Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Canada’s euthanasia for the mentally ill

342 replies

Noicant · 01/05/2023 08:34

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

Canada is in the process of introducing the option of Euthanasia for the mentally ill. It looks like this has been delayed for the time being but AIBU to find this concerning?

Just to be clear I fully support euthanasia as an option for people with terminal or chronic conditions. I think it’s human to offer people a peaceful death when there is no chance of things improving.

BUT this seems utterly mad to me. I’ve suffered from poor mental health in the past and only started feeling better after going through a few therapists and finding the right one. There were many times over 20years where I would have happily signed up for death. If someone is so ill that they are very impaired by their condition are they truly competent to make a decision like this and if it’s milder isn’t there a possibility of recovery?

It seems utterly dystopian. I guess I’m looking for someone to help me understand if I’ve missed something or not understood something that will help me understand why anyone would think this is a good idea.

Expansion of assisted dying for mental illness to be delayed until 2024 in new bill - National | Globalnews.ca

Justice Minister David Lametti has said the delay is needed after the federal government heard concerns that Canada's health-care system might not be prepared for the expansion.

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
JuvenileEmu · 02/05/2023 12:57

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 11:44

Having a mental health condition does not mean the person is incapable of making any rational or reasoned decisions.

There are a lot of posters here who seem to think it does. Which is worrying. But that view is also not supported by the mental capacity act. Which is law.

https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/social-care-and-support-guide/making-decisions-for-someone-else/mental-capacity-act/

Do you mean that someone who is on a section could be deemed to have capacity to make a decision to agree to euthanasia? IANAL but I find it hard to believe a court would go along with that, even if it is theoretically allowed. And tbh I would be very concerned that there could be coercion or influence involved.

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 12:31

user4567890754 · 02/05/2023 12:09

Well, we’re talking about the extension of euthanasia in Canada to the mentally ill. And PP commented that this is a slippery slope to euthanising children who can’t possibly consent.

I think it’s pretty relevant to point out that this is a valid concern, given that doctors in Canada are already arguing for that very thing.

I disagree. The thread is about the MAID programme in Canada which is for people seeking medically assisted dying due to a severe, treatment-resistant health condition, being extended to potentially include mental health conditions.

That proposal is not a slippery slope to forced euthanasia in any way, the article says that. But the thread was derailed by the suggestion and unhelpful and offensive comparisons to Nazi Germany.

"Canadians who weren't already nearing death became eligible for MAID in 2021, when the government changed the law in response to a lower court ruling. That change allows people with "grievous and irremediable" medical conditions who are experiencing "intolerable suffering" to seek a doctor's help to die — even if their natural deaths are decades away"

Above is what is being discussed. Whether or not someone experiencing "intolerable suffering" from a "grevious and irremdiable mental health condition and not just a physical one, should have the right to seek assisted dying.

Not babies. Not the medical/psychiatric profession choosing to kill people. Not people with a mental illness in the throes of an episode with no MH history or a proven history of recovering or partially recovering between episodes having a Dr back up their current possibly illness-driven desire to die when they don't really mean it.

It's about people who are experiencing intolerable suffering from a health condition who can evidence that they have attempted numerous treatments over a significant amount of time which have not helped them and who want to die and not do so in a way that will cause trauma to others.

As suicide always does traumatise whoever finds the body, is the train driver that hits them and so on.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 02/05/2023 12:21

user4567890754 · 02/05/2023 12:09

Well, we’re talking about the extension of euthanasia in Canada to the mentally ill. And PP commented that this is a slippery slope to euthanising children who can’t possibly consent.

I think it’s pretty relevant to point out that this is a valid concern, given that doctors in Canada are already arguing for that very thing.

Just to make we didn't actually argue the same position:

Are you against assisted suicide in general?

Are you against assisted suicide for people with all MH conditions and illnesses?

Are you against assisted suicide services being provided on the basis of somebody being diagnosed with a MI?

Or are you simply worried about this being a slippery slope in regards to children?

user4567890754 · 02/05/2023 12:09

Well, we’re talking about the extension of euthanasia in Canada to the mentally ill. And PP commented that this is a slippery slope to euthanising children who can’t possibly consent.

I think it’s pretty relevant to point out that this is a valid concern, given that doctors in Canada are already arguing for that very thing.

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 11:51

user4567890754 · 02/05/2023 11:44

@TrufflySnufgl6

There are doctors associations in Canada making representations to Parliament to legalise euthanising disabled children.

“Dr. Louis Roy, of Quebec's College of Physicians, said his group believes assisted death could be offered to babies up to one year old "with severe deformities and very serious syndromes for which the chances of survival are virtually nil, and which will cause so much pain that a decision must be made to not allow the child to suffer."

https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/assisted-dying-carla-qualtrough-1.6625412

Not what I'm talking about. Or the subject of the thread.

user4567890754 · 02/05/2023 11:44

@TrufflySnufgl6

There are doctors associations in Canada making representations to Parliament to legalise euthanising disabled children.

“Dr. Louis Roy, of Quebec's College of Physicians, said his group believes assisted death could be offered to babies up to one year old "with severe deformities and very serious syndromes for which the chances of survival are virtually nil, and which will cause so much pain that a decision must be made to not allow the child to suffer."

https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/assisted-dying-carla-qualtrough-1.6625412

Federal minister says she's 'shocked' by suggestion of assisted deaths for some babies | CBC News

Canada's minister of disability inclusion says she's offended by a Quebec doctor's suggestion that infants less than a year old should have access to medically assisted death if they are unlikely to survive and are dealing with severe health issues.

https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/assisted-dying-carla-qualtrough-1.6625412

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 11:44

ClareBlue · 02/05/2023 10:29

All assisted death legislation relies on you being of a sound mind when making the decision and not being pressurised to do it.
How does this fit with that. People can not make a rational and reasoned decision when suffering from a mental health issue so this legislation gives not protection. All this type of legislation is sold to us that it is compassionate and will never be used to dispose of people to save money or make judgement on someone's quality of life. But once you normalise it along comes this, and then the tests get weaker and weaker until we have an upright doctor, maybe called Shipman, making decisions for us.
This isn't progressive, it's just plain scarey.

Having a mental health condition does not mean the person is incapable of making any rational or reasoned decisions.

There are a lot of posters here who seem to think it does. Which is worrying. But that view is also not supported by the mental capacity act. Which is law.

https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/social-care-and-support-guide/making-decisions-for-someone-else/mental-capacity-act/

nhs.uk

Mental Capacity Act - Social care and support guide

What is the Mental Capacity Act and what does it mean for you?

https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/social-care-and-support-guide/making-decisions-for-someone-else/mental-capacity-act

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 11:33

finallygotospeaktoSky · 02/05/2023 10:53

A certain country that had disabled, mentally ill and ND people and wiped them out between1939 -1941 in the guise of racial purity
Slippery slope, three of my adult dc would have been victims had they been around at the time. Doesn't bear thinking about.

Not the same thing at all though is it?

This is a thread talking about voluntary euthanasia or medically assisted dying for people who do not want to live anymore due to serious and treatment-resistant health conditions.

finallygotospeaktoSky · 02/05/2023 10:53

A certain country that had disabled, mentally ill and ND people and wiped them out between1939 -1941 in the guise of racial purity
Slippery slope, three of my adult dc would have been victims had they been around at the time. Doesn't bear thinking about.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 02/05/2023 10:41

Interesting. It is not what I asked but I do agree that this would be very concerning.

I still believe that assisted suicide (not allowing somebody to actively kill a patient!) is important and should be legislated for.

As you said, people will nearly always have the option to commit suicide (with enough determination). The one thing we can determine is the "how" and under which circumstances.

Sudeko · 02/05/2023 10:41

Agree. There are various compromises being made to our human rights which get second billing by the tabloids or even lower in favour of trashy gossip stories. Once these changes go through unchallenged, it will be hard to ever reverse them. Within ten years, we have gone from disabled people's rights being recognized in the workplace and social settings to them being unfairly deprived of the basic tools which they require to function properly like benefits they are rightfully entitled to claim and now this.

ClareBlue · 02/05/2023 10:29

All assisted death legislation relies on you being of a sound mind when making the decision and not being pressurised to do it.
How does this fit with that. People can not make a rational and reasoned decision when suffering from a mental health issue so this legislation gives not protection. All this type of legislation is sold to us that it is compassionate and will never be used to dispose of people to save money or make judgement on someone's quality of life. But once you normalise it along comes this, and then the tests get weaker and weaker until we have an upright doctor, maybe called Shipman, making decisions for us.
This isn't progressive, it's just plain scarey.

user4567890754 · 02/05/2023 10:25

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 02/05/2023 10:20

I am also very glad that you survived this time of your life. Which does not erase my experience and perspective.

I do not know of any political party, mainstream medical association or government that is suggesting assisted suicide for suicidal minors. Could you please point me in the right direction?

The law against taking someone else’s life away is there to protect all of us.

There is a difference between assisted suicide and taking somebody's life. This discussion requires nuance instead of black and white thinking.

https://globalnews.ca/news/9491605/maid-minors-canada-medically-assisted-dying-committee-report/amp/

Minors should be eligible for assisted dying, parliamentary committee says - National | Globalnews.ca

Canada's assisted dying laws should be expanded to include minors, a parliamentary committee has recommended in a new report tabled in the House of Commons Wednesday. 

https://globalnews.ca/news/9491605/maid-minors-canada-medically-assisted-dying-committee-report/amp/

Sudeko · 02/05/2023 10:21

There are patients who sound credible and even mislead doctor's into misdiagnosing their true capacity. That is the thing about interpreting a lot of mental health conditions. There is often nothing visibly diagnosable so it is reliant upon external observations and anecdotal evidence.
Perhaps the solution is to place those who have proven suicidal intent in non safety-proofed environments where the regular risk items are left in situ. I very much doubt that they will all end up taking their own lives. The threats are sometimes serious, at other times merely cries for help and it may swing frequently from one to another.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 02/05/2023 10:20

user4567890754 · 02/05/2023 10:09

I do have personal experience. I was that suicidal child. I’m very glad that I didn’t live in a country where I would have been assisted to carry that out. I live a full and happy life now, and I am very grateful for my life.

Laws should be made on the basis of public protection. The law against taking someone else’s life away is there to protect all of us.

I am also very glad that you survived this time of your life. Which does not erase my experience and perspective.

I do not know of any political party, mainstream medical association or government that is suggesting assisted suicide for suicidal minors. Could you please point me in the right direction?

The law against taking someone else’s life away is there to protect all of us.

There is a difference between assisted suicide and taking somebody's life. This discussion requires nuance instead of black and white thinking.

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 10:11

SwitchDiver · 02/05/2023 09:10

If they are inpatient, then how can they have the mental capacity to truly consent? If they had mental capacity, they would not be detained under the mental health act, right? Even the NHS webpage says:

”Consent to treatment
If you're held under the Mental Health Act, you can be treated against your will.
This is because it's felt you do not have sufficient capacity to make an informed decision about your treatment at the time.
This is also the case if you refuse treatment but the team treating you believe you should have it.”
https://www.nhs.uk/mental-health/social-care-and-your-rights/mental-health-and-the-law/mental-health-act/

So you’d be euthanising certain people without their true consent and in some cases without them even being aware what was happening.

What about the fact that as a patient you cannot leave? Apparently we could be chosen to die, but there is no right to leave the secure ward/unit?

Capacity isn't a global issue and doesn't apply to every circumstance. Different medications, therapies, ECT, psychosurgery etc all have different rules.

It is not assumed that being under section means you don't have the capacity to make any decisions or that you have no rights. The mental health act and mental capacity act are complex legislation.

Sec 2 for example is a section for assessment so you can't administer medication without consent unless in an 'emergency'. A Sec 3 is for treatment but even then, if the patient is still not consenting to medication after 3 months, the psychiatrist has to state their intention to continue to enforce medication without consent and a second opinion is required from another psychiatrist who reviews the notes and meets with the patient and agrees or not.

You can't be forced to have medical (physical) health treatment under any section for example unless under specific legislation of the MHA where it is proven that the refusal for the medical treatment is directly related to the mental disorder that you are being treated for. NG feeding for anorexia nervosa patients starving themselves to death is the most common example where medical treatment is enforced without consent under that legislation.

So in the case of the person I mentioned earlier, they were being treated for a personality disorder. They were able to refuse treatment for cancer because their capacity to make that decision was assessed, they demonstrated full understanding of the proposed treatment and the potential consequences of not having it and their refusal to accept cancer treatment was not consdered to be related to the mental disorder they were being treated for.

A person can be required to remain on the unit under section but the fact is that if they did leave and returned home and refused to return to the hospital, they could be discharged. Because using the Police to force entry into someone's home to return them to hospital requires a warrant issued by a magistrates court where it has to be proven that not doing so would result in serious harm as the person would be unable to look after themselves. I can't count the number of times when I was working in inpatient, that someone under section went AWOL and we discharged them after 48 hrs and used their bed.

I am not proposing 'euthanising' anyone nor suggesting anyone be 'chosen to die'.

I'm talking about the individuals who would be able to say "I relive my CSA in flashbacks every single day, I've been in hospital for X years, I've tried X number of treatments, nothing has helped. I feel tortured and I want to die".

Because currently we say 'tough shit' to those people and force them to live miserable lives on specialist units, watch them bath and use the toilet, give them a TV in a perspex box to watch and give them plastic plates and plastic cutlery to eat with. Remove anything that they could use to harm themselves and then when they're banging their head on the wall trying to stop the horrible images in their head (we can't remove walls!) we have a bunch of staff pin them down on the floor which really reminds them of their CSA btw and wait till they've tired themselves out or pull their pants down a bit which again reminds them of CSA, to give an injection into their buttock and hopefully make them too sedated to try to harm themselves.

Then do it again the next day or a few days later. For years. That's why I felt abusive.

user4567890754 · 02/05/2023 10:09

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 02/05/2023 09:54

And I wish we all lived long and happy lives and died peacefully in our sleep. I wish that nobody had to see a loved one die and that nobody had to experience a potentially painful or distressing death.

But that is clearly not realistic and cannot be used as a basis to determine law and health policies.

I don’t see that “assisted suicide” is obviously or necessarily less traumatic for family members than solo suicide. I can imagine the grief of parents being made to witness or be complicit with the suicide of their child. I can imagine parents seeing their child be “assisted” by the medical profession to kill themselves, and being powerless to intervene or protect that child.

I'm glad that you're such an empathetic person and willing to draw on our imagination.

I wish you also used some of that empathy and imagination for some of us who have personal experiences with this process and are extremely thankful their loved ones have/had that opportunity.Not to mention the vulnerability of people with MH or neurological issues to coercion by more sinister family members.

Good point. Which is why the Swiss organisations and Swiss criminal law do not let anybody - particularly family members - with a vested interest be involved in this. I would encourage you to look into how this is practiced in various countries.

I do have personal experience. I was that suicidal child. I’m very glad that I didn’t live in a country where I would have been assisted to carry that out. I live a full and happy life now, and I am very grateful for my life.

Laws should be made on the basis of public protection. The law against taking someone else’s life away is there to protect all of us.

Sittingonabench · 02/05/2023 10:08

At the root of the matter it is trying to work out if it is what is best for the patient. If the patient believes it is what is best for them and the doctor also believes it is best then that would appear to be a good indication. Timelines should be indicative depending on the circumstances and earlier directives could be used to illustrate a level of consistency. Someone who is suicidal due to mental health may require a longer timeline and a more robust degree of evidence that this is best for them and what they want in order to take into account the highs and the lows as well as having tried other routes. However yes in an underfunded system with limited resources - there is dangers so the patient needs to remain at the very heart of it

NooNooHead1981 · 02/05/2023 09:59

BibbleandSqwauk · 01/05/2023 09:38

In the documentary Pru Leith did recently they interviewed a man in Canada, in his 80s who had lived with depression for decades. His wish to die was rational, calm and supported by his wife. Currently he cannot access it whilst a man with Parkinson's who had similarly had enough, could. I agree that there is an inevitable danger of economic factors pushing an agenda but I think we do need to move away from a "life at all costs" approach (figuratively speaking). If a person is able to rationally, calmly and over a period of time express a consistent wish then I'm not sure what the moral basis is for refusing that autonomy.

This, perfectly said.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 02/05/2023 09:54

user4567890754 · 02/05/2023 09:33

I’d prefer no one ever felt so much suffering as to take their own life.

I’m not talking about methods that would put others at risk.

I don’t see that “assisted suicide” is obviously or necessarily less traumatic for family members than solo suicide. I can imagine the grief of parents being made to witness or be complicit with the suicide of their child. I can imagine parents seeing their child be “assisted” by the medical profession to kill themselves, and being powerless to intervene or protect that child.

Not to mention the vulnerability of people with MH or neurological issues to coercion by more sinister family members.

Ingestion (or injection) of lethal substances has the potential to be painful and distressing for the person whether they are assisted or unassisted in the process.

And I wish we all lived long and happy lives and died peacefully in our sleep. I wish that nobody had to see a loved one die and that nobody had to experience a potentially painful or distressing death.

But that is clearly not realistic and cannot be used as a basis to determine law and health policies.

I don’t see that “assisted suicide” is obviously or necessarily less traumatic for family members than solo suicide. I can imagine the grief of parents being made to witness or be complicit with the suicide of their child. I can imagine parents seeing their child be “assisted” by the medical profession to kill themselves, and being powerless to intervene or protect that child.

I'm glad that you're such an empathetic person and willing to draw on our imagination.

I wish you also used some of that empathy and imagination for some of us who have personal experiences with this process and are extremely thankful their loved ones have/had that opportunity.Not to mention the vulnerability of people with MH or neurological issues to coercion by more sinister family members.

Good point. Which is why the Swiss organisations and Swiss criminal law do not let anybody - particularly family members - with a vested interest be involved in this. I would encourage you to look into how this is practiced in various countries.

Sudeko · 02/05/2023 09:45

Have you not heard about how so few people have medical power of attorney arrangements in place? Even those who do often have to fight to uphold the rights of the inpatient. In most cases though, medics have carte blanche.

user4567890754 · 02/05/2023 09:42

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 08:54

How about when the individual is an inpatient and actively prevented from taking their life for years on end?

They're the people I'm thinking about that this may be relevant for.

If they’re an inpatient then they wouldn’t have capacity to consent at that time, so they wouldn’t qualify for voluntary euthanasia unless you want to throw out the idea of consenting to be murdered and just go straight to murdering people instead.

user4567890754 · 02/05/2023 09:33

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 02/05/2023 08:22

I agree, suicide is (nearly) always possible for those determined. You also correctly point out that assistance therefore is not a requirement.

So why not provide options for assisted suicide?
These other methods you alluded to tend to put other people at risk, often traumatise bystanders, families and / or are incredibly painful.

Why do you prefer that to assisted suicide?

I’d prefer no one ever felt so much suffering as to take their own life.

I’m not talking about methods that would put others at risk.

I don’t see that “assisted suicide” is obviously or necessarily less traumatic for family members than solo suicide. I can imagine the grief of parents being made to witness or be complicit with the suicide of their child. I can imagine parents seeing their child be “assisted” by the medical profession to kill themselves, and being powerless to intervene or protect that child.

Not to mention the vulnerability of people with MH or neurological issues to coercion by more sinister family members.

Ingestion (or injection) of lethal substances has the potential to be painful and distressing for the person whether they are assisted or unassisted in the process.

Sudeko · 02/05/2023 09:24

We are rapidly arriving at a point where the balance will tip in favour of people keeping away from doctors and deliberately not seeking out help for mental health and related conditions along with avoidable casualties. It is also a chilling thought that the eugenicists mostly escaped the Nuremberg Trials and many countries in Europe retailed their concentration camps (often, the same countries which sell tours of their long depopulated Jewish ghettos). It is true that they are now open as museums but for many decades, they simply lay empty without explanation and it was very unclear why they were not destroyed.

Coolblur · 02/05/2023 09:24

While I can see how this plan has come about, it is in no way a reasonable alternative to proper lasting mental health support and care.
My husband suffers with his mental health and has made several suicide attempts (classic 'cries for help' rather than really trying to end his life) when he's feeling absolutely desperate. When he's ok he can see that he doesn't want to die, just wants not to feel that way anymore, and would do whatever necessary to make it stop. I think at his lowest points he would opt for this if offered.
But...what about us, his family? And the family of those Canadians who take this option? Is their welfare and the subsequent impact on their mental health taken into account? Asking a person with severely impaired mental health to make a rational decision on something as huge as this is a big mistake. Yet how can anyone else make the choice for them?