Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Canada’s euthanasia for the mentally ill

342 replies

Noicant · 01/05/2023 08:34

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

Canada is in the process of introducing the option of Euthanasia for the mentally ill. It looks like this has been delayed for the time being but AIBU to find this concerning?

Just to be clear I fully support euthanasia as an option for people with terminal or chronic conditions. I think it’s human to offer people a peaceful death when there is no chance of things improving.

BUT this seems utterly mad to me. I’ve suffered from poor mental health in the past and only started feeling better after going through a few therapists and finding the right one. There were many times over 20years where I would have happily signed up for death. If someone is so ill that they are very impaired by their condition are they truly competent to make a decision like this and if it’s milder isn’t there a possibility of recovery?

It seems utterly dystopian. I guess I’m looking for someone to help me understand if I’ve missed something or not understood something that will help me understand why anyone would think this is a good idea.

Expansion of assisted dying for mental illness to be delayed until 2024 in new bill - National | Globalnews.ca

Justice Minister David Lametti has said the delay is needed after the federal government heard concerns that Canada's health-care system might not be prepared for the expansion.

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
SwitchDiver · 02/05/2023 09:12

I do not trust our society's view of disability to be able to support assisted suicide.

Same. I don’t trust myself when I’m unwell and I would not be able to trust any doctors if they could legally choose the convenience of euthanising me. There would be nowhere safe to go when I’m suffering. No where. Unless charities set up “no kill” secure mental units. Sort of like the “no kill” animal rescues we have.

Polkadothot · 02/05/2023 09:10

Just to be clear I fully support euthanasia as an option for people with terminal or chronic conditions. I think it’s human to offer people a peaceful death when there is no chance of things improving.

But why do you see a difference with chonic MH conditions then OP?
I'm not sure about euthanasia personally. Yes good in some cases, but I worry about people feeling under pressure and a burden.

SwitchDiver · 02/05/2023 09:10

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 08:54

How about when the individual is an inpatient and actively prevented from taking their life for years on end?

They're the people I'm thinking about that this may be relevant for.

If they are inpatient, then how can they have the mental capacity to truly consent? If they had mental capacity, they would not be detained under the mental health act, right? Even the NHS webpage says:

”Consent to treatment
If you're held under the Mental Health Act, you can be treated against your will.
This is because it's felt you do not have sufficient capacity to make an informed decision about your treatment at the time.
This is also the case if you refuse treatment but the team treating you believe you should have it.”
https://www.nhs.uk/mental-health/social-care-and-your-rights/mental-health-and-the-law/mental-health-act/

So you’d be euthanising certain people without their true consent and in some cases without them even being aware what was happening.

What about the fact that as a patient you cannot leave? Apparently we could be chosen to die, but there is no right to leave the secure ward/unit?

nhs.uk

Mental Health Act

In most cases when people are treated in hospital or another mental health facility, they have agreed or volunteered to be there. But there are cases when a person can be detained, also known as sectioned, under the Mental Health Act (1983) and treated...

https://www.nhs.uk/mental-health/social-care-and-your-rights/mental-health-and-the-law/mental-health-act/

Ilkleymoor · 02/05/2023 09:01

The care we offer in this country isn't good enough. We have people waiting years for diagnosis, no mental health support until total crisis, no home care even when trying to manage terminal cancer. This will be supported by governments because it is cheaper and easier. I might feel differently if our care offer was consistently good but it's consistently poor so I can't support assisted suicide.

We already saw disabled people given do not resusitate orders in covid without their or their families knowledge - including a man who was merely deaf and just needed a translator and a 19 yr old with downs syndrome. I do not trust our society's view of disability to be able to support assisted suicide.

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 08:54

user4567890754 · 02/05/2023 08:02

People already have the freedom to make that decision for themselves. I’m not going to list ways of killing oneself but we all know that there are plenty of substances freely available without prescription that will do the job. It’s a personal decision, sad and regrettable. But suicide is not illegal and also not always irrational in my opinion, depending on the circumstances.

However, there is no reason or need to involve anyone else in that decision, actively or passively. The “helper” is then made responsible for judging who qualifies, ie which lives are valuable and worth living, and which are futile and pointless. This is dangerous and unethical, and it completely undermines the ideal of personal autonomy. The only person to weigh the value of a life should be the owner of that life.

How about when the individual is an inpatient and actively prevented from taking their life for years on end?

They're the people I'm thinking about that this may be relevant for.

SwitchDiver · 02/05/2023 08:51

user4567890754 · 02/05/2023 08:02

People already have the freedom to make that decision for themselves. I’m not going to list ways of killing oneself but we all know that there are plenty of substances freely available without prescription that will do the job. It’s a personal decision, sad and regrettable. But suicide is not illegal and also not always irrational in my opinion, depending on the circumstances.

However, there is no reason or need to involve anyone else in that decision, actively or passively. The “helper” is then made responsible for judging who qualifies, ie which lives are valuable and worth living, and which are futile and pointless. This is dangerous and unethical, and it completely undermines the ideal of personal autonomy. The only person to weigh the value of a life should be the owner of that life.

This. There are even substances that will provide a painless and peaceful end. Fighting to walk on past where I know I can get some, is a weekly battle as I go by on my way to my Dr appts. I do not need yet another voice whispering encouragement in my ear or enabling me.

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 08:27

RumandSpinach · 01/05/2023 19:57

From a mental health nurse: this.

There are cases where mental illness doesn't respond to treatment, sadly this is particularly true when the person is too affected by trauma that they cannot work with psychology even with xyz medications on and off-licence to reduce distress/suicidality.

There are absolutely cases where the person could make a capacitious decision to die. Emotional pain can fucking hurt and there is a cohort of people who are being forcibly kept alive after years of psychology, OT, nursing and pharmacology have not worked.

Agreed. Out of the 5 long-term (years) 1:1 chronically suicidal inpatients I'm thinking of, 4 of them had experienced unimaginable trauma, no treatment had helped and they didn't want to live with that trauma any more.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 02/05/2023 08:22

user4567890754 · 02/05/2023 08:02

People already have the freedom to make that decision for themselves. I’m not going to list ways of killing oneself but we all know that there are plenty of substances freely available without prescription that will do the job. It’s a personal decision, sad and regrettable. But suicide is not illegal and also not always irrational in my opinion, depending on the circumstances.

However, there is no reason or need to involve anyone else in that decision, actively or passively. The “helper” is then made responsible for judging who qualifies, ie which lives are valuable and worth living, and which are futile and pointless. This is dangerous and unethical, and it completely undermines the ideal of personal autonomy. The only person to weigh the value of a life should be the owner of that life.

I agree, suicide is (nearly) always possible for those determined. You also correctly point out that assistance therefore is not a requirement.

So why not provide options for assisted suicide?
These other methods you alluded to tend to put other people at risk, often traumatise bystanders, families and / or are incredibly painful.

Why do you prefer that to assisted suicide?

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 08:09

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 17:21

I’m sorry you felt abusive, I hope it helps to know that not all of us trying to kill our selves in acute wards do actually want to die. Yes the experience is humiliating and traumatising, but not all medical care is pretty or nice, it’s about what is necessary. I am beyond grateful to staff like you that kept me alive. Did you ever get to hear from patients after discharge who had gone on to be more stable? It would be so demoralising to not see the positive impacts of your work.

I'm thinking of 5 people all of whom were inpatients on 1:1 for several years when I knew them. One did make a phenomenal recovery which no-one would have predicted. Largely I heard, because she had a baby. That was wonderful to hear.

One last I heard was in an expensive out of area secure placement so 20 + years roughly of inpatient treatment. One died of cancer because they refused treatment for it. The other 2 eventually managed to take their own lives while still inpatients but trying to step down from 1:1. And I felt relief for them to be honest.

Of course loads more people I knew during inpatient admissions that made fantastic recoveries too! But a small number of people don't despite every treatment being tried and they get stuck living miserable lives in specialist units trying to end their lives.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 02/05/2023 08:08

Sudeko · 02/05/2023 08:03

True, but splitting the definition into ten variants is not going to detract from just how intrinsically horrifying it is on a fundamental level. It paints a dystopian picture of a future where many obedient workers will do as they are told to systemically implement legalized murder of the disabled as part of their humdrum day job with the approval of the state.

I fail to see how you would consider this 10 different variants.

Assisted suicide (suicide. Not actively killing anyone else) should be legal but tightly regulated (imo).

Palliative care and pain management, which may decrease life expectancy, should definitely be legal as well. Anything else would be dystopian to me!

Sudeko · 02/05/2023 08:05

It is more credible in Switzerland with high GDP per capita and a robust healthcare system then it would be in Britain where the collapsed NHS system has failed the individuals. It is making the weakest pay with their lives for the failings of the powers that be.

Sudeko · 02/05/2023 08:03

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 02/05/2023 07:35

I can only speak for Switzerland as I am very familiar with the Swiss process (due to personal experiences).
It is quite tightly regulated. What is legal and practiced by some of the prominent organisations is "active aid to suicide". The means (medication etc.) are provided but the person wanting to die has to do it to his/herself.

It also has to be done whilst still being mentally able and there is quite a lot of hoopla to jump through. There have been court cases and sentences for doctors when the mental state of the deceased was considerd inadequate...
Situations like in the link above in regards to the case of the Netherlands would be considered (extremely) illegal. Any kind of direct and actived in ending somebody's life isn't legal according to Swiss law.

=> Enthusiastic is a therefore a really incorrect description imo.

True, but splitting the definition into ten variants is not going to detract from just how intrinsically horrifying it is on a fundamental level. It paints a dystopian picture of a future where many obedient workers will do as they are told to systemically implement legalized murder of the disabled as part of their humdrum day job with the approval of the state.

user4567890754 · 02/05/2023 08:02

People already have the freedom to make that decision for themselves. I’m not going to list ways of killing oneself but we all know that there are plenty of substances freely available without prescription that will do the job. It’s a personal decision, sad and regrettable. But suicide is not illegal and also not always irrational in my opinion, depending on the circumstances.

However, there is no reason or need to involve anyone else in that decision, actively or passively. The “helper” is then made responsible for judging who qualifies, ie which lives are valuable and worth living, and which are futile and pointless. This is dangerous and unethical, and it completely undermines the ideal of personal autonomy. The only person to weigh the value of a life should be the owner of that life.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 02/05/2023 07:42

Gtsr443 · 02/05/2023 07:32

For the supporters of this dystopian hell I'd ask - how will the killing be done?

At the start of Aktion T4 the Nazis instructed nurses to kill disabled babies by leaving them outdoors to freeze to death.
They then used injections to kill disabled children and adults as they systematically emptied asylums and hospitals. (This was performed by doctors).
Then they expanded to old peoples homes and prisons to include the elderly and criminally insane.

Individual injections took too long and they needed a more effective method of extermination and disposal so they constructed large crematoria and created mobile gas chambers.
And so it began.
This is where the Nazis learnt how to industrialise killing of people the state deemed "unworthy of life". They started with the disabled and the sick. And it was all performed by doctors to provide a veneer of scientific legitimacy.

Unworthy of life - several people on this thread have come very close to using that exact phrase.

I would say that there is a massive difference between assisted suicide (direct but passive aid) and medical staff actively ending a life (direct and active aid - aka killing).

Providing the means to end one's own life under specific circumstances (I personally feel that certain MH conditions should preclude somebody from receiving assisted suicide services and definitely should not be a reason to provide said assistance) is imo simply part of living in a society that respects people's liberties and their right to make informed medical decisions.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 02/05/2023 07:35

Gtsr443 · 02/05/2023 06:40

Belgium, Canada, Netherlands, Switzerland. Why is it the world's most boring countries are such enthusiastic advocates of euthanasia?

I can only speak for Switzerland as I am very familiar with the Swiss process (due to personal experiences).
It is quite tightly regulated. What is legal and practiced by some of the prominent organisations is "active aid to suicide". The means (medication etc.) are provided but the person wanting to die has to do it to his/herself.

It also has to be done whilst still being mentally able and there is quite a lot of hoopla to jump through. There have been court cases and sentences for doctors when the mental state of the deceased was considerd inadequate...
Situations like in the link above in regards to the case of the Netherlands would be considered (extremely) illegal. Any kind of direct and actived in ending somebody's life isn't legal according to Swiss law.

=> Enthusiastic is a therefore a really incorrect description imo.

Gtsr443 · 02/05/2023 07:32

For the supporters of this dystopian hell I'd ask - how will the killing be done?

At the start of Aktion T4 the Nazis instructed nurses to kill disabled babies by leaving them outdoors to freeze to death.
They then used injections to kill disabled children and adults as they systematically emptied asylums and hospitals. (This was performed by doctors).
Then they expanded to old peoples homes and prisons to include the elderly and criminally insane.

Individual injections took too long and they needed a more effective method of extermination and disposal so they constructed large crematoria and created mobile gas chambers.
And so it began.
This is where the Nazis learnt how to industrialise killing of people the state deemed "unworthy of life". They started with the disabled and the sick. And it was all performed by doctors to provide a veneer of scientific legitimacy.

Unworthy of life - several people on this thread have come very close to using that exact phrase.

Sudeko · 02/05/2023 06:52

It is slowly catching on in terms of acceptability and dull and dependable can often dupe more volatile countries.

Gtsr443 · 02/05/2023 06:40

Belgium, Canada, Netherlands, Switzerland. Why is it the world's most boring countries are such enthusiastic advocates of euthanasia?

Sudeko · 02/05/2023 06:20

It should also be pointed out that (due to the public sector cuts and other reasons) many ASD sufferers have a single primary carer who is usually their parent. Of course they would be distressed when they lose that carer. They could literally be led by replacement carers down this line of thought with an intractable end result. En masse.
It feels sinister in view of the fact that the media are happy to run daily 'broken NHS' stories as though we should all be resigned to the fact that the system is now unsalvageable when it would have been taboo to even state it on TV only a decade ago.

GoldenAye · 02/05/2023 03:02

@SparklyBlackKitten

I read some people on here talking about their severely autistic kids that are causing nothing but suffering and can't go the the toilet themselves. Can't communicate, Cant be taken outside without severe meltdowns. Violence. The mums scared of their own kid. Those People have 0 qualify of life. And their parents /caretakers are jailed for life having to endure the mental illness from a child that brings 0% joy to their lives.

Apart from the rest of your horrifying post, this sums up what is so troubling about how some people think of euthanasia. They are considering how removing a person eases a burden - in this case, a child that brings 0% joy? Remove it! Bring joy back into your life by killing your child!

Rather than using other tools and services to manage the issue, why consider euthanasia for a child? I'm glad a good amount of sensible voices recognise the ableist conversation that has sprung up around AD.

ashitghost · 01/05/2023 23:26

That country is lost. Trudeau is a very malevolent man.

4plusthehound · 01/05/2023 23:22

LangClegsInSpace · 01/05/2023 23:17

She had signed an advance directive.

I've seen posters on previous threads actually defending this death and saying that enlisting her family to hold her down and administering the injection while she fought against it was the right thing to do.

Bloody hell.

I don't know what to say.

LangClegsInSpace · 01/05/2023 23:17

4plusthehound · 01/05/2023 22:58

They then went to inject her, she kicked the syringe out of the doctors hand. The doctor had her held down and then euthanised her.

WHAT AM I READING????

She had signed an advance directive.

I've seen posters on previous threads actually defending this death and saying that enlisting her family to hold her down and administering the injection while she fought against it was the right thing to do.

4plusthehound · 01/05/2023 23:14

StressedToTheMaxxx · 01/05/2023 15:51

I couldn't really care less if you're disturbed by my responses. I'm sick of people like @MrsEdnaWelthorpe thinking she speaks for everyone. I've suffered mental health issues in the past however I'm in no way arrogant enough to think that my own lived experience is the only experience and that what I wish to be the gold standard for my treatment is what I should impose on everyone else.

@MrsEdnaWelthorpe can't play the vulnerable person when she feels like it simply to not have anyone disagree with her. She claims that she is no longer unwell so she should be up for debate. She got quite hostile and rude towards my first post therefore I responded in kind. If she wants polite discourse, she'll receive it, absolutely. If you look at my first post, it was polite and considered. However she got extremely rude and personal in her response to my first post. That's fine - if she wants rudeness, she'll get it. She didn't like me responding to her in the same manner that she spoke to me hence the faux wide eyed victim card being played.

She seems much like a pro lifer in that they don't agree with a medical choice - abortion. Which is absolutely fine - don't get one for yourself. But don't aggressively force your opinions on everyone else and demand that others who need to consider using a pathway, don't get access to it. She has absolutely no right to state that the consideration of euthanasia should be off the table for everyone with mental health issues. I get just as angry at those who would like to deny euthanasia to everyone full stop, people with debilitating, painful, degenerative illnesses, thus forcing them to endure suffering. Selfish, selfish people and these peoples voices do affect the access to choices that other people have.

You really need to step away.

4plusthehound · 01/05/2023 22:58

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 11:38

Personally I believe in body autonomy, your body your right to make an informed decision.

Thats all well and good when you have full mental capacity, but if you suffer a mental health condition that periodically takes away your mental capacity so you have no real autonomy, such that you can’t even trust your own decisions. You are also especially vulnerable to coercion regardless of intention, well meaning or no.

When I’m sectioned, I cannot refuse treatment. I lose my right to bodily autonomy. Rightfully so as I am too unwell to have the mental capacity to choose what I want or need.

The thing is, I then have to have absolute trust in whatever doctors are on duty to decide what is best for me while I am psychotic.

If euthanasia is legalised, what is stopping doctors from making that decision for me? There was a case in the Netherlands where a woman was held down and euthanised. They put sedative in her tea. They then went to inject her, she kicked the syringe out of the doctors hand. The doctor had her held down and then euthanised her. All because when unwell the woman had made comments about wishing to die when the time is right. They went by what she said at her lowest moments, but ignored her desperate physical struggles when they went to euthanise her. To me that was murder.

They then went to inject her, she kicked the syringe out of the doctors hand. The doctor had her held down and then euthanised her.

WHAT AM I READING????