Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Canada’s euthanasia for the mentally ill

342 replies

Noicant · 01/05/2023 08:34

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

Canada is in the process of introducing the option of Euthanasia for the mentally ill. It looks like this has been delayed for the time being but AIBU to find this concerning?

Just to be clear I fully support euthanasia as an option for people with terminal or chronic conditions. I think it’s human to offer people a peaceful death when there is no chance of things improving.

BUT this seems utterly mad to me. I’ve suffered from poor mental health in the past and only started feeling better after going through a few therapists and finding the right one. There were many times over 20years where I would have happily signed up for death. If someone is so ill that they are very impaired by their condition are they truly competent to make a decision like this and if it’s milder isn’t there a possibility of recovery?

It seems utterly dystopian. I guess I’m looking for someone to help me understand if I’ve missed something or not understood something that will help me understand why anyone would think this is a good idea.

Expansion of assisted dying for mental illness to be delayed until 2024 in new bill - National | Globalnews.ca

Justice Minister David Lametti has said the delay is needed after the federal government heard concerns that Canada's health-care system might not be prepared for the expansion.

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 22:54

@LangClegsInSpace
Hear hear
Well said, and 110% agree.

LangClegsInSpace · 01/05/2023 22:48

pointythings · 01/05/2023 20:33

@LangClegsInSpace so do you think that people with autism are not ever capable of consenting to assisted dying based on how their autism affects their lives? (And that is without considering the fact that autism often has other MH comorbidities)

I'd also be interested to hear what in your opinion exemplifies the Netherlands as an example of bad practice. My personal experience of family members who have had assisted suicides, alongside the experience of family members who either could not (because pre legislation) or were rightly denied (my dad) makes this an interesting question to me. Please note that I am not saying that everything always goes perfectly in NL - it doesn't. It can't - not anywhere. I do not see this as a reason not to try at all though.

Sorry in advance, this is long:

No, I have no doubt that many, but not all, autistic people have just the same capacity to choose assisted dying as anyone else.

If we had decent levels of medical, social and palliative care in the UK then I would be in favour of legalising AD in the case of terminal illness with ~6 months or less to live, with safeguards in place to ensure patients had made a voluntary, clear and settled decision to end their life, with time to consider all other options. That would mean they had mental capacity to make the decision at the time of death, mandatory counseling, prescribed information, second opinions, high court for difficult cases. I have no doubt that many autistic people could meet those criteria just as well as I could.

That's not at all the same as saying we should allow AD because of autism, or learning disability, or mental distress.

Are you familiar with the swiss cheese model of safeguarding? No slice of safeguarding is foolproof, there are always holes. The more layers of safeguarding there are, the less chance there is that all the holes will line up. The more layers you remove, the more likely the holes will all line up and cause a safeguarding failure.

Allowing assisted dying at all removes a layer of safeguarding.

Allowing assisted dying for people who are not dying removes another layer.

Allowing assisted dying for LD, autism, mental illness etc., conditions which, by their very nature, require close attention to mental capacity removes another layer. And this particular layer seems to have a lot of holes.

A huge issue is doctors' ability to reliably and accurately assess people's ability to consent. Baroness Finlay:

The danger is that it depends on the ability of the clinicians making the assessment. I had the privilege of chairing the Mental Capacity Forum for six years. I have to say that it was worrying to see the inability of clinicians to assess capacity — particularly fluctuating capacity. Another group of patients where there is a real worry is where there is frontal lobe involvement in the brain, where they can appear as if they have capacity but actually they cannot understand the implications of their decision for themselves and others.

Only last week, I came across a clinical case of somebody in ICU, who appeared to have complete capacity to stop treatment. By chance, his girlfriend arrived. I won’t go into the details because it is a long story, but he then decided to marry her. Afterwards, he had absolutely no recall whatsoever of any of the conversations that had taken place when he had said that he did not want to be treated. At the time his clinicians — not just one, but three of them — thought that he was absolutely crystal clear that he wanted to stop treatment, and would have stopped his ventilation, but for the chance arrival of his girlfriend.

The potential safeguarding failure here is that you deliberately cause someone's death who did not want to die, who was coerced or persuaded against their best interests that they wanted to die, or who was not capable of consenting to being killed.

The stakes could not be higher.

How many of those kinds of deaths are acceptable so that you or your loved one can choose the time and manner of your death?

If there's the remotest doubt then the default must be that you do not take active and deliberate steps to end someone's life.

There are just too many layers of safeguarding missing for me to be comfortable with this, before even considering all the other missing layers of poor health care, poor social care etc.

I'd also be interested to hear what in your opinion exemplifies the Netherlands as an example of bad practice.

An example of bad practice in the Netherlands is when they held down a woman and euthanased her against her will. Details have been given upthread. Advance directives are not safe because people change their minds. In one study, 50% of terminally ill patients who said they wanted AD for themselves later changed their minds.

https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/193281

Also I think NL decision to allow assisted dying because of LD, autism and or MH issues is bad practice. The only reason they're not in a worse state than Canada is because they have decent health and social care. Long may that continue.

We don't, we're much closer to Canada in that regard.

4plusthehound · 01/05/2023 22:35

Hbh17 · 01/05/2023 11:29

Well, I think euthanasia should be legal in any and all circumstances. If I wish to end my life in a civilised way, I think it's barbaric that the state has a right to stop me. So I would prefer a total relaxation of assisted suicide laws. Personal choice matters.

But you can!

You can end it at any time. Many people do - including in my own family.

This is objectionable because it will be promoted . To patients who are viewed as too expensive.

And we know, after watching the surrogacy creep that the poor and vunerable will be hit.

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 22:34

user4567890754 · 01/05/2023 22:27

It looks like that is actually where Canada is headed. What a dystopian future. Once you open the door to murder with consent for adults, you get people pushing for murder without consent for children.

“As of September 2017, both the Federal Act and the Quebec Act clearly prohibit non-voluntary euthanasia for all patients. However, given the human rights framework advanced in Carter v. Canada, the parents of a dying and/or severely disabled child who is deemed to be suffering may, in the near future, be looking to the courts to support a right to end their child’s life.

Decision-making for treatment of never-competent children is based on the ‘best interest standard’: choosing among options that reasonable persons, acting in good faith on another’s behalf, would consider acceptable in similar circumstances [22].

In the foreseeable future, parents may challenge health care decisions in court on the grounds that continued life, as experienced by their dying or profoundly disabled child, is not in that child’s best interests.”

https://cps.ca/en/documents/position/medical-assistance-in-dying

It’s more likely though that doctors will simply sign off on the parents requests to put down their kids. The CPS wouldn’t care if all legal paperwork is signed. Both the parents and doctors can build a case to make their decision look reasonable, kind and so on and no one can counter it, least of all the recently deceased child.

I think the only court cases would be other relatives vs parents. Or divorced couples one vs the other. To try and stop it, or to prosecute for murder/manslaughter if after the fact.

4plusthehound · 01/05/2023 22:29

Gtsr443 · 01/05/2023 09:40

I suppose the fear is that instead of offering (often expensive) treatment and day to day support and paying out welfare to vulnerable people this will be the 'prefered' option which just so happens to save the state millions...

This is how the Nazis managed to sell Aktion4 - the mass killing of the mentally ill and the disabled. It as much about cost cutting and burden on the state as genetic purity.
Euthanasia for psychiatric patients and eugenics go hand in hand.
Churchill was a big fan and spoke about putting the wretched creatures out of their misery.
Supporters will try to sell this as progress and compassion.
I call bullshit.

Agree with you - point very well made.

Churchill was keen for others to put out of their misery but funnily enoughnot himself. Even though he suffered terribly from depression.

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 22:28

user4567890754 · 01/05/2023 22:18

Yes, and then if you change your mind and say actually life is fine like this and you want to live after all, they hold you down and murder you anyway.

Yep. Especially if the family agrees. Family who would financially benefit from more inheritance if your care home fees come to an abrupt end.

user4567890754 · 01/05/2023 22:27

Enncee · 01/05/2023 22:14

I think there are too many pitfalls to this many which have been discussed already. The worrying thing is cases like the article upthread, of a man choosing euthanasia over homelessness. If this were to happen in the UK, I can see our current government welcoming people in such situations choosing euthanasia instead of providing the support they need - they don't even do it now as we've seen with people not being able to afford energy prices as well as food.

Then there are people like @SparklyBlackKitten who think it's perfectly okay to have human beings put down because someone else decides their life isn't worth living. I know this word is overused on MN, but I found that post inutterably disgusting. While we have people who will happily come out with things such as euthanising people who cannot consent due to disability is a sort of "blessing" without an inkling of how vile and ableist they are being, it's a dangerous law to introduce.

It looks like that is actually where Canada is headed. What a dystopian future. Once you open the door to murder with consent for adults, you get people pushing for murder without consent for children.

“As of September 2017, both the Federal Act and the Quebec Act clearly prohibit non-voluntary euthanasia for all patients. However, given the human rights framework advanced in Carter v. Canada, the parents of a dying and/or severely disabled child who is deemed to be suffering may, in the near future, be looking to the courts to support a right to end their child’s life.

Decision-making for treatment of never-competent children is based on the ‘best interest standard’: choosing among options that reasonable persons, acting in good faith on another’s behalf, would consider acceptable in similar circumstances [22].

In the foreseeable future, parents may challenge health care decisions in court on the grounds that continued life, as experienced by their dying or profoundly disabled child, is not in that child’s best interests.”

https://cps.ca/en/documents/position/medical-assistance-in-dying

user4567890754 · 01/05/2023 22:18

Desperatelyseekingcommonsense · 01/05/2023 22:04

In countries where they do allow euthanasia for dementia sufferers. You have to make up your mind in advance and be very clear about your wishes whilst you still have capacity. I also have dementia in my family and it is an awful prospect.

Yes, and then if you change your mind and say actually life is fine like this and you want to live after all, they hold you down and murder you anyway.

TeenLifeMum · 01/05/2023 22:16

@user4567890754 i assume it would be like signing a do not resuscitate treatment escalation plan. I don’t know the detail of the Canadian paper so can’t comment. It’s a very tricky area.

Enncee · 01/05/2023 22:14

I think there are too many pitfalls to this many which have been discussed already. The worrying thing is cases like the article upthread, of a man choosing euthanasia over homelessness. If this were to happen in the UK, I can see our current government welcoming people in such situations choosing euthanasia instead of providing the support they need - they don't even do it now as we've seen with people not being able to afford energy prices as well as food.

Then there are people like @SparklyBlackKitten who think it's perfectly okay to have human beings put down because someone else decides their life isn't worth living. I know this word is overused on MN, but I found that post inutterably disgusting. While we have people who will happily come out with things such as euthanising people who cannot consent due to disability is a sort of "blessing" without an inkling of how vile and ableist they are being, it's a dangerous law to introduce.

Desperatelyseekingcommonsense · 01/05/2023 22:04

user4567890754 · 01/05/2023 21:57

That would also be murder. If you have disappeared into dementia then you have no capacity to consent.

In countries where they do allow euthanasia for dementia sufferers. You have to make up your mind in advance and be very clear about your wishes whilst you still have capacity. I also have dementia in my family and it is an awful prospect.

user4567890754 · 01/05/2023 21:57

TeenLifeMum · 01/05/2023 20:03

I would assume this would cover dementia? Having seen my grandmother disappear to dementia, if I went the same way I think euthanasia would be a kindness for me and my family members. I would expect there to be clear guidance.

That would also be murder. If you have disappeared into dementia then you have no capacity to consent.

JandalsAlways · 01/05/2023 21:51

DisquietintheRanks · 01/05/2023 09:03

How long would you insist a person lives with severe mental illness I hope of a cure? 10 years? 20? 40?

The reality is that many, at some point, decide they've had enough and die by their own hand. I guess this change would allow that option for those in secure accommodation.

There's no doubt this is a difficult area to legislate for, but I do doubt the humanity of forcing someone to live under suicide watch for years on end on the basis that they might one day feel better.

This

Desperatelyseekingcommonsense · 01/05/2023 21:48

The Netherlands allows Euthanasia for the mentally ill. Psychiactric reasons accout for a small proportion of deaths 1% of 7000ish cases a year. People can find mental illness a source of unbearable suffering.

user4567890754 · 01/05/2023 21:45

CatSpam3 · 01/05/2023 16:11

You @StressedToTheMaxxx are a bully. I hope you get the help you need and find peace in your life.

Agreed.

user4567890754 · 01/05/2023 21:38

SparklyBlackKitten · 01/05/2023 14:10

Most mh issues can be treated with pills and therapy . But some people are beyond help. And trapped in a world of misery and darkness. Every single day being tortured by evil thoughts and not a single ray of light. Euthanasia for them would be welcomed in with open arms.

And I think it should be an option.

But also when I think of euthanasia for the mentally ill, what comes to mind is a non verbal, 10yo with the mental capacity of a 2yo,that has fits and throws tantrums and can't ever be allone and needs 2:1 care 24/7 .

I read some people on here talking about their severely autistic kids that are causing nothing but suffering and can't go the the toilet themselves. Can't communicate, Cant be taken outside without severe meltdowns. Violence. The mums scared of their own kid. Those People have 0 qualify of life. And their parents /caretakers are jailed for life having to endure the mental illness from a child that brings 0% joy to their lives.

I would say that euthanasia would be the most human thing to do.

Pets are put down when they are sick and no longer can live a life worthy of living.
And this makes sense. And people aren't dogs. And I know that. But it makes sense to end life when it is no longer worth living or when it should end because they are alive. But they don't live!

I do think in some cases euthanasia is a dark blessing. And merciful

Wow. So now we have moved from murder with consent to just straight up murder of vulnerable and disabled children, no consent required.

Timothhorton · 01/05/2023 21:27

Some very interesting points made here. I agree with those who say the Canadian model is flawed. The same person who approves the application can actually carry out the procedure and if you live in a tiny town up north the lack of accountability this builds into the procedure is frightening. Whilst people are autonomous they don't live in a bubble, for those parents who nurse their children through physical and mental illnesses and who devote their whole lives to alleviating their child's suffering the idea that they could just disappear one day in a state provided suicide with multiple inputs from people who didn't tell you, the parent, is frightening. Rupa Supramanya's article on this is interesting Free Press

I cannot get behind the "Mature Minors" consent for mental illness that they are proposing nor can I get behind the euthanisation of babies under one with "severe malformations” and “grave and severe syndromes” for which their “prospective of survival is null, so to speak" as proposed by the Quebec College of Surgeons, as if survival is null, then it is unecessary. "Syndromes" is too vague as well, do they mean Downs? It's just too dystopian for me.

It builds into society the idea that you must never be a burden nor should you ever put up with suffering. Clearly some suffer a great deal more than others and people have shared some very painful experiences here but with rates of MAID at 5% in some provinces I feel it's a slippery slope and is doing more to save the government money and exploit the most vulnerable in society. Duchess Lois on twitter is another example, indigenous on a reservation, had a botched sex change operation and has now applied for MAID. It was all avoidable had she received good mental health care in her teens.

Duchess Lois

Scheduled to Die: The Rise of Canada’s Assisted Suicide Program

What do you do when you discover your son has made an appointment for his death?

https://www.thefp.com/p/scheduled-to-die-the-rise-of-canadas

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 21:00

LangClegsInSpace · 01/05/2023 18:24

This is already happening in NL.

In her evidence to the inquiry, Baroness Hollins said:

As a clinician and as a researcher, I see how the lives of people I am particularly concerned about — people with learning disabilities and autistic people — are not valued, and how their own lack of confidence and their own quality of life can lead to changes in the perception of those who are caring for them. We saw it during the pandemic, when people with Down’s syndrome had a six times higher death rate. A lot of that was due to “Do not resuscitate” and assumptions being made about the quality of life.

My research in the Netherlands has found that the evidence there is unusual. They actually provide case histories of people who have had euthanasia. It is normally euthanasia in the Netherlands — I think 96% of cases — because it is easier and more effective, and because the complication rate from physician-assisted suicide is so high. We did not expect to find those in the learning disability and autism community represented among those euthanised, but they were. We found 38 cases, described in our study. This will be an underestimate because they are not all described. We found 38 cases of people with learning disability and/or autism who were euthanised simply because of the symptoms of having a learning disability or autism. That is the sort of safeguard that I am concerned about.

... I am particularly concerned about the extension to people with mental illness, and to disabled people, particularly people with learning disability and autism, who are so open to suggestion.

Yes, I agree. I have seen similar concerning trends. It’s terrible to in the context of those with autism + capacity to choose as most of their distress isn caused by autism but by a wider society that does not accommodate or support their neurodiversity.

Sudeko · 01/05/2023 20:48

will

Sudeko · 01/05/2023 20:48

It is a slippery slope and strongly suggestive of a descent into eugenics. People who are deemed to not have the capacity will have the decision made for them so many people who wish to live will end up euthanized against their wills. Canada and the Netherlands are both led by people who portray themselves as being very tolerant and liberal which makes it even more horrific.

pointythings · 01/05/2023 20:33

@LangClegsInSpace so do you think that people with autism are not ever capable of consenting to assisted dying based on how their autism affects their lives? (And that is without considering the fact that autism often has other MH comorbidities)

I'd also be interested to hear what in your opinion exemplifies the Netherlands as an example of bad practice. My personal experience of family members who have had assisted suicides, alongside the experience of family members who either could not (because pre legislation) or were rightly denied (my dad) makes this an interesting question to me. Please note that I am not saying that everything always goes perfectly in NL - it doesn't. It can't - not anywhere. I do not see this as a reason not to try at all though.

JMSA · 01/05/2023 20:21

Crikey, I find this rather scary.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 01/05/2023 20:19

RumandSpinach · 01/05/2023 19:57

From a mental health nurse: this.

There are cases where mental illness doesn't respond to treatment, sadly this is particularly true when the person is too affected by trauma that they cannot work with psychology even with xyz medications on and off-licence to reduce distress/suicidality.

There are absolutely cases where the person could make a capacitious decision to die. Emotional pain can fucking hurt and there is a cohort of people who are being forcibly kept alive after years of psychology, OT, nursing and pharmacology have not worked.

I find the difference in mental health professionals versus recovered patients opinions quite stark on this thread. I can see it from both perspectives but a few patients have said that they are against this whilst the professionals have said they are for it - I assume because you have seen the full spectrum.

LangClegsInSpace · 01/05/2023 20:17

pointythings · 01/05/2023 19:55

@LangClegsInSpace that isn't how your quote reads at all. I have no problems with being cautious in these things, but in the case that I posted, the whole process took close to three years. So don't tell me it is not possible to do this in a rigorous, carefully assessed way, at least elsewhere in the world.

And no, I do not think it is currently possible in the UK; however, your post implied that people with autism/learning disabilities were being euthanised wholesale without any safeguards in the Netherlands and that is just not the case.

Baroness Hollins highlighted the Netherlands as if it were an example of bad practice and that isn't OK.

however, your post implied that people with autism/learning disabilities were being euthanised wholesale without any safeguards in the Netherlands and that is just not the case.

Where did my post imply this? How do you get here from 'We found 38 cases ...'?

Baroness Hollins highlighted the Netherlands as if it were an example of bad practice and that isn't OK.

Of course it's OK if that's what she believes, based on her research!

I happen to agree with her that NL and Canada are both examples of bad practice. Even the other side were keen to reassure parliament that of course we wouldn't be like Canada or NL, we'd be more like Oregon.

Swipe left for the next trending thread