Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Canada’s euthanasia for the mentally ill

342 replies

Noicant · 01/05/2023 08:34

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

Canada is in the process of introducing the option of Euthanasia for the mentally ill. It looks like this has been delayed for the time being but AIBU to find this concerning?

Just to be clear I fully support euthanasia as an option for people with terminal or chronic conditions. I think it’s human to offer people a peaceful death when there is no chance of things improving.

BUT this seems utterly mad to me. I’ve suffered from poor mental health in the past and only started feeling better after going through a few therapists and finding the right one. There were many times over 20years where I would have happily signed up for death. If someone is so ill that they are very impaired by their condition are they truly competent to make a decision like this and if it’s milder isn’t there a possibility of recovery?

It seems utterly dystopian. I guess I’m looking for someone to help me understand if I’ve missed something or not understood something that will help me understand why anyone would think this is a good idea.

Expansion of assisted dying for mental illness to be delayed until 2024 in new bill - National | Globalnews.ca

Justice Minister David Lametti has said the delay is needed after the federal government heard concerns that Canada's health-care system might not be prepared for the expansion.

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
SleepyRich · 04/05/2023 14:16

CleverLilViper · 03/05/2023 19:22

That makes zero sense.

If someone wants to utilise this for mental health reasons, they are, indeed, suicidal.

Because this isn't a simple area to legislate or process. But it simply can't be allowed in law to have one type of healthcare available for people without mental illness whilst excluding others from it because they have a mental illness.

Assisted dying is an emotive issue and you will never get agreement from all sides. It's not a million miles away from legislation of abortion, there will never be agreement across the population but people have a right to choose what happens to their bodies/lives and ultimately we have to be equal and fair in that provision.

LangClegsInSpace · 03/05/2023 22:02

Please do keep fighting on @Mooshamoo . The best revenge is a life well lived Flowers

Inthedarkagain · 03/05/2023 21:28

I don' t want anyone to read into this too much, as hopefully our leaders will get their shit together and sort out the financial mess the world is in, but i have made the decision to die around the age of 70 if things don't change. I'm not able to buy a house and it is getting too late due to age. I don't want to live in poverty in old age and be a burden to my kids, and I expect my older OH would be on his way or passed on by then. For me making this decision has been a relief. i dont have to worry about money or being homeless or destitute when I retire anymore, and I can enjoy the years I have left and make the most of them.

If I can do it in a way that is controlled and more likely to be painless then great.

In terms of MH, you would have really had to try every option first. It's difficult, as it is open to abuse, but at the same time some people have had rotten lives and will find a way to do it in a painful way or a way that means they are just left severely disabled (I work in an area where I see a lot of this). It really should be the last resort if someone is severely suffering, but has full capacity to decide.

Mooshamoo · 03/05/2023 21:02

LangClegsInSpace · 03/05/2023 19:20

Sorry you are feeling so low Mooshamoo.

The Canadian government website says you must be eligible for government funded health services and so generally, visitors to Canada are not eligible for medical assistance in dying.

https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/medical-assistance-dying.html#a2

Jesus you can't even die when you want to! :) Light-hearted jokes can be made in awful situations

I have looked at euthanasia in Europe. I looked into it quite seriously earlier this year. They sent me brochures and said that it looked likely that I would qualify.

I've had to really think about it. I know I don't want to live. I know I don't want to be in this endless suffering.

On the other hand what stops me is I think - i don't want to let those bastards (the people that abused me) kill me. I don't want to let them kill me.

I might try to keep fighting on. It's important to talk about euthanasia I think

ohyouknowwhatshername · 03/05/2023 20:43

Mooshamoo · 03/05/2023 10:17

I also think that euthanasia should be available for people who have gone through horrendous traumas.

My father abandoned me as a child. I had an abusive mother. I had no grandparents. I had no love. I grew up in poverty, lack of love. I'm 39. I don't want to be in this life.

I often wake up and think, only fifty more years to go.
Many people who went through extreme trauma are just existing not living.

I don't want to be in this life that I'm in. I want to do euthanasia. I'm going to look into this in Canada.

This makes me feel heartbroken @Mooshamoo I wish there was someone or something that could help you to feel better and to want to stay alive. I hope that you will find the right treatment one day. You are only 39. Please don't give up 💐

CleverLilViper · 03/05/2023 19:22

SleepyRich · 01/05/2023 08:51

Isn't it the expansion of an existing bill to include mental illness as opposed to targeting people with mental illness? I suspect this would be severely life limiting mental illness that the person no longer wanted to live with. It's specifically not for use in cases of depression/suicidal ideation. So a suicidal person would never be offered this under the law,

That makes zero sense.

If someone wants to utilise this for mental health reasons, they are, indeed, suicidal.

LangClegsInSpace · 03/05/2023 19:20

Sorry you are feeling so low Mooshamoo.

The Canadian government website says you must be eligible for government funded health services and so generally, visitors to Canada are not eligible for medical assistance in dying.

https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/medical-assistance-dying.html#a2

NooNooHead1981 · 03/05/2023 16:30

Mooshamoo · 03/05/2023 16:23

Is anyone thinking of going for euthanasia? I think it's important to talk about this.

I've very occasionally thought about it but as I have a family and 3 children, I couldn't ever put them through the loss of their mum.

Mooshamoo · 03/05/2023 16:23

Is anyone thinking of going for euthanasia? I think it's important to talk about this.

Mooshamoo · 03/05/2023 10:17

I also think that euthanasia should be available for people who have gone through horrendous traumas.

My father abandoned me as a child. I had an abusive mother. I had no grandparents. I had no love. I grew up in poverty, lack of love. I'm 39. I don't want to be in this life.

I often wake up and think, only fifty more years to go.
Many people who went through extreme trauma are just existing not living.

I don't want to be in this life that I'm in. I want to do euthanasia. I'm going to look into this in Canada.

ClareBlue · 03/05/2023 09:52

In these debates the extreme cases are difficult to argue against. So extreme intorable suffering unresponsive to any treatment where a reasoned decision can bé made, we understand. But then we move into the margins as we normalise it. What actually is extreme or intorable, the scrutiny of family and society influence becomes more and change what is viewed as intorable, people join supervising committees with their own agendas, vocal sections hold undue influence on decision making. Other people start dominating the decisions. People will say that won't happen, but it always does with legislation for social change. There are some very clear examples going on now, which there is no need to mention on this thread.

SwitchDiver · 03/05/2023 08:22

It’s been discussed? All through the thread many of us have discussed the fact that if a person in full possession of their mental faculties wishes to die there are many many ways freely available for them to do so. Including ways that are objectively also a form of lethal injection as used in euthanasia.

It’s also been discussed that the assertion there are people with a long term will to die, how does anyone know that is their actual will and not part of mental illness? Because that is the most frequent cause of such self-destructive desires, expressions and actions.

And it’s been discussed numerous times that there is no certainty in telling the ones who want to die apart from the ones who seem to want to die. So any legalisation would result in unwanted death for some people.

It’s been discussed too that no one can predict who has no hope of recovery. In regards to MAiD, the Canadian Mental Health Association has warned it is "not possible" to determine whether any particular case of mental illness is incurable and strongly opposes the coming expansion. Some leading psychiatrists, like University of Toronto's Karandeep Sonu Gaind, have said the odds of predicting curability are worse than a coin flip. So even if a patient has lost hope, should their doctors cave into that and sign off on their death?

I think the comparison to dementia is fair, but we need to recognise it is an end of life disease that affects mental capacity. It isn’t a mental illness per se in that it has a physical cause of brain damage which cannot be repaired, it is progressive and ends in death- there can be no recovery. To lump in the chronically mentally ill with those who have end of life dementia doesn’t make sense to me. I think they should be considered separately.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 03/05/2023 07:44

This is a very difficult, very complex area and I am glad I don't have to make the decisions. I do, absolutely, want to take that route out if dementia comes and fortunately for me, I'd be able to.

But I do note that some of the people here are making blanket statements without nuance, and that they do not address the fact that some people have an enduring, long term and stable wish to not be alive, and that others try suicide and leave themselves in a permanently terrible condition.

By not answering that you are ignoring and condoning sometimes extreme suffering., and overriding an individual's stated and long - term will.

They are also speaking form their own experience and not acknowledging that their experience is not universal. Other people may have other experiences and condemning people who have stated that they want to take a dignified route out on the basis of their own experience is disrespectful.

But as said this is a very complex, difficult and nuanced area and in the UK I would be afraid of it being misused. The MH system is far too damaged to provide effective support.

SwitchDiver · 03/05/2023 07:42

@LangClegsInSpace
“If there's the remotest doubt then the default must be that you do not take active and deliberate steps to end someone's life.”

I was thinking this morning regarding doubt and how it applies to other forms of death.

The existence of doubt was the primary reason we abolished the death penalty. Because even though the vast majority of people sent to the hangman were guilty of their crimes, there had been a tiny minority of innocent men and women executed. And we thought, if we cannot separate guilty and innocent with 100% certainty, then the death penalty is barbaric and should be abolished in a civilised society. So we did.

Doubt also applies in the question of true consent and mental capacity for the mentally ill, especially since a desire to die with or without suicidal behaviour is a key symptom of many mental disorders. To me, it is objectively much more difficult for doctors or family to know if a person is “all there” and truly wanting and consenting to euthanasia than it is to solve a murder. And we are encouraged to divulge our darkest and most destructive thoughts to these same doctors- thoughts that often are intrusive thoughts which are not of our own making but are imposed on us and distress us. It’s just a slight subjective shift in perspective for a doctor to decide certain thoughts are not intrusive, but true desires.

Since we give murderers and child rapists, the benefit of the doubt, then why can we not do so for the mentally ill?

I think some would answer it’s because we suffer? So with criminals it’s taking away a life they want, but for the mentally ill it’s saving us from suffering. Everyone with a disability suffers to a certain extent. The presence or amount of suffering isn’t a justification to decide someone else should die imho and it would be doctors and family deciding this when it comes to a person so mentally unwell they are suicidal.

And in an environment where a person who is perhaps on benefits due to disabling mental health conditions, or their mental disorder is violent/creates mess and distress it is all too tempting for government policy to be influenced by considerations of cost savings or for doctors/staff to be influenced by sympathy fatigue/numbness when setting the requirements for and signing off on what is a medical version of a death warrant.

LangClegsInSpace · 03/05/2023 00:11

To repeat:

The potential safeguarding failure here is that you deliberately cause someone's death who did not want to die, who was coerced or persuaded against their best interests that they wanted to die, or who was not capable of consenting to being killed.

The stakes could not be higher.

How many of those kinds of deaths are acceptable so that you or your loved one can choose the time and manner of your death?

If there's the remotest doubt then the default must be that you do not take active and deliberate steps to end someone's life.

LangClegsInSpace · 02/05/2023 23:58

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/05/2023 22:53

@pointythings I live in the NL now too and get how the system works.

It comes down to respecting the individual's will when made in their right mind.

The elderly woman who was held down had previously said she did not want to live beyond a certain point, and iirc defined that point. When it came the family and the doctor took action.

A woman I knew who lost her child to suicide had the courage to say at her funeral "I don't understand the choice you made, but I respect it". That really shook me, but also got me thinking; for a mother to say that about her only daughter while her heart is breaking, really -is- respect.

The huge difference between the NL and the UK is that there is a good health system here where care -is- available and people with MH illnesses are treated much better. I get the impression now that that just isn't the case in the UK. The vast majority of people who need help get limited, broken and inadequate help so things get worse.

One problem that no one has mentioned (admittedly I skipped a few pages) is that in the absence of medical euthanasia some people try to commit suicide, fail and are left with unbearable physical damage. To be trapped by unhelpable mental distress and by severe physical damage with no way out is cruel.

It comes down to respecting the individual's will when made in their right mind.

The elderly woman who was held down had previously said she did not want to live beyond a certain point, and iirc defined that point. When it came the family and the doctor took action.

I can't believe you are condoning the way this woman died.

It is normal for terminally ill people to choose assisted dying and then change their minds. What you are saying is that people with mental capacity should be alowed to change their mind but people with dementia should not. She was shouting and kicking and screaming against death but they carried on and ended her life because of what she had written on a bit of paper, years earlier.

'Respecting the individual's will' my big fat arse.

I do not want to live in a country where that death would be considered lawful.

LangClegsInSpace · 02/05/2023 23:43

LangClegsInSpace · 02/05/2023 22:37

If you are advocating for assisted dying for sectioned patients because of unrelievable distress caused by their mental health condition then you cannot say that such assistance is a treatment unrelated to their mental health condition.

This is nothing like sectioned patients being assessed as having mental capacity to refuse cancer treatment!

Also you absolutely can be treated without consent on a section 2 and it doesn't need to be an emergency. The guidance just says they're supposed to ask you nicely first and if you refuse then they can make you.

Also what psychosurgery? I'm not aware of any advances in this field since lobotomies. Have I missed something?

LangClegsInSpace · 02/05/2023 23:39

The mental health act allows the state to deprive you of your human right to liberty (Article 5) and deprive you of your right to refuse medical treatment (Article 8) as long as specific conditions are met.

For a section to be lawful one of the conditions is that you are a danger to yourself or others. So the state can remove your liberty if an AMHP and two doctors all agree that in the interests of your own health or safety there is no other option than to detain you in hospital. If you are very unwell then your 28 day section 2 will turn into a 6 month S.3 and maybe then another and if you're still not safe after that then it becomes a yearly tick box exercise.

However shoddily this process works in practice, at every stage, at every renewal, the state officially reasserts its right to deprive sectioned patients of their article 5 and 8 human rights on the legal basis of keeping them safe.

So how would the MHA work in conjunction with a law that said sectioned patients can be helped to die? Are we redefining 'safe' now, along with all the other words? What legal basis would the state have for depriving someone of their liberty in the first place? How on earth could it be lawful to detain someone for their own safety and then help them to die?

Whenever the state takes away people's liberty, whether in hospitals, prisons, detention centres, care homes or children's homes, they need to make very sure they have a legal basis for doing that and they need to make very sure they are protecting the rest of people's human rights because by detaining someone the state becomes wholely responsible for their welfare. People who have had their liberty removed are by definition extremely vulnerable because they cannot escape whatever conditions they find themselves in.

I have no doubt that there are a small number of people for whom assisted dying would be a blessed relief in the face of unrelievable, unrelenting mental distress. I wish there was a safe way of allowing this group of people the good death they seek without compromising other people's right to life (article 2) but there's just not. It's just not safe. Rights need to be balanced.

DisquietintheRanks · 02/05/2023 23:37

@madbongolee all the most severely ill people, or just some of them? What happens to the others?

Nat6999 · 02/05/2023 23:34

Isn't it better for someone who has suffered from mental illness for a long time & may have tried every treatment available to be allowed to die in a controlled way with their family & loved ones there to support them? Or to die alone from suicide & their family have the horror of finding them dead? Some people sadly suffer from mental illness all their lives & nothing can help them, therapy or medication can only do so much.

micpop · 02/05/2023 23:24

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 09:24

“It is also incredibly patronising to assume that someone who is mentally ill cannot consent to assisted dying. Everyone who makes this point should read up on the Mental Capacity Act and the Mental Health Act - you'll find it isn't nearly as simple as you think.”

OP wasn’t assuming though, her opinion is based on her experience of being mentally ill including 20yrs of feeling suicidal. I have similar experience and I agree with her. I don’t think reading Acts of Parliament is going to give the sort of insight that survivors of mental illness like us have? And if you’re not going to listen to us, but rely on legal text then what is the point?

You are aware that just because you and another poster have one type of similar experience, does not mean that other people have the same experiences yes?

micpop · 02/05/2023 23:20

Honestly, if someone mentally ill or not decides to apply and go through the process, who is anyone to actually stop them? We are all equal here on this earth, all born the same. We should be entitled to make our own decisions. And if someone is feeling like it's too painful to be alive, then it's too painful for them to be alive and they should be allowed to make that decision.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/05/2023 22:53

@pointythings I live in the NL now too and get how the system works.

It comes down to respecting the individual's will when made in their right mind.

The elderly woman who was held down had previously said she did not want to live beyond a certain point, and iirc defined that point. When it came the family and the doctor took action.

A woman I knew who lost her child to suicide had the courage to say at her funeral "I don't understand the choice you made, but I respect it". That really shook me, but also got me thinking; for a mother to say that about her only daughter while her heart is breaking, really -is- respect.

The huge difference between the NL and the UK is that there is a good health system here where care -is- available and people with MH illnesses are treated much better. I get the impression now that that just isn't the case in the UK. The vast majority of people who need help get limited, broken and inadequate help so things get worse.

One problem that no one has mentioned (admittedly I skipped a few pages) is that in the absence of medical euthanasia some people try to commit suicide, fail and are left with unbearable physical damage. To be trapped by unhelpable mental distress and by severe physical damage with no way out is cruel.

SwitchDiver · 02/05/2023 22:42

@TrufflySnufgl6
At no point have I ever said that 'euthanasia of psychiatric inpatients be allowed

You didn’t use that exact phrase, but you did say:
I 100% support this [euthanasia] as an experienced MH practitioner. I haven't worked on acute wards or PICUs for a decade but when I did, the majority of staff time was taken up trying to prevent people who wanted to die, from dying. People who had been receiving treatment for years or decades. Sometimes 1:1 care (or 2:1) for years which is degrading and humiliating for the the individual to have someone watch them bathe, urinate, defecate, and insert and remove tampons.

Agreed. Out of the 5 long-term (years) 1:1 chronically suicidal inpatients I'm thinking of, 4 of them had experienced unimaginable trauma, no treatment had helped and they didn't want to live with that trauma any more.

How about when the individual is an inpatient and actively prevented from taking their life for years on end? They're the people I'm thinking about that this [euthanasia] may be relevant for.

The above adds up to advocating a law change allowing the euthanasia of psychiatric inpatients. All you’d require is for them to say they want to die:
I'm talking about the individuals who would be able to say "I relive my CSA in flashbacks every single day, I've been in hospital for X years, I've tried X number of treatments, nothing has helped. I feel tortured and I want to die"

I posted that I have been a patient like that also saying that I wanted to die, because when I’m sectioned I’m at my lowest and most vulnerable. Yet you see fit to describe me when you don’t know me at all. What ‘wealth of evidence’ I don’t want to die? My records say otherwise. Thousands of pages of them. You’re going by this thread alone which is less than 24hrs of my life and saying things like you know me.

LangClegsInSpace · 02/05/2023 22:37

TrufflySnufgl6 · 02/05/2023 10:11

Capacity isn't a global issue and doesn't apply to every circumstance. Different medications, therapies, ECT, psychosurgery etc all have different rules.

It is not assumed that being under section means you don't have the capacity to make any decisions or that you have no rights. The mental health act and mental capacity act are complex legislation.

Sec 2 for example is a section for assessment so you can't administer medication without consent unless in an 'emergency'. A Sec 3 is for treatment but even then, if the patient is still not consenting to medication after 3 months, the psychiatrist has to state their intention to continue to enforce medication without consent and a second opinion is required from another psychiatrist who reviews the notes and meets with the patient and agrees or not.

You can't be forced to have medical (physical) health treatment under any section for example unless under specific legislation of the MHA where it is proven that the refusal for the medical treatment is directly related to the mental disorder that you are being treated for. NG feeding for anorexia nervosa patients starving themselves to death is the most common example where medical treatment is enforced without consent under that legislation.

So in the case of the person I mentioned earlier, they were being treated for a personality disorder. They were able to refuse treatment for cancer because their capacity to make that decision was assessed, they demonstrated full understanding of the proposed treatment and the potential consequences of not having it and their refusal to accept cancer treatment was not consdered to be related to the mental disorder they were being treated for.

A person can be required to remain on the unit under section but the fact is that if they did leave and returned home and refused to return to the hospital, they could be discharged. Because using the Police to force entry into someone's home to return them to hospital requires a warrant issued by a magistrates court where it has to be proven that not doing so would result in serious harm as the person would be unable to look after themselves. I can't count the number of times when I was working in inpatient, that someone under section went AWOL and we discharged them after 48 hrs and used their bed.

I am not proposing 'euthanising' anyone nor suggesting anyone be 'chosen to die'.

I'm talking about the individuals who would be able to say "I relive my CSA in flashbacks every single day, I've been in hospital for X years, I've tried X number of treatments, nothing has helped. I feel tortured and I want to die".

Because currently we say 'tough shit' to those people and force them to live miserable lives on specialist units, watch them bath and use the toilet, give them a TV in a perspex box to watch and give them plastic plates and plastic cutlery to eat with. Remove anything that they could use to harm themselves and then when they're banging their head on the wall trying to stop the horrible images in their head (we can't remove walls!) we have a bunch of staff pin them down on the floor which really reminds them of their CSA btw and wait till they've tired themselves out or pull their pants down a bit which again reminds them of CSA, to give an injection into their buttock and hopefully make them too sedated to try to harm themselves.

Then do it again the next day or a few days later. For years. That's why I felt abusive.

If you are advocating for assisted dying for sectioned patients because of unrelievable distress caused by their mental health condition then you cannot say that such assistance is a treatment unrelated to their mental health condition.

This is nothing like sectioned patients being assessed as having mental capacity to refuse cancer treatment!

Swipe left for the next trending thread