Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Canada’s euthanasia for the mentally ill

342 replies

Noicant · 01/05/2023 08:34

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

Canada is in the process of introducing the option of Euthanasia for the mentally ill. It looks like this has been delayed for the time being but AIBU to find this concerning?

Just to be clear I fully support euthanasia as an option for people with terminal or chronic conditions. I think it’s human to offer people a peaceful death when there is no chance of things improving.

BUT this seems utterly mad to me. I’ve suffered from poor mental health in the past and only started feeling better after going through a few therapists and finding the right one. There were many times over 20years where I would have happily signed up for death. If someone is so ill that they are very impaired by their condition are they truly competent to make a decision like this and if it’s milder isn’t there a possibility of recovery?

It seems utterly dystopian. I guess I’m looking for someone to help me understand if I’ve missed something or not understood something that will help me understand why anyone would think this is a good idea.

Expansion of assisted dying for mental illness to be delayed until 2024 in new bill - National | Globalnews.ca

Justice Minister David Lametti has said the delay is needed after the federal government heard concerns that Canada's health-care system might not be prepared for the expansion.

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
emanresu000 · 01/05/2023 09:48

I think there was a case of a girl in the Netherlands who had a severe eating disorder who was offered euthanasia (or to be allowed to die). I remember feeling very strongly at the time that this was the wrong decision. I felt it was wrong because I had experienced a serious eating disorder and reached 3 stones ten in weight.. At that weight, I was not capable of making a decision. Indeed, I thought that if I could choose to die, it would be the best thing because I could select the time and place, and it may be cleaner and more respectable than, perhaps dying of a heart attack after vomiting down the toilet. Intervention was taken to save my life and it worked, fortunately for me.

I realise this is my experience, but I think there is a world of difference between offering euthanasia rather than treatment and support for people with some mental illnesses, and offering someone with a terminal illness that will result in a painful and undignified death, the chance to avoid the final stages.

Maraudingmarauders · 01/05/2023 09:46

Its a very difficult and challenging issue, but at the base of my beliefs (note, I say MY) I agree with this provision being made - with strict controls.
I believe that if we have a legal right to life, we also have a legal right to death. Without that, a right to life means very little. To have a right to death should therefore mean a right to access death through calm, clean, controlled environments. Not by having to do the job in a way that can't guarantee success and risk disability or incapacity. Families should be able to spend their last moments together rather than in secrecy and horror.

That explai s why I support euthanasia in general. If someone is chronically mentally ill to a point where their life is almost permanent misery, then I cannot morally distinguish between it and physical deterioration. If someone is suffering highs and lows, then there would need to be criteria in place to prevent them accessing the services at a time when they are unstable. But if it is a chronic, non-stopping affliction which has shown no improvement through medication or therapy (and these have be supplied and tried), then I don't believe we should be able to prevent access to euthanasia. Chances are they will complete the job anyway, by their own hand.
It's terribly tragic and terribly hard, but I think a civilised society should have an obligation to provide a civilised method of suicide/euthanasia.

snowandshowers · 01/05/2023 09:46

In fact, many assisted suicides are facilitated by doctors who have not treated the patient and only met them briefly for the purpose of obtaining the lethal prescription. These days, assisted suicide can even be obtained in a Zoom call.

Vermont Legalizes Assisted Suicide by Zoom | National Review

Remember when we were told that assisted suicide would only be engaged in as part of an intimate and long-term physician/patient relationship?

https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/vermont-legalizes-assisted-suicide-by-zoom/

Gtsr443 · 01/05/2023 09:40

I suppose the fear is that instead of offering (often expensive) treatment and day to day support and paying out welfare to vulnerable people this will be the 'prefered' option which just so happens to save the state millions...

This is how the Nazis managed to sell Aktion4 - the mass killing of the mentally ill and the disabled. It as much about cost cutting and burden on the state as genetic purity.
Euthanasia for psychiatric patients and eugenics go hand in hand.
Churchill was a big fan and spoke about putting the wretched creatures out of their misery.
Supporters will try to sell this as progress and compassion.
I call bullshit.

BetweenWhatAndWhat · 01/05/2023 09:40

pbdr · 01/05/2023 09:09

I can see the argument for allowing euthanasia for patients with extreme and unremitting (for decades) mental illness that has proven intractable despite exhausting every avenue of treatment and is causing appalling suffering with no realistic prospect of ever improving. It would need very tight controls though to ensure that there truly are no other treatment options and that the person's capacity to make such a decision remains intact despite their illness.

I agree. I have a friend who has spent the past 15 years (so pretty much her whole adult life) in and out of mental health facilities, trying every treatment and getting nowhere. She has no quality of life. I would absolutely understand if she or others like her took this decision. Though of course they shouldn't ever feel pressured too. But I think feelings of suicidality can be separated from a logical decision to escape from a seemingly never ending health condition that ruins your life.

DisquietintheRanks · 01/05/2023 09:38

maddening · 01/05/2023 09:28

But if the person has not received sufficient or appropriate robust mental health treatment how can you say all avenues have been tried - until a government can prove that their mental health provision is provided to all mental health patients and that that provision is thorough and robust I don't think you could evidence that sufficiently to allow this.

Do you also think people with cancer should be forced to explore "every last avenue" for a cure, endure anything, because they might get better? If you are quadriplegic do you have to hang on in there because there's bound to be a solution one day?

There are many issues to deal with when it comes to the treatment of mental health but one of these is that not everything treatable and a good quality of life isn't possible for everyone.

BibbleandSqwauk · 01/05/2023 09:38

In the documentary Pru Leith did recently they interviewed a man in Canada, in his 80s who had lived with depression for decades. His wish to die was rational, calm and supported by his wife. Currently he cannot access it whilst a man with Parkinson's who had similarly had enough, could. I agree that there is an inevitable danger of economic factors pushing an agenda but I think we do need to move away from a "life at all costs" approach (figuratively speaking). If a person is able to rationally, calmly and over a period of time express a consistent wish then I'm not sure what the moral basis is for refusing that autonomy.

AlyssumandHelianthus · 01/05/2023 09:36

user4567890754 · 01/05/2023 08:58

It’s absolutely awful, but it follows logically from legalising any kind of euthanasia.

Agree. I think this is really good evidence for slippery slope arguments around euthanasia.
However much we might want to allow euthanasia in individual cases, I think it's wrong to legalise it for this reason.

Noicant · 01/05/2023 09:35

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 09:24

“It is also incredibly patronising to assume that someone who is mentally ill cannot consent to assisted dying. Everyone who makes this point should read up on the Mental Capacity Act and the Mental Health Act - you'll find it isn't nearly as simple as you think.”

OP wasn’t assuming though, her opinion is based on her experience of being mentally ill including 20yrs of feeling suicidal. I have similar experience and I agree with her. I don’t think reading Acts of Parliament is going to give the sort of insight that survivors of mental illness like us have? And if you’re not going to listen to us, but rely on legal text then what is the point?

Yes thank you, I’m also talking about my family, bi-polar disorder is common, schizophrenia, personality disorders. There have been sections, drugs, therapy (so much therapy). Many of those people have had down periods that lasted years but then on the up for a bit.

I understand there will be people who are much worse off and never have periods of stability. I’m not saying outright that offering it as an option is 100% the wrong thing to do but it worries me.

Les Landry has disabilities and managed to get signed off from a doctor to be put forward for MAID and clearly said afterwards it’s because he can’t afford to live. He’s very much alive and kicking but the fact that he managed to get it signed off and made it through the screening process is concerning.

OP posts:
Oaktree1233 · 01/05/2023 09:34

I think that mental illness can be extraordinarily painful and to see someone descend into the abyss and be unable to help is equally disturbing. Are you wanting people to be forced to live with extreme bi polar or schizophrenia. That’s like condemning them to 40 or 50 years of Hell.

My mother died of vascular dementia and if I get diagnosed with it I have absolutely desire to die as soon as it moves to low to medium. Timing will be critical to make sure that I have capacity or maybe a form of living will.

DisquietintheRanks · 01/05/2023 09:34

heldinadream · 01/05/2023 09:10

How?
How would it help the loved ones of those people in enough despair to avail themselves of it? How would it help those people who are in despair, giving them the most final and despairing 'way out'?
It seems to me it will only massively increase the mental health crisis.

In the right circumstances it could help the person with mental illness by ending their suffering. Which is kind of the point.

CatSpam3 · 01/05/2023 09:31

Good point @maddening ...is there any country that we can say yes, mental health care is top notch and has done all it can?

CatSpam3 · 01/05/2023 09:30

However, I also agree with @pointythings ...sometimes there is no hope, no recovery...I've actually seen people say on here that all mental illness is curable with the right treatment but no, no it isn't...and for those who every caring effort has been made to genuinely help them then I actually do think that to let them go would be the kinder thing....

maddening · 01/05/2023 09:28

pbdr · 01/05/2023 09:09

I can see the argument for allowing euthanasia for patients with extreme and unremitting (for decades) mental illness that has proven intractable despite exhausting every avenue of treatment and is causing appalling suffering with no realistic prospect of ever improving. It would need very tight controls though to ensure that there truly are no other treatment options and that the person's capacity to make such a decision remains intact despite their illness.

But if the person has not received sufficient or appropriate robust mental health treatment how can you say all avenues have been tried - until a government can prove that their mental health provision is provided to all mental health patients and that that provision is thorough and robust I don't think you could evidence that sufficiently to allow this.

produ · 01/05/2023 09:28

It was a disabled athlete asking for a wheelchair lift

That's outrageous

loislovesstewie · 01/05/2023 09:27

What concerns me, and I do agree that those with terminal illness should be given assistance to die, is that people who need long term care might be persuaded that an assisted death would be better. In other words, you are costing the state too much, off with you.

LakeTiticaca · 01/05/2023 09:26

OH and I had this discussion a while back when it was in the news.
We both asked the question why those with a terminal condition, ie: cancer etc, have the right to decline further treatment yet those who suffer years and years of debilitating depressive illnesses that just can't be cured, are expected to suffer.

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 09:26

heldinadream · 01/05/2023 09:20

What?
I mean - what? Have you got any links about that? That's horrific.

Yes. There was a man on benefits due to disability and when his rent was raised and no housing available and no increase to his benefits, he went to the local government to say he couldn’t survive homeless on the streets and was offered euthanasia.

CatSpam3 · 01/05/2023 09:26

I suppose the fear is that instead of offering (often expensive) treatment and day to day support and paying out welfare to vulnerable people this will be the 'prefered' option which just so happens to save the state millions...

This is a timely thread for me as after decades of severe mental ill health I said to my NHS HCP last week that if the state doesn't want to give me the treatment I need (haven't seen a psychiatrist in years and it's pot luck if they even listen to you when you do), provide the support I need to live a less isolated life (day centres closed), if I feel constantly judged for being on benefits (see it all the time on here), if I will live constantly with the threat of homelessness due to no social housing and being discriminated against in the private sector (was all set to sign a tenancy agreement once, had 2 months up front, deposit, perfect credit score etc then once it was discovered I was 'DSS' refused) all while going through regular periods of hearing voices, being so frozen i cant wash, feed myself properly, being so depressed i can barely speak, then for gods sake let me die.....

Of course, an empathetic society that actually cares for its most vulnerable above money would be preferable but the voting electorate has consistently decided against that in the last 12 years. So here we are.....might see if I can access it

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 09:24

“It is also incredibly patronising to assume that someone who is mentally ill cannot consent to assisted dying. Everyone who makes this point should read up on the Mental Capacity Act and the Mental Health Act - you'll find it isn't nearly as simple as you think.”

OP wasn’t assuming though, her opinion is based on her experience of being mentally ill including 20yrs of feeling suicidal. I have similar experience and I agree with her. I don’t think reading Acts of Parliament is going to give the sort of insight that survivors of mental illness like us have? And if you’re not going to listen to us, but rely on legal text then what is the point?

maddening · 01/05/2023 09:23

7Worfs · 01/05/2023 08:55

Canada has always been a trailblazer in eugenics.
Wasn’t there something recently about a disabled athlete asking for MH treatment and being offered euthanasia instead?

It was a disabled athlete asking for a wheelchair lift
https://nypost.com/2022/12/03/canada-offered-to-help-euthanize-christine-gauthier/

Christine Gauthier rips Canadian government for offering to euthanize her

Christine Gauthier is ripping her government, which offered to euthanize her after she complained about delays having a wheelchair lift installed in her home.

https://nypost.com/2022/12/03/canada-offered-to-help-euthanize-christine-gauthier

heldinadream · 01/05/2023 09:20

Sudeko · 01/05/2023 09:17

Tbh, I was more alarmed when the law was changed last year to allow "the poor" to be euthanized in Canada.

What?
I mean - what? Have you got any links about that? That's horrific.

pointythings · 01/05/2023 09:19

I'm with @DisquietintheRanks . It's cruel to dangle the carrot of hope in front of someone with severe and enduring mental illness. Nobody ever answers the question of how long you want to force people to suffer, take heavy medication which still doesn't work, be constantly watched, be forcibly admitted to inpatient units. For some people there is no recovery and we have to accept that. I'm from the Netherlands which already allows assisted dying for people who are mentally ill. There have been very few cases because the process is incredibly strictly managed, but the option is there. That's as it should be.

It is also incredibly patronising to assume that someone who is mentally ill cannot consent to assisted dying. Everyone who makes this point should read up on the Mental Capacity Act and the Mental Health Act - you'll find it isn't nearly as simple as you think.

willlow23 · 01/05/2023 09:19

Actually assisted dying has been a thing in canada for a while now - lots of ethical questions about people choosing it do they don't become a burden when they are terminally ill www.dyingwithdignity.ca/end-of-life-support/get-the-facts-on-maid/