Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Canada’s euthanasia for the mentally ill

342 replies

Noicant · 01/05/2023 08:34

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

Canada is in the process of introducing the option of Euthanasia for the mentally ill. It looks like this has been delayed for the time being but AIBU to find this concerning?

Just to be clear I fully support euthanasia as an option for people with terminal or chronic conditions. I think it’s human to offer people a peaceful death when there is no chance of things improving.

BUT this seems utterly mad to me. I’ve suffered from poor mental health in the past and only started feeling better after going through a few therapists and finding the right one. There were many times over 20years where I would have happily signed up for death. If someone is so ill that they are very impaired by their condition are they truly competent to make a decision like this and if it’s milder isn’t there a possibility of recovery?

It seems utterly dystopian. I guess I’m looking for someone to help me understand if I’ve missed something or not understood something that will help me understand why anyone would think this is a good idea.

Expansion of assisted dying for mental illness to be delayed until 2024 in new bill - National | Globalnews.ca

Justice Minister David Lametti has said the delay is needed after the federal government heard concerns that Canada's health-care system might not be prepared for the expansion.

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Noicant · 01/05/2023 10:18

Comedycook · 01/05/2023 10:17

If you believe euthanasia should be legalised then I can't see why you'd object to this. It's the natural progression.

Fwiw, I'm against euthanasia because as you can see it's a very slippery slope.

Because in certain situations the only way is down.

OP posts:
Noicant · 01/05/2023 10:17

StressedToTheMaxxx · 01/05/2023 10:13

There are some mental illnesses that are treatment resistant. Sadly, some folk with severe mental illness have no quality of life, none whatsoever.

As a mental health nurse, I've worked with some patients who have been under the services for years, in and out of hospital. Even at their best, they barely function. I'm talking mainly about the likes of chronic schizophrenia. Of course many people with this condition live very meaningful lives, with the correct treatment regime and support. But yes, there are those who don't have a quality of life (and not just in my opinion, in their own opinions).

It's something that would have to be assessed very very carefully and on a case by case basis. I can understand the controversy. But I can also understand why some people who live daily with such a torturous illness wouldn't want to go on.

It's certainly a very thought provoking argument.

I do recognise that, the schizophrenic I am related to had to be on heavy duty anti-psychotics permanently and had no ability to engage with the world and was incapable of self care. But they also wouldn’t have had competency to make a decision about euthanasia.

OP posts:
Comedycook · 01/05/2023 10:17

If you believe euthanasia should be legalised then I can't see why you'd object to this. It's the natural progression.

Fwiw, I'm against euthanasia because as you can see it's a very slippery slope.

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 10:17

@pointythings
Could you please stop using derogatory adjectives for others opinions on this? It’s really not on to say our views are “incredibly patronising”, “the sort of patronising attitude that makes me see red”, “You disrespect them utterly” “arrogant” “presumptuous” and so on.

We are respecting your opinion, but you are not respecting our opinions at all.

AndTheSurveySays · 01/05/2023 10:16

A good friend of mine died by euthanasia due to mental illness in the Netherlands. I hate that it was allowed, I feel like he was murdered.
His life wasn't all miserable, he wasn't in constant hell like people pretend you have to be in order to be killed by the state. He'd suffered terrible CSA and couldn't get over the fact that no one had ever been punished for it, they just walked free. Knowing his abusers were out there tormented him greatly and he never truly felt safe he said.
I feel like it as just easier for the authorities to allow his death than to pull their fingers out and of their jobs properly.

Flowerly · 01/05/2023 10:16

Everyone should have the right to end their lives painlessly and at the time of their choosing. If you disagree with this then don't choose to do it.

I am hoping that the UK sees sense on this very soon.

Noicant · 01/05/2023 10:15

pointythings · 01/05/2023 10:04

How would people feel if it was their child choosing to die because of mental illness. Should there be a minimum age?

I don't think there should be a minimum age, I think there should be medical scrutiny. Going back to the case of Noa Pothoven, who was 17 when she died (but did not receive euthanasia) in the Netherlands, this was a young woman whose life had been marked by massive trauma and mental illness. I would recommend that anyone who opposes assisted dying for mental illness read her testimonials online (most are in Dutch but translation software is there for you to use). Other cases and testimonials are also there for you to read.

I understand it is enormously emotive, but I have a child with mental illness. We've recently had a suicide scare because of an adverse reaction to new medication. It was terrifying. Right now my DC is well, enjoying life, but the fear is always there. However, my DC is an adult. It is not for me to decide what they do with their life, it's for them.

Yes I take your point, she chose to kill herself in a horrible way. Do you think once it was clear she would die she should have been eased on her way or that she should have been offered the choice earlier? How much earlier?

PP got to 3 stone (I’m so sorry you were so sick I can’t imagine what that must be like) and probably would have taken the option but is now recovered. How long does someone have to be ill to know that they will never recover? 5years 10 years?

Our brains aren’t even fully mature by 25. I’m sure there are many people on mumsnet who have children who could be classed as very ill in their teens but by their 30’s are ok.

In the depth of mental illness many of us here have said we would have taken the option yet we are still here. I know I would have cultivated my narrative to the best of my ability to obtain my euthansia as well. I would have said anything I needed to to get it. I wouldn’t have been lying but I would have emphasised the darkness and ignored any light.

OP posts:
RachelGreep87 · 01/05/2023 10:15

A lot of our jobs will be replaced by AI in the coming years so I would rather be euthanised than irrelevant and starving on the streets.

StressedToTheMaxxx · 01/05/2023 10:13

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 08:59

@SleepyRich
I don’t think you have that correct. It says assisted dying will become available to those with mental illness under existing provisions for those whose deaths are not foreseeable

If a persons death is not imminent or foreseeable, then how can it be a “severely life limiting mental illness”? Do these even exist? I cannot think of one mental illness that is “severely life limiting” with treatment.

And isn’t wanting to die a key symptom of depression and suicidal ideation? If you’re physically or mentally ill, you are at high risk of developing depression on top of whatever else you have because you are ill. How on Earth are they going to filter out the depressed from not depressed?

There are some mental illnesses that are treatment resistant. Sadly, some folk with severe mental illness have no quality of life, none whatsoever.

As a mental health nurse, I've worked with some patients who have been under the services for years, in and out of hospital. Even at their best, they barely function. I'm talking mainly about the likes of chronic schizophrenia. Of course many people with this condition live very meaningful lives, with the correct treatment regime and support. But yes, there are those who don't have a quality of life (and not just in my opinion, in their own opinions).

It's something that would have to be assessed very very carefully and on a case by case basis. I can understand the controversy. But I can also understand why some people who live daily with such a torturous illness wouldn't want to go on.

It's certainly a very thought provoking argument.

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 10:12

pointythings · 01/05/2023 10:07

what I see is a medical system giving up and convincing a vulnerable ill patient that everyone would be better off if they ended their life. It’s heartbreaking.

You are clearly unable to see past your own experience. You assume that everyone who feels this way must have been influenced by 'the medical system'.

That view is arrogant and presumptuous. You are not the only person who has a child with serious mental illness. I do too. Why is my view less valid than yours?

Well, have you ever tried to kill yourself? More than once? Have you ever been sectioned and put on suicide watch? I’d say your opinion is equally valid if you have any experience of the above.

DisquietintheRanks · 01/05/2023 10:11

@Noicant there's no need for the state to provide euthanasia to "anyone for any reason" as most people have recourse to suicide. Euthanasia is (or is intended to be) a safeguard to those who, for whatever reason, are physically unable to act independently.

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 10:10

Especially since the goal of a mental illness is to kill its host. Seriously, it’s like a brain virus that instead of killing you by attacking your lungs or other organs, it attacks the brain and then forces you to harm and or try to kill yourself. When you are suicidal and I am speaking from personal experience as well as what others like me have said as we sat talking in the secure mental unit is that it’s isn’t the real you that wants to die, it is the illness speaking for you and you are no more than a puppet you are so far down that rabbit hole you can see no way out and you are in so much psychic agony you think the only way out is death. Those of us that come out the other end have nothing but gratitude for the paramedics and doctors that took the time, often YEARS, and effort to not give up on us and help us combat our mental illness to the point where we are stable and can identify when it starts to mount another attack on us so we can get help. And you know what? If euthanasia starts to be regularly offered to the mentally ill, anyone with a complex case or stubborn mental illness that takes “too long” to respond to treatment will be killed in the name of “kindness”.

QueefQueen80s · 01/05/2023 10:09

Yeah I don't get the not being available for suicidal people.. surely the point is that it will be a peaceful, planned death as opposed to jumping infront of a train.
If you're not suicidal, why would you want to die..

Noicant · 01/05/2023 10:07

RudsyFarmer · 01/05/2023 09:01

We have no ability to control our descent into this world so I think all of us should have the priori on to control our ascent. That’s how I feel about it.

I’ve felt some sympathy with this point in the past, if my life is truly my own I should be able to end it whenever I wish for whatever reason I wish. I think as I get older I realise that people often have multiple pressure points on them so death is an option because of their circumstances rather than a deeply held desire.

Please don’t take this as an attack I am genuinely curious. Do you therefore believe that we should provide euthansia to anyone for any reason?

OP posts:
pointythings · 01/05/2023 10:07

what I see is a medical system giving up and convincing a vulnerable ill patient that everyone would be better off if they ended their life. It’s heartbreaking.

You are clearly unable to see past your own experience. You assume that everyone who feels this way must have been influenced by 'the medical system'.

That view is arrogant and presumptuous. You are not the only person who has a child with serious mental illness. I do too. Why is my view less valid than yours?

pointythings · 01/05/2023 10:04

How would people feel if it was their child choosing to die because of mental illness. Should there be a minimum age?

I don't think there should be a minimum age, I think there should be medical scrutiny. Going back to the case of Noa Pothoven, who was 17 when she died (but did not receive euthanasia) in the Netherlands, this was a young woman whose life had been marked by massive trauma and mental illness. I would recommend that anyone who opposes assisted dying for mental illness read her testimonials online (most are in Dutch but translation software is there for you to use). Other cases and testimonials are also there for you to read.

I understand it is enormously emotive, but I have a child with mental illness. We've recently had a suicide scare because of an adverse reaction to new medication. It was terrifying. Right now my DC is well, enjoying life, but the fear is always there. However, my DC is an adult. It is not for me to decide what they do with their life, it's for them.

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 10:03

pointythings · 01/05/2023 09:58

@SwitchDiver ultimately when your DD is an adult, it will be her decision to make. You want to deny people agency and choice because they have a mental illness. Ultimately this isn't about 'negativity', this is about allowing people to choose their own path. If you really think that the people who have chosen euthanasia in other countries based on mental ill health have done so because it was the easy way out, you need to read their testimonials, because that is a horrific point of view. These are people who have striven and tried and battled for many years and who are done fighting. You disrespect them utterly.

No, that’s not it at all. The point is that mental illness impairs your ability to choose what you want. In many cases, mental illness compels you to think and do things that you do not want but you are powerless to do anything. Mental illness robs you of your agency and your ability to choose. Asking mentally ill people to consent to their own murder is taking advantage of the fact they are not at full mental capacity. I’m not disrespecting anyone, and I have read the testimonials and what I see is a medical system giving up and convincing a vulnerable ill patient that everyone would be better off if they ended their life. It’s heartbreaking.

Noicant · 01/05/2023 09:58

pointythings · 01/05/2023 09:49

@Noicant and @SwitchDiver I do understand your personal concerns. I've worked in mental health for many years. However, when these threads come up it's always in the light of the Canadian approach to this. The Canadian approach is bad, it has insufficient safeguards, it is ill thought through. But other models are available.

I had a cousin in the Netherlands who had psychosis. Nothing helped him. He killed himself by jumping off a block of flats, to the immense distress of the people who witnessed it. This included children. Is that better than offering a way out? Where I grew up there was a stretch of train track that was notorious for suicides. It was horrific for the train drivers. Is that better than offering a way out?

I think broadly speaking the Netherlands has it right. It isn't perfect, but it's a hell of a lot better than leaving people permanently stuck in a life with little or no hope.

My main concerns about introducing assisted dying in the UK is that we have a government that only cares about money and selling stuff off to their wealthy friends. I'd like to see that change, and then I'd like to see the introduction of PR, before we take action on assisted dying. But I have no issues with AD itself, if done properly.

Yeah thats my other concern that people who end their own lives do it in a terrifying painful messy way and the people who find them. If someone is 100% going to do it is it better that they do it at a time of their choosing and peacefully.

How would people feel if it was their child choosing to die because of mental illness. Should there be a minimum age?

OP posts:
pointythings · 01/05/2023 09:58

@SwitchDiver ultimately when your DD is an adult, it will be her decision to make. You want to deny people agency and choice because they have a mental illness. Ultimately this isn't about 'negativity', this is about allowing people to choose their own path. If you really think that the people who have chosen euthanasia in other countries based on mental ill health have done so because it was the easy way out, you need to read their testimonials, because that is a horrific point of view. These are people who have striven and tried and battled for many years and who are done fighting. You disrespect them utterly.

pointythings · 01/05/2023 09:56

@emanresu000 ok, you were talking about the case of Noa Pothoven, who was 17.

She did not receive euthanasia.

People get this wrong all the time. She committed suicide by refusing to eat or drink and the decision was taken that she should have palliative care only at this point, so clearly she had capacity.

She didn't just have an ED, she had many other comorbid and serious illnesses.

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 09:55

pointythings · 01/05/2023 09:51

@emanresu000 the anorexia case in the Netherlands was a 30 year old woman who had lived with her illness for 20 years. How much longer did you want her to carry on suffering? This is the sort of patronising attitude that makes me see red. It isn't your lived experience, it's someone else's.

Well your pessimistic attitude is worse. How dare you assume that anyone’s life would be nothing but suffering simply because they have anorexia? My DD has anorexia…should I have just smothered her with a pillow at 16 to spare her “suffering”? And what motivation will the government and health service have to help the mentally ill if they can simply tell the person, it’s incurable, you will suffer the rest of your life so sign here and we will kill you humanely.

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 09:52

I realise this is my experience, but I think there is a world of difference between offering euthanasia rather than treatment and support for people with some mental illnesses, and offering someone with a terminal illness that will result in a painful and undignified death, the chance to avoid the final stages.

Yes, me too. They are nothing alike and the constant conflation of the two is very disturbing.

pointythings · 01/05/2023 09:51

@emanresu000 the anorexia case in the Netherlands was a 30 year old woman who had lived with her illness for 20 years. How much longer did you want her to carry on suffering? This is the sort of patronising attitude that makes me see red. It isn't your lived experience, it's someone else's.

Flappingtarps · 01/05/2023 09:50

I’m very much on the fence about this.

I think there is a lot of evidence now to support the slippery slope arguments and it’s all too easy, when health care is commercialised, for the frail and vulnerable to feel pressured by economic factors.

On the other hand, part of taking mental illnesses seriously and imbuing them with the same “value” and seriousness as physical illnesses, is acknowledging that they can cause intense lifelong suffering and occasionally cannot be cured.

As someone who has experienced suicide in my close family, I can’t decide if future generations will look back and think that forcing people to take matters in to their own hands was intensely uncivilised, brutal and medieval? Or will they be dismayed at our lack of ability to treat and cure?

I’m not sure … .

pointythings · 01/05/2023 09:49

@Noicant and @SwitchDiver I do understand your personal concerns. I've worked in mental health for many years. However, when these threads come up it's always in the light of the Canadian approach to this. The Canadian approach is bad, it has insufficient safeguards, it is ill thought through. But other models are available.

I had a cousin in the Netherlands who had psychosis. Nothing helped him. He killed himself by jumping off a block of flats, to the immense distress of the people who witnessed it. This included children. Is that better than offering a way out? Where I grew up there was a stretch of train track that was notorious for suicides. It was horrific for the train drivers. Is that better than offering a way out?

I think broadly speaking the Netherlands has it right. It isn't perfect, but it's a hell of a lot better than leaving people permanently stuck in a life with little or no hope.

My main concerns about introducing assisted dying in the UK is that we have a government that only cares about money and selling stuff off to their wealthy friends. I'd like to see that change, and then I'd like to see the introduction of PR, before we take action on assisted dying. But I have no issues with AD itself, if done properly.