/05/2023 10:59

You're still putting words in my mouth!

Using algorithms is bad because computer says no.
Having a panel of qualified people use those guidelines alongside face to face assessment of the patient is bad because it is subjective.

Nothing will ever be good enough for you because your position is 'no, never'.

That's fine and you are entitled to that opinion, but how do you think medical decision making works in the real world? We have the NICE guidelines, which underpin everything. Within those guidelines, medical professionals make decisions. Because they are human beings, those decisions will always contain some kind of subjectivity. That's how the world is!

Your thinking it so completely zero sum it isn't even funny. Medical decision making will never be 100% perfect, just as there is no such thing as a medication that is 100% safe. In your world this means that no decisions should ever be taken, and no medication prescribed, if we take it to the extreme.

Although we have NICE guidelines based on cost - so treatments too expensive are off limits, so in the current system I do not believe we can properly evidence that a person has been given access to every possible treatment as it is limited by cost etc as well as competence of the staff -.so a person who has received treatment limited by cost and by potentially long chain of substandard staff in a stretched resourced area could be signed off where they may be able to recover.

Sudeko · 01/05/2023 11:27

I barely lasted working a few months of my training in a psych ward. It is a tough gig. You cannot fix a mind without a lot of trial and error and massive, unrealistic massive, leaps of faith at times. Some of the treatment plans will prove counterproductive, even downright detrimental. I still don't support euthanasia of the mentally ill. There is already a mechanism which will control the numbers of those who are suffering acutely and constantly and will do their best to release themselves of life. Euthanasia is not required as a back up. It would eliminate too many who would have made it and even thrived later on in their lives. It doesn't matter if it is outwardly less 'messy' or 'kind to family' because cleanliness is not the end goal and death is rarely a kind process.

MrsEdnaWelthorpe · 01/05/2023 11:24

ChaosOnTheCoast · 01/05/2023 11:17

Having worked in MH for decades, I do believe there is such a thing as ‘terminally’ mentally unwell. I have had patients who have tried every medication and therapy available.

Some patients simply do not get better. That could be because of hugely traumatic experiences which they cannot move on from, their current social problems from which there is no way out or simply due to their genetics. I can certainly imagine a cohort of people who have the capacity to make this decision. And it feels pretty rational to me.

Do I support euthanasia in this group? I honestly don’t know. But the pain of poor mental health is truly unbearable for many.

People may not get "better", but they may be able to be supported to live an ok life. I am currently not "well" exactly (still some symptoms) but am relatively content. I think if people with schizophrenia were generally treated with more compassion, and more respect, more of us would find the world a comfortable place to live in.

Choconut · 01/05/2023 11:18

Personally I'm all for the option of euthanasia, we wouldn't let dogs suffer the way some people have to. I also think it should be available to those with treatment resistant MH issues. However I think where places that have it available are going wrong (especially Canada) is by offering it as a solution that someone hasn't explicitly asked for.

I don't think Euthanasia should ever be offered, obviously everyone will be aware if there are clinics and it is available, but no one should be offered it. It needs to be for them to come forward and say 'I need this'.

I also don't think anyone (apart from their own doctor) has the right to decide whether other people should be allowed to be euthanised or not. Make the decision for yourself of course but you have no right to make blanket decisions for other people.

There are plenty of people who are completely against abortion and think it is very wrong, that doesn't mean they should get to decide that others shouldn't be allowed one. Personally I believe in body autonomy, your body your right to make an informed decision.

ChaosOnTheCoast · 01/05/2023 11:17

Having worked in MH for decades, I do believe there is such a thing as ‘terminally’ mentally unwell. I have had patients who have tried every medication and therapy available.

Some patients simply do not get better. That could be because of hugely traumatic experiences which they cannot move on from, their current social problems from which there is no way out or simply due to their genetics. I can certainly imagine a cohort of people who have the capacity to make this decision. And it feels pretty rational to me.

Do I support euthanasia in this group? I honestly don’t know. But the pain of poor mental health is truly unbearable for many.

ShannonMcFarland · 01/05/2023 11:12

I'm not always actively suicidal but I've never especially wanted to live. The main thing that's stopped me unaliving is not knowing how to do it in a way that's relatively painless and doesn't have a considerable risk of failing and leaving me a vegetable. Why should people be expected to live like this for several decades just to avoid upsetting the living? Now THAT'S the real selfishness.

nilsmousehammer · 01/05/2023 11:11

Comedycook · 01/05/2023 10:46

Whilst I can see the argument for this from a theoretical perspective...the reality would be very frightening. Coercion would be a real concern and if you wanted to catastrophise what if we ended up in a place were people with certain conditions were immediately assumed to do this.

Or as in that appalling article, financial options get involved.

"We can't provide you with what you need/this treatment/this stair lift/this wheelchair/benefits/whatever else you need to cope with your condition, but we'll happily help you die if you want."

There's a path there that's a cheap way to gatekeep services by leaving people to get into dire enough straits that they'll take the only remaining path.

MrsEdnaWelthorpe · 01/05/2023 11:08

StressedToTheMaxxx · 01/05/2023 10:57

I don't need to get a different job, I'm actually very good at it going by feedback from staff and patients alike. I'm not sure if you have problems with reading but that's not what my post said at all. Clearly you're letting your own personal experiences cloud your little outburst there.

No, I don't have problems reading, what kind of fucked up response is that? You really really need to get a different job, if your "patients" knew what was going on inside your head, and the contempt you have for people who disagree with you, I doubt they would feel very positively about .

SmallFerret · 01/05/2023 11:07

Youdoyoubabe · 01/05/2023 09:02

It could help the mental health crisis.

Yay, it's 1930's Germany again.
Or 1910's Bloomsbury - take your pick: genocide & eugenics, what a heady mix, & the desire to inflict them on humanity yet again so succinctly expressed, one could almost believe Youdoyoubabe is a wannabe mass murderer. Or maybe just hasn't quite thought this one through ...

gogohmm · 01/05/2023 11:06

I'm not a supporter except in the last 6 months of life. But they already allow it for chronic illness, mental health can be under this too. I think it's allowed in Belgium too

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 11:06

pointythings · 01/05/2023 10:59

You're still putting words in my mouth!

Using algorithms is bad because computer says no.
Having a panel of qualified people use those guidelines alongside face to face assessment of the patient is bad because it is subjective.

Nothing will ever be good enough for you because your position is 'no, never'.

That's fine and you are entitled to that opinion, but how do you think medical decision making works in the real world? We have the NICE guidelines, which underpin everything. Within those guidelines, medical professionals make decisions. Because they are human beings, those decisions will always contain some kind of subjectivity. That's how the world is!

Your thinking it so completely zero sum it isn't even funny. Medical decision making will never be 100% perfect, just as there is no such thing as a medication that is 100% safe. In your world this means that no decisions should ever be taken, and no medication prescribed, if we take it to the extreme.

Unlike physical health, say terminal cancer, our medical knowledge is too bad, too incomplete for anyone or any computer to make the kind of assessment you are envisioning with any degree of accuracy or confidence. We can tell if cancer is terminal, we can tell if someone is brain dead and no chance of coming out of a coma, but we cannot tell if any mental health condition is the equivalent of terminal.

Yes, in future there may be something good enough, but realistically medicine isn’t there right now imho when it comes to mental illness.