Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Canada’s euthanasia for the mentally ill

342 replies

Noicant · 01/05/2023 08:34

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

Canada is in the process of introducing the option of Euthanasia for the mentally ill. It looks like this has been delayed for the time being but AIBU to find this concerning?

Just to be clear I fully support euthanasia as an option for people with terminal or chronic conditions. I think it’s human to offer people a peaceful death when there is no chance of things improving.

BUT this seems utterly mad to me. I’ve suffered from poor mental health in the past and only started feeling better after going through a few therapists and finding the right one. There were many times over 20years where I would have happily signed up for death. If someone is so ill that they are very impaired by their condition are they truly competent to make a decision like this and if it’s milder isn’t there a possibility of recovery?

It seems utterly dystopian. I guess I’m looking for someone to help me understand if I’ve missed something or not understood something that will help me understand why anyone would think this is a good idea.

Expansion of assisted dying for mental illness to be delayed until 2024 in new bill - National | Globalnews.ca

Justice Minister David Lametti has said the delay is needed after the federal government heard concerns that Canada's health-care system might not be prepared for the expansion.

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
madbongolee · 02/05/2023 20:56

It is obscene, I work in mental health and see on a daily basis even the most severely ill people move into recovery and live brilliant lives. I have worked with the most desperately unwell and suicidal people, who get better. I recently went to a talk from a guy who spent almost twenty years in and out of hospitals (seventies and eighties when long stay patients were a thing) who has just finished a phd and is leading research into new treatments for severe mental illness.

What is needed is investment in care, in treatment, in education so people are able to recover and able to see that they can recover and have the space and time to do so and not patched up and kicked out on the street again.

SchoolShenanigans · 02/05/2023 20:48

I think it's reasonable to think that for some people, with crippling long term mental health conditions, who have treatment with no avail, euthanasia is the right option for them. It's much more humane than taking an overdose or jumping off a bridge.

Obviously there needs to be carefully considered limits around it.

LangClegsInSpace · 02/05/2023 20:43

Thank you to everyone who has shared their stories of mental distress. Your voices are really important in this debate Flowers

JuvenileEmu · 02/05/2023 20:08

@TrufflySnufgl6 also, I have been involved in many board level discussions around the problems that these units can end up with staff. With patients kept on units for years, often "out of sight, out of mind", very unhealthy working practices can develop, with staff burnt out and believing that patients are hopeless cases who have no chances of recovery. Which can result in neglect, poor treatment and even abuse. The way you have been speaking to posters who have been open about their illnesses, I think you are showing signs of this yourself.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 02/05/2023 17:07

I would never suggest that people living with MI do not deserve to live. And they (obviously) deserve medical care, compassionate treatment etc.
This is not about eugenics or health care costs (at least to me).

But if they decided during (a stable period) that they still wanted to die? And if (various) medical experts independently came to the conclusion that they were capable of making that choice?

I ultimately still believe that people should be allowed to make their own decisions. Mental illness therefore shouldn't automatically preclude somebody from assisted suicide, especially in the case of other comorbidities. (Assisted suicide, not euthanasia!).

I have however reread this thread and appreciate that many people shared their own experiences with severe mental illness and suicidality. And that they do not share my opinion.

and these voices obviously should be listened to.
I also believe that we need to ensure that people do not fear mental health providers etc. due to fearing offers of assisted suicide or euthanasia (should they experience suicidality after the beginning of treatment etc.). That might lead to horrible outcomes... Their needs should be prioritised if something like this were to be implemented.

Anyhow, this has been extremely interesting. I unfortunately don't have time to continue participating in the discussion. But I will definitely continue to think about this.
I wish everyone a nice evening.

JuvenileEmu · 02/05/2023 16:24

Oh, also the trust that I am involved with through work are currently trying very hard to bring as many of the people detained in out of area placements back to local units with a long term goal of them being safe enough to live in the community.

Because, these days it is accepted that this kind of unit very rarely produces good outcomes. The very restrictive environment ends up, as in the case of some of your patients, actually embedding very harmful coping strategies- for example, extreme self harm leading to restraint.

Admittedly, it can be quite difficult to work with people who are so institutionalized but so far there has been quite a few successes.
Surely a better answer than, you won't get better but the nice doctor will give you an injection so everything goes away.

ohyouknowwhatshername · 02/05/2023 16:19

Creepyrosemary · 02/05/2023 14:05

Funny how most of us feel that we shouldn't dictate if women keep a pregnancy or not but we feel that we do get to decide that strangers aren't allowed a peaceful death, they should just jump from a building or something.

I do think that people need to be offered help, but who am I to decide about life or death?

Maybe that's because a lot of people see a fetus as not yet a 'person' in their own right? It's a different situation to dealing with a fully grown adult who very much does have a life, but one they don't enjoy and desperately want to get out of.

Sudeko · 02/05/2023 16:17

I practiced in that field, briefly. I could not wait to leave. I have my hesitations. As I said before, the compromise solution would be to create some secure units which are not safety-proofed beyond what you would expect in a regular care home and allow those who have demonstrated a true desperation to end their lives the opportunity to live in a less controlled environment where their medications are still being administered, they are not a danger to others but little else beyond that. I maintain that it will result in a % of deaths well below one hundred unlike if the same cohort was euthanized.

JuvenileEmu · 02/05/2023 16:03

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 15:29

Nope. At no point have I ever said that 'euthanasia of psychiatric inpatients be allowed '.

I'm not suggesting psychiatric inpatients be eathanised', I'm suggesting there are certain circumstances where a person experiencing intolerabe suffering for years on end, should be given the right to end that suffering and not as currently happens, be forced to live shitty lives.

This would never apply to SwitchDriver given everything she's said on this thread
Since she doesn't want to die, and even if she wanted to when in hospital, there'd be a wealth of evidence to say she did not have a treatment-resistant mental illness since she gets treated and goes home repeatedly and during those times, is very clear that she does not want to die and says suicidality is just a symptom of her mental health crises.

And don't try to make assumptions about my experiences of working in the the mental health system. It was a decade ago, not 20 years that I stopped working inpatients ( you didn't read my posts ) but funnily enough, still work in the same NHS trust, still have friends and colleagues who do still work on wards who tell me how things are now since we're friends and talk about our lives/work.

I didn't work in inpatient for ' a short time'. , that's a major assumption on your part It was 4 years. Long enough to get a good idea of what was happening.

You suggest I found it 'unpleasant' as if I made a judgement and it was not nice or not what I expected. Not really. I was diagnosed with PTSD after the trauma I experienced on the wards.

Just a short list in 4 years would be someone setting fire to themselves, trying to cut someone down that had hanged themselves, slipping over a massive pool of blood as I entered someone's room after a night shift, trying to restrain someone as they were on a chair smashing their hands into the tube lights, showering everyone including me with blood.

Oh and being physically and sexually assaulted.

And 99% of the time when I was restraining someone and forcibly medicating them I did it because I really believed that it was in the person's best interests because they would get better.

But sometimes, I didn't believe that at all so questioned myself. Which is in regards to the small of group of inpatients that I've already referenced.

I didn't previously mention any of the traumatic things I endured because they are entirely irrelevant to the thread.

It's not about , .me or anyone else deciding if someone should die, but caring enough about the individual to think they should have that right.

But since you decided to claim things that aren't true about me, I've responded.

I will also add that in the 4 years I worked on wards/PICUS there were more days than not, where I wasn't exposed to trauma and many lovely days with patients who were getting better and we even had fun.

You're still making it about yourself though. Your trauma. Some of the patients made you feel traumatized. But some of the other patients didn't make you feel traumatized, so you don't think they would be suitable to be offered euthanasia to. I'm sure it was a very difficult environment. But you are not able to be objective.

Oh, and I would say 10 years is a long time ago tbh. I work in a mental health/ homelessness/ addictions based charity and things have change massively in a decade.

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 15:38

SwitchDiver · 02/05/2023 14:42

“I'm talking about people who are 'intolerably suffering' who have been inpatients on a 1:1 or more for years “

Yes and I asked you, what time limit would you put on things then? 2yrs? 5yrs? and if not recovered, euthanise away? You say they’d be perfect candidates, but haven’t said how you’d implement this. Implementing would involve a time limit of some sort. A get better or die deadline, unless doctors can make assessments and decide it’s hopeless after a few months for some patients but go longer for others (like that would be unbiased!)

Do you think doctors should have this power over patients? Or are you still asserting that such patients can all fully, knowingly and truly consent to euthanasia? Patients that can’t even stop harming themselves if left unsupervised.

”no treatment has helped them and they're living a really shitty life..”
Ah, a life so shitty it is not worth living?

“every time we've tried to reduce from 1:1, they harm themselves so we go back to 1:1.”
Have you thought that perhaps being alone and in pain is worse than having 1:1 care and being in pain?

I don't have to come up with an answer. I'm not designing legislation..

YOU have to think about why your fear of being killed by the state, which is absolutely not what is being proposed here makes YOU think that other people with more severe mental health problems than yours, should not ever be able to choose to end their lives and suffer intolerably.

This literally is not about you.

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 15:29

JuvenileEmu · 02/05/2023 14:02

@SwitchDriver has been sharing some very personal things on this thread, and it has certainly given me a lot of insight into what being a mental health inpatient involves, and I expect many others reading. And tbf you can't really criticise others for talking about their personal experiences when a lot of what you have posted suggests that it is you own experiences that have led you to think euthanasia of psychiatric inpatients should be allowed.

To give two examples that have stood out for me: you spent some, limited, time working on a secure unit-and I notice in your last post that this was about two decades ago, so far from recent, and you found this unpleasant and that you felt involved in abuse of patients because you were preventing them from harming themselves. You also commented that suicide is traumatic for the person who finds the body. With respect, neither of those are reasons to take someone's life. They are both basing the decision on the feelings of someone other than the person potentially being euthanised.

And I don't think it is fair to say that people don't understand the difference between the idea of capacity in the MHA and more generally. I am sure that there are legal differences and that you are correct in that, but you seem to look at the issue in a very black and white way. Something may be legally possible and yet ethically wrong.

Nope. At no point have I ever said that 'euthanasia of psychiatric inpatients be allowed '.

I'm not suggesting psychiatric inpatients be eathanised', I'm suggesting there are certain circumstances where a person experiencing intolerabe suffering for years on end, should be given the right to end that suffering and not as currently happens, be forced to live shitty lives.

This would never apply to SwitchDriver given everything she's said on this thread
Since she doesn't want to die, and even if she wanted to when in hospital, there'd be a wealth of evidence to say she did not have a treatment-resistant mental illness since she gets treated and goes home repeatedly and during those times, is very clear that she does not want to die and says suicidality is just a symptom of her mental health crises.

And don't try to make assumptions about my experiences of working in the the mental health system. It was a decade ago, not 20 years that I stopped working inpatients ( you didn't read my posts ) but funnily enough, still work in the same NHS trust, still have friends and colleagues who do still work on wards who tell me how things are now since we're friends and talk about our lives/work.

I didn't work in inpatient for ' a short time'. , that's a major assumption on your part It was 4 years. Long enough to get a good idea of what was happening.

You suggest I found it 'unpleasant' as if I made a judgement and it was not nice or not what I expected. Not really. I was diagnosed with PTSD after the trauma I experienced on the wards.

Just a short list in 4 years would be someone setting fire to themselves, trying to cut someone down that had hanged themselves, slipping over a massive pool of blood as I entered someone's room after a night shift, trying to restrain someone as they were on a chair smashing their hands into the tube lights, showering everyone including me with blood.

Oh and being physically and sexually assaulted.

And 99% of the time when I was restraining someone and forcibly medicating them I did it because I really believed that it was in the person's best interests because they would get better.

But sometimes, I didn't believe that at all so questioned myself. Which is in regards to the small of group of inpatients that I've already referenced.

I didn't previously mention any of the traumatic things I endured because they are entirely irrelevant to the thread.

It's not about , .me or anyone else deciding if someone should die, but caring enough about the individual to think they should have that right.

But since you decided to claim things that aren't true about me, I've responded.

I will also add that in the 4 years I worked on wards/PICUS there were more days than not, where I wasn't exposed to trauma and many lovely days with patients who were getting better and we even had fun.

DisquietintheRanks · 02/05/2023 15:00

@SwitchDiver well what time limit would you put on things? How much suffering before a person can decide they have had enough?

SwitchDiver · 02/05/2023 14:42

“I'm talking about people who are 'intolerably suffering' who have been inpatients on a 1:1 or more for years “

Yes and I asked you, what time limit would you put on things then? 2yrs? 5yrs? and if not recovered, euthanise away? You say they’d be perfect candidates, but haven’t said how you’d implement this. Implementing would involve a time limit of some sort. A get better or die deadline, unless doctors can make assessments and decide it’s hopeless after a few months for some patients but go longer for others (like that would be unbiased!)

Do you think doctors should have this power over patients? Or are you still asserting that such patients can all fully, knowingly and truly consent to euthanasia? Patients that can’t even stop harming themselves if left unsupervised.

”no treatment has helped them and they're living a really shitty life..”
Ah, a life so shitty it is not worth living?

“every time we've tried to reduce from 1:1, they harm themselves so we go back to 1:1.”
Have you thought that perhaps being alone and in pain is worse than having 1:1 care and being in pain?

SwitchDiver · 02/05/2023 14:31

Thank you to all those listening.

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 14:27

SwitchDiver · 02/05/2023 13:23

No one has said that having a MH condition means a person cannot make any rational decisions. I have questioned you saying that you think euthanasia would be especially applicable to:

TrufflySnufgl6 · Today 08:54
How about when the individual is an inpatient and actively prevented from taking their life for years on end? They're the people I'm thinking about that this may be relevant for.

Inpatient and actively suicidal. As in likely to be detained under the Mental Health Act, in which they are in fact deemed to not even be able to consent to treatment and can be treated against their will.

Yet you are saying they could consent to euthanasia. A treatment with irreversible consequences, a treatment that is no treatment but rather disposing of the person in their entirety.

I can't keep repeating myself about the mental capacity act and mental health act but will reiterate again, that being sectioned doesn't mean that not consenting to MH treatment at that time doesn't mean the person is unable to consent to any other treatment.

I'm talking about someone that has been in hospital for years. On a 1:1 because even 5 minutes observations result in them trying to end their life.

For years.

Because they are so tormented by their CSA or other trauma or the auditory hallucinations they hear every day.

And every medication has been tried. And every therapy has been tried.

And it hasn't helped.

I'm not talking about people who are acutely psychotic and not in touch with reality.

Or someone who is suicidal as they're currently extremely unwell and distressed and not able to see a way out but there are ways out that they've used before so can do the same now.

I'm talking about people who are 'intolerably suffering' who have been inpatients on a 1:1 or more for years for whom no treatment has helped them and they're living a really shitty life on a specialist unit and their care team would be able to provide evidence to support that.

It's not about Dr's or staff wanting to kill people or whatever else, it's about them providing objective evidence that yes, this person has been in hospital for X years, X treatments didn't help and every time we've tried to reduce from 1:1, they harm themselves so we go back to 1:1.

And it's where mental illness and having suffered unimaginable trauma for example often come into this discussion as they can be conflated and one can result from the other and contribute to any MH illness.

The assumption of many, is that severe trauma can be 'treated'. The right meds or the right therapy or even the right therapist can help.

For some people, it doesn't. For some people they relive their horrendous trauma every day with no relief. And they've tried all that can be offered by mental health services. Which hasn't helped and they're tormented.

Having been diagnosed with a mental health problem doesn't mean those people can't make a decision about how tortuous their lives are and want to end it. Currently, for those inpatients, they're prevented from doing so and living miserable, tortuous lives.

They're the people I'm talking about and think the MAID system could benefit.

JuvenileEmu · 02/05/2023 14:17

Something that stands out on this thread is that the people most against this idea are the people who have lived experience of mental illness and being a patient in a MH unit.

And the posters most in favour are people who:
a. Have worked in MH units, and
b. Have been very dismissive of the posters who have experienced mental illness.

Which leads me to believe it is the first group who should be listened to. I'm not sure what to say about the second group. At least two (unless it's one and they name-changed) seem to have little regard for the feelings and opinions of the people they are supposed to be caring for. Which is really quite disturbing.

Creepyrosemary · 02/05/2023 14:05

Funny how most of us feel that we shouldn't dictate if women keep a pregnancy or not but we feel that we do get to decide that strangers aren't allowed a peaceful death, they should just jump from a building or something.

I do think that people need to be offered help, but who am I to decide about life or death?

SwitchDiver · 02/05/2023 14:05

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 13:45

Literally every unit I worked in, could be 'escaped from'. They're not hermetically sealed, they're buildings with an enclosed garden with walls/fences that can be climbed or there's sec 17 leave where someone gets taken to the shops, or their Mums house or anywhere else or just for a walk around the grounds and they leg it.

People have 'escaped' from Broadmoor, Rampton and Ashworth the most high-security psychiatric hospitals in the country. People escape from prison FGS which have similar or higher levels of security.

I'm talking about working on units in the late 90s to a decade later. When I started we had patients that were there voluntarily. By the time I left there were zero patients that were there voluntarily. It just doesn't happen anymore in my MH trust area. If you'd be agreeing to be in hospital, you'd be agreeing that you're mentally ill and need treatment, and therefore you can be treated at home. You can't be sectioned if you know you're unwell and will accept treatment in the community.

You copying and pasting stuff about being sectioned is completely irrelevant. I've explained over and over again about the mental capacity and mental health act. You choosing not to read is not my problem.

This thread is NOT ABOUT YOU. You get unwell, you go into hospital and you go home. No-one is suggesting you be euthanized or that if you were suicidal during an admission, the staff would be lining up to support you wanting to die.

That's not what is being discussed here. No-ones trying to kill you. You don’t want to die and no-one is suggesting that you be killed.

Do you seriously think the patients you described would be allowed on leave to go to the shops? You know they would not.

“You copying and pasting stuff about being sectioned is completely irrelevant. I've explained over and over again about the mental capacity and mental health act. You choosing not to read is not my problem.”

We have both pasted from the NHS webpages. The NHS webpage says that I can be treated against my will because I am not deemed to have the mental capacity to consent to treatment.
Consent to treatment. If you're held under the Mental Health Act, you can be treated against your will. This is because it's felt you do not have sufficient capacity to make an informed decision about your treatment at the time. This is also the case if you refuse treatment but the team treating you believe you should have it. https://www.nhs.uk/mental-health/social-care-and-your-rights/mental-health-and-the-law/mental-health-act/

You also posted an NHS webpage regarding “making decisions for others” and it witters on about when making decisions for patients to take in to consideration their preferences in terms of what to wear and always deciding what you think is “in their best interests.” The first paragraph doesn’t even say what you think it does:
”The Mental Capacity Act (MCA) is designed to protect and empower people who may lack the mental capacity to make their own decisions about their care and treatment. It applies to people aged 16 and over. It covers decisions about day-to-day things like what to wear or what to buy for the weekly shop, or serious life-changing decisions like whether to move into a care home or have major surgery.” https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/social-care-and-support-guide/making-decisions-for-someone-else/mental-capacity-act/

It doesn’t say that I had the right to refuse treatment. It doesn’t say I can simply leave and go home like you are saying it does. Nor did I actually have these rights you are claiming I had when I was sectioned.

“This thread is NOT ABOUT YOU. You get unwell, you go into hospital and you go home. No-one is suggesting you be euthanized or that if you were suicidal during an admission, the staff would be lining up to support you wanting to die. That's not what is being discussed here. No-ones trying to kill you. You don’t want to die and no-one is suggesting that you be killed.”

How rude. I know this thread isn’t about me. But unlike you, safe in your position as potential euthaniser, I’m in the position of potential euthanisee.

I have been that inpatient person in a pit of despair and suffering, under an uncontrollable compulsion to kill myself caused by my illness. So yes, I think I can empathise better with the people you have said on this thread that you think are perfect candidates for euthanising.

nhs.uk

Mental Health Act

In most cases when people are treated in hospital or another mental health facility, they have agreed or volunteered to be there. But there are cases when a person can be detained, also known as sectioned, under the Mental Health Act (1983) and treated...

https://www.nhs.uk/mental-health/social-care-and-your-rights/mental-health-and-the-law/mental-health-act/

user4567890754 · 02/05/2023 14:02

Personally, I believe that all human lives are valuable and worthwhile, that every person has a right to life, and that no one else should be legally permitted to interfere with that.

I understand completely the compassionate motivations of those who argue for assisted suicide in the cases of terminally ill patients who genuinely request and consent. However, I think that improved palliative care and education would reduce this perceived need. I have also noted that suicide is legal and not always irrational. This is informed by personal experience of caring for a family member with a terminal illness. When you encourage, enable or assist a person to end their life, you take that power, that right to life, out of their hands, and in my view you are morally culpable, whether or not you actually administer the drug.

When you give up that legal protection, that moral principle, you open the door to cases where proper consent is impossible to obtain - dementia patients, depressed people, children. This is the pathway being demonstrated right now in Canada.

You give doctors the power and responsibility of judging which patients have lives that are not worth living. You leave doctors open to the charge of carrying out euthanasia when their intention is to relieve pain. You undermine trust in the medical profession who have sworn to “first do no harm” and make people afraid to seek medical treatment.

You encourage society to view certain lives as disposable. There is so much ableism already, and an overly negative portrayal of life with physical disability and MH conditions, and the possibility of recovery, or of living a meaningful, joyful and purposeful life, despite, or even because of enduring conditions. Again, I think the moral response is improved care, support and education.

JuvenileEmu · 02/05/2023 14:02

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 13:45

Literally every unit I worked in, could be 'escaped from'. They're not hermetically sealed, they're buildings with an enclosed garden with walls/fences that can be climbed or there's sec 17 leave where someone gets taken to the shops, or their Mums house or anywhere else or just for a walk around the grounds and they leg it.

People have 'escaped' from Broadmoor, Rampton and Ashworth the most high-security psychiatric hospitals in the country. People escape from prison FGS which have similar or higher levels of security.

I'm talking about working on units in the late 90s to a decade later. When I started we had patients that were there voluntarily. By the time I left there were zero patients that were there voluntarily. It just doesn't happen anymore in my MH trust area. If you'd be agreeing to be in hospital, you'd be agreeing that you're mentally ill and need treatment, and therefore you can be treated at home. You can't be sectioned if you know you're unwell and will accept treatment in the community.

You copying and pasting stuff about being sectioned is completely irrelevant. I've explained over and over again about the mental capacity and mental health act. You choosing not to read is not my problem.

This thread is NOT ABOUT YOU. You get unwell, you go into hospital and you go home. No-one is suggesting you be euthanized or that if you were suicidal during an admission, the staff would be lining up to support you wanting to die.

That's not what is being discussed here. No-ones trying to kill you. You don’t want to die and no-one is suggesting that you be killed.

@SwitchDriver has been sharing some very personal things on this thread, and it has certainly given me a lot of insight into what being a mental health inpatient involves, and I expect many others reading. And tbf you can't really criticise others for talking about their personal experiences when a lot of what you have posted suggests that it is you own experiences that have led you to think euthanasia of psychiatric inpatients should be allowed.

To give two examples that have stood out for me: you spent some, limited, time working on a secure unit-and I notice in your last post that this was about two decades ago, so far from recent, and you found this unpleasant and that you felt involved in abuse of patients because you were preventing them from harming themselves. You also commented that suicide is traumatic for the person who finds the body. With respect, neither of those are reasons to take someone's life. They are both basing the decision on the feelings of someone other than the person potentially being euthanised.

And I don't think it is fair to say that people don't understand the difference between the idea of capacity in the MHA and more generally. I am sure that there are legal differences and that you are correct in that, but you seem to look at the issue in a very black and white way. Something may be legally possible and yet ethically wrong.

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 13:45

SwitchDiver · 02/05/2023 13:12

Well the secure units I was in, you couldn’t just go AWOL. We were locked in the ward, and outside the ward (general areas, classrooms, shower rooms, toilets and our sleeping rooms there was a hallway with more locks on the other end to go into an entry/foyer area for visitors that itself had locking exterior doors. We had a small 3mx3m courtyard for “going outside” but it was enclosed with 5m high brick walls topped with an inward curving wire barrier like you see on bridges over the motorway. Inside there were lines taped on the floor that you had to be behind when they wheeled the food trolleys in. So no chance of a dash to the hallway, which was locked down at the other end anyway.

Are you sure you are talking about those who are detained like I was rather than those who have come in voluntarily? Again, this is what the NHS webpage says and it matches my experience. The asking “consent” was more asking if I was going to be quiet or make a fuss, it wasn’t actually giving me a choice, either way the treatment/medication/ assessment was happening. There has to be a limit to the power of doctors over patients and I think power of euthanasia is too much.

”Consent to treatment
If you're held under the Mental Health Act, you can be treated against your will.
This is because it's felt you do not have sufficient capacity to make an informed decision about your treatment at the time.
This is also the case if you refuse treatment but the team treating you believe you should have it.”
https://www.nhs.uk/mental-health/social-care-and-your-rights/mental-health-and-the-law/mental-health-act/

Literally every unit I worked in, could be 'escaped from'. They're not hermetically sealed, they're buildings with an enclosed garden with walls/fences that can be climbed or there's sec 17 leave where someone gets taken to the shops, or their Mums house or anywhere else or just for a walk around the grounds and they leg it.

People have 'escaped' from Broadmoor, Rampton and Ashworth the most high-security psychiatric hospitals in the country. People escape from prison FGS which have similar or higher levels of security.

I'm talking about working on units in the late 90s to a decade later. When I started we had patients that were there voluntarily. By the time I left there were zero patients that were there voluntarily. It just doesn't happen anymore in my MH trust area. If you'd be agreeing to be in hospital, you'd be agreeing that you're mentally ill and need treatment, and therefore you can be treated at home. You can't be sectioned if you know you're unwell and will accept treatment in the community.

You copying and pasting stuff about being sectioned is completely irrelevant. I've explained over and over again about the mental capacity and mental health act. You choosing not to read is not my problem.

This thread is NOT ABOUT YOU. You get unwell, you go into hospital and you go home. No-one is suggesting you be euthanized or that if you were suicidal during an admission, the staff would be lining up to support you wanting to die.

That's not what is being discussed here. No-ones trying to kill you. You don’t want to die and no-one is suggesting that you be killed.

SwitchDiver · 02/05/2023 13:37

The constant assertion of people on this thread that they can't possibly make that decision because they have a mental illness is disablist.

No, we have expressed doubt that anyone whose mental illness is currently so bad that they are detained in a secure mental health unit under the MHA would have the true capacity to consent to euthanasia- the exact people you have said you think euthanasia would be the perfect solution for.

For many of us that doubt in your assertions is based on our lived experience of being in that state due to our mental illnesses. It’s not ableist for a wheelchair user to tell a HCP like you that no they can’t walk 100m, so why are you accusing us of ableism when we are telling you that when we are so unwell that we are sectioned, we cannot truly consent to be euthanised. That we know after coming out the other end of that particular kind of living hell that our brains were not working sufficiently well enough to be able to knowingly and fully consent to euthanasia. We know our illnesses better than you ever could. You may observe us and pity us when we are inpatient, but you don’t know what it is like to be us.

SwitchDiver · 02/05/2023 13:23

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 11:44

Having a mental health condition does not mean the person is incapable of making any rational or reasoned decisions.

There are a lot of posters here who seem to think it does. Which is worrying. But that view is also not supported by the mental capacity act. Which is law.

https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/social-care-and-support-guide/making-decisions-for-someone-else/mental-capacity-act/

No one has said that having a MH condition means a person cannot make any rational decisions. I have questioned you saying that you think euthanasia would be especially applicable to:

TrufflySnufgl6 · Today 08:54
How about when the individual is an inpatient and actively prevented from taking their life for years on end? They're the people I'm thinking about that this may be relevant for.

Inpatient and actively suicidal. As in likely to be detained under the Mental Health Act, in which they are in fact deemed to not even be able to consent to treatment and can be treated against their will.

Yet you are saying they could consent to euthanasia. A treatment with irreversible consequences, a treatment that is no treatment but rather disposing of the person in their entirety.

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 13:19

JuvenileEmu · 02/05/2023 12:57

Do you mean that someone who is on a section could be deemed to have capacity to make a decision to agree to euthanasia? IANAL but I find it hard to believe a court would go along with that, even if it is theoretically allowed. And tbh I would be very concerned that there could be coercion or influence involved.

In certain circumstances yes. If appropriately assessed and weighed up with evidence.

Someone on a section already has the right to make decisions under the mental capacity act and mental health act to refuse medical (physical) treatment if you look at my previous posts.

So if someone on a section has the right and capacity to refuse treatment for cancer for example, why should they not have the capacity and right to choose to die by a less drawn-out and physically painful process?

There are an astonishing amount of people on this thread who don't understand the concept of mental capacity in law, either entirely or as it applies to people on a section of the MHA.

I've provided lots of information, examples and info on the mental capacity act. I don't know how else to explain it to someone with the unreasonable idea that someone with a mental illness is immediately judged to not have the capacity to make decisions about their own lives, including the decision to not want to be forced to live in intolerable suffering by society or the psychiatric system as it currently works.

There are some people living in unending torment due to their mental illness who are currently forced to live because there is no option for them to commit suicide or be medically assisted to die.

The constant assertion of people on this thread that they can't possibly make that decision because they have a mental illness is disablist.

SwitchDiver · 02/05/2023 13:12

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 10:11

Capacity isn't a global issue and doesn't apply to every circumstance. Different medications, therapies, ECT, psychosurgery etc all have different rules.

It is not assumed that being under section means you don't have the capacity to make any decisions or that you have no rights. The mental health act and mental capacity act are complex legislation.

Sec 2 for example is a section for assessment so you can't administer medication without consent unless in an 'emergency'. A Sec 3 is for treatment but even then, if the patient is still not consenting to medication after 3 months, the psychiatrist has to state their intention to continue to enforce medication without consent and a second opinion is required from another psychiatrist who reviews the notes and meets with the patient and agrees or not.

You can't be forced to have medical (physical) health treatment under any section for example unless under specific legislation of the MHA where it is proven that the refusal for the medical treatment is directly related to the mental disorder that you are being treated for. NG feeding for anorexia nervosa patients starving themselves to death is the most common example where medical treatment is enforced without consent under that legislation.

So in the case of the person I mentioned earlier, they were being treated for a personality disorder. They were able to refuse treatment for cancer because their capacity to make that decision was assessed, they demonstrated full understanding of the proposed treatment and the potential consequences of not having it and their refusal to accept cancer treatment was not consdered to be related to the mental disorder they were being treated for.

A person can be required to remain on the unit under section but the fact is that if they did leave and returned home and refused to return to the hospital, they could be discharged. Because using the Police to force entry into someone's home to return them to hospital requires a warrant issued by a magistrates court where it has to be proven that not doing so would result in serious harm as the person would be unable to look after themselves. I can't count the number of times when I was working in inpatient, that someone under section went AWOL and we discharged them after 48 hrs and used their bed.

I am not proposing 'euthanising' anyone nor suggesting anyone be 'chosen to die'.

I'm talking about the individuals who would be able to say "I relive my CSA in flashbacks every single day, I've been in hospital for X years, I've tried X number of treatments, nothing has helped. I feel tortured and I want to die".

Because currently we say 'tough shit' to those people and force them to live miserable lives on specialist units, watch them bath and use the toilet, give them a TV in a perspex box to watch and give them plastic plates and plastic cutlery to eat with. Remove anything that they could use to harm themselves and then when they're banging their head on the wall trying to stop the horrible images in their head (we can't remove walls!) we have a bunch of staff pin them down on the floor which really reminds them of their CSA btw and wait till they've tired themselves out or pull their pants down a bit which again reminds them of CSA, to give an injection into their buttock and hopefully make them too sedated to try to harm themselves.

Then do it again the next day or a few days later. For years. That's why I felt abusive.

Well the secure units I was in, you couldn’t just go AWOL. We were locked in the ward, and outside the ward (general areas, classrooms, shower rooms, toilets and our sleeping rooms there was a hallway with more locks on the other end to go into an entry/foyer area for visitors that itself had locking exterior doors. We had a small 3mx3m courtyard for “going outside” but it was enclosed with 5m high brick walls topped with an inward curving wire barrier like you see on bridges over the motorway. Inside there were lines taped on the floor that you had to be behind when they wheeled the food trolleys in. So no chance of a dash to the hallway, which was locked down at the other end anyway.

Are you sure you are talking about those who are detained like I was rather than those who have come in voluntarily? Again, this is what the NHS webpage says and it matches my experience. The asking “consent” was more asking if I was going to be quiet or make a fuss, it wasn’t actually giving me a choice, either way the treatment/medication/ assessment was happening. There has to be a limit to the power of doctors over patients and I think power of euthanasia is too much.

”Consent to treatment
If you're held under the Mental Health Act, you can be treated against your will.
This is because it's felt you do not have sufficient capacity to make an informed decision about your treatment at the time.
This is also the case if you refuse treatment but the team treating you believe you should have it.”
https://www.nhs.uk/mental-health/social-care-and-your-rights/mental-health-and-the-law/mental-health-act/

nhs.uk

Mental Health Act

In most cases when people are treated in hospital or another mental health facility, they have agreed or volunteered to be there. But there are cases when a person can be detained, also known as sectioned, under the Mental Health Act (1983) and treated...

https://www.nhs.uk/mental-health/social-care-and-your-rights/mental-health-and-the-law/mental-health-act/